Re: Punjab unrest
Kulbir Singh · 19 May 2007
The article is interesting and the similarities drawn between the current conflict and the 1978 conflict are quite accurate.
--------
This time it will not be Sikh vs. Hindu though
-----------
This is because Hindus have smartened up and supported the Sikhs this time unlike last time when communal editors like Lala Jagat Narayan openly supported the naqli Nirankaris and condemned Sikhs every day in their newspapers. This time I am hearing good words from RSS, Bajrang Bal, BJP and other Jan Sanghis. For this reason, you are correct in saying that this time it will not be Sikh Vs Hindu.
The conflict between the Sikhs and Hindus was never because of Sikhs. In 1947 and before that period, Sikhs always helped Hindus against Muslims and at other such times but Sikhs were totally taken aback when after 1947, Hindus came out openly against Sikh demand for Punjabi suba and against Punjabi language. Hindus disowned their mother tongue Punjabi and because of this many Punjabi speaking areas like Fazilka, Abohar, Ambala, Chamba and other cities were left out of Punjab and given to Haryana and Himachal. That sowed the seeds of discontent between Sikhs and Hindus. Then during the 1978 conflict, the Hindus stood with the cultist leader of naqli Nirankaris.
---------
but Akali vs. Dera Sacha Sauda (or Sikh vs. Lower Caste Sikh).
---------
It's not Sikh vs Lower Caste Sikh and it can never be so because Dalits who are not members of Sacha Sauda are not supporting Sacha Sauda but supporting Sikhs. As an example, Balmikis in Jalandhar openly came out in support of Sikhs and against Sacha Sauda. Everyone loves Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee and how can they all not be offended by the wrongdoing of the cult leader - Gurmit-Ram-Rahim
[%sig%]
Re: Punjab unrest
Kulbir Singh · 19 May 2007
---------
come on kulbir singh ji - the conflict was never because of the sikhs? that's a totally biased statement. sikhs are as much to blame as hindus. hindus were against the punjabi suba because it wasn't for punjabis but for sikhs and hindus would have been clearly relegated to second class citizens in punjab. i hope you are aware that before it was garbed in the moderate term "punjabi suba", the demand really was for "sikhistan" and this is what hindus did not want.
---------
I try not to be biased and this time too I believe I was not biased when I wrote that the Hindu Sikh conflict was started by Hindus (mostly Arya Samajis).
You believe that Hindus were against the Punjabi suba because they thought they would have been relegated to second class citizens there. Siddhartha, I ask you to look back in history. Prior to the Punjabi suba agitation, the Sikhs always treated the Hindus with love and affection. In 1947 Sikhs in Punjab protected and helped the Hindus. In Rawalpindi, many battles were fought against the Muslims by the Sikhs and Hindus unitedly. The Sikh leader Master Tara Singh was born a Hindu and so were many Sikhs. There was no question of even thinking of treating the Hindus as second class citizens.
Prior to that, at the time of Sikh Raj in Punjab, were Hindus treated as second-class citizens? Even Muslims were not treated as second-class citizens, let alone Hindus. During the Raj of Maharaja Ranjit Singh, Hindus were given many prominent administrative positions. There was no discrimination. Same is true with the Malwa Sikh kingdoms like Patiala, Nabha etc.
Where did the Hindus get the idea that they would be treated as second class citizens. Now that the Punjabi suba has been created, have Hindus been treated as second class citizens.
I think the gullible Hindus were led to believe by the Arya Samaji leaders that the Sikhs would treat them as second class citizens and this led the Hindus to disown the Punjabi language thereby sowing the seeds of trouble between Sikhs and Hindus. Sikhs were never the first ones to start trouble with anyone.
[%sig%]
Re: Punjab unrest
Bachitar Singh · 19 May 2007
Not this again. Hindus are out to get sikhs. The brahmins are still pissed of because of what the Guru Granth Sahib says about them. For thousands of years the brahimans demanded respect. Our Guru Granth sahib has thrown them into the dirt. At least that is what I think the reason is. Remeber they are the ones that started the problem. Our only solution is a soverign state. Which our Guru sahib promised.
Re: Punjab unrest
Khalsaspirit · 20 May 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Bachitar Singh jio,
quote "Not this again. Hindus are out to get sikhs. The brahmins are still pissed of because of what the Guru Granth Sahib says about them. For thousands of years the brahimans demanded respect. Our Guru Granth sahib has thrown them into the dirt. At least that is what I think the reason is. Remeber they are the ones that started the problem. Our only solution is a soverign state. Which our Guru sahib promised."
We could not understand your understanding about Gurbani which has Brahmin or pandit word because from your perspective seems like that Gurbani is only condemning the certain ethnicity called brahman or Pandit but Singh sahib jio as per our understanding Guru ji condemned the practice they followed so this Gurbani similarly implies to even those so called Sikhs who followed the same practice. Now either our understanding is wrong or your's.
Next you are asking for soverign state let's see our performance for the state.
We guess there are about 600-700 Gurudwara Sahib in U.S/Canada and check the performance of these Gurudwaras since last 15-20 years. Majorty of Gurudwaras are fighting for power, number of times physical fights broke out and even some are closed or sealed at this moment. Now are there any brahmin or pandits sitting in those Gurudwaras answer is no but brahmin/pandit practice is their in Sikhi saroop so this clears out that do not blame just brahmins blame the same practice which we are carrying now and soverign state with this practice! forget about it. Veer mere only Gurmat is soluation and then Guru Sahib will be parsun (happy) on us then they will give us whatever you looking for.
Jab lag khalsa rahay niyara tab lag tej deon mai sara, jag aah gahay bipran ki reet mai na karron in ki parteet. (by Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji)
And that is what happening now. For Guru sake instead of blaming others first we have to practice the GURMAT.
Guru mehar karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Punjab unrest
Bachitar Singh · 20 May 2007
"bachitar singh - if hindus stand up for themselves, then they are out to get sikhs. how foolish is that? "
Sidharth you are a fool. When has the hindu ever stuck up for himself. If hindus had stuck up for themselves then they would not be ghulams, servants or property of the muslimans for hundreds of years. My friend sidharth you can talk all you want, but I doubt you grew up in Punjab. If you had grown up there then you wouldn't have the balls to be saying anything. Only the people that have experienced the hardship against them know what I am talking about.
Khalsa Spirt we have already laid down the foundation for Khalistan. It has been fortified with the blood of our shaheeds. In 1986 Khalistan was declared. Now your either with us or out of our way. Asa Di Vaar tears up a lot of hindu practices. That is what I am talking about. Not just brahmins.
You people call yourselves the children of Guru Gobind Singh. No child of Guru Gobind Singh would let what happened in Punjab be. I am not talking about revenge, but justice.
I am an uparh person. I have not been given the luxury to attain an education. What I am saying may and probably is wrong. You guys are much smarter then me and it is your job to show me the light.
by the way great posts Somesingh
[%sig%]
Re: Punjab unrest
Bijla Singh · 21 May 2007
Sidharth, the article you provided has no references. Anyone can come up with some quotes and pin them on others. Ajit Singh Sarhaddi in his book Punjabi Soobay Di Gatha provides many of the speeches by Tara Singh and others and provides references. Not a single speech mentions a Sikh state that would discriminate against Hindus. In fact, hindus tend to have this nature which is apparent in India today.
In Sikh Kingdom, Hindus must have become Sikhs at their own discretion not out of force like in Mughal Empire. Hindu dogras held high positions in the Kingdom. Not a single death sentence was given. Money was donated to hindu temples by the Maharaja. At least provide some historical facts in your posts not imaginary unrealistic assumptions.
“if hindus stand up for themselves, then they are out to get sikhs. how foolish is that?”
Let’s see. When they united: they attacked Guru Sahib at Anandpur Sahib, helped the Mughals to hunt down Sikhs, caused first Sikh holocaust known as Chota Ghallughara, betrayed the army of Baba Banda Singh, betrayed the Sikh army fighting the British, opposed Gurdwara Sudhaar Lehar, opposed Punjabi Sooba and Anandpur Sahib Resolution, distributed sweets to soldiers who came to destroy our Gurdwaras, burnt Sikhs alive and dishonored Sikh women in the streets of Indian capital, and last but not least stood against distinct Sikh identity. Need more?
“well, you better choose another solution, becasue this one has failed.”
This is once again an assumption. Look back at the history of hindus and see if any movement has succeeded the first time. It took hindus almost 200 years to get independence from the British and I am sure English people would’ve said the same thing to hindus after failure of 1857.
Re: Punjab unrest
Bijla Singh · 21 May 2007
I don't see any educated assumptions on your part but in any case in 1857 Sikhs did not betray hindus as propagated by the biased indian media. It was Jhani di rani, a hindu, who betrayed her community.
http://www.panthic.org/news/129/ARTICLE/2623/2006-07-16.html
http://www.panthic.org/news/129/ARTICLE/2639/2006-07-23.html
http://www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/2660/2006-07-30.html
"the second was from this very site by balpreet singh who wrote an essay on the kingdom of raja ranjit singh and he is a well read guy so i'm sure he would've done his research before writing this. i will try to find that post but i remember one sentence very clearly, "it paid to be a sikh in a sikh kingdom""
I rather see the sources and evaluate them.
"the examples you quote are the ones where we were never united and the distributed sweets to the soldiers part was when bhindranwale was killed not because the golden temple was attacked. i was too young to remember any of that but from all his speeches and videos that i have seen, i would have been happy too."
Ironic how you turn your back on something that doesn't go in your favor. 12 hindu hill kings of Punjab attacked Guru Sahib at once and you don't consider it a unity? What would you call unity then? When exactly did they unite? Was there a Bhindrawala in every Gurdwara of Punjab or in every Sikh house of Delhi? I am astonished by your foolishness but I guess it is common among those who fall prey to the Indian media. Sant Jarnail Singh never even harmed let alone kill a hindu. On the contrary he helped whosoever came to him. You need to do some research before making uneducated conclusions.
Re: Punjab unrest
Mehtab Singh · 22 May 2007
From my limited knowledge, Sikhs chose not to help the bhaiyya rebels in 1857 because:
1.) It was these same bhaiyyas who helped the British annex Punjab in 1849 successfully.
2.) These bhaiyyas chose to declare the then Mughal emperor as the king of India after ousting the British. The Sikhs, who knew the real character of the Mughals throughout their history could never accept this. Moreover, letting an age-old enemy rule you just because you have a new enemy is stupid. Thus the Sikhs chose to "trust" the British a bit more than they could trust the Mughals or the bhaiyyas for that matter.
Also, don't forget that it was Baba Ram Singh Naamdhari who started the 1st satyagrah and loads of Kukas were martyred by the British by being blown into pieces by a canon.
my 2 cents (Bhai Kulbir Singh ji please correct me wherever I'm wrong).
[%sig%]
Re: Punjab unrest
Harjas Kaur · 23 May 2007
[quote]This time it will not be Sikh vs. Hindu though - but Akali vs. Dera Sacha Sauda [/quote]
No. It is very clear that hinduization and corruption of Gursikhi in Punjab with fake satguru's and pakhandi babas is not working. So pro-Hindutva media is distorting the provocation of dera Sacha sauda by minimizing that it is about his clothes and not his corruption of Amrit Sanchaar. Also by saying Sikhs are not that upset, but fanatical Akalis and militant Khalistanis with support of fundamentalist Akal Takht are....even though it was the fanatical dera cultists who unleashed the violence attacking and injuring 25 peacefully protesting Sikhs and killing one while Punjab Police did nothing. No doubt because of the deras close political ties with Congress.
Obviously there is only ONE Khalsa Panth and everyone is upset with all the state sponsored support of pakhandi babas! Stop trying to create more artificial divisions amongst Sikhs. We are united against Hinduization of Gursikhi. And the Panth is united against Indian State terrorism against Sikhs in the name of suppressing Sikh protests. There is already a video of Indian government agent in Akal Takht who dropped his hidden gun in view of everyone. Obviously Guruji Himself exposed him, and the GOI's interference.
[quote] And hours after Badal said that the bandh tomorrow would be peaceful, his alliance partner, the BJP, distanced itself from his handling of the situation, saying it would not support the bandh.
The BJP warned of “hard decisions” in case the government failed to maintain law and order. After a meeting presided over by Punjab unit chief Rajinder Bhandari, the BJP said: “If anything goes wrong in any part of the state, the government headed by Parkash Singh Badal shall be solely responsible and answerable. BJP will not hesitate in taking hard decisions in the larger interests of the people of Punjab.”
The statement is being seen in the light of the BJP’s efforts to keep its Hindu votes intact. The message, that is believed to have the sanction of the BJP Central leadership, takes into account what it feels are sentiments of the Hindu community in the state: while they do not support the Dera chief’s act, they cannot accept the fact that people waving swords should be walking freely. After working hard to win back its base among Hindus and in urban areas, the BJP is worried that this may come under threat if the party does not articulate their sentiments.
http://www.indianexpress.com/story/31543.html[/quote]
[%sig%]
Re: Punjab unrest
Khalsaspirit · 25 May 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Bachitar Singh jio,
Quote "Khalsa Spirt we have already laid down the foundation for Khalistan. It has been fortified with the blood of our shaheeds. In 1986 Khalistan was declared. Now your either with us or out of our way."
The time will let you know who will be out and who will be in. By the way what is your contribution for that foundation?
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Punjab unrest
Harjas Kaur · 27 May 2007
[quote]Amazing there r the few who go on about this Hindu betrayal, who was Dyal Ram, did he not offer his head to Guruji, at Anappursahib 1699, and like many other Hindus joined the battle against Mughals. Who was Lachman Dev? Hindu from Jammu, who Guruji met at an ashram and he became Banda Singh!!
[/quote]
The Sikhs you are talking about are not Hindus. They may have been Hindus, but they became Sikhs. And there were Mughal converts to Sikhism as well. Or are you implying only the Hindu converts were the real Sikhs because Sikhism is Hindu? And maybe you would also imply certain castes who converted are better Sikhs than other castes? You see that kind of thing is RSS ideology. But it isn't what Guruji taught. Sikhism is a different religion. It's completely independant of Hindu ideology. It's not submissive to Hindu dharam.
There is no reason why Sikhs should be at conflict with Hindus at all. It has more to do with Kalyug, plus the politics of being a minority, and all the fights over land, money, power. Its all ugly politics, without which, I'm sure everyone would be peaceful, respectful, and tolerant. But when a nation of majority Hindus wants to assert itself politically for financial gain, they divert the waters, they bankrupt the farmers, they eliminate the capital (Chandigarh), they try to eliminate the language (Punjabi) and make everything Hindu-Hindi-Hindustan. And that's the problem. I don't see anywhere Sikhs attacking or belittling or depriving Hindus. But endlessly we see this Hindutva attack on Sikhs. When it stops, people will stop complaining about the obvious.
Hindu betrayal has been on-going since time of partition. But no one can question it's reality after 1984. And that unfortunately is just sad fact.
[img]http://www.khalistan.8m.com/akal-damaged.jpg[/img]
Hindustan needs to get out of Khalistan!
[img]http://www.panthic.org/data/images/news/categories/cat_129/2005-07-10_illustrated7.jpg[/img]
Hinduization of Gursikhi is NOT ACCEPTABLE! Hindutva needs to stop the malicious mischief!
http://www.panthic.org/news/129/ARTICLE/1524/2005-07-10.html
[%sig%]
Re: Punjab unrest
Harjas Kaur · 28 May 2007
[quote]Khalistan and Hindustan need to get out of Punjab !![/quote]
Punjab is part of the land of the Khalsa. So that will be hard to achieve getting Khalistan out of itself.
[img]http://solarider.org/my-pics/sikh-human-rights-03-10-2006[/img]
[img]http://solarider.org/my-pics/sikh-widow-03-10-2006[/img]
NEVER FORGET 1984!
[%sig%]
Re: Punjab unrest
Harjas Kaur · 28 May 2007
[quote]My concern is the bigotry towards Hindus as being traitors, this is not accpetable, as each person is an individual, and of course many Hindu families in Punjab made their first Son Sikh, as im sure u know. Majority of Hindus do not want hinduisation, do u see RSS getting majority votes????
Only a bigot deals in absolutes, ie. Hindus this Hindus that. It is not a sad fact as not all support the loud mouth minority. The tremendous sacrifices of the Gurus will never be forgotten.[/quote]
1. Where is it bigotry towards individual Hindus to confront atrocities of GOI and malicious assimilation campaign by Hindustan against Sikhs? It seems clear where the bigotry lies.
2. Whether it is Congress Party or Hindutva BJP-RSS, who is actually working on behalf of the best interests of the Sikhs? It is evident that Hindu politicians are working on behalf of the best economic and political interests of the majority Hindus. As evidenced in the occupation of Punjab since days of militancy, the impunity of the Punjab Police, the neferious and calculated anti-Sikh propaganda of the media, the degrading Bollywood depictions, the financial sponsorship of anti-Sikh corrupting influences of fake babas and dehdhari gurudoms, the malicious re-writing of Sikh history to conform to Hindutva ideals, the denial of Sikh independance even as a separate religion, and the brutal suppression of human rights activism or fair and honest inquiries into the genocidal crimes of the Indian government against Sikhs. The Nanavati Commision did not even begin to scratch the surface. And to this day Amnesty International is still barred from Punjab. There are very realistic grievances which Khalistanis have with Hindustan. If you kill or silence every Khalistani...the grievances will still remain.
3. Hindu families raising one child as a Sikh...is this some legitimacy to the Hindutva argument that Sikhs are Hindus? What does this mean? During the time of Sikh Raj, and during British rule, it was advantageous for some families to raise a child as a Sikh since this opened doors of opportunity. But seriously this practice has no practical purpose today, and has fallen into disuse. Further for part of recent Sikh history Hindu mahants, udasis, nirmalas, sanatan Nihangs and Naamdharis were more likely to have contributed to this practice since they believe Sikhism belongs to Hindu dharam. I have never heard a case where a Sikh family raised their son to be a Hindu! So it was certainly not a reciprocol practice, and fails to establish anything. What is the point?
4. You use words like bigotry and traitor and treason as if there was some neferious agenda to blacken the faces of Hindus. When the reality remains that Hindu India has since partition been betraying the best interests of Sikhs politically and economically. And moreover, since Hindutva groups like Arya Samaj, RSS-BJP there have been numerous attempts by these quasi-fascist groups to undermine and corrupt the Sikh religion. And if you add to all these critical hostilities repeatedly done against the Sikh nation, the Congress Government invasion of Harmandir Sahib, the subsequent anti-Sikh riots following Indira Gandhi's assassination, and the decades long genocidal suppression of the Sikh Freedom Movement...Rather than some nebulous debate about anti-Hindu bigotry, the Sikh Panth is STILL WAITING FOR JUSTICE! This is just not the kind of thing where a simple apology pretends this never happened. It's not even like there are positive steps in the right direction. All that Sant Ji warned against is coming to pass. Sikhs are persecuted in their own country.
5. Why is no one addressing the grievances of the Sikh nation, or speaking on behalf of justice so long denied...but wax endlessly about poor Hindu sentiments being offended by mention of anti-Sikh injustices? What hypocrisy! All you are doing is trying to silence the truth by derailing facts with false accusations. Where were the voices of protest against anti-Sikh violence? Where are Sikhs doing anything against Hindus? To confront honestly the genocidal policies of Hindustan has nothing to do with bigotry. To speak on behalf of Sikh sovereignty and independance has nothing to do with anti-Hinduism. Hindus need to confront where the Government of India has been an oppressive force, rather than always blaming Sikhs for divisions their own leadership keeps creating.
[quote]The tremendous sacrifices of the Gurus will never be forgotten.[/quote]
Guruji's own darshan has been sacrificed in every shaheed Singh. Who can forget? But Sikhs sacrifice for justice. Not as a sword-arm at the bidding of Hindus.
[quote]Mr Rajewal said his organisation had received reports that 13,000 farmers had committed suicide in recent years. Mr Inderjit Singh Jaijee said that in two blocks — Moonak and Andana — of Sangrur district 1,360 farmers had committed suicide. He claimed that in the entire state, 40,000 farmers committed suicide between 1987 and 2005.
[url]http://www.tribuneindia.com/2006/20060415/punjab1.htm[/url][/quote]
[img]http://solarider.org/my-pics/ensaaf-14-01-2007.jpg[/img]
1984 JUNE REMEMBRANCE MARCH AND FREEDOM RALLY
[url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mcOyuUkO0iM[/url]
1984...NeVeRForGeT
[url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzrMfXYyb0A[/url]
Sons of Guru Gobind Singh 1984 recollection
[url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F4xkWkyEY1E[/url]
Tribute to Sikh (Shaheeds) Martyrs of 1984
[url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x6eB1Fk5voU[/url]
Jaswant Singh Khalra's Last International Speech
[url]http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=6027286376112784432&q=last+international+speech[/url]
[%sig%]