Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

doctor...

doctor...

lowest of the low singhni · 02 Jun 2004

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh If the doctor/dietician tells you that eating meat will help you if you have an illness, what should you do? ~l~ vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: doctor...

bairaagi · 02 Jun 2004

sarab rog kaa aukhad naam _________________ mayraa baid guroo gobindaa har har naam mukh aukhad dayvai kaatai jam kee phandaa _________________ jo jo deesai so so rogee rog rehat mayraa satgur jogee _________________ bin gur rog n thuttee houmai peerr n jaae || _________________ chi(n)thaa rog gee ho peerraa aap karae prathipaalaa jeeo ||2|| _________________ sa(n)thasa(n)g mil har har japiaa binasae aalas rogaa jeeo ||1|| _________________ thith bal rog n biaapai koee ||1|| _________________ simar simar kaattae sabh rog || _________________ saadhh kai sa(n)g mittae sabh rog || _________________ naanak rog gavaae mil sathigur saadhhoo sajanaa ||1|| _________________ dhookh rog bheae gath than thae man niramal har har gun gaae || _________________ (all from guru granth sahib) and there are many more :) bhul chuk maaf karnaa

Re: doctor...

bairaagi · 02 Jun 2004

sorry i misquoted the shabad "mayraa baid guroo gobindaa" it should be "har har naam aukhad mukh dayvai kaatai jam kee phandaa"

Re: doctor...

simran_sewa_sacrifice · 02 Jun 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!! Do not throw away your Gursikhi by committing a bajjar kurehit. There have been many instances where Gursikhs have even been cured of cancer by relying on kirpa of Guru Maharaj alone. The following is a part of the conversation between Akali Kaur Singh and Bhai Randheer Singh. It deals somewhat with what you are asking. The entire dialogue can be found here: http://www.tapoban.org/akalikaur.htm ################################################ Daas– Here is a letter from Narinder Singh, from Mahindipur, the one who you served the chicken to having killed it with your own hands. He has passed away. For eight or nine years he was ill from tuberculosis, but he was such a believer in his faith that he refused to eat meat and eggs, though many doctors had advised it strongly. Even many of his close friends attempted to convince him, but he remained true to his faith. Due to his faith, his condition began to get better and better, he even put on eighteen pounds in weight. All the doctors were amazed. Everyone admitted that it was his faith which brought on this improvement. From the day that you fed him that chicken, his health has deteriorated. After a few days, the eating of the meat had taken his life. Firstly you are responsible for ‘murdering’ his faith, secondly you murdered him and thirdly you murdered the chicken. All this rests upon your head. I don’t know how many other sins you have committed, in addition to these three, and to hug you would be like ‘murdering’ the true spirit of act act of hugging someone. Poor soul. Dear Narinder Singh became a victim of your crooked thinking. ################################################ waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!! [%sig%]

Re: doctor...

Jaguar · 02 Jun 2004

Bhainji whatever you do, DO NOT give up the Sikhi principles and follow what this doctor is telling you. It's just not worth it. No doctor in the world can tell you what you can do to make yourself better/healthier. Only Guru Sahib can do that since everything that happens is in Guru Sahib's hands. I truely think this is a MAJOR test of faith Guru Ji is putting you through to see just how strong His Singhnee can be. But please do not fall down and fail this test. Instead, do some pyaar-filled ardasas in front of Guru Sahib everyday asking Guru Sahib to give you strenghth to become healthier. Guru Sahib will surely help heal you if you obey His hukams instead of what some doctor tells you to do.

Re: doctor...

DO NOT EAT MEAT · 02 Jun 2004

DO NOT EAT IT IS UR DOCTOR BETTER THAN THE GURUS AND GOD COMBINEDDD ahhhhhhh no!

Re: doctor...

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 02 Jun 2004

my question is that if its sommin else other then meat, like surgery where the area must be shaved..should the sikh juss keel over and die? [%sig%]

Re: doctor...

Jinder. · 02 Jun 2004

I know I am in the same boat, I have really bad problems actually with my skin and entire body, i was lacking protein and iron in my diet. I started eating meat, its up to you paanji. Just a word to the wise, possibly buy some whey protein, but if you have to then buy soya products such as burgers, weiners

Re: doctor...

tarunjeet singh · 03 Jun 2004

vaheguru ji ka khlasa vaheguru ji ki fathe Bhenji ask the panj pyaaray. I know of someon who was told by the panj pyaraay that they could eat meat due to there illness. Ideally knowone wants to "bend the rules" but in some cases it is allowed. vaheguru ji ka khlasa vaheguru ji ki fathe

Re: doctor...

believer · 03 Jun 2004

wjkk wjkf. Bhenji, stick to your faith, at the end of the day no hukam is greater than that of the Guru's so surrender to that order knowing that all that shall happen will be right. when you have to give account for this life what will you say-you compromised your faith because of what a doctor said??? bhul chuk marf karni. wjkk wjkf.

Re: doctor...

Rashpal Singh · 03 Jun 2004

VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh The true Doctor is Satguru! Worldly 'doctors' are all false. Im telling you, actually, Guru Sahib is telling you that the medicine for ALL illnesses is Naam. In Bhai Randhir Singhs autobiography, it talks about when his father was ill with a VERY high fever, over 100 and could not pass urine. Bhai Sahib also caught the illness off his father who was in hospital, the doctors had no hope for Bhai Sahibs father surviving. They had given up, although, they told Bhai Sahib to save himself from suffering the same fate as his father, they requested him to take medicines, so they left them by his bedside to take later on. Bhai Sahib was not even Amritdhari then, but he had immense faith in the healing powers of Gurbani. So he wrapped himself in a blanket and sat on his bed, and started reciting Japji Sahib with great faith that his father would be cured. After he finished the recitation he stood up and did a silent ardaas, which work wonders. He went to his fathers bed and saw that he had passed urine and was now sweating, his fever had gone down, Bhai Sahibs fever was also gone.. When the doctors came to find that Bhai Sahibs father was alright now, they were shocked and surprised to find that someone who had a fever over 100 and couldn't pass urine for days had just done so, without medicines. When the doctors were about to ask him how this happened, he stopped them by speaking in Urdu, he said 'dont disturb me, I can hear the Manai Kee PauRee of Sri Japji Sahib ringing in my ears.' The doctors got filled with pride and bloated with ego that they had somehow cured his father. From this incident, Bhai Sahibs faith in Silent prayers and the healing powers of gurbani increased even more. I will try and type this chapter up from Bhai Sahibs autobiography. VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh

Re: doctor...

kaur · 03 Jun 2004

Well. my personal view is no, no, no, no and no! But the thing is, this is where you have to make a descision for yourself. There will be those who say that meat is not a kurehit and so it's ok anyway, those that say yes it is a kurehit, but if it's for medical purposes then that's ok and those that are completely against it under any circumstances (like me!). You have to read Gurbani and decide for yourself what you believe. Personally, I can't see any of our Guru Sahibs/Shaheeds etc of the panth ever killing an animal for eating. If there is a medical problem, then Bani gives us the answer "maira Baid Guru Govinda" (my Guru alone is my physician). If you have faith in bani Singhni jee, then all your troubles will vanish and so will any medical problems! Bhul chuk maaf if i've said anything to offend you Vaheguru Ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru Jee kee fateh

Re: doctor...

v singh · 03 Jun 2004

the panj are the guru reps, please consult with them.

Re: doctor...

mandeep · 04 Jun 2004

here is a simple but probably wrong way of thinking....... if something can be avoided (no matter what the costs inc. time etc....) then you should not commit a kurehit e.g. eating meat - all the nutritional value etc... of meat can be obtained through a vegetarian diet and therefore eating meat for sake of health is not permissive. My mum had TB and was strongly recommended eating eggs and meat to regain her strength...to this day she hasnt and is very 'strong' and healthy. if something cant be avoided e.g. shaving needed for brain surgery etc... then i think it MIGHT be permitted and would require you to have 'peshi' again. Bhul chuk maaf karni. Daas, Mandeep Singh

Re: doctor...

Eat from · 04 Jun 2004

IF you are low on Iron eat from Sarbloh, you will have no problem then. Also answer lies in NAAM. Doctors never have the answer, Only Guru jee has the Answer.