Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 02 Jun 2007

[b][u]*SARSE WALA SAADH GURU GOBIND SINGH NAHI BAN SAKDA*[/u] Talwandi Slem (Nakoder Samagam - 19/05/2007)[/b] [b][u]-SANT BABA RANJIT SINGH JEE KHALSA DHADRIANWALE-[/u] (Gurdwara Parmeshar Dwar Saahib Patiala) of Sree Nirvair Khalsa Dal (Jatha Dhadrian)[/b] [b][url]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-461117233586573860&hl=en-GB[/url] (Part 1 of 4) [url]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=377001457355595146&hl=en-GB[/url] (Part 2 of 4) [url]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=108204532292416881&hl=en-GB[/url] ( Part 3 of 4) [url]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-8388430727423590196&hl=en-GB[/url] (Part 4 of 4)[/b] [b]...A recent live diwaan recording regarding the current state of affairs in Panjab concerning Pakhand "Dera Sacha Sauda" and "Raam Raheem Baba"...[/b] [i]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/i] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

bebiha · 03 Jun 2007

I think you should take a look at the DODGY video that was once circulated around the internet...where he wear a kalgi...sits on a tabia....and people bow to him....with a basket loaded with money on the side... if you still didn't get my message...HEZ ONE OF THEM! [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianw

Harjas Kaur · 03 Jun 2007

[quote]SANT BABA RANJIT SINGH JEE KHALSA DHADRIANWALE[/quote] [quote]SANT JARNAIL SINGH JEE KHALSA BHINDRANWALE... May I ask why people are stretching Dhadrianwales name to be ever so close to Sant Ji's name if they aren't creating a propagandistic parallel? Seems mighty suspicious to me.[/quote] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

S-Singh · 04 Jun 2007

All very convenient for the likes of Bheva and Dhadrian to use the Sirsa pakhandi story to gloss over their pasts. Plus what a great selling point for Bheva when the rumour gets round that he offered RS 1 crore to whoever would bring him the head of sirsa pakhandi. How panthic bheva is. Vedanti asked police to speed up cases against sirsa pakhandi but what about just asking the police to start investigating the sexual abuse accusations against bheva. At the same time Vedanti could tell bheva to fly to Canada and face justice.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khatarnak Times · 04 Jun 2007

HarjasKaur why have you referred to Baba Jarnail Singh as "Sant Ji"? Who are you to judge if he was a Sant or not? It is this continuous "Sant-ization" of people within the Sikh community that has led to the current atmosphere. We are all supposed to be Bhai's and Veer's. IF we refer to the likes of Baba Buddha Ji, Baba Deep Singh with "Baba" then why start this new trend of labelling people Sants. Baba Jarnail Singh was a Singh like many before him. Lets leave it at that. Dhadrianwala is not a sant. Why do Sikhs want to attach themselves to people rather then the Guru? Gurbani is our guru, the Khalsa is Guru but there is no room for one person to have such a role in Sikhi. Anyone who allows others to touch his feet, anyone who sits atop a throne while other Sikhs sit on the floor around him is not fit to be called Sant. People need to wake up and realize that by calling these people Sants you are helping the rot that has attached itself to Sikhi. People claim that Dhardrianwala doesn't want people to touch his feet but people do it forcibly out of sharda and he is not able to stop them. Well if people wanted to touch his dastarr would he not stop them then? Are his hands tied. He isn't the first person to whom stupid Sikhs bow. Others have successfully avoided people touching their feet. Guru sahib has given us all buddhi and we do ardaas for bibek budhi everyday. Use the test of Gurbani and think about what you are doing. So many people are following a person rather then Guru sahib. This is absolutely pathetic. Then we wonder how such people like the idiot head of Sacha Sauda can get the courage to go around acting like Guru Gobind Singh Jee. WE MAKE THE CIRCUMSTANCES WHERE SUCH PEOPLE CAN PROSPER. IT IS OUR OWN DOING. GURU SAHIB HAS TIME AND TIME AGAIN TRIED TO SHOW US HOW WE ARE HEADING DOWN THE WRONG PATH BUT WE CHOOSE TO IGNORE HIM AND RATHER ATTACH OURSELVES TO DHADRIANWALAY OF THE WORLD. JAB EH GA-A BIPRAN KEE REET MAIN NA KAROUN EN KEE PARTEET.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

SomeSingh · 04 Jun 2007

Could you guys back up your claims that we are not suppposed to use the word Sant with Gurbani?

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianw

confused · 04 Jun 2007

Vaaheguroo

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khatarnak Times · 04 Jun 2007

SomeSingh, In Gurbani it says that only one mahapursh can know the state of another. Unless you yourself are a very chardi kala Gursikh you can't possible know what the avastha of another is. Gurbani also states that we shouldn't do ninda or unwarranted ustat of anyone and that it is bad karma to do so. Infact, doing unwarranted ustat is equivalent to doing nindia in terms of bad karma. I can't come up with the exact panktis' at this time but I'm sure if you search Sikhitotothemax you can find some yourself. Or maybe some other Singhs have time to look them up and post them here. But why do you insist on calling people Sants? If someone had said instead that you shouldn't do nindia of someone would you have requested Gurbani pankti's for that as well? Doing undeserved ustat and nindia are the same thing. Hope this helps.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalistan_zindabaad · 04 Jun 2007

Khatarnak Times how about bhai sahib bhai randheer singh jee khalsa giving the status of SANT to Bhai Juallaa Singh jee, calling him SANT jualla singh jee? so what if ppl call sant jarnail singh jee a sant, whats your issue with it, i personally have reffered to sant jee as SRI maan sant giani jarnail singh jee khalsa bhindranvale. In one speech sant jee actually states summit like i havnt become a SANt by the votes of the public, but by satguru sahib jee kirpa. SO now what you gonna do state that he was incorrect for saying that. iehu sMswru ibkwru sMsy mih qirE bRhm igAwnI ] eihu sa(n)saar bikaar sa(n)sae mehi thariou breham giaanee || This world is engrossed in corruption and cynicism. Only those who know God are saved. Dhan Dhan sahib sree guru granth sahib jee maharaaj. a nice quotation ''Baba Jarnail Singh was a Singh like many before him. Lets leave it at that'' NOT

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianw

Harjas Kaur · 04 Jun 2007

[quote]HarjasKaur why have you referred to Baba Jarnail Singh as "Sant Ji"?[/quote] I do not think of him as the same as Guru Sahib, and never did he make himself out to be. But if ever anyone has earned the title of sant, than he surely did. I refer to him as Sant Ji out of respect. Because that is how his own Jatha refers to him, and he has earned this tremendous respect. He was the greatest Sikh general of the twentieth century. Calling him Sant Ji cannot possibly be the cause of dera sacha sauda which is an obvious plant by Indian government. Why are you engaging in petty criticisms and Panthic divisions? I am not the person who invested this title in Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale. Take up the point with Damdami Taksal. Unless you are intending to accuse that Damdami Taksal is just like Dera Sacha Sauda? Because that's off the beam. [url]http://www.damdamitaksal.com/his_jath_14.htm[/url] Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale Speech During Dharam Yudh Morcha [url]http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=6527395626730297639&q=bhindranwale[/url] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 04 Jun 2007

BREHAMGIANEE SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JEE KHALSA BHINDRANWALE WAS ONE OF THE GREATEST SAINTS TO WALK ON THIS PLANET WHO WOKE A SLEEPING NATION AND WILL ALWAYS BE REMEMBERED IN SIKH HISTORY AS A SANT MAHAPURKH WHETHER PEOPLE ON HERE LIKE IT OR NOT!!! Just like... Than Than Brehamgianee SANT Baba Gurbachan Singh Jee Bhindranwale Than Than Brehamgianee SANT Baba Nand Singh Jee Kaleran Wale Than Than Brehamgianee SANT Baba Kartaar Singh Jee Bhindranwale Than Than Brehamgianee SANT Baba Isher Singh Jee Rara Saahib Wale Than Than Brehamgianee SANT Baba Isher Singh Jee Nanaksar Wale Than Than Brehamgianee SANT Baba Harnaam Singh Jee Rampur Khere Wale ...and many many more, Sant Jee will always be remembered as the great Saint Soldier Sant Sipahee that no one here can ever compare to... THAN THAN BREHAMGIANEE SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JEE KHALSA BHINDRANWALE! [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 04 Jun 2007

"[i]SomeSingh[/i]" Jee, do not worry what a very few people in the Panth think or claim about the title "Sant", the fact of the matter is, the Mahapurkhs that have come and gone have always been referred to as SANTs and will [u]always[/u] be called SANTs in Sikh History for generations to come! [u]Nothing can change that[/u], no matter what people type on here... ...regarding Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Jee, people refer to him as a 'Sant' today and will [u]continue[/u] to do so... "[i]Harjas Kaur[/i]" Penjee, [b]NO ONE[/b] is comparing Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Jee to Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee. This is propaganda to bring down the very few Panthic Parchaaraks that are out there in the present time today, working day and night to spread the message of the Guroo Saahibaan and Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj. Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Jee are doing their Gurmat Parchaar in the Diwaans of Than Than Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj in acres of fields in Panjab daily, with hundreds of thousands that have already taken Amrit. Dhaas does not have some sort of “agenda” to ‘support’ or ‘defend’ Sant Dhadrianwale, but I think that if at [u]such a young age[/u] they are doing [u]powerful and influential Panthic Gurmat Parchaar[/u] which is [u]encouraging hundreds of thousands[/u] of people to take Than Guroo Gobind Singh Saahib Jee's [u][b]AMRIT[/u][/b], then the person making this endeavour should be fully supported, backed and ‘defended’ from anti-Panthic forces and media that create propaganda. Dhaas hopes this will not offend anyone, but it is personal opinion… [b]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/b] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 05 Jun 2007

...I agree with all the points made by Veer "khalistan_zindabad" Jee... [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Bazzer · 05 Jun 2007

You so called Singhs/Singhnis of Guru Gobind Singh Ji are the very ones doing the greatest disservice to the Panth. Hang your heads in shame. You pull down every parcharrak there is and then complain that no one does any parchaar. You find fault in each and every guru-tha-piyara right doen to what colour his chola is or why does he wear a certain style of dastaar. Sants are sent by Akalpurkh to put moorakhs like us on the path of Guru Ji but all we do is critisize, critisize and critisize, no one has measured up and on one will for you singh/Singhnis. No matter how much you bleat, Sants will remain Sants and those fortunate enough to recognise them will fall at their charan. There is nothing wrong with placing your head on the charan of a true Sant. If AkalPurkh has pargat in some one would you not fall at his feet ? This is exactly what happens with a Sant, and those who can recognise this will reap the rewards , those who sneer and turn these noses up , well Guru Gobind Singh Ji will sort them out.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

jassmannn · 05 Jun 2007

Nirvair Khalsa, Sant Baba Nand Singh Ji maharaaj lived the kind of Jeevan that can warrant the term 'Sant'. Bhinderawale was too embroiled in politics, and if you look at the history of how he became involved with congress, then rebel and then there is the famous point where he slept in a room above the guru sahib saying something along the lines of 'desperate times call for desperate measures', and also taking refuge in the Golden Temple, to cause all that damage and disrespect at the holiest of Sikh shrines. I do not doubt that Jarnail Singh did a lot of path and I'm sure he had kamaiyaa, but after all of that and everything that has happened you cannot put Sant Baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaaj in the same category. Totally totally not appropriate.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 05 Jun 2007

[quote]You so called Singhs/Singhnis of Guru Gobind Singh Ji are the very ones doing the greatest disservice to the Panth. Hang your heads in shame. You pull down every parcharrak there is and then complain that no one does any parchaar. You find fault in each and every guru-tha-piyara right doen to what colour his chola is or why does he wear a certain style of dastaar. Sants are sent by Akalpurkh to put moorakhs like us on the path of Guru Ji but all we do is critisize, critisize and critisize, no one has measured up and on one will for you singh/Singhnis. No matter how much you bleat, Sants will remain Sants and those fortunate enough to recognise them will fall at their charan. There is nothing wrong with placing your head on the charan of a true Sant. If AkalPurkh has pargat in some one would you not fall at his feet ? This is exactly what happens with a Sant, and those who can recognise this will reap the rewards , those who sneer and turn these noses up , well Guru Gobind Singh Ji will sort them out.[/quote] ______________________________________________________ [b]Dhaas could not have ever put it better than "Bazzer" Veer Jee - What a great post!!![/b] [b]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/b] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalistan_zindabaad · 05 Jun 2007

how about bhai sahib bhai randheer singh jee khalsa giving the status of SANT to Bhai Juallaa Singh jee, calling him SANT jualla singh jee? so what if ppl call sant jarnail singh jee a sant, whats your issue with it, i personally have reffered to sant jee as SRI maan sant giani jarnail singh jee khalsa bhindranvale. In one speech sant jee actually states summit like i havnt become a SANt by the votes of the public, but by satguru sahib jee kirpa. SO now what you gonna do state that he was incorrect for saying that. iehu sMswru ibkwru sMsy mih qirE bRhm igAwnI ] eihu sa(n)saar bikaar sa(n)sae mehi thariou breham giaanee || This world is engrossed in corruption and cynicism. Only those who know God are saved. Dhan Dhan sahib sree guru granth sahib jee maharaaj. a nice quotation ''Baba Jarnail Singh was a Singh like many before him. Lets leave it at that'' NOT

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

SomeSingh · 05 Jun 2007

" Gurbani it says that only one mahapursh can know the state of another." Gurbani does not state this anywhere. It states Bhramgyani ki gatt bhramgyani na jae (bhul chuk maaf for romanisation mistakes). Even then, as we all know, the bachan of a bhramgyani, will come true. by giving bachan to another they could enable a person to be able to recognise who is a bhramgyani. You know, you remind of this scholar I once met. He promoted false beliefs about Gurmat - he said that sants don't exist, the word is either used in reference to sangat, or to the Guru. I confronted him about this and disproved his point, and you know what he said? he said 'we have to lie like this so fake sants won't mislead sangat!!!' waheguru, he justifies twisting Gurmat teachings and misleading people so people won't be mislead!!! no wonder there's so much confusion in the lay sangat.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

jassmannn · 05 Jun 2007

Well said Bazzer

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khatarnak Times · 05 Jun 2007

Wow, this is very very impressive. All these people who don't know wether they support Santdom or not? My question is why do we need Sants? Why not just go to guru sahib for guidance and knowledge. If we truly believe "pargat gurran kee deh" then why listen to so called sants when the ultimate Sant is Guru Granth Sahib Jee. And any genuine Sant only became a Sant through Guru's grace. If they can do it why can't you? If Guru Gobind Singh Jee was alive would you go to another Singh no matter how much chardi kala they had? Would you consider that Singh infallible and equal to Guru sahib? Because that is exactly what you people are doing when you give someone lofty titles and generally accept them to be beyond mistakes. There is no difference between Guru Gobind Singh jee as he was and Guru Granth Sahib jee as we have today. "paragat gurran kee deh" We have panj pyare to lead, not one person regardless of how chardi kala they might claim or others might claim them to be. Why go to someone like dhadrianwala when he tells people to sit down and listen to his lecture and matha tek afterwards because there is too much sangat to get through???? If you want to go on labelling people sants and whatnot that is your business just don't be surprised and DON'T COMPLAIN when panth dokhis take advantage of the atmosphere YOU'VE helped create. That is my point. WE DON'T NEED SANTS. WE HAVE GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE MAHARAJ. A sikh only needs his Guru for guidance. No Sants or mahapursh are needed. >>> "BREHAMGIANEE SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JEE KHALSA BHINDRANWALE" >>> I see. Where in Sikh traition he would simply have been Bhai Jarnail Singh. Wording and titles as you've chosen are used to make OTHERS belive that someone is a Sant. They are used when there is doubt that there are those who won't believe. It is a simple marketing strategy. Someone commented that these supposed Sants are sent by God to do parcchar. Well, I suppose God tells you which one he has sent and which are are self-made and which ones are government sponsored. Or do you have some sort of a radars which allows you to pick out avtars.. ??? Or do you actually use your bibek budhhi and analyze things for yourself and determine wether they are according to gurmat or not???? oh... a strage concept I know .. but give it a try... strage things will begin to happen .. like you'll want to go to gurdwara for sake of doing sewa and listening to keertan rather then because a Sant A or Sant B is there. It wouldn't be the first time someone started out saying gurmat things about Sikhi and then injected poison in between the sugary words. Kala AFghana ring a bell????

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Bazzer · 05 Jun 2007

Khatarnak Times Saab Ji, If Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself came and stood infront of you lot you would still do nindhia, that is the level you are at. You say you have Guru Granth Sabhib Ji and need none else, who actually follows what guru Ji says ? this is exactly what Guru Granth Sahib Ji says, Sukhmani Sahib Ji, astpathai 15 : Sant Ki dhoot kar isnaam, sant koe jai-ya kurbaan sant ki sewa wadbhagi pie-yah, sant ki sewa naam dhiyaya (sorry for the roman translation) It is plain as plain can be, ignore it at your peril - <<< If Guru Gobind Singh Jee was alive >>> Guru Gobind Singh Ji is forever alive yaar, forever with us every second of the day, open your eyes. <<< Why go to someone like dhadrianwala >>> because only through such Guru-they-piyaray will you find the true path of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Sant ka marag, Dharam ki pauri, koe wadbhagi pie-yeh. And if you do do mutha take of such mahapursh, my word what paap we have done, to place our head at the feet of such kumai walley Singh. I make no apologies, if you meet a true Sant then bow with great adhav, only you pun will increase.. <<< Someone commented that these supposed Sants are sent by God to do parcchar. Well, I suppose God tells you which one he has sent and which are are self-made and which ones are government sponsored. Or do you have some sort of a radars which allows you to pick out avtars.. ??? >>> Be as cynical as you like, a cynic never gained anything, ever. Sant is a Sant is a Sant, you can deny it or not but his Kumai will shine through like a bright star in the darkness of space, and those fortunate ones will follow, no matter how much nindhia from so called Guru-kay-Singhs.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalsaspirit · 05 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh, Khalsa jio, [gurbani]ausqiq inMdw doaU ibbrijq qjhu mwnu AiBmwnw ] lohw kMcnu sm kir jwnih qy mUriq Bgvwnw ]1] qyrw jnu eyku AwDu koeI ] kwmu k®oDu loBu mohu ibbrijq hir pdu cIn@Y soeI ]1] rhwau ][/gurbani] All Singhs mentioned in thread were great gursikhs of sikh panth and we have high respect for them. Just to clarify some thing we have question for somesingh ji. somesingh jio please answer this question were Baba Thakhur Singh jee a brahamgiani? We have high respect for their saintly behaviour but we like to hear your opinion on them. Please answer calmly no rush and this question is not to offend any one either. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianw

Harjas Kaur · 06 Jun 2007

1. The fact remains that sants exist. This is completely separate from fake santdom which is currently problematic. Because fake santdom is problematic, people need to be extremely cautious and not merely grant labels for sake of granting labels. Where you have an entire Jatha with a tradition of conferring sant labels such as Damdami Taksal, I think respect needs to be given to the Jatha. (I am not a Taksali, but I do support Taksal). You cannot start a Panthic revolution where you undermine completely a tradition within a Jatha simply because you disagree, or because the Indian government has been infiltrating fake babas into the Panth. I too had concerns when people started altering Gurbani to make sant refer only to Sangat in order to eliminate recognition of any sants. This is not an appropriate response to the fake baba thing. It invalidates the pure truth of Gurbani which even common sense shows us that sants exist. 2. Dhadrianwale has created problems for himself when the video surfaced of him allowing people to mata tek to him, and dressing up in overly fancy outfits replete with jewelry, decorative chains and (okay, I wont say kalgi but sure looks like one to me) baubles dangling from his khanda. Even on his website he is wearing pearl necklace. By placing several professional photo shots of himself on the website, plus his kirtan comes across as egotistical and self-promoting. Because he has been doing these things, he draws legitimate criticism. I am not condemning him. I simply do not trust him because of these things. Time will tell what the truth is about him. I cannot accuse him of anything beyond mistakes we know he has done, and I do not. But to accuse that people cannot exercise the faculties of their own critical analysis of someone who has already had problems is asking for blind faith. It simply won't happen. Most people will view him with a critical eye. He has done some good things. The concern is, will he become another government sponsored dera which creates artificial division within the Panth. In other words, by converting so many, is he making his own Sikhs who will support GOI over Panthic interests? Unfortunately, the way the government and RSS are interfering, these are legitimate concerns. 3. By what extreme illogic is anyone using Kala Afghana as an example that anyone here is blaspheming Gursikhi? Kala Afghana is a secularist who accuses Sikh history of being brahmanical fairytales, challenges the authority of the Rehit Maryada, invalidates the Dasam Granth as bani, undermines the legitimacy of Damdami Taksal. If anyone is closer to Kala Afghana, it is someone who undermines the legitimate Gursikhi jeevan of Damdami Taksal. Even if someone does not agree with Bhindranwale as being a sant, I don't accuse that person of being like a blasphemer. He has a right to his own opinion, which is not anti-Panthic. Although in justice to Damdami Taksal, and to millions within the Panth, Bhindranwale is a recognized shaheed AND sant. Even the fact he was a shaheed should give him respect among the Panth regardless of the political situation, unless you are a supporter of the government of India and justify the attack on Harmandir Sahib. Now people are really starting to do nindya when they accuse of being like Kala Afghana. Not only is it a lie, it is an irresponsible and illogical comparison made only because of the extreme power to discredit someone by linking them to an excommunicated anti-Panthic author. 4. Even if I draw criticism here, I'm going to say it because it needs to be said. But there are sants in all religions. And it is obvious who they are by the way they live their lives. Even their photographs are glowing. This is not to say we should hero-worship them, make a cult of personality to them, or even seek out their counsel and blessing if it takes us away from the Sikh Panth. We have everything we need in Gurbani and sangat. But to deny the reality of sants is not in accord with the truth. Extraordinarily good and holy people should be respected. You are known by your deeds. This is what we are all supposed to be becoming, great lights. It will be a point of ridicule if every other religion in the world has the power to make sants, but Sikh religion refuses to acknowledge any sants or that anyone can become a light. [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalistan_zindabaad · 06 Jun 2007

how about bhai sahib bhai randheer singh jee khalsa giving the status of SANT to Bhai Juallaa Singh jee, calling him SANT jualla singh jee? so what if ppl call sant jarnail singh jee a sant, whats your issue with it, i personally have reffered to sant jee as SRI maan sant giani jarnail singh jee khalsa bhindranvale. In one speech sant jee actually states summit like i havnt become a SANt by the votes of the public, but by satguru sahib jee kirpa. SO now what you gonna do state that he was incorrect for saying that. iehu sMswru ibkwru sMsy mih qirE bRhm igAwnI ] eihu sa(n)saar bikaar sa(n)sae mehi thariou breham giaanee || This world is engrossed in corruption and cynicism. Only those who know God are saved. Dhan Dhan sahib sree guru granth sahib jee maharaaj. a nice quotation ''Baba Jarnail Singh was a Singh like many before him. Lets leave it at that'' NOT

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalistan_zindabaad · 06 Jun 2007

its funny how katarnack times is now trying to change things around from his orignial post how about bhai sahib bhai randheer singh jee khalsa giving the status of SANT to Bhai Juallaa Singh jee, calling him SANT jualla singh jee?

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Bazzer · 06 Jun 2007

Bhio and Beno, I think the underlying fear for most of you is two fold, and they are quite legitimate concerns. 1.) you think that by acknowledging a Mahapursh you are some how disrespecting Guru Granth Sahib Ji or you are being led away from Guru Ji or the panth. What one must understand is that Guru Granth sahib Ji’s bani has many many references to Sant / Mahapursh, that you should seek out Sants and take their sangat. (And before some one says that all references of Sant are to AkalPurkh or the Sangat, this is quite incorrect. For example Sukhmani Sahib has a whole astpathi on “Sant ka dhoki……..” meaning - the tormentor of a Sant….. how can this refer to Akalpurkh?) For example, Bhagat Kabir Ji poses a question. If AkalPurkh and your Guru/Sant is stood infront of you, who do you bow to first ? Answer – your Guru, because he has shown you the path to AkalPurkh. By having sangat of a Mahapursh in no way leads you away from the Panth, infact your Sikhi and your simran increases in leaps and bounds in ways that will amaze you. 2.) That by going to a Sant/Mahapursh you may end up with a fake one. If you wonder about aimlessly, then yes you will encounter these types of people. BUT if you are on the Gurus path and you do bainti to meet a true sant, then no way will you ever be deceived, never will AkalPurkh let you encounter anything other then a True Sant, that is Guru Jis promise. But if you have closed your inner-door to Sant/Mahapursh then of course you will meet all manner of people, that is our own fault. I would implore all Guru’s Singhs please less of the nindhia, because you may end up in such chakar that you are stuck for janam upon janam upon janam, all because you have bad mouthed a Sant/mahapursh. Sants are AkalPurkhs own. We all recite it every day, Guru Gobind Singh Ji in Chaupai Sahib says : “Santan dukh pai tay dukhi, sukh pai sadhun kay sukhi” When Sant are hurt, so is akalPurkh, when they are Sukhi then AkalPurkh is happy. Sants are in many guises and some not to the taste of sunsaries (worldly people) but they do not worry about this because they follow a different rhythm, not that of the sansaar. Sansaries and Sants are always are odds with each other, because Sansaries will always look towards sansaar before hey do anything, but a Sant will only take his queue from AkalPurkh and if that is not to the taste of the world, they do not care. Once Bhagat Kabir Ji decided to test his sangies particularly the local raja. Kabir Ji asked the local “ladies of the night” to join him in the morning on a cart, they filled bottles with water to look like sharaab and with the ladies on each arm Kabir Ji rode on a cart through the town. They made out they were drunk and having a good time, shouting and singing. Everyone was appauled, they all did nindhia. The story is a little long but the crux of it is that all the people had no faith in Kabir Jis character or spirituality even though they had been sangies for years and years, all failed the test. Sometimes Sants Mahapursh do strange things, some times it is a test, but all the time it is in accordance with “Guru – tha – pakh“ Bazzer = Bundha. [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khatarnak Times · 06 Jun 2007

I see. Allow me to clarify a few points. When I mean we don't need Sants, I don't meant to imply that SAnts don't exist. They do and these guru pyaray live in Guru's hukam and lead gurmukh lives. Baba Buddha jee was a sant, BAba Deep Singh jee was a SAnt and yet they weren't given these titles by the panth. Think about it. They were referred to as Bhai and Baba. Why? Because it is very easy for the public to start following people instead of Guru sahib. If you call someone a brother or respectuflly call them BAba then you avoid falling into traps of becoming their chela. I realize Gurbani says that Sants exist and thats fine. I understand that they do. However, my problem is people who think that whatever their Sant says is beyond question. And besides how does one recognize Sants? Just because you say someone is a Sant doesn't mean that they are and lofy titles such as "Sri Maan SAnt Baba Super Duper Brahmgiani" are meant to convince others that someone is a Sant. As for Bhai RAndeer Singh jee using the title of Sant, I believe he only published the book rangle sajjan after the Singhs had passed on. And in the book he uses the title of Sant for Jawala Singh jee. He didn't try to make him out to be beyond error and he sure as hell didn't try to market Sant Jawala Singh jee for his own purposes as the DDT does BAba Jarnail Singh. Allow me to offer my interpretation of the shabad that Bazzer has attempted to quote: ਸੋਰਠਿ ਮਹਲਾ ੫ ॥ ਗੁਰਿ ਪੂਰੈ ਕਿਰਪਾ ਧਾਰੀ ॥ ਪ੍ਰਭਿ ਪੂਰੀ ਲੋਚ ਹਮਾਰੀ ॥ ਕਰਿ ਇਸਨਾਨੁ ਗ੍ਰਿਹਿ ਆਏ ॥ ਅਨਦ ਮੰਗਲ ਸੁਖ ਪਾਏ ॥੧॥ ਸੰਤਹੁ ਰਾਮ ਨਾਮਿ ਨਿਸਤਰੀਐ ॥ ਊਠਤ ਬੈਠਤ ਹਰਿ ਹਰਿ ਧਿਆਈਐ ਅਨਦਿਨੁ ਸੁਕ੍ਰਿਤੁ ਕਰੀਐ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ ਸੰਤ ਕਾ ਮਾਰਗੁ ਧਰਮ ਕੀ ਪਉੜੀ ਕੋ ਵਡਭਾਗੀ ਪਾਏ ॥ ਕੋਟਿ ਜਨਮ ਕੇ ਕਿਲਬਿਖ ਨਾਸੇ ਹਰਿ ਚਰਣੀ ਚਿਤੁ ਲਾਏ ॥੨॥ ਉਸਤਤਿ ਕਰਹੁ ਸਦਾ ਪ੍ਰਭ ਅਪਨੇ ਜਿਨਿ ਪੂਰੀ ਕਲ ਰਾਖੀ ॥ ਜੀਅ ਜੰਤ ਸਭਿ ਭਏ ਪਵਿਤ੍ਰਾ ਸਤਿਗੁਰ ਕੀ ਸਚੁ ਸਾਖੀ ॥੩॥ ਬਿਘਨ ਬਿਨਾਸਨ ਸਭਿ ਦੁਖ ਨਾਸਨ ਸਤਿਗੁਰਿ ਨਾਮੁ ਦ੍ਰਿੜਾਇਆ ॥ ਖੋਏ ਪਾਪ ਭਏ ਸਭਿ ਪਾਵਨ ਜਨ ਨਾਨਕ ਸੁਖਿ ਘਰਿ ਆਇਆ ॥੪॥੩॥੫੩॥ {ਪੰਨਾ 621-622} If you read the pankti before Sant ka marag wali pankti it says: ਊਠਤ ਬੈਠਤ ਹਰਿ ਹਰਿ ਧਿਆਈਐ ਅਨਦਿਨੁ ਸੁਕ੍ਰਿਤੁ ਕਰੀਐ which means as follows: While standing or sitting (meaning all the time) jaap naam, do this good karma all the time. sukrit = good karm Then guru sahib goes on to say: ਸੰਤ ਕਾ ਮਾਰਗੁ ਧਰਮ ਕੀ ਪਉੜੀ ਕੋ ਵਡਭਾਗੀ ਪਾਏ which I will translate in sections: ਸੰਤ ਕਾ ਮਾਰਗੁ means "the Guru's path" (the path refers to the pankti before where we are told to jaap naam all the time) ਧਰਮ ਕੀ ਪਉੜੀ means "the pauri which will take you to God" meaning repetition of God's name is dharam kee pauri. ਕੋ ਵਡਭਾਗੀ ਪਾਏ means "the few with good karms get this pauri" (only those with God's karma ever find this pauri of naam simran) This is my understanding of the shabad. I am not saying that Brahmgiani Singhs don't exist. That would be stupid and undermining to the Sikh religion. Guru sahib came to this world to make us brahmgiani's. And that is exactly my point. Guru sahib came to this world to help us. Gurbani speaks to us directly. Why do you want someone to get in between you and guru sahib? If you have trouble understanding gurbani then go do santhiya in sangat because Sangat is also roop of guru. If you have troubles or have made mistakes, go see the panj pyare. Gurbani tells us how to be good Sikhs. Gurbani tells us how to control kaam krod lobh moh ahankar, gurbani tells us how to get the things we need in material life, gurbani tells us how to be happy both in this world and the next... WHAT EXACTLY CAN PEOPLE OFFER YOU THAT GURBANI IS LACKING???? I am not trying to change anything my original post. I have always maintained that Sikhi is about being a Sikh of the Guru and not of a SAnt. What exactly can Dhadrian wala tell you that Guru Sahib can't??? Using bibek buddhi isn't being cynical. It is following guru's hukam. We have to examine the actions of people and determine wether they are a bad influence or good influence. Wether they are fit to be called Sikhs let alone be called SAnts. My only concern is that by following so called sants we have lost much. I have seen many DDT youth give the reasoning that "SAnt ji said so... and if you don't belive that then you are not a Sikh" This mentality is what is causing decaying within the panth. Many have become Sikhs of people rather then Sikhs of the Guru. Gurbani and naam have made real chardi kala walay gursikhs like baba deep singh jee. Any kamaiee that someone has done has been because of BAni. Then why go to someone else who has used bani to get avastha when you get the avastha yourself???? [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianw

Nirvair Khalsa · 06 Jun 2007

The tone of "Harjas Kaur" Penjee's latest post has now changed for the better. At least Sant Mahapurkhs are accepted (I think?), although “Point 4” seems to state opposite. I sense there is only just the anti-Panthic media propaganda which is at play, nothing more. I agree that time will tell (to most it is already in front of us), that who is the true Panthic personality and who is the fake. Dhaas will reply back to Penjee’s post in more detail later… If Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Jee is a “fake”, then at least the thousands that take Amrit under their influence are not. The Amrit the thousands per month take is not from him, but from the Panj Pyaare. If he is "Kacha" and “Fake”, at least the Guroo they follow and bow down to in the end after they listen to the Diwaan and take Amrit (Sree Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj) is Pakka and True. Conclusively, if someone is encouraging Kalgee Wale Pithaa Jee’s Amrit Sanchaar and directing the Sikh Sangat to take Sree Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj as their only Guroo, then that person/Sant (such as Sant Dhadrianwale) should be appreciated and respected. It is saddening to observe that when such a dark time is currently shadowing over Panjab, our so-called Sikhs are still worried about bringing down such Panthic individuals, when the real cults, enemies and anti-Panthic forces are openly trying their best to degrade and humiliate Sikhi. We have fake Saadhs and Babe like “Raam Raheem” trying to imitate Than Guroo Gobind Singh Saahib Jee Maharaaj, Singh’s are becoming Shaheed, but our so-called Sikhs still have their internal agendas, even when the mainstream Panth is the closest to unity and Ekta since a long time. In the present state of affairs in Panjab, Sant Dhadrianwale are also in the forefront of the battle against the “Sacha Sauda” cult. Just recently during the ‘Bandh’ in Panjab, when the Singh’s in Ambala clashed with the Police during the peaceful protest, it was Singh’s of Sant Dhadrianwale’s Jatha, the Nirvair Khalsa Dal (Ambala) that have been injured, just like the first day of this battle against the fake Saadh in Bathinda. We have Panthic Sikhs here who mean good from the heart, but are side-tracked by false media propaganda supported and backed by anti-Panthic agencies... [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 06 Jun 2007

[b]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!! The post by “Harjas Kaur” Penjee is in italics and Dhaas’ humble comments stated below:[/b] ________________________________________________ [i]1. The fact remains that sants exist. This is completely separate from fake santdom which is currently problematic. Because fake santdom is problematic, people need to be extremely cautious and not merely grant labels for sake of granting labels. Where you have an entire Jatha with a tradition of conferring sant labels such as Damdami Taksal, I think respect needs to be given to the Jatha. (I am not a Taksali, but I do support Taksal). You cannot start a Panthic revolution where you undermine completely a tradition within a Jatha simply because you disagree, or because the Indian government has been infiltrating fake babas into the Panth. I too had concerns when people started altering Gurbani to make sant refer only to Sangat in order to eliminate recognition of any sants. This is not an appropriate response to the fake baba thing. It invalidates the pure truth of Gurbani which even common sense shows us that sants exist.[/i] ________________________________________________ You are correct Penjee that there are fake "Sants" out there. A recent example is of Raam Raheem, or there is Asutosh, Bhaniarewala, Narakdharee, Radhasoamee, Naamdharee...etc and others that like to sit on thrones and give their own "Amrit" or "Naam" by proclaiming to be living Sathguroo's, or the other fake "Sants" that lead Sikhs away from the teachings of the Guroo Saahibaan by giving them things such as "Thageh" and "Thaveet"...etc. These are the fake “Sants”, not those who have dedicated their entire life to preach Gurmat and encourage Amrit Sanchaar, who are the true ones. ________________________________________________ [i]2. Dhadrianwale has created problems for himself when the video surfaced of him allowing people to mata tek to him, and dressing up in overly fancy outfits replete with jewelry, decorative chains and (okay, I wont say kalgi but sure looks like one to me) baubles dangling from his khanda.[/i] ________________________________________________ Sant Dhadrianwale never created no problem for himself, the Nindaks, the anti-Panthic agencies and those with bad ‘Karams’ created their own problem by twisting facts and generating false propaganda, like the Canadian “Shaved-face-want-to-be-Sikhs” from the Des Pardes programme or the Darshan Professor who lied to the Panth and in the Hazoori of Sree Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj that Sant Dhadrianwale was wearing a Kalgi. He did however admit that he was wrong later on live radio. They (Sant Dhadrianwale) wore a “shiny” Chola ONCE; the reason behind this was established in the famous Canadian radio conversation between Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Khalsa and ex-Jathedhaar of Akal Thakat Darshan Singh. ________________________________________________ [i]Even on his website he is wearing pearl necklace.[/i] ________________________________________________ Never seen them wearing a “Pearl Necklace” before, it is normally just a nice normal Mala. Again, this is speculation and guesswork over very minor (in fact in this case, nothing at all) issues Penjee that the Panth can do without in this time. ________________________________________________ [i]By placing several professional photo shots of himself on the website, plus his kirtan comes across as egotistical and self-promoting.[/i] ________________________________________________ Do you think they have time to go to studios and get “Professional Photo shots of himself” taken? They are on the go 24-7 hours a day (pretty much), with daily on going Samagams in the presence of Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj and Amrit Sanchaar’s being organised everywhere in India. It is recording companies such as “T-Series” or “Emm Pee” that have their photographers in Diwaans that take them while Baba Jee is in the Diwaan or on the go, or it is other Gursikhs who have the knowledge of taking good photographs, then other Gursikhs that like to edit these and put them on websites. Its very simple and nothing to do with “Professional Photography” in the context that has been mentioned. Once again, speculation and guesswork over very minor (if even anything at all) issues that the Panth can do without. Keertan cannot come across as “egoistical” and “self-promoting”, the Katha of Sikh philosophy and history in the Panth is nothing that can be “egoistical” and there is no room for “self-promoting” in massive Diwaans, filled with Chardhee Kalaa Singh’s, in the presence of SathGuroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj. Dhaas has seen hundreds of Diwaans on DVD, as well as live in India and abroad. This impression has never been made to people in India or abroad, otherwise the Diwaan halls would be empty after the first Samagams in any place or country. The only thing that Sant Dhadrianwale “promotes” is Gurmat, and the taking of Amrit. ________________________________________________ [i]Because he has been doing these things, he draws legitimate criticism. I am not condemning him. I simply do not trust him because of these things. Time will tell what the truth is about him. I cannot accuse him of anything beyond mistakes we know he has done, and I do not. But to accuse that people cannot exercise the faculties of their own critical analysis of someone who has already had problems is asking for blind faith. It simply won't happen. Most people will view him with a critical eye. He has done some good things.[/i] ________________________________________________ Dhaas agrees that time will tell (to most it is already obvious), that who is the true Panthic personality and who is the fake? Who is the one that is preaching Gurmat and who is the one claiming to be a living SathGuroo, preaching their own Manmat? Who is the one encouraging the taking of Dasmesh Pithaa Jee’s Amrit and who is the one making their own Amrit? Who is the one preaching the fact to read and contemplate on the Banee in Than Than Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj, and who is the one making up their own Granth for his followers to read? If “most people will view him with a critical eye”, then by now they would have also stopped attending the Samagams organised by the Jatha. But evidently this is not the case in India or abroad; the Sangat is still attending the Diwaans in unparalleled numbers (in the Panth today) and thousands still taking Amrit in India. Sant Ranjit Singh has done many good things at the young age of around 22/23 years. ________________________________________________ [i]The concern is, will he become another government sponsored dera which creates artificial division within the Panth. In other words, by converting so many, is he making his own Sikhs who will support GOI over Panthic interests? Unfortunately, the way the government and RSS are interfering, these are legitimate concerns.[/i] ________________________________________________ If Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Jee is a “fake”, then at least the thousands that take Amrit under their influence are not. The Amrit the thousands per month take is not from him, but from the Panj Pyaare. If he is "Kacha" and “Fake”, at least the Guroo they (the Amritdharee Gursikhs) follow and bow down to in the end after they listen to the Diwaan and take Amrit (Sree Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj) is Pakka and True. The Sangat will attend the Samagam and Diwaan done by Sant Dhadrianwale in the presence of SathGuroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj perhaps once a year? They will receive Guroo Gobind Singh Saahib Jee’s Amrit from the Panj Pyaare only once on the day. Then for the rest of their life they are ultimately going to bow down to Sree Guroo Granth Saahib Jee and follow the Rehat Maryada established by Saahib Sree Guroo Gobind Singh Jee Maharaaj. Sant Dhadrianwale has never got involved in Politics as of yet. The government sponsored Dera’s are blatantly in the open. These are Dera’s like “Sacha Sauda” and the fake Saadh “Raam Raheem”…etc. It is true that the government and RSS is interfering in Sikh affairs, but to label every Sant and Jathebandhee “Government RSS Sponsored” is also wrong when the Jathebandhee’s good and Mahaan Sewa is visible. Dhaas is not comparing Sant Dhadrianwale to the following, every Sant Mahapurkh has been different and unique, but did Sant Isher Singh Jee Rara Saahib Wale turn into a “Government Sponsored Dera”? Did Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee Rampur Khere Wale become an agent of the Government of India and the notorious RSS? People (either the real agents, or those influenced by false media propaganda) claimed that Sant Sipaahee Brehamgianee Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale was an agent of the Congress, was this the case? Of course it was not, but the anti-Panthic agencies did their most greatest to defame Sant Jee Bhindranwale in Panthic circles. It is factual that the government and RSS do not want another Sikh leader to rise or any genuine Sant Mahapurkh to influence thousands upon thousands more people into Sikhi and join the Khalsa, that is why they release the fake Saadhs into the Panth to split it, but nothing is concealed from the Panth and these are also brought to the front. If anyone is fake, it will not be unseen, Guroo Maharaaj himself has set the precedents for this, Singh’s in the past have punished those that have tried to manipulate and insult Gurbani to create their own following. The end of fake Saadh Gurbachana Narakdharee is a prime example. This will always be the case in the future. ________________________________________________ [i]3. By what extreme illogic is anyone using Kala Afghana as an example that anyone here is blaspheming Gursikhi? Kala Afghana is a secularist who accuses Sikh history of being brahmanical fairytales, challenges the authority of the Rehit Maryada, invalidates the Dasam Granth as bani, undermines the legitimacy of Damdami Taksal. If anyone is closer to Kala Afghana, it is someone who undermines the legitimate Gursikhi jeevan of Damdami Taksal. Even if someone does not agree with Bhindranwale as being a sant, I don't accuse that person of being like a blasphemer. He has a right to his own opinion, which is not anti-Panthic. Although in justice to Damdami Taksal, and to millions within the Panth, Bhindranwale is a recognized shaheed AND sant. Even the fact he was a shaheed should give him respect among the Panth regardless of the political situation, unless you are a supporter of the government of India and justify the attack on Harmandir Sahib. Now people are really starting to do nindya when they accuse of being like Kala Afghana. Not only is it a lie, it is an irresponsible and illogical comparison made only because of the extreme power to discredit someone by linking them to an excommunicated anti-Panthic author.[/i] ________________________________________________ This being aimed at a different poster, but yes true (most of it I think?), linking Kala Afghana to anything in the Panth is illogical. Denying the title of Sant to one of the most greatest Sant Sipaahee’s of all time, the 14th Jathdhaar of Guroo Gobind Singh Maharaaj Jee’s Damdami Taksaal is unsound and in Dhaas’ opinion inhumanely against Sikhism. Sant Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale is now a part of Sikhism. ________________________________________________ [i]4. Even if I draw criticism here, I'm going to say it because it needs to be said. But there are sants in all religions. And it is obvious who they are by the way they live their lives. Even their photographs are glowing. This is not to say we should hero-worship them, make a cult of personality to them, or even seek out their counsel and blessing if it takes us away from the Sikh Panth. We have everything we need in Gurbani and sangat. But to deny the reality of sants is not in accord with the truth. Extraordinarily good and holy people should be respected. You are known by your deeds. This is what we are all supposed to be becoming, great lights. It will be a point of ridicule if every other religion in the world has the power to make sants, but Sikh religion refuses to acknowledge any sants or that anyone can become a light.[/i] ________________________________________________ Unless Dhaas is mistaken here, you have earlier said that Sants do exist, Sant Bhindranwale was one, and that Gurbani says they do as well, but now are saying Sikhism “refuses to acknowledge any Sants”? Again, if this is the case, Gurbani says the opposite. Large sections of SathGuroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj are dedicated to Sant Mahapurkhs. If Dhaas has misunderstood you, then ignore this comment and forgive Dhaas. [b]This post has not been directed at just “Harjas Kaur” Penjee, but at others as well. It does not matter what a very few people in the Panth think or claim about the title "Sant", the fact of the matter is, the Mahapurkhs that have come and gone have always been referred to as SANTs and will always be called SANTs in Sikh History for generations to come! Nothing can change that, no matter what people think in their own minds. Dhaas apologises if this post is misunderstood as against Gurmat in anyway or against anyone. Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/b] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 06 Jun 2007

[b]Why has the person is question still not answered Veer "Khalistan_Zindabad" Jee's question?[/b] It is shameful how people can refer to one of the greatest people to ever walk this earth without the Sant title. The Sant-title Nindaks should note that no matter what they say or refer to Sant Jee Bhindranwale as, “Jarnail Singh”, “Bhai” or whatever…etc (apologies for mentioning Sant Jee’s name in that manner), history and the world will remember and refer to the great Sant Sipaahee as SANT Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale. Nindaks who think they should not be called SANT and that Sant ''Baba Jarnail Singh was a Singh like many before him. Lets leave it at that'' need to wake up. Believe it or not, even till this day their Parchaar is still going on. Many Sikhs are still taking Amrit because of their influence, their speech recordings and Katha Diwaans, the biography of their Jeevan, and because of their very birth into this world. Sikh youth around the world are wearing t-shirts and clothing bearing their divine words and images. It is too late to “leave it as that” now; they are officially the greatest Sikh of the 20th Century. People who think Sant Jee Bhindranwale was not a SANT and were not unique are blinded and fooled by either false media propaganda or the wrong Sangat around them. Regardless of what you think about where they are now, sorry to ruin the day for the Nindaks, Sant Jee Bhindranwale are a LIVING SOURCE OF INSPIRATION for generations and generations to come! Nindaks of Sants, WAKE UP from your doze and pray to Vaheguroo Jee to open your blinded eyes - This is what the Panth will always remember the great Sant Sipaahee as: [b]THAN THAN MAHAPURKH BREHAMGIANEE SANT BABA JARNAIL SINGH JEE KHALSA BHINDRANWALE (14th Jathedhaar of Damdami Taksaal)[/b] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

jassmannn · 07 Jun 2007

Bazzer, totally agree with you mate. You seem to hit the nail on the head. Keep it up mate!!

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Bazzer · 07 Jun 2007

<<< And that is exactly my point. Guru sahib came to this world to help us. Gurbani speaks to us directly. Why do you want someone to get in between you and guru sahib? >>> If you feel that you have the spiritual intellect to understand the deeper meanings of Gurbani then you obviously do not need the assistance of a Mahapurkh. If you know the true path and how to traverse it then you do not need a mahapurkh for assistance. If you know all the techniques to improve your spiritual meditation then you do not need the assistance of a mahapurkh. If you can sit in a quite place and do Naam Simran with “ek man ek chitt“ then you do not need the assistance of a mahapurkh. If you can take a single pangti of gurbani and do abviaas on it for half an hour then you do not need the assistance of a mahapurkh. If you have such khoje of gurbani and have such deep knowledge of Gurbani then you do not need the assistance of a mahpurkh. For the rest of us moorakhs we shall seek out the sangat of such mahapursh. <<< If you have trouble understanding gurbani then go do santhiya in sangat because Sangat is also roop of guru.>>> True, Sangat is Guru Roop, but if there is no naam abviasee in the Sangat, then what? The other day I went to Gurudawara Sahib Ji and there were a few singhs sat in dewan, all young, four with short hair. They are also sangat, if I had asked them a deep gurbani question they would not be able to answer it. A child is given many text books when he is at school, he can go away a read them but at some point he will need the assistance of a teacher. Why? Because the teacher has already walked the path, he knows the knowledge, he knows the pit falls, he knows because he has experienced it himself. In the same way a Sant is like a teacher he can show you the way because he has already walked that path. How can you understand something you have little knowledge of? A child is given a text on quadratic equations, how can he understand this when he is only learning how to add and subtract? He will need a teacher. <<< Gurbani tells us how to be good Sikhs. Gurbani tells us how to control kaam krod lobh moh ahankar, gurbani tells us how to get the things we need in material life, gurbani tells us how to be happy both in this world and the next...>>> You have obviously mastered all these techniques and have a deep understanding so you do not need a mahapurkh. <<< What exactly can Dhadrian wala tell you that Guru Sahib can't??? >>>> Just go ask the thousands who have listened to his kathaas and have taken Amrit and become Singhs, <<<< Gurbani and naam have made real chardi kala walay gursikhs like baba deep singh jee. Any kamaiee that someone has done has been because of BAni. Then why go to someone else who has used bani to get avastha when you get the avastha yourself???? >>> Becaue they can help you get to that avastha, because they have already walked that path, you think they did not get assistance from earlier Mahapurkhs when they first started out ??? [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 07 Jun 2007

...Once again the, "there are no Sants" Nindaks are changing their mind and stories. They state something in one post, then can't prove or answer in the next and completely change their tone. There are many people in the Panth today who seem to be confused and cannot make their mind up...May Vaheguroo Jee do Kirpa and bring Ekta in the Panth... [b]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/b] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalsaspirit · 07 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Nirvair Khalsa's Quote "It is shameful how people can refer to one of the greatest people to ever walk this earth without the Sant title." Nirvair Khalsa jio your high sentiment for a Gursikh personality is good. But do not forget Sants did not come to this earth only in 20th century. There were Sants since Guru Sahib's times and they did not require the title to be recognized as Sant. Well if you like to rewrite the whole history with Sant name before every Gursikh came to this earth then go ahead and do that but make sure you are responsible for but you are trying to do. We will give a short list of greatest Gursikhs who also walked this earth: 1. Baba Budha jee 2. Bhai Sahib Bhai Gurdass jee 3. Piyare Bhai Dya Singh jee 4. Piyare Bhai Dharam Singh jee 5. Piyare Bhai Sahib Singh jee 6. Piyare Bhai Mohkam Singh jee 7. Piyare Bhai Himmat Singh jee 8. Baba Ajit Singh jee 9. Baba Zuzar Singh jee 10. Baba Zoravar Singh jee 11. Baba Fateh Singh 12. Bhai Mani Singh Jee 13. Bhai Gurbakash Singh jee (Baba Banda Singh Bhadur) 14. Baba Deep Singh jee 15. Baba Phoola Singh ji 16. Bhai Bachitter Singh jee 17. Sardar Bhai Hari Singh Nalua And countless others. Do you have doubt that they were not Saint or Saint Soldiers? Again you are totally illogical here. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalsaspirit · 07 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, 1) For Zindabad Murdabad jio As per understanding of somesingh ji for following gurbani tuk ----------------------------------------------------------- Author: SomeSingh Date: 06-05-07 10:14 " Gurbani it says that only one mahapursh can know the state of another." Gurbani does not state this anywhere. It states Bhramgyani ki gatt bhramgyani na jae (bhul chuk maaf for romanisation mistakes)." ---------------------------------------------------------- So Zindabad Murdabad jio for your question Quote"how about bhai sahib bhai randheer singh jee khalsa giving the status of SANT to Bhai Juallaa Singh jee, calling him SANT jualla singh jee?" your were answered alreaday by somesingh ji. 2) For Nirvair Khalsa jio Thanks for your long ad of new Dera but your grant for Santgiri to this Dera by misusing the credibility of a Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh jee is very suspicious. Secondly there are millions of followers who likes their kind of Baba ji but not the other's Baba(Sant). Not to go far the prime example is even within this topic. Re-read this -------------------------------------------------------------------- Author: jassmannn Date: 06-05-07 07:55 Nirvair Khalsa, Sant Baba Nand Singh Ji maharaaj lived the kind of Jeevan that can warrant the term 'Sant'. Bhinderawale was too embroiled in politics, and if you look at the history of how he became involved with congress, then rebel and then there is the famous point where he slept in a room above the guru sahib saying something along the lines of 'desperate times call for desperate measures', and also taking refuge in the Golden Temple, to cause all that damage and disrespect at the holiest of Sikh shrines. I do not doubt that Jarnail Singh did a lot of path and I'm sure he had kamaiyaa, but after all of that and everything that has happened you cannot put Sant Baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaaj in the same category. Totally totally not appropriate. -------------------------------------------------------------------- And we can tell you there are millions who have same trouble. Why your new dera has problem with Dera pehowa who has millions of followers and there Sant is Man Singh. Adversiting a dera as you did is fine but where you draw the line granting SANT? 3) For Jassman jio Why you have trouble with Sant Jarnail Singh ji Bhindrawale enlisted with others? 4) For Some Singh jio You have not answered our question. Should be assume you found already what we like to point out in that question. If answer is yes then we would not ask you further. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 07 Jun 2007

[b]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/b] [b]Veer “Khalsa Spirit” Jee, you posted the following:[/b] ___________________________________________________ [i]Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Nirvair Khalsa's Quote "It is shameful how people can refer to one of the greatest people to ever walk this earth without the Sant title." Nirvair Khalsa jio your high sentiment for a Gursikh personality is good. But do not forget Sants did not come to this earth only in 20th century. There were Sants since Guru Sahib's times and they did not require the title to be recognized as Sant. Well if you like to rewrite the whole history with Sant name before every Gursikh came to this earth then go ahead and do that but make sure you are responsible for but you are trying to do. We will give a short list of greatest Gursikhs who also walked this earth: 1. Baba Budha jee 2. Bhai Sahib Bhai Gurdass jee 3. Piyare Bhai Dya Singh jee 4. Piyare Bhai Dharam Singh jee 5. Piyare Bhai Sahib Singh jee 6. Piyare Bhai Mohkam Singh jee 7. Piyare Bhai Himmat Singh jee 8. Baba Ajit Singh jee 9. Baba Zuzar Singh jee 10. Baba Zoravar Singh jee 11. Baba Fateh Singh 12. Bhai Mani Singh Jee 13. Bhai Gurbakash Singh jee (Baba Banda Singh Bhadur) 14. Baba Deep Singh jee 15. Baba Phoola Singh ji 16. Bhai Bachitter Singh jee 17. Sardar Bhai Hari Singh Nalua And countless others. Do you have doubt that they were not Saint or Saint Soldiers? Again you are totally illogical here. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh[/i] ___________________________________________________ Veer "Khalsa Spirit" Jee, I agree with all the names of the Mahaan GurSikhs of the past you have mentioned. Whether they were named Sant at the time or not, indeed they were Sant Sipaahee's - no doubt, however there is also no doubt that Brehamgianee Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale was also the same, just like Sant Gurbachan Singh Jee, Sant Isher Singh Jee, Sant Kartar Singh Jee...etc before them. Sant Jee Bhindranwale called them Sant/Brehamgianee/Mahapurkhs, and after Sant Jee, GurSikhs and other Mahapurkhs also call them Sant.....the greatest Sikh of the 20th Century.....there is nothing we can do about this now anyway, like it or not, Sant Jee Bhindranwale will be known as SANT Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale in the history books throughout the world for the future generations to come... [b]In your second post Veer “Khalsa Spirit” Jee, you put forward the following, which Dhaas has split a few times:[/b] ___________________________________________________ [i]2) For Nirvair Khalsa jio Thanks for your long ad of new Dera but your grant for Santgiri to this Dera by misusing the credibility of a Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh jee is very suspicious.[/i] ___________________________________________________ If you think Dhaas has advertised a “dera”, you have either read wrong or misunderstood greatly. Everything written is not any “ad”, but all straightforward fact. You say Dhaas has misused credibility of Sant Jee Bhindranwale to give Sant status to Sant Dhadrianwale? Again, you have followed a different plot altogether.....You think calling Sant Jee Bhindranwale by the title SANT is misusing their credibility, but fact is, they are called Brehamgianee SANT Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale by the whole world, not just Dhaas! Is the whole world misusing their credibility? – Doubt it very much! Furthermore, Dhaas does not need to grant Sant Ranjit Singh Dhadrianwale the SANT title, as like Sant Mahapurkhs before them, they have already earned this title from the Sikh Sangat around the world. No matter where they go in the world, whatever Gurdwara Saahib in the world, the stage secretary will call them SANT, the Sangat will call them SANT, and whoever meets them calls them SANT. Again, Dhaas is not the only one, but hundreds of thousands around the world have “granted” the SANT title to Sant Ranjit Singh Jee Khalsa Dhadrianwale. ___________________________________________________ [i]Secondly there are millions of followers who likes their kind of Baba ji but not the other's Baba(Sant). Not to go far the prime example is even within this topic. Re-read this -------------------------------------------------------------------- Author: jassmannn Date: 06-05-07 07:55 Nirvair Khalsa, Sant Baba Nand Singh Ji maharaaj lived the kind of Jeevan that can warrant the term 'Sant'. Bhinderawale was too embroiled in politics, and if you look at the history of how he became involved with congress, then rebel and then there is the famous point where he slept in a room above the guru sahib saying something along the lines of 'desperate times call for desperate measures', and also taking refuge in the Golden Temple, to cause all that damage and disrespect at the holiest of Sikh shrines. I do not doubt that Jarnail Singh did a lot of path and I'm sure he had kamaiyaa, but after all of that and everything that has happened you cannot put Sant Baba Nand Singh Ji Maharaaj in the same category. Totally totally not appropriate. -------------------------------------------------------------------- And we can tell you there are millions who have same trouble.[/i] ___________________________________________________ Dhaas does not think that any type of “jealousy” is present in the post by “Jassmannn” Jee, as you have implied, but certainly there is gross misunderstanding of Brehamgianee Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale, either because of wrong Sangat misleading or the wrong information, or perhaps just arrogance. The only thing Dhaas agrees with in that post is that Sant Baba Nand Singh Jee lived the kind of Jeevan that can warrant the term “Sant”. The rest of the post by “Jassmannn” Jee Dhaas does not agree with even 0.1% as it is incorrect, false and an example of Government RSS type of fake propaganda influence at work. ___________________________________________________ [i]Why your new dera has problem with Dera pehowa who has millions of followers and there Sant is Man Singh.[/i] ___________________________________________________ First it is not Dhaas’ “new dera”. Second, there is no such thing as “Dera Pehowa”, there are no followers of “Dera Pehowa”, but just Amritdharee Gursikhs influenced by the Parchaar of Sant Baba Maan Singh, and those “millions”, as you put it, are followers of Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj as they have received Than Than Guroo Gobind Singh Saahib Jee’s Amrit. You may be getting confused with “Dera Sacha Sauda” and their fake Saadh Baba “Raam Raheem”. Thirdly, Dhaas does not know of any “problem” between either, as you have put it, “Dera”…again this is speculation and rumour to make divides in the Khalsa Panth. ___________________________________________________ [i]Adversiting a dera as you did is fine but where you draw the line granting SANT?[/i] ___________________________________________________ Like Dhaas mentioned earlier, this is a mistake from your end and a misunderstanding regarding any “advertising” of a “Dera”. There is nothing to advertise and no benefit gained by doing so. “Granting Sant” has been explained above, that Dhaas does not need to “grant” Sant Ranjit Singh Dhadrianwale the SANT title, as like Sant Mahapurkhs before them, they have already earned this title from the Sikh Sangat around the world. No matter where they go in the world, whatever Gurdwara Saahib in the world, the stage secretary will call them SANT, the Sangat will call them SANT, and whoever meets them calls them SANT. Again, Dhaas is not the only one, but hundreds of thousands around the world have “granted” the SANT title to Sant Ranjit Singh Jee Khalsa Dhadrianwale. Dhaas does not need to “advertise” anything on a forum just to “grant” a title that they already have got by the Sangat. “Where you draw line granting SANT?” - Dhaas guesses only the SANGAT can draw the line, not any individual... [b][i]Humble apologies for any misunderstanding or harsh words used against anyone. Please forgive and correct Dhaas.[/i][/b] [b]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/b] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

S-Singh · 08 Jun 2007

>>Author: Bazzer Date: 06-05-07 14:27 >Khatarnak Times Saab Ji, >If Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself came and stood infront of you lot you would still do nindhia, that is the level you are at. You say you have Guru Granth Sabhib Ji and need none else, who actually follows what guru Ji says ? this is exactly what Guru Granth Sahib Ji says, >Sukhmani Sahib Ji, astpathai 15 : >Sant Ki dhoot kar isnaam, sant koe jai-ya kurbaan sant ki sewa wadbhagi pie-yah, sant ki sewa naam dhiyaya (sorry for the roman translation) Well done bazzer for completely missuing Gurbani. Please enlighten me further and tell me what the term Sant has been used for ? Did Guru Ji use it for the current lot of Sant Samaj members like Sant Bheva and Sant Jagera of Ludhiana or even this Sirsa guy who calls himself Sant Ram Rahim ? These Sant Samaj wale are not Guru Ji. Do you think Guru Ji made big fundemental mistakes ? Dhadrian wale has had to back track and apologise on more than one occassion for mistakes he has made. It is strange why the Sant Samaj brigade never quote the following Shabad by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Aasaa on Pannaa 476. gaj saadtae thai thai dhhotheeaa thiharae paaein thag || They wear loin cloths, three and a half yards long, and triple-wound sacred threads. galee jinhaa japamaaleeaa lottae hathh nibag || They have rosaries around their necks, and they carry glittering jugs in their hands. oue har kae sa(n)th n aakheeahi baanaaras kae t(h)ag ||1|| They are not called Saints of the Lord - they are thugs of Benares. ||1|| aisae sa(n)th n mo ko bhaavehi || Such 'saints' are not pleasing to me; ddaalaa sio paeddaa gattakaavehi ||1|| rehaao || they eat the trees along with the branches. ||1||Pause|| baasan maa(n)j charaavehi oopar kaat(h)ee dhhoe jalaavehi || They wash their pots and pans before putting them on the stove, and they wash the wood before lighting it. basudhhaa khodh karehi dhue choolaeh saarae maanas khaavehi ||2|| They dig up the earth and make two fireplaces, but they eat the whole person! ||2|| oue paapee sadhaa firehi aparaadhhee mukhahu aparas kehaavehi || Those sinners continually wander in evil deeds, while they call themselves touch-nothing saints. sadhaa sadhaa firehi abhimaanee sagal kutta(n)b ddubaavehi ||3|| They wander around forever and ever in their self-conceit, and all their families are drowned. ||3|| jith ko laaeiaa thith hee laagaa thaisae karam kamaavai || He is attached to that, to which the Lord has attached him, and he acts accordingly. kahu kabeer jis sathigur bhaettai punarap janam n aavai ||4||2|| Says Kabeer, one who meets the True Guru, is not reincarnated again. ||4||2||

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Bazzer · 08 Jun 2007

S-singh <<< It is strange why the Sant Samaj brigade never quote the following Shabad by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Aasaa on Pannaa 476. >>> How would you know this ????? How can you possibly know this? Are you with them 100% of the time? so how do you know they have never quoted this shabad ?

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

SomeSingh · 08 Jun 2007

<<< It is strange why the Sant Samaj brigade never quote the following Shabad by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Aasaa on Pannaa 476. >>> Go to http://gurmatveechar.com/katha.php and listen to Baba Gurbachan Singh ji's katha on Pannaa 476. There may be other katha's on this there if you want an alternate explanation. If you're still not satisfied, go to sfsikhcenter.org and listen to sant Giani Thakur Singh ji's katha of Guru Granth Sahib ji.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalsaspirit · 08 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Nirvair khalsa jio Good! Now you are on same page with us A) Quote ""Khalsa Spirit" Jee, I agree with all the names of the Mahaan GurSikhs of the past you have mentioned. Whether they were named Sant at the time or not, indeed they were Sant Sipaahee's - no doubt". Now this means if those Gursikhs without Sant title were fully recognizable by you as Sant Sipaahee's then khalsa jio [gurbani]Awp jI dy[/gurbani]following previous bachan "It is shameful how people can refer to one of the greatest people to ever walk this earth without the Sant title". Now wouldn't they imply on you also! Or you like to change those bachans. B) Quote "Dhaas guesses only the SANGAT can draw the line, not any individual..." That’s what we were trying to say, SANGAT drew the line since last 300 years as per above list we gave you. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

S-Singh · 08 Jun 2007

>>S-singh <<< It is strange why the Sant Samaj brigade never quote the following Shabad by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Aasaa on Pannaa 476. >>> >>How would you know this ????? How can you possibly know this? Are you with them 100% of the time? so how do you know they have never quoted this shabad ? Come on please enlighten me and show me when Dhadrian or Bheva have used the shabad. The Sant Samaj are a big joke, they cannot agree on a common rehat maryada yet are able to brainwash people into thinking that they are one with Waheguru. Please explain why the Sant Samaj cannot get a few of their top guys together and go directly find out from Waheguru what the rehat maryada should be. After all they are self assumed Saints and as such should have direct contact with Waheguru. Please read Shabad Hazara and decipher for yourself who the title Sant was used for. It certainly was not for the Sant Samaj wale headed by Dhuma. The words Gur Sant were used to refer to Guru Ji ! Do you seriouly think these guys deserve a prefix that was used to describe Guru Ji ?

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 08 Jun 2007

[b]Veer “Khalsa Spirit” Jee,[/b] You say: ____________________________________________ [i]A) Quote ""Khalsa Spirit" Jee, I agree with all the names of the Mahaan GurSikhs of the past you have mentioned. Whether they were named Sant at the time or not, indeed they were Sant Sipaahee's - no doubt". Now this means if those Gursikhs without Sant title were fully recognizable by you as Sant Sipaahee's then khalsa jio Awp jI dyfollowing previous bachan "It is shameful how people can refer to one of the greatest people to ever walk this earth without the Sant title". Now wouldn't they imply on you also! Or you like to change those bachans.[/i] ____________________________________________ I stand by my original post where I quote: [i]”Veer "Khalsa Spirit" Jee, I agree with all the names of the Mahaan GurSikhs of the past you have mentioned. Whether they were named Sant at the time or not, indeed they were Sant Sipaahee's - no doubt, however there is also no doubt that Brehamgianee Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale was also the same, just like Sant Gurbachan Singh Jee, Sant Isher Singh Jee, Sant Kartar Singh Jee...etc before them. Sant Jee Bhindranwale called them Sant/Brehamgianee/Mahapurkhs, and after Sant Jee, GurSikhs and other Mahapurkhs also call them Sant.....the greatest Sikh of the 20th Century.....there is nothing we can do about this now anyway, like it or not, Sant Jee Bhindranwale will be known as SANT Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale in the history books throughout the world for the future generations to come...”[/i] Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale has been called a SANT by the whole of the Panth. This should be respected. They were one of the greatest people to ever walk this earth, and the title which the Panth calls them, which they WERE, should not be challenged, but respected. It is not a good thing if the whole Panth, including Chardhee Kalaa Gursikhs have referred to Sant Jee Bhindranwale in such a respected manner, called them SANT Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale, then if someone comes and refers to them as “Jarnail Singh” or “was just a Singh like many before him” or whatever, it is an obvious sign of disrespect if looked at logically. What gives that person the authority to say that such a Mahaan Gursikh who woke a sleeping nation should not be called a SANT? No one here can even compare to the Mahapurkhs mentioned, Mahapurkhs such as Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale. Then you say: ____________________________________________ [i]B) Quote "Dhaas guesses only the SANGAT can draw the line, not any individual..." That’s what we were trying to say, SANGAT drew the line since last 300 years as per above list we gave you.[/i] ____________________________________________ In the last 300 years the Sangat has also used the title SANT to Brehamgianee’s such as Sant Baba Nand Singh Jee Kaleran Wale, Sant Baba Isher Singh Jee Rare Wale, Sant Baba Pooran Singh Jee, Sant Baba Gurbachan Singh Jee Bhindranwale, Sant Baba Isher Singh Nanaksar Wale, Sant Baba Kartar Singh Jee Bhindranwale, Sant Baba Harnaam Singh Jee Rampur Khere Wale, Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale…etc etc. Putting everything to one side, are we trying to say that the above Gursikhs mentioned did NOT deserve the SANT title (which they have already got know anyway)? I do not think this is the case. No one here can even think they were anywhere close to any of the above Gursikhs. Their Naam Kamayee was immense, their Jeevan cannot be compared. If these great Gursikhs called others SANT or BREHAMGIANEE, then how can fools like us think they did not deserve or should not be called SANT. The greatest Sikh of the 20th Century, he who woke the sleeping nation, inspired generations of Sikhs and generations to come, Mahapurkh Brehamgianee Sree Maan Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale referred to Sant Baba Gurbachan Singh Jee Khalsa Bhindranwale as SANT and BREHAMGIANEE, they referred to Sant Baba Kartar Singh Jee as SANT, if the greatest Sikh of the 20th Century did not question their status of SANT, then who are we fools to even think of doing such a thing. Like Veer “Khalistan_Zindabad” Jee has said earlier, even Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Jee gave the SANT title to Bhai Juallaa Singh Jee, referring to them as Sant Juallaa Singh Jee. Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Jee, we do not even need to discuss their Mahaan Jeevan, and they gave the SANT title to another Gursikh. Are we greater than them, such a GEM of the Panth that shines in Sikh history, so do we have more knowledge and Gyaan if a Gursikh should be referred to as a SANT or not more than them – Bhai Saahib Bhai Randheer Singh Jee? If anyone thinks that then they have serious brain damage and are not a SIKH, full-stop. Everyone has their own respected views and Dhaas thinks this topic and discussion will not conclude anywhere… [b]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/b] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 08 Jun 2007

The Sangat and history can distinguish who is the true Panthic personality and who is the fake? Who is the one that is preaching Gurmat and who is the one claiming to be a living SathGuroo, preaching their own Manmat? Who is the one encouraging the taking of Dasmesh Pithaa Jee’s Amrit and who is the one making their own Amrit? Who is the one preaching the fact to read and contemplate on the Banee in Than Than Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj, and who is the one making up their own Granth for his followers to read? Like Dhaas has said earlier, those who are fake, it will not be unseen and hidden from the Khalsa. Guroo Maharaaj himself has set the precedents for this, Singh’s in the past have punished those that have tried to manipulate and insult Gurbani to create their own following. The end of fake Saadh Gurbachana Narakdharee is a prime example. This will always be the case in the future. Yes, there are many self-proclaimed fakes, but these are always brought into the open. A recent example is of Raam Raheem, or there is Asutosh, Bhaniarewala, Narakdharee, Radhasoamee, Naamdharee...etc and others that like to sit on thrones and give their own "Amrit" or "Naam" by proclaiming to be living Sathguroo's, or the other fake "Sants" that lead Sikhs away from the teachings of the Guroo Saahibaan by giving them things such as "Thageh" and "Thaveet"...etc. NOT ONE of the these can be compared to the Sant Mahapurkhs mentioned in this topic above, these are the fake “Sants”, not those who have dedicated their entire life to preach Gurmat and encourage Amrit Sanchaar, who are the true ones……… [b][url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MqnF9LavI2Y[/url][/b] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianw

confused · 09 Jun 2007

my question to all is this....does Bhai Sahib Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale's jeevan suffer if he is not referred to as sant...is he in sachkhand suffering because people arent calling him sant...if in fact it is paap to boast about something that we cannot know to be true (no disrespect to bhai sahib) then why take a risk...by referring to someone that is living as sant jee, we are risking their ego...they may say "oh people think im a sant, i can do whatever whenever" this will eventually destroy them inside to maya...just avoid it for the living...after they are gone and passed it is your decision what you refer to them as and once again no disrespect to Bhai Sahib, everytime you say Dhan Dhan Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale jin sutee kaum jaagaee...you could be saying dhan any of Guru Jee's Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Nanak Dev Sahib Jee, Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Angad Dev Sahib Jee, Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Amar Das Sahib Jee, Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Ram Das Sahib Jee, Dhan Dhan Sr Guru Arjan Dev Sahib Jee, Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee, Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Har Rai Sahib Jee, Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Harkrishan Sahib Jee, Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib Jee, Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee, Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee because Bhai Sahib may have awaken the kaum but without our Pyaarai Guru Sahib Jee's there wouldnt have been any kaum to awaken gurumukh naanuk aaraadhiaa sabh aakhuhu dhunn dhunn dhunn gur soee As Gurmukh, Nanak worships and adores the Lord; let everyone proclaim, ""Blessed, blessed, blessed is He, the Guru!""||29||1||Sudh||

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

SomeSingh · 09 Jun 2007

Actually, your understanding of this is incorrect. There are those sikhs who use 'bhai' to refer to sants. but in discussion they will say that bhai xxx is a true sant, or is a true bhramgyani. So you see, they do refer to them as sant. And, when you think about it, arguing about such a topic diverts people from important issues. I think it's fine either way, whether you use the title or not. But if you have a serious problem with people using the title, I suggest you take a look at yourself - why do you have such a problem with this? why are you making such a fuss over a non-issue? Nothing wrong with doing vichaar on it, but making a fuss only seems to create divisions, which it looks like people who make a fuss UNINTENTIONALLY do.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 10 Jun 2007

Dhaas agrees with Veer "SomeSingh" Jee. Everyone has their own opinion, but at the moment there are much bigger problems in the Panth that need to be addressed... Galthee Maarf Karnee! Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!! [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalsaspirit · 10 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, 1) For Nirvair Khalsa jio, Quote "I stand by my original post where I quote:” This is expected from a chela and advertisers because if they change their views they will loose the business. [gurbani]rotIAw kwrix pUrih qwl ][/gurbani] rotteeaa kaaran poorahah taal || They beat the drums for the sake of bread. NOW LISTEN CAREFULLY Shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh ji died for kaum in 1984 and since then he is famously known as shaheed Sant Jarnail Singh ji or Shaheed baba Jarnail Singh jee. Now until your baba die for the kaum under gurmat till then manipulating claims from advertisers under the credibility of Baba Jarnail Singh jee will be remain suspicious. And when this baba will attain that moment then kaum will decide what to title him as Baba, Sant etc till then keep advertising for him to have more business. 2) For Somesingh jio, Seems like you have a meter to tell right way who is Brahmgiani, Mahapurakh, Sant blah blah but you did not answer our question yet. What happened to your meter now? Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

SomeSingh · 12 Jun 2007

Baba Thakur Singh ji was a bhramgyani. Sant Jarnail Singh ji himself referred to Baba ji as a Bhramgyani. I have other reasons for my belief as well, but these are private. and no, I don't have a "meter". But I have been lucky enough to have a lot of sangat with different sants, overtime one gets a feel for the real ones.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalsaspirit · 12 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Somesingh jio, Quote "I have other reasons for my belief as well, but these are private. and no, I don't have a "meter"." Now you have to change even your belief meter because previously you said Quote "Even then, as we all know, the bachan of a bhramgyani, will come true. by giving bachan to another they could enable a person to be able to recognise who is a bhramgyani." Now whole panth knows how the bachan of bhramgyani recognised by you found to be completly false which we do not have to mention here. So it is very clear that for publicity stunt of a dera how titling the Brahmgiani, Mahapurkh, Sant etc etc were put before names to those who do not even deserve it. Jago Jago Guru kay Sikho. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

SomeSingh · 12 Jun 2007

"Now you have to change even your belief meter because previously you said" no, i never. Reread my post.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalsaspirit · 13 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Brahamgiani Somesingh jio, Quote "no, i never. Reread my post." We think you have also developed the habit of lying by listening to liars. Now you are denying that you did not say this! Come on SomeSingh jio open your eyes. Re-read your post which you posted earlier in this topic in which you mentioned those bachans. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Author: SomeSingh Date: 06-05-07 10:14 " Gurbani it says that only one mahapursh can know the state of another." Gurbani does not state this anywhere. It states Bhramgyani ki gatt bhramgyani na jae (bhul chuk maaf for romanisation mistakes). Even then, as we all know, the bachan of a bhramgyani, will come true. by giving bachan to another they could enable a person to be able to recognise who is a bhramgyani. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Now every one knows who wrote that and how easily the denials of some thing can be made by liars. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

SomeSingh · 13 Jun 2007

khalsaspirit, you need to understand what was written instead of attacking what you believe was written. A bhramgyani is a mahapursh, but not all mahapursh are bhramgyani. That's why I wrote what I wrote. Additionally, the bachan of a bhramgyani comes true. So surely a bhramgyani, who is one with the Guru, could confer the power of recognizing bhramgyanis onto someone? And I never said that such a power had been conferred onto me, it hasn't. If you still think I did after reading my posts, than I suggest you learn how to properly read english, or maybe take a few deep breaths so that you're not in a self-righteous rage when you read the post.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalsaspirit · 13 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Brahamgiani SomeSingh jio, After your falisified claim of Brahamgiani now you developed another defination of Mahapurkh. Kirpa karo Brahmgiani jio you are the one running the self-righteous rage even we proved you that to whom you granted as a Brahmgiani, he found to false on his bachans. Guru Mehar Karay aap ji Brahmgiani hee Rahoo. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 13 Jun 2007

What happened to this discussion? There is no point in even replying to “KhalsaSpirit” Jee's posts no more, he ‘thinks’ Dhaas is "advertising"??? No appropriate and justified response could be made, so he has come to the conclusion this is an “advertisement”. It is good that the Khalsa should so Vichaar on Sikh principles, but when people start to go off-topic, making personal accusations and calling others “advertisers” for a “baba”, then it just develops into an uncivilised argument going in circles such as this one… [b]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/b] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 13 Jun 2007

...Also, what “SomeSingh” Jee is saying is entirely sound and clear, don’t know why “KhalsaSpirit” Jee is confused or does not understand? Earlier in this topic “KhalsaSpirit” Jee was doing good Vichaar and making points in a sensible manner that could be discussed, however, he seems to have lost the plot of this issue now...Bhull chuk maarf Khalsa Jee... [b]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/b] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

jassmannn · 14 Jun 2007

This post as with many others has veered off course. I think that we should listen to what people say, don't them down with nasty comments and actually try and understand what they are saying and why they are saying it. Can any of us in this post who all think we know it all, that's the impression I get from the above posts, prove any of what we are saying. Jarnail Singh is a very argued over person, and I personally have very mixed feelings. Now if someone wants to call them a sant ot whatever, then that's your choosing. My studies have been different to your, and so has my sangat, so I can only draw an understanding from the information that U have and the reliability of my sources. The rest is for us all. In this debate, people should just let people say there piece and there respectfully respond with either your counter argument, or any evidence that you may have.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalsaspirit · 14 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Nirvair jio, Quote "It is good that the Khalsa should so Vichaar on Sikh principles" Are these type of Vichaar "It is shameful how people can refer to one of the greatest people to ever walk this earth without the Sant title." have Sikh principles? Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

SomeSingh · 14 Jun 2007

Thank you to some of the above posters. Perhaps some additional clarification is needed, as there are probably some people who are less experienced with Sikhi here. Some terminology - sant is a certain spiritual level, very high up. mahapursh is an even higher level, way above sant, very powerful. people often refer to sant jarnail singh ji as a mahapursh. bhramgyani is the highest level, one with god. So a bhramgyani can be called a sant or a mahapursh, but not necessarily vice versa. many also believe that sant ji was a bhramgyani, others don't. The Guru is like a powerhouse. A mahapursh is like an electrician who connects people to the powerhouse and helps make sure the wiring and everything is correct. this is a definition from saint scholar Naranjan Singh ji.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 14 Jun 2007

[b]Khalsa Jee, [i]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/i] There is no sense in debating about this subject as it has never in the past been settled, or changed the viewpoints of members of each side, but eventually the topic is only closed once a debate starts. Dhaas does not believe this topic will be any different. If you believe there are Brehamgianee’s, Sant’s or Mahanpurkh’s that have existed in the past, present and will do in the future to come, then that is good, if you do not think there are such titles, and these titles are solely reserved for SathGuroo Maharaaj Jee, then that is fine as well. Let Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Khalsa Dhadrianwale carry on with the Amrit Sanchaar, and those who dislike/slander him to keep disliking/slandering him. No one is forced to attend or listen to the Gurmat Parchaar Diwaans by him, so those who want to attend (hundreds of thousands around the world in every country where he goes), can keep attending, and those who do not want to listen to the Gurmat Parchaar Diwaans by him do not have to go, but can go to other Gurmat Parchaar programmes elsewhere. Furthermore, if anyone has the nerve to approach Sant Baba Ranjit Singh themselves for an issue they may have with him, please go ahead, as this is almost certainly the best way forward. They visit many countries worldwide; when/if they are at your country of residence, please do approach them if you wish; it is not too difficult to get in contact with them while they are out of India, especially as Diwaans take place nationally in all main Gurdwaras of the country they visit. It was hoped that by now people would respect each others views and leave the debate to one side as we all know it will not get anywhere. Let us anticipate this will be the case in the future and the Sangat can accept the views of others in such obvious controversial issues. It is up to the Administration Jee of this forum to decide whether to perhaps close this topic and such others in the future if members cannot respect the point of view of others where such clearly controversial issues are the root of the discussion/news and it is blatantly apparent no one will alter their stance in such issues. Humble apologies and request for forgiveness from those members of Sangat that Dhaas/topic-starter may have offended by starting this topic... ...As Sikhs, we can all clearly have the same opinion that: THAN THAN is the Present Eternal SathGuroo Jagdhee Jyot of the Ten SathGuroo Saahibaan Sache Paatshah Sree Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj... ...As Sikhs, we can clearly have the same opinion that in this time...NAAM JAPO! [i]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/i][/b] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Khalsaspirit · 15 Jun 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, If you like to close the topic then let's close it with Guru Sahib's bachan. Please every one read it carefully. [gurbani]igAwnu igAwnu kQY sBu koeI ] kiQ kiQ bwdu kry duKu hoeI ] kiQ khxY qy rhY n koeI ] ibnu rs rwqy mukiq n hoeI ]2] igAwnu iDAwnu sBu gur qy hoeI ] swcI rhq swcw min soeI ] mnmuK kQnI hY pru rhq n hoeI ] nwvhu BUly Qwau n koeI ]3][/gurbani] panna 831 Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

SomeSingh · 15 Jun 2007

Gr bwrI hoie vriqAw Gr bwrI isK pYrIN pwieAw ] "A Sikh is to be a householder, if the Sikh is a true Sikh (i.e. a Brahmgyani) and one meets such a Sikh, One is to surrender at the feet of such a Sikh and do their seva in humility." (Bhai Gurdas Jee Var. 6, Pauri 2)

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

bebiha · 20 Jun 2007

This is a video...which clearly show the corrupted character of Dadriawala....... To all his supporters...watch this video before you post! http://youtube.com/watch?v=4XppyuTTHKU&mode=related&search= [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Nirvair Khalsa · 20 Jun 2007

Khalsa Jee, [i]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/i] There is no sense in debating about this subject as it has never in the past been settled, or changed the viewpoints of members of each side, but eventually the topic is only closed once a debate starts. Dhaas does not believe this topic will be any different. If you believe there are Brehamgianee’s, Sant’s or Mahanpurkh’s that have existed in the past, present and will do in the future to come, then that is good, if you do not think there are such titles, and these titles are solely reserved for SathGuroo Maharaaj Jee, then that is fine as well. Let Sant Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Khalsa Dhadrianwale carry on with the Amrit Sanchaar, and those who dislike/slander him to keep disliking/slandering him. No one is forced to attend or listen to the Gurmat Parchaar Diwaans by him, so those who want to attend (hundreds of thousands around the world in every country where he goes), can keep attending, and those who do not want to listen to the Gurmat Parchaar Diwaans by him do not have to go, but can go to other Gurmat Parchaar programmes elsewhere. Furthermore, if anyone has the nerve to approach Sant Baba Ranjit Singh themselves for an issue they may have with him, please go ahead, as this is almost certainly the best way forward. They visit many countries worldwide; when/if they are at your country of residence, please do approach them if you wish; it is not too difficult to get in contact with them while they are out of India, especially as Diwaans take place nationally in all main Gurdwaras of the country they visit. It was hoped that by now people would respect each others views and leave the debate to one side as we all know it will not get anywhere. Let us anticipate this will be the case in the future and the Sangat can accept the views of others in such obvious controversial issues. **It is up to the Administration Jee of this forum to decide whether to perhaps close this topic and such others in the future if members cannot respect the point of view of others where such clearly controversial issues are the root of the discussion/news and it is blatantly apparent no one will alter their stance in such issues.** Humble apologies and request for forgiveness from those members of Sangat that Dhaas/topic-starter may have offended by starting this topic... ...As Sikhs, we can all clearly have the same opinion that: THAN THAN is the Present Eternal SathGuroo Jagdhee Jyot of the Ten SathGuroo Saahibaan Sache Paatshah Sree Guroo Granth Saahib Jee Maharaaj... ...As Sikhs, we can clearly have the same opinion that in this time...NAAM JAPO! [i]Vaheguroo Jee Kaa Khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee Kee Phateh!!![/i] [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

Prabhjoyt Singh · 21 Jun 2007

does he still taka mathay? yes or no? if he does then he is a fake if not then i suppose hes ok. but why dont he jsut drop the Sant title start sing Gurbani and explaining the arths instead of singing nursery rhymes? would that not be better?

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

jassmannn · 21 Jun 2007

That video is appalling.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

S-Singh · 21 Jun 2007

>>Author: Prabhjoyt Singh Date: 06-21-07 03:48 >>does he still taka mathay? yes or no? Sure does. How else can he fund the continued expansion of his dera. At a time when Vedanti and co are telling Sikhs to avoid dera, people like this self titled Sant are allowed to build a cult type following. They never build a Gurdwara it is always a dera. >>if he does then he is a fake if not then i suppose hes ok. but why dont he jsut drop the Sant title start sing Gurbani and explaining the arths instead of singing nursery rhymes? would that not be better? Why sing Gurbani ? The special moves that his chele do with the chemtey would just not go down right. Plus Gurbani does not sell as well as dharmi songs, this would upset his bosses at T-Series. He cant drop the Sant title as then it would further degrade his marketing strategy.

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

bebiha · 21 Jun 2007

http://forums.waheguroo.com/-Sarse-Wala-Saadh-Guru-Gobind-Singh-Nahi-Ban-Sakda--t19481.html see the thread above....Nirvair Khalsa promoted dadri baba till it got to a 12 pages long debate!lol...(just read the last 5 pages) also please take a look at this thread below: http://forums.waheguroo.com/index.php?showtopic=19672&pid=147418&st=0&#entry147418 [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianw

Harjas Kaur · 22 Jun 2007

I will be honest...I did not support Dhaddrianwala because of the video. Allowing people to mata tekk to him will dog him the rest of his life, because it was that big of a mistake. Many good Gursikh people will never trust or accept him because of this. They are not wrong to point out obvious failings. True criticism will make someone like Dhaddrianwale be a better person, because he will change the wrong things. At least, he has an opportunity to. Humility will go farther on his behalf than blind defensiveness against what was really wrong. But he doesn't have to be perfect. I know I'm not perfect. And I really do distrust the baba thing...although I recognize and respect that we do have sants. but a true sant is someone very very humble. He has nirmata, not photo ops and fancy outfits. But..... ..... ..... I honestly don't even see any outreach to the Sikh youth. I honestly don't even see parchaar of Gursikhi to people who have taken amrit... .... .... And I have watched all my friends Gursikh amritdhari kids take off kakkars and cut kes as soon as they got to University... and no one in the Jatha ever even gave them a phone call or tried to be any kind of support... So maybe... Dhaddrianwale isn't such a bad thing compared to the alternative. At least he is reaching the kids. And on that note, I will let time be the judge of him. Yogi Bhajan also had some crazy ideas and things not in line with purataan Gursikhi...but because of his parchaar, after his death he left a legacy. And it is entirely possible that 3HO sangat in time WILL become more and more purataan with Guruji's kirpa. Already you have third generation Western kids raised as Sikhs, speaking fluent Punjabi, completely fluent in Gurmukhi, skilled in playing traditional raag, and keeping bana. These are all of our brothers and sisters. They are not a separate caste. Let's not outcaste them because they're not brown. (I do see a lot of this kind of prejudice against converts). I believe Guruji has the power to take human failings and make them work out into something powerful and good because Guru loves the innocent people who come to give their heads to Him. I don't believe evil has the power to taint beautiful good things. Guruji is stronger. The truth is, while it is easy to crush and criticize Dhaddrianwale, because of his past mistakes...most of us couldn't reach and inspire the kids if we tried. He DOES have a special blessing. Why not support and help him to do the right thing with that gift? I mean if you compare his dera with the local Gurudwara, for the most part...[i]we[/i] are the crying shame. So after reflection. I do withdraw my criticism of Dhaddrianwale. He is not even as bad as the majority of people criticizing him. And if he can reach the kids...I support that with my heart and soul. Because honestly we are losing the kids...by the thousands. This is by far the bigger evil. Maybe he is not a sant. But at least he is trying. And I do respect that. Harbhajan Singh Yogi really wasn't much different, and he made the same kind of mistakes. But in my opinion, he still left a beautiful legacy because of Guruji's kirpa, not any human perfection. Human beings are basically a work in progress. But we never will have progress if we kept finding the thousand faults and never support the precious good things. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R5MudTn1wYM[/url] [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txyJvBVZbmw[/url] [url]http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=3041362466680950827&q=chardikala+jatha&total=7&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=6[/url] ~Bhul chuk maaf karni ji [%sig%]

Re: ..RECENT DIWAAN ON PAKHANDI "BABA" & "DERA SACHA SAUDA".. by *Sant Dhadrianwale*

SomeSingh · 28 Jun 2007

Here's Baba Hari Singh ji discussing the reality of the events behind Sirsa dera. http://www.sfsikhcenter.org/multimedia/listing.php?q=f&f=%2F04-Katha%2F05-Sant+Baba+Hari+Singh+Ji+%28Randhawe+Wale%29