Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

Kulbir Singh · 21 May 2004

-------- This post is with respect to the post by "MB Singh" under the following thread: http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=11502&t=11502 ------- I agree with our Veer MB Singh (Bhai Meharbaan Singh from Amritsar Sahib) that it is a big event that a Sikh person has been chosen as the prime minister of India. That incident that you write about, where you saw Manmohan Singh at 2am in Darbar Sahib tells a lot about this person. If Manmohan Singh fails or performs badly, it will have an adverse affect on all the Sikhs. If he succeeds, then it will be good for the sikhs worldwide. One thing is for sure. Manmohan Singh is not a nationalist Sikh and as such we should not expect much from him in that area. There are other Sikhs like Simranjit Singh Mann, who are working in this area and we cannot expect Manmohan Singh to raise the cause of Sikh nation as he is just not the person for this job. By the same token, it does not hurt to have a Sikh person as the head of 1 billion people in the world. If Manmohan Singh really wants the Sikhs to cherish his memory in the future years, he should do something for the Sikhs. I am not expecting from him, anything to do with Sikh nationalism but here are some of my recommendations to him, that he can easily do: 1) He should focus towards the economic well-being of the country. If the economics benefits flow down to the common person, they will flow to the Sikhs too. This will enhance the image of Sikhs world-wide. 2) He should focus on doing something for Punjab. To begin with, Punjab has no heavy industry. He can announce some heavy industry in Punjab. This will create jobs in Punjab and will bring prosperity in Punjab. Punjab has the best work force in whole of India. Any industry will benefit from it. 3) He should do something about the IT industry in Punjab. Currently the South is reaping all fruits of the IT development. Punjab has excellent potential for becoming a centre of IT (information technology). The Chandigarh area would be ideal for such industry. Currently Calcutta is fast becoming the centre of IT and is trying to dethrone Hydrabad and Banglore. If Calcutta can do it, then Punjab can too. We just need some support from our leaders. 4) He should try to solve the Pakistan problem and open trade with Pakistan. Punjab would benefit immensely if there is open trade between the two Punjabs. This will bring harmony in India. 5) What he can really do for the Punjabis, considering that the majority of Sikhs in Punjab are farmers, is that he should give Punjabis right to sell their wheat and rice to any state, and if possible even in Pakistan. This move alone will make Punjab very prosperous as they will get up to 2 times the price that the government currently pays them. 6) He should let Punjabi farmers to own more than 16 acres of land. Farming should be done like business and if someone wants to own more land and do farming at a greater scale, such person should be allowed to do so. This will certainly increase output in Punjab. Since most Sikhs are farmers, it would be good if he can do something for the farmers. By limiting the farmers to 16 acres, he is depriving the Sikhs of their true economic potential. 7) He should make it illegal for states like Himachal Pradesh and Rajasthan to ban Punjabis from owning land there. This move is definitely unconstitutional and Manmohan Singh should take action in this direction. Sikhs will flock to neighbouring Rajasthan and Himachal Pradesh and buy land there, if they are allowed to. This will benefit Sikhs greatly. If anyone else has any ideas about Punjab, they should post them here. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

hm · 21 May 2004

i wana understand these economic reforms better. from what i seen india might have got out of bankrupcy but its let in foreign companies who are using there advertising mass media methods and slowly changing the east into western influence. is this rescueing a country? multinational companies walk in and change the whole set up with their financial clout. Look at the way people dress today compared to 1990? the way people now think? the kind of chain stores, is this development good or bad?

Re: Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

Punjab · 21 May 2004

Manmohan Singh should make sure all Punjabi speaking areas of the undivided East Punjab which were awarded to Haryana state, Himachal Pradesh and those which were merged into Rajasthan should be reunited with the Punjab state. If that leaves Haryana and Himachal with little land left, then those two states should be merged back with Punjab completely. Chandigarh should not be a UT, it should be under the Punjab government. The in Hindi onslaught on Chandigarh should be countered. Hindi speakers have their native states already, why they try to gobble up Punjab is poor reflection on these people. Manmohan Singh should make sure all peoples, languages, cultures and religions are treated equally. India is not a Hindu country, despite having a Hindu majority. It is claimed as 'secular'. He should make sure this is not just words on paper.

Re: Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

hm · 21 May 2004

if that ghappened then we wud be a even smaller minority cos there wud be more hindus in this united punjab

Re: Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

me · 21 May 2004

'Chandigarh should not be a UT' what does UT stand for?

Re: Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

Kulbir Singh · 21 May 2004

UT stands for Union Territory. There are about 9 union territories in India. UTs are controlled directly by the federal government as opposed to the provincial government. Ideally, Chandigarh should be under Punjab and not under Federal government. Some of the other Union Territories are Goa, Andaman Nicobar Islands, Delhi etc. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

curious · 22 May 2004

punjab "Hindi speakers have their native states already, why they try to gobble up Punjab is poor reflection on these people." veerji are you reffering to the people living in the other parts of divided punjab? then what are the native states of say a rajistani?i always thought it was rajistan. If thats the case how did they gobble punjab? was not rajistani culture and identity seperate from punjab? when did it co mingle? how did rajistan end up on a punjabi map? and at what date?

Re: Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

curious · 22 May 2004

veerji sorry i pressed the post button before i fully checked that you wrote parts of rajistan. I understand what your saying now.

Re: Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

Punjab · 22 May 2004

Sikhs are a minority in Delhi but look how well they are doing compared to Delhi's other communities. Punjabis (Sikhs in particular) are actually doing so well in Delhi that Punjabi language has been introduced in every government and government aided school as a compulsory subject. Also, every sign board, street name, buses.. will have Punjabi on them. Delhi is nothing without us. You go anywhere in Delhi, Rajouri Garden, Punjabi Bagh, Shalimar Bagh, Connaught Place, Karol Bagh... Who is number 1? Punjabis are... Hindus are even going in such large numbers to Bangla Sahib and Gurdwara Sis Ganj instead of their mandirs. Being only a small majority (65%) of Punjab state what exactly is there to lose by reuniting 3 small states back together instead of having them separate with unnecessary number of ministers etc. More progress can occur under one government and outstanding/petty issues can be resolved. Look at a map of India and then look at how small, ineffective and useless looking Punjab, Haryana and HP are compared to rest of states in the country. Sikhs of Haryana and HP would definitely benefit and so would Chandigarh. Kulbir Ji was right in saying that UT's are controlled by the centre. You think the centre even bothers to develop Chandigarh? No. Chandigarh belongs to Punjab and should be controlled by Punjab government. They at least will have the time to remove the jhuggis which have appeared in Chandigarh over recent years and develop the city. Haryana government would only turn 'city beautiful' into Hindi speaking backwards slum you find in Uttar Pradesh, Manmohan Singh must resolve all issues which affect Punjab and Sikhs. If it hasnt been done already, then he should also make sure Sikhism is recognized as a religion in India's constituation and not apart of "Hindu Dharm" which it is not. Agriculture will not sustain Punjab's economy forever. Especially with over fertilization of the fields depleting them of natural resources. Quality of life cannot be sacrificed for sake of having slight Sikh majority in a tiny state with limited options. It was not harmful to Sikhism when Sikhs were an even smaller minority in pre-1947 Punjab. Sikhs ruled most of it infact for a number of decades before 1849... Regards, [%sig%]

Re: Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

bhopinder singh · 22 May 2004

India is not hindu country.70 percent indians do not believe in nor except hindu faith because it defines them as shudra (untouchable).That is the reason dr. br ambedkar was given the father of the constitution status. Hindus form only about ten crore of the population the reason shiv sena and vhp asking and begging the hindus to have more than two children. It was intelligent of them to have dr ambedkar as father of the constitution yet gandhi as father of the nation though he was from the minorty and yet in their minds they know that they can fool the world only so much as the day of doom is coming. Hindus know that the reason for the downfall of india and hindu religion was castism but with shrewd minds they devolped the idea of reservation because any dalit that chooses islam ,bhudism or christanity loose the right to reservation theirby they exploit them and at the same time stop them from converting which would makeothers to be the majorty and them loosing power christians being in power and intelligent got some rights for converted shudras,But muslims could not and are asking for it as a bargain for babri masjid hidu knows what that means they will give up mandir but never do that

Re: Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

everpresent devils · 22 May 2004

everyone heard............................................... Sonia out,...................................Manmohan in but the everpresent devils whispered..................... pizza out,................................., paratha in lasagnia out...............................lassi in macaroni out.............................makki roti in Subway machi out....................sabazhi mendi in garlic bread out.......................,gajhar roti in parmesan cheese out...............pendu chutney in Rome out..................................Rawalpindi in 'salut'(bye in italian) out...........sat sri akal in finally , gandhi out................................gabroo in!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :) vjkkvjkffromtheeverpresentdevilsinVaticancity:)) [%sig%]

Re: Suggestions to Manmohan Singh

Singh · 27 May 2004

I think, more the sikhs respond and hail about the new PM as a sikh; more difficult it will be to help his community. Communal majority in India will never like a sikh perform good. At present, they have no option but saying "Manmohan is good."