Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Confrontations with other groups

Confrontations with other groups

Dalbiri · 18 May 2007

I think Sikhs are too quick to have knee jerk reactions to confrontations with other schismatic groups which give the nobodies a higher profile then they would otherwise have. I think it would be better to generally ignore them and concentrate on developing our own vichaar in an inclusive way. Failure to do this is exactly the reason why people leave and join so and so dera or baba. Also Sikhs get a reputation for being excessively violent and closed minded when they go overboard which is not good and jumped upon by various media, be this in India or the west. Recently I was talking to a Panjabi from a nonSikh background and she was telling me how a certain communist newspaper editor she knew was murdered by Sikh militants in the 80s, she seemed to have a bad impression of Sikhs. I subtlety told her that such activity was not confined to Sikhs and how some of the militants who were apparently killed are now resurfacing and the question of who exactly WAS killed in their place was broached. I realise the panth has gone through a big trial and we must learn from this and never again waste our own blood unless it is the last and only resort. It is time to grow and in this day and age this is closely tied to modern education. I'm not saying we compromise anything but that we face the modern world with confidence, embracing it whilst retaining our own heritage and reflecting on mistakes of the past.

Re: Confrontations with other groups

SomeSingh · 18 May 2007

I agree. but this situation is somewhat different, b/c sgpc protested nonviolently - although they did burn his effigy. still, they didn't attack anyone. sacha sauda people started attacking sikhs. they also attacked cops. the poor profile sikhs have is largely due to government actions in communalising people before 84, and newspapers spreading propaganda (times of india admitted that CBI asked them and other papers to spread propaganda about kharkhoos and thatmany papers had agreeed). this cult leader has no small profile, on channel M punjabi news a newsman from india said the cult leader has 30 000 followers in punjab alone.

Re: Confrontations with other groups

Dalbiri · 19 May 2007

Well, I think if we study the development of other religions it should come as no surprise that schismatic groups form. No one has been immune to this. But again, we have to think in terms of what our own people are doing that makes the growth of such groups possible in our midst. I often hear a long list of gripes about the modern day panth by people from Sikh backgrounds such as corruption, hypocrisy, greed and excessively violebt reactions to situations etc. etc. Why are we never reflecting on this and instead always looking for bogey men to blame. I'm not saying that there aren't forces against Sikhism but that blaming all our problems on external sources blinds us to the things we do wrong and keeps us from growing.

Re: Confrontations with other groups

SomeSingh · 19 May 2007

agreed. responses should be more thoughtful and account for the fact that the note that radhasoamis have never been attacked by sikhs despite their wrong prachaar and government ties. sant nirankarees and choota sauda both attacked sikhs, which made what could have been a big nonviolent protest into a huge uproar lasting several days.