Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

UK says NO to Kala afghana

UK says NO to Kala afghana

tarunjeet singh · 01 Jun 2004

Sikhs gathered from various organisations to peacefully protest against a conference held by Kala Afghana at Hounslow Civic Centre (U.K) Continuous pleas to the police and to the organisers were made to cancel the event, but were not herd. The group of Sikhs acting on the interest of the Panth then forced their way in and shouted “jakaray” just before Kala Afghana was to address his audience. The Singhs proceeded to the main stage and demonstrated. At this point all the women attending surrounded Kala Afghana to protect him, whilst the men went to seek police assistance. A small struggle occurred at this point, in which punches were exchanged and in the process Kala Afghana’s turban came off, and several of his supporters were injured. Armed police was quick to rush in, and segregate the two parties. The Singhs continued their process until the event was cancelled. Kala Afghana left the building via a back door (police escorted) exit

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

simran_sewa_sacrifice · 01 Jun 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!! This is GREAT news! this has really made my day. No one should give this pakhandee even a minutes worth of rest. Its good to see that uk singhs have taken appropriate action. All of those who invited Kala, their names should be exposed to the sikh sangat and they should be boycotted. Dhan Guru, Dhan Guru Pyareh. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!! [%sig%]

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Mkhalsa · 01 Jun 2004

>>>>>>>A small struggle occurred at this point, in which punches were exchanged and in the process Kala Afghana’s turban came off, and several of his supporters were injured. ........ Kala Afghana left the building via a back door (police escorted) exit<<<<<< HAHAHAHA!!! I wish I was there!! Kala afghana will soon realize there he is not accepted anywhere and that there is nowhere for him to run. On a more serious note: If UK sangat knows of any gursikhs who are having any legal trouble as a result of this, please let the sangat know as I am sure there is sangat that would be more than willing to help them.

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Rashminder Singh OZ · 01 Jun 2004

yeh thats rite he is out of the panth bycott him else his supporter is automatically out of the panth gurfateh ji

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Singhstah · 02 Jun 2004

quote:All of those who invited Kala, their names should be exposed to the sikh sangat and they should be boycotted. end of quote yeah and they should give ALL the protesters saropas:) i wish i was there

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Gurpartap Singh · 02 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Why do we just keep on protesting about this idiot. Why not put an end to the source of all confusions. Get rid of him!! Anyway its for Guru sahib to decide when his time finishes. I have just one more news to share with the sangat. Kala Afgana appeared on UK's very famous Panjab Radio which is being financed by most of the UK Sangat (I have said most not everyone). Unfortuntaely there have been many occasions when organisations like Akhand Keertani Jatha have also donated generously to keep this radio alive. The presenter who is adored as one of the very gursikh ones among UK sangat was all praise for Kala afgana and throughout the discussion it appeared as if he was too much inspired by afgana. The idiot afgana talked all nonsense and worse even at age of 80+ he talked like a person who has no sense how to speak at a public forum being heard by all age groups, members of family sitting together. He narrated an incident of meeting with some christian priest and having discussion about sex etc. This is his mentality and intellectualism. If you want to listen to what he said the full program is available in an mp3 at http://www.waheguroo.com/users/pub/keertan/KALA%20AFGHANA/kala%20afganha%20on%20panjabradio.mp3 Guru Fateh Ji Daas, Gurpartap Singh

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

iamconfused · 02 Jun 2004

if this person has been ex-communicated from the panth why are so called sikh media etc. entertaining him? i am no model sikh in anyway, but and regardless of what jathedar is at the helm of Akal Takhat Sahib should we not obey the hukam from this seat of power? why do individuals think they have a higher knowledge than Guru-Ji? did Guru-Ji Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji say we must obey the edicts from Akal Takhat Sahib? we have so many sikh millionaires why can't we all pool together and start a totally Gurmat media outlet? not one which dedicates a few hrs in the morning and 1hr at night......but 24hrs of gurbani come sangat ji

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

singh · 02 Jun 2004

can someone pls explain who this guy is and what exactly he has done, i've tried to do some research on the net but not got far

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Curious · 02 Jun 2004

Vaheguroo jee ka Khalsa Vaheguroo jee ki Fateh. I've got a few quesries - I am ignorant, hwoever I am AGAINST any1 who gos against Akal Takhat, and was myself EXTREMLY SURPRISED that Panjab Radio invited him. I am extremly Against Kala Afghana, as he's been excommunicated by Panth, and has not gotten pesh, and am against a LOT of his view, i.e Akal Takhat, Amritvela etc. I've done a bit research on him now. i was tol tha he was excommunicated due to POLITICS. I t is claimed that Vedanti *jathedar of AKal Takhat* wrote the book, Gurbilas Patshai 6, which Kala Afghan pointed out mistakes - I have been told that this book included a lot of Bahman *superiority* thingy , and tha it misleed ppl. Later on, when Kala wrote his book, Vedanti banned it, and I ahve been told that most 'Vidvans' agree with his writings. Although I know I don't agree with his talks on, Amrit, Amritvela, Sant ji - I still don't udnerstand why he didn't get pesh. Oh yeah btw, i read an article where it sad that he asked for video conversation with Vedanti - but he refused -i.e he tried to caht to him - but Vedanti refused. But What I don't unda stand is - WHY DIDN'T HE GO AND GET HMSELF PESH - AND CHAT TO THEM THERE? please help me here - for those of you who know a lot about KA thanks alot Again - it's what I have been TOLD, please please PLEASE help me out here, and tell me all fo this politcs is not true, as a lot of Kala Afghana supporter keep brining this up when I discuss about KA - so can someone please refute it . I need help! thanks bhull chukk maaf

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

singh · 02 Jun 2004

but regardless of what he said or done if hes ex-communicated hes ex-communicated end of. and boycott punjab radio at the end of the day they have shown their true colours.............prestige and listening numbers are more important to them than panthic issues regardless of the fact they try and present themselves as 'panthic' i use the word casually here!

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

avidya · 02 Jun 2004

I have nothing but disdain for this man and his poor scholarcism along with the Institue of Sikh Studies and Dilgeer who have followed a similar angle to Kala Afghana ...but I have equal disdain for people helping making a martyr out of him by knocking his dastar off! You need to beat the man with a pen, not with a group of mates otherwise you are no better than a pack of dogs

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Gurpartap Singh · 02 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Dear "Curious", there are lot of singhs/singhnis who are not happy at the state of affairs in SGPC(Shiromani gurdwara parbandhak committee) and Sri Akal Takht Sahib. There have been lot of issues/controversies surrounding appointment/removal of Jathedaars, but at the end of the day Akal Takht sahib is not known by the Jathedar, its the Jathedar who is supposed to be known because of the existence of Sri Akal Takht Sahib. Anyone who has committed something wrong against the maryada or writes things which are not as per gurmat norms should be asked to present himself before the Akal Takht Sahib and clarify his stand. If such person is found guilty then panth has to decide the tankhaah. Although the Jathedaars today are also being apointmentd and are right/left hand man of Badal/Tohra sort of guys who have brought the status of Sikhi to the lowest level ever in Sikh history, but when there is a call to come and present yourself before Sri Akal Takht Sahib it is the duty of the sikh to do so. There are not just jathedaars who are sitting there. Sri Akal Takht Sahib is the supreme authority and our beloved Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji maharaaj is present there. Even if other people sitting in presence of Guru sahib are not 100% fit for the role why should we shy away from presenting ourself to the Guru sahib. In presence of Guru Sahib talk to the Jathedaars and also specify you stand. After that leave to the true Guru Sahib. He is there listening/watching every one. If the Jathedaar takes a wrong decision going against Gurmat he will face the music in True dargaah and if its the person's fault and he gets the correct justice then there is nothing wrong. But Kala Afgana has another motive. He is not there to promote sikhism, or cleanse sikhism of Brahmanical thinghs that have creeped in. He is there to take away the very basic foundation by question each and every brick of this foundation on which Sikhism stands. He wants to promote confusion/bitterness among sangat by questioning the very basic thoroughly proven practices and ideologies of the Sikh panth which have been experienced by so many Gursikhs around the world. Just try to read his books. He has gone to the lowest level of blaming Bhai Shaib Randhir Singh ji and many other gursikhs and labeled them as Bipar (brahmin)'s agent. Without any ego let me tell you, I have read each and every single book of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji. And I have not read them just once but every single book I have thoroughly read atleast 4-5 times. The beauty in bhai sahib's books cannot be judged without reading the full literature that god gifted him to write and provide to manmukhs like myself. These kala/peela/hara/chitta afgana's can never understand what Bhai sahib has written. Reason is simple. They are not there to understand but they are only there to critisize. Take one point from a specific book and just talk rubbish about it and based on that label such a mahaan gursikh as bipar agent. Similarly he said things about Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindranwale. He himself is a thief who has two FIR's in his name in India for stealing a cycle and car engine. Also he was thrown out of one gurdwara sahib for molesting a sikh bibi. Now also as soon as singhs come he runs away with his kachcha wet under protection of his luchcha gang bibian and police. Look who is talking about the jeevan of bhai randhir singh ji or sant jarnail singh ji. His own life is not even 0.0000001% of what these two great souls did for panth. They laid down their life. Bhai sahib spent 16 hrs in kaal kothri of british jails getting the worst tortures. Sant ji sacrificed his whole life for gurmat parchaar and ultimately for Sri Akal Takht Sahib and Sri Darbar Sahib. This afgana was asked to present himself before the Akal Takht and he said that he is unable to come because he is afraid that Indian govt would arrest him and torture him for his connections with Sant ji. Sometime he would say his old age doesnot allows him to travel back to India. Such a fearful mouse is talking about mahaan singhs of their time. Now he went back to India and stayed there under full protection of Panjab police. Its for your goodself to judge who the real thief/culprit here is. And shame on Panjab radio for inviting such a **admin cut** and supporting him fully during the interview. Bhul chuk di khima da jaachak, Daas, Gurpartap Singh

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Gurpartap Singh · 02 Jun 2004

Guru fateh ji, Sorry ammendement to my previous post. Bhai sahib spent 16 years not 16 hrs. Sorry for the typing mistake. Daas, Gurpartap Singh

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

? · 02 Jun 2004

Very well said. still, i'm wondering does he say anything at all of value in that interview? I'm asking those who heard it b/c i see no use in wasting antother hour if he didn't.

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Mkhalsa · 02 Jun 2004

Curious Jee, Gur bilaas is a book that was written hundreds of years ago and has been released and rereleased many many times. Vedanti re released it for historical purposes, knowing full well there were problems with it, this doesnt get rid of historical significance though. At any rate, vedanti himself later banned it. Kala afghana had already released blasphemous books before that. Once he found out about this gurbilaas thing, he latched on to it and wrote a book about it so that he can look like some kind of victim. It is interesting to note that taksalis do quote from it (gur bilaas) heavily. Esp to prove raagmala as bani.

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

pill pill · 03 Jun 2004

this is really bad. who said "kala afghana" was a sant? and why his teaching are bad i will never know.tarunjeet singh wrote:

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Curious · 03 Jun 2004

Vaheguroo je eka Khalsa Vaheguroo jee ki Fateh ji! Daas sincerely thanks Mkhalsa ji, and Gurpartap Singh for posting very and enlightening posts. Thank you admins for posting my message and allow daas to get rid of querries bhull chukk maaf Vaheguroo jee ka Khalsa Vaheguroo jee ki Fateh

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

UK dude · 03 Jun 2004

------Unfortuntaely there have been many occasions when organisations like Akhand Keertani Jatha have also donated generously to keep this radio alive.------------- Panjab Radio is an independent and unbiased radio, they have an AKJ presenter (Satnam Singh) and have regularly played AKJ kirtan. Unless you have seen the brilliant work done by the station, I suggest you get your facts in order, before slandering with hostile comments. This is the only station in the UK that has and still is broadcasting excerpts of Jarnail Singh's speeches in the run up to the 6 June Programme. FYI - The presenter you seem to have the hump with was the same person who played these on air for the first time. Log onto the net and listen to the presenters broadcast '84 related programmes from 1800 onwards (UK time) all week.

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

uksingh · 03 Jun 2004

so what if they play jatha kirtan? should we be happy because they play jatha kirtan erm no i dont think so lets try and see the bigger picture this person afghana has said and written things which cant be tolerated or go unpunished thus the boycott he is the same person who slandered sant jarnail singh but its ok as the station plays sant jis speeches? and yet they interview the person who has slandered sant ji? i think sant ji would rather we boycott this person than have there speeches broadcast lets get some perspective i think the bigger sinner here is the radio station.......... ukdude the media dont give two hoots about anyone!

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Daas · 04 Jun 2004

Still the question remains why on earth would a presenter who is supposedly panthic and educated allow this cretin on in the first place, it seems as though this presenter is one of the good ones on radio stations but one action like this can tar his reputation, technically speaking the presenter is also in violation of the hukamnama against the cretin. So before we start defending the presenter he should come out and state the reasons for allowing him on !!!!! and then apologise for this incident !!!!!

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Gurpartap Singh · 04 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Dear "UK dude", So if All India Radio which is fully sponsored and paid for by Indian govt starts to play Sant ji's speeches tomorrow will you start considering them panthic? Its too easy to say that so and so played speeches and so and so allowed such and such keertan to be broadcast. I don't think they did it for free. You have to take seva of the time before you can expect anything like this to happen. Like any other business obviously there will be free slots and promo slots. But this does not mean that the specific person/business gets the right to do whatever they wish to do. Kala Afgana has been declared tankhaiya and later ex-communicated from the panth. As I mentioned in my previous post its not for me or you to question the decision of Sri Akal Takht Sahib. When the organisations say we accept Sri Akal Takht Sahib as supreme authority then they are binding themselves to the decisions as well. Again I don't want to start writing about how decisions ar ebeing taken that is for the whole panth to decide. Any individual has no right to say I can frame the guidlines. When it comes to panth it includes all jathebandis and most of them so far have agreed with the Hukamnama. Just because a person/radio played speeches live on air or arranged number of samagams does not give them right to start doing anything they want. When some one is anit panthic, has been ex-communicated, hukamnama has been issued to not keep any kind of contact it means any kind of contact. Rehat maryada also says not to keep any contact with dheermapliye ramariye. There is another hukamnama about narakdaharis as well. If Kala afgana can be allowed, one day the others can be invited and interviewed as well. This makes me think if Panjab radio is really panthic? I still stand by my previous statement. Shame om panjab radio for inviting such a panth dokhi. I hope sangat will realise the true importance of Sri Akal Takht Sahib and may be one day there will be perfect saint soldier jathedars. Bhul chuk di khima da jaachak Gurpartap singh Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Singh · 04 Jun 2004

"I hope sangat will realise the true importance of Sri Akal Takht" Exactly so lets ALL follow the Sikh Rehat Maryada as established by the united Guru Khalsa Panth from Sri Akal Takt Sahib.

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Singh · 04 Jun 2004

Guru fateh. Please do not misunderstand me, I have some different line of thinking. Is it not possible, we leave the devil alone. Those who want to be with Kala, can not we ignore them Just see, who these people are. If they are mischief makers, alert the believers about them. If they are ignorant, persuade them, tell them how they are wrong. Is it not possible that we ignore "excommunicated" and lose nothing. I wonder, how we find time, for these foolish sort of people. Excommunication means ignore that man, but it does not mean, go where ever he goes. I appreciate the feelings about this post, but being in India, can not exactly understand the atmosphere at your place. Please help me out.

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Gurpartap Singh · 04 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Veerji, Fully agree with you that we should leave them alone. That's what we need to do. But leaving them alone doesnot mean that we don't keep a watch on the specific activities of these people which affect our socity and institutes. Every sikh has to let others live as they want but also act as guard with open ears/eyes to make sure that nothing unjustified is happening and wrong does are persuaded to give up mischief/punished. Thats' what the role of a saint soldier should be. I have nothing to do with Kala Afgana personally. I am not writing here wasting my time on a person with whom I don't want to keep any link. Reason for my posts was only to make sangat aware of this person and also role of media which has gained importance among panth. Hope I don't have to post anymore on this topic. Bhul chuk di khima da jaachak, Daas, Gurpartap Singh

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

Admin · 04 Jun 2004

Heeding to Singh jee's request, we are closing this thread now. No more posts under this thread will be approved. Admin.

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

singh · 31 Jul 2005

By Dhanwant Singh Ex-Communication is not Sikhism Sikhism is a religion of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji & not of a particular person or a body. A person who dedicates & surrender one’s life to the teachings i.e. Sikhaya of Guru Granth Sahib is entitled to be called a Sikh. Appearance of a Sikh person is also natural & not man made. That is also fashioned by its Creator Himself-only for the man being. All of us should be grateful to the Great GURU who reverted us into a proper man’s appearance. The Supreme Guru also re-energized us into our natural living with Gurbani teachings. No doubt, the human being had defaced & lost, one way or the other his appearance & living human values. Hence the Sikhism is a property of the Supreme Guru Himself & its Creator, and not the property of any body else. It is only Gurbani, which has to decide if a person is a Sikh or not. Therefore if a person or a body, which claims or dares to ex-communicate some Sikh person or personality from Sikhism, resides in heaven of dreams. They should first learn the teachings & Philosophy of Gurbani which clarifies: "nf ko bYrI nhI ibgfnf sgl sMig hm kAu bin afeI" (Page 1299 GGS) "hoie iekqR imlhu myry BfeI duibDf dUir krhu ilv lfie ] hir nfmY ky hovhu joVI gurmuiK bYshu sPf ivCfie ] 1 ] (Page 1185 GGS) & so on which can be translated as "No one is my enemy, and no one is a stranger. I get along with everyone" & "Come and join together, O my Siblings of Destiny; dispel your sense of duality and let yourselves be lovingly absorbed in the Lord." Respetively. Be cautious that excommunication is not the principal of Guru Granth Sahib and this medieval verdict itself goes against are those persons or the society as a whole, who claims so. On the other hand if a few misguided or ignorant persons goes to some Bhaniara, Asutosh, Narinkari or somebody of the category and claims, these people as their gurus, instead of Guru-Gurbani. It all is due to the clergies and gurdwara system of the day, which is absolutely responsible for this. But the people who are deserting Sikhism are again less faulty than these. For this ignorance which is increasing day by day in Sikhism, rather the clergy system as well as Sikh preachers & the Gurdwara management of the time should get ashamed of it. The day will come, when those ignorant persons will have to repent and come back. But at that time, they will have to curse the clergies and Sikh preachers along with Gurdwara management of this day. But these original culprits, who are wrongly boasting and declaring themselves the right persons and ex-communicating the genuine devotees, simply because of some chair-table issue. Also ex-communicating the Research Scholars or Intellectuals of the Community. When Such researchers & scholars who declare that none of writings on the earth can be parallelized to Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. The genuine researchers & scholars who dare fully warns the Sikh masses from brhmanical living which has highly crept into Sikhism & damaged the Sikh living-rom socalled Dasam Garanth etc. Alas! our Christian brotheren have increased their population and converted 1/3 of the whole universal population. The Mohammedans have got so many countries in the world but the Sikh masses are daily busy in ex-communication of their Researchers, Scholars and genuine Devotees- but can not control apostasy, intoxication, gurudom, which seriously is being crept into Sikhism and has already swallowed above 95% of the Sikh masses

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

... · 01 Aug 2005

I agree with GurPartap Singh ... Panjab Radio is the most anti-Panthic station around. They always do Nindya of Gurmukhs that do Gurmat Parchaar, and they let Panthic Dushts like Afgana on their shows, going directly against Akal Takhat. Shame on Panjab Radio!!!

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

uk singh · 01 Aug 2005

All these people who are doing Ninda of Jasvir Singh should arrange a meeting with him. He is very approachable and will even give you time on one of slots to air your views. Rather than bash people without speaking to them, please try and contact them directly. You can always phone the station when he is on air and ask to speak to him directly. Panjab Radio is a business at the end of the day and they represent all sections of the community - just like any news organisation. You wont find BBC radio refusing an interview with an Al Qaeda backer or IRA member!

Re: UK says NO to Kala afghana

;) · 01 Aug 2005

Let me tell you about any radio station, they WANT to make money! To make money you need listeners To get listeners, you have to talk about with controversial people or talk about controversial issues. Even panthic people will just listen to see what is said Therefore advertising rates are increased, more money is made, oh yeh people don't forget to sponsor a sukhmani sahid da patth, wots the difference between any radio station that needs sponsorship for pathh to be done and people like Grewal who take maharaj's saroop into Halls.... NOTHING both are selling their Guru for MONEY which goes into their OWN pockets & not the panths Panjab Radio is not panthic... its a business just like any radio station, thats it!