Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Vik · 11 Apr 2007

Hi I have a question. Can one be a Sikh and an Athiest? I'm born of Sikh parents, had an arranged marriage to another Sikh etc... I support the Sikh traditions and cultures and have given the name Singh to my sons. But I don't believe there is a God. I consider Sikh the values (as I see them) of standing on your own two feet, working hard, excelling, community support, equality and bravery as ones that I think are important and want to support. But I don't think I need a God to help me to that. Am I still a Sikh? Furthermore, I eat meat, drink beer and only go to Gurdwara on those special occasions (along with all my other Sikh cousins, in-laws etc) I say that it is possible to be a Sikh and not believe in a God.

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Balpreet Singh · 11 Apr 2007

Can there be such a thing as cold fire? The short answer to your question is No, it is not possible to be a Sikh without belief in God. Sikhi begins from Ik Oankaar and there is no Sikhi without God. As an identity I suppose there wouldn't be any problems. As I mentioned in another post, many people take "Sikh" as an identity but aren't really in the truest sense of that word. A Sikh is a student of Satguru Nanak. Satguru Nanak's first teaching is that there is a God. So as you can see, what you suggest is problematic. I'd be interested to know what makes you think there is no God?

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Bachitar Singh · 11 Apr 2007

No. You have a punjabi culture not a sikh culture. There is a big difference. In fear of this argument blowing out of proportion I will not list many differences. I'll list one. Bhangra is not in the sikh culture and is against what sikhi stands for. People do it and consider themselves sikhs but there not. Bhangra is in the musilman culture.

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Demonic Warrior · 11 Apr 2007

'Vik' 'I consider Sikh the values (as I see them) of standing on your own two feet, working hard, excelling, community support, equality and bravery as ones that I think are important and want to support. But I don't think I need a God to help me to that.' For this reason man is called proud and egotistic in Gurbani, as they follow their own mind by saying 'I' can do this and 'I' can do that without God. Even though everything you are doing God is making you do - Gurbani calls us puppets and God the puppeteer. Everything you have in your life is a gift from God, but we ignorant humans do not even think about thanking God but saying that there is no God as 'I' did all this. God is also named the great giver in Gurbani. You may not know but you are very fortunate to have taken birth in this religion from so many other religions in this world. Have you ever thought about why you are here on earth? Do you think its so that we live a householder life, go down to the pub, have fun etc, and in this way our life is at balance, and then we die. What happens then? God sent down so many prophets for proof of God's existence. Even fire, the moon, the sun etc, are witnesses of God's existence. Finally, why do you think you have not seen anything spiritual ever in your life? Well, let me explain it: Life is like a gigantic ocean, deluded by Maya, and to swim across it would be to end this cycle of birth and death. If we indulge in worldliness and attach ourselves to pleasures and sin in this world then we would be drowning in that ocean. Although, if we engage in reciting God's name and religion then we would be in a boat, which is Guru Ji, helping us get across. Meaning, we are dead while yet alive, as we are practicing religion while leading a householder life away from worldly pleasures and sin. This connects us outside the play of Maya to the spiritual - the bigger picture. To be a Sikh is to have love, faith and fear of God while practicing every teaching of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, as well as the rehits given by him. Humans have to have so many life times until they are born as a Sikh.

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Man Singh · 11 Apr 2007

If you are honestly trying to investigate the higher truth including God, then you are a sikh as sikh means student. A student who wants to learn the truth from Guru Nanak can be an athiest. Guru Nanak will definietly teach him and show him that yes God is here. Ik Onkar. Gaining knowledge through your senses (Indriya) is first stage Gaining knowledge using mind is the next stage. Gaining deeper knowledge using your intellect (Budhi) is third stage Gaining further deeper knowledge using intution( antargyan) is next. Gaining further knowledge using light of soul is the ultimate stage. If you are an honest seeker of knowledge and could not find so far then you can be a sikh even without beliveing in God. If you are an athiest without making any efforts to find the truth, then you are hypocrat and can not be the sikh. We learn mathematics and science for 18 years to reach Ph D level and then after investigating the truth we can say if you found newton or einstein right or wrong. Without proper knowledge we have no right to say so. The same way spritual knowledge being even deeper then newton or einstein, we need to do sadhana to investigate the truth at least for 6 years and then only should say if you find God or not?

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

singh sahib · 11 Apr 2007

it seems like you are looking for justification to your question, which most likely wouldnt be supported. you need to read bani and find out who god is, and what he does, for you to understand him, and in turn believe or not believe him.

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Vik · 12 Apr 2007

Thanks for the comments, all... Man Singh wrote: > If you are honestly trying to investigate the higher truth > including God, then you are a sikh as sikh means student. > > A student who wants to learn the truth from Guru Nanak can be > an athiest. Guru Nanak will definietly teach him and show him > that yes God is here. Ik Onkar. > I like that message. I didn't come to be an athiest out of any deliberate rebellion. I just can't believe in a God - that was an early emotional childhood stance and I've followed this up through various reading and studies. Without going into too much detail let me just say that it would be dishonest for me to say there is a Supernatural being. I can't "make" myself believe or pretend that a God exists. For me being a "Sikh" despite not believing in a Theistic Being is as much about "Tribal Loyalty" as anything else. I remain committed to the traditions of it, give money to the Gurdwara, give money to the local school fund of my dad's Punjabi village etc because it's important that there is that sense of "Tribal cohesion", community support and Identity. Does all this merely make me a Punjabi as opposed to a Sikh specifically? I guess that was the crux of my question and I've had mixed answers here. Again without getting into much detail, an athiest can aspire to live to a moral code and values as much as any "Believer" can and succeed. I know many "Believing " Sikhs and Gurdwaraa who appear very "Divine" but are, in my opinion , full of cant. The same applies to non-Believers of course, as well. The strength of Sikhism as I see it - and why Sikhs have on the whole been sucessful where ever they have gone globally - is that it is not a fundamentalist religion. You can't regulate your way to Heaven. You need to adapt and use your intelligence and maximise you potential. There are certain norms, "rites of passage", family networks etc that can give a Sikh "identity", in my opinion, without trying to believe in a Theistic Being. I mean, I respect Monty Panesar, for example and he is a great role model for my kids. But if I started to believe in a God, wear a turban, stop drinking and prayed everyday I would feel a fraud.

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

jassmannn · 12 Apr 2007

You cannot be an atheist and a sikh at the same time. Being born in a sikh family doesn't make you a sikh, it only makes you one by name. I have no problem with you being an atheist. You can only go by what you understand of the world around you. My point is that the two cannot coincide as they are a complete contradiction, and I dare say that many people who actually claim to be Sikhs are in fact further from being so - than an atheist. Regards,

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Atma Singh · 12 Apr 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Veer 'Vik' Jee, i used to be an atheist for various reasons. One major reason was that i couldn't accept the idea of an anthropomorphic (human-like) 'God'. When i found Sikhee after having 'evaluated' other major religions, i was positively shocked. Sikhee's concept of The One is mindblowing, unique and in many ways stretches the boundaries of science. In fact it is more relevant to refer to The One in Sikhee as 'Infinite Love', 'Unchanging and Stable Energy', 'Timeless Form', 'Architect of Destiny' etc. The way in which Vahiguroo is referred to and described is dramatically different to what the West and Semitic religionists are used to...i can't stress how important it is to learn Gurmukhee. Translations simply can't do Gurbanee justice. i would recommend all atheists/sceptics to take the scientific approach - learn Gurmukhee, take Amrit, keep Rehit, meditate on Naam, contemplate Gurbanee...then see if you begin to feel intimations regarding 'The One' or indeed experience first-hand spiritual occurrences. Vik, at least you can say you gave it a shot; the proof is in the pudding after all. [%sig%]

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

abc2 · 12 Apr 2007

Hi Vik There is no such tribe called 'Sikh'. There are many tribes or castes or communities with shared heredity, whose members have become Sikhs. In fact, the majority of Sikhs have come from Jat community. Therefore, it can be said that I share Sikh beliefs in common with some Jats, but myself and those Jats do not belong to the same tribe because I am not a Jat. However, they are Sikhs and so am I. Tribal identity is not the concern of the Sikh marg or panth. Sikhism or Sikhness is concerned with Sikh dharam as espoused by Guru. All of the Sikhs belong to their own tribes, and there is no 'Sikh tribe'. A tribe is something you're born into, but Sikh is a student of Guru. There are many white people who identify with Sikh panth because they are very serious and committed students of Guru, but they do not identify 'Sikh' tribally because tribe is not relevant to Sikhi. Being born to Sikh parents but not sharing the fundamental tenets of belief, even in Ek Onkar, means that you are not a Sikh. Perhaps you can enlighten us as to why you wish to identify as a Sikh?

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Roopkaur · 12 Apr 2007

But what I dont get is, whose Sikh will you be? A Sikh is a disciple, but what kind of disciple will not follow their Guru's very first hukam? Sikhi is not an ethnicity, it is a whole lifestyle, a way of living, a life philosophy. If a doctor has a child, that child does not automatically become a doctor. Likewise a child born in a SIkh household does not automatically become a Sikh, if he or she does not believe in it.

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Vik · 13 Apr 2007

Then I guess I am more a member of a "Jat Punjabi" Tribe with Sikh Family, as the consensus seems to be here that an atheist cannot be a Sikh. I can accept that and be comfortable with it. I guess there is some confusion inthe UK in that Sikhs are, legally, both an ethnic group and a religious group. (Rightly or wrongly and globall irrelevant, I know). I've also talked to some Jews interesteingly enough - there you can be a Jew just by having a Jewish mother and a belief ia a God is not relevant. But again that's not an issue. I'll still keep taking my kids along to the gurdwara and doing the other things I am - that way the kids can decide for themselves. But to conclude, I'd feel a fraud saying I believed in a God when I just don't. Cheers all...

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

harveen_singh_manchester · 13 Apr 2007

WOW! well i just wanted to say (sorry) but 'vik' ji trust me its useless, belive it or not.

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

abc2 · 13 Apr 2007

Vik I respect your stance for being unequivocal. I think it's the honest thing to do - an atheist has a right to be an atheist but not to take cover of any religion. We are here and in the gurdwaras as 'Sikhs', but this is only a name for people who are on a journey to Sach Khand, with SGGS as the guide to show us the way to get there. If you don't want to come alongthen it does not make any sense to associate with people trying to go there. We have to keep moving, and ultimately even close family and friends will take second place to our destiny/destination. Attachments to people in this lifetime have no value for a Sikh. Regarding the decision of British judges to call Sikhs an "ethnic group", in fact this simply means that Sikhs are to be considered an "ethnic group" for the purposes of the Race Relations Act of England and Wales. If this were not the case, then Sikhs would not have had the legal right to wear turban, kirpan, etc. because there was no religious discrimination law at the time. Furthermore the British judiciary does not have any jurisdiction over Sikh matters such as the definition of who is a Sikh. Akaal Takht has authority. As does Kesgarh Sahib, Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib. Sikhs can't be an ethnic group, because nobody can join an ethnic group. If I accept that Sikhs are now an ethnic group, then I insult my own tribe. Furthermore if you say Sikh is ethnic group, then you are insulting the mothers and fathers of the growing number of white non-Punjabi converts. Regarding the Jewish people, they have their own rules and their ways and I don't understand how you could believe that they are any kind of example for anyone else. Suffice to say, there is considerable doubt that the present day 'Jews' are the tribe of Judeans of the Old Testament, and the Ashkenazim and Sephardim lineages are more likely mostly European, with Central Asian (khazar) heritage also. There are also Iranian, Palestinian, even Indian Jews with completely different ancestry. What brings them together is shared religious beliefs, and the nation-state of Israel which has caused considerable misery and suffering. I don't know who you are but from what I've read in this thread, these things are primarily important to you: 1) Being hard-working; 2) Bringing in enough money to support yourself and your family; 3) Having conservative attitude to traditions/customs of your forefathers. All of these things are fine, but they are all matters of your own ego and not spiritual matters. Further these are not 'Sikh'-exclusive values, and the Sikh panth is equally open to the childless unemployed, poor people who you might consider drop-outs or good-for-nothings. I know who my father is, but Sikh panth is also open to people who don't. If it's also a 'tribe' then the membership of such persons would be a problematic issue for you and you probably wouldn't want anything to do with it. However, the wisdom of Guru is open to all and therefore no man can stake a tribal claim to it. [%sig%]

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Man Singh · 13 Apr 2007

Panth means a path to reach God. A Sikh means a student trying to move on that path. That means undertraining to reach God follwoing path of Khalasa. There is no question of `believing' in any thing. It is simple scientific study. We spend 18 years in school to become an engineer or doctor. We know pretty well that in spite of spending such valuable 18 years of time our career is still not guarenteed as we may even get failed. Exactly the same way , If we want to reach the level of sprituality we need to spend sometime in practice. If even without practising something we claim tat there is no God then it is our hypocrisy. Therefore for a Sikh (student) can be an athiest provided he is genuinely investingating existence of God. Without that genuineness, he is nothing but a hypocrat. Therfore let's try. Let's verify what Gurus told us exactly the way we do experiment with newtons laws or Einthiesn's theories. Nothing to worry, we make mistakes in doing experiments, we will repeat the observation again and again unless results of reasonable accuracy are achived. Carry on.

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Vik · 16 Apr 2007

Thanks abc2 and Man Singh. Plenty I agree with and some I don't. But plenty of food for thought. I liked Man Singh's interpretation of a Sikh and the need to clarify what an "athiest" is, especially in relation to scientific study and intellectual rigour. And abc 2's thoughts on ethnicity/tribalism are clear and, I think, hard to disagree with.

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

sloughsingh · 16 Apr 2007

Can one be a meat eating vegetarian? Can one be a law abiding criminal? I could carry on forever.....

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Vik · 17 Apr 2007

<> I have a brother who eats fish but not meat. What is he? I know turbanned Sikhs who believe there is a God but haven't really thought it through and behave the same as any athiests or agnostics. I know many athiests and agnostics who have higher morals and values then many "Believing" Sikhs. I think the final word from me, at this point, is that one must be honest to oneself. If one cannot take that "leap of faith" to say "Yes. There is a supernatural Being that impacts on my life and of the community around me" then it will be a lie to pretend that one does. One can be an athiest after having studied and thought hard and make a decision about why the values and moral codes of a certain Religion may have arisen and still make perfect sense today. Life is never black and white - it is full of grey areas that only you can make sense of. To claim a fundamnetalist view of anything - of what "God" thinks, of what athiesm is, of how people should behave can only backfire, become dangerous and actually hold people back. This is what has happened to Islam in the UK - in my opinion - where that faith is now a point of fear and ridicule by non-Muslims. "Sikhs" - whether the truly religious ones or those who have "merely" inherited a certain tribal and religious custom from the Punjab are held in the UK, I would like to think, in far more esteem and, indeed, outperform the indigenous population economically, educationally etc. Ultimately, and to use an extreme example, if it came down to drawing up barricades and fighting a battle (I know, it's an extreme example but I'm making a point) myself and all my cousins - lukewarm believers of Sikihism or not, followers of just the tribal customs or not, will still be on the same side. Isn't claiming that one must believe in a Supernatural Being (no offence intended - it's the way I think) to be a Sikh just as exclusive as saying that one can be a Sikh merely if one's parents bring you up as one and you follow all the Gurdwara rituals etc? Somebody pointed out earlier that Sikh means to "study". If that is done genuinely and honestly......

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Atma Singh · 18 Apr 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Veer 'Vik' Jee, It's seriously scary just how much they way you think reminds me of they way i used to think. i don't mean to belittle you by saying that. It is important to understand that what begins as faith becomes, in time, first-hand experience. As far as Sikhee is concerned, there is no 'leap of faith' - we are here to become at One with what we start out by 'believing-in' and in doing so, come to KNOW Vaheguroo...without coming to KNOW Vaheguroo whilst alive, this human birth is next to useless. Therfore, Sikhee believes in achieving an OBJECTIVE not SUBJECTIVE understanding of Vaheguroo. As Maharaaj Jee says: [gurbani]suixvfwAwKYsBukoie ][/gurbani] sun vaddaa aakhai sabh koe || Hearing of His Greatness, everyone calls Him Great. [gurbani]kyvfuvfwfITwhoie ][/gurbani] kaevadd vaddaa ddeet(h)aa hoe || But just how Great His Greatness is-this is known only to those who have seen Him. [gurbani]kImiqpwienkihAwjwie ][/gurbani] keemath paae n kehiaa jaae || His Value cannot be estimated; He cannot be described. [gurbani]khxYvwlyqyryrhysmwie ]1][/gurbani] kehanai vaalae thaerae rehae samaae ||1|| Those who describe You, Lord, remain immersed and absorbed in You. ||1|| The last Panktee is very revealing. [%sig%]

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

cov_singh_tj · 21 Apr 2007

ATHEIST - Someone who does not believe in god SIKH - LOVES GOD!

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Singhz R Kingz · 23 Apr 2007

Hello Vik, I am currently in a grade 12 philosphy class and i came up across an article that seemed quite interesting and relates to your situation. Its called The Wager and its written by the philospher Blaise Pascal. I suggest you give it a read. I will just briefly summarize his article: Make a table with 2 columns and 2 Rows. In the first column, write down God exists and in the second one, God doesnt exist. In the first row, write down I believe and in the second one, I dont believe. The first Row: If God exists and you believe in him, you have "infinity to gain" or nothing to lose. If God doesn't exist but you believed in him, you lose lets say 666 worldly pleasures. (thats the number our class came up with as the majority are christians) The second row: If God exists and you dont believe in him, you have "infinity to lose" (you will go to hell). But on the other hand, if you dont believe in God and it turns out he doesnt exist, then you only have 666 pleasures to gain. Now look at both rows. The one with the greater benefit would be the first row as you have infinity to gain but in the second row, you only have 666. if you believe in God, you sacrifice 666 of your pleasures and have infinity to gain (ie go to heaven). But if you dont believe and God exists, you will only have experienced 666 fun things but will have "infinity to lose". Its your decision. As the title of the article says, you have to wager and obviously you are going to want to bet on the side that would hold your best interests. But the rest is up to you. Anyways, bhula chuka dee khima waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Vik · 25 Apr 2007

Singhz R Kingz The issue I have with Pascal's wager is the idea that one can "will" oneself to believe in a supernatural being (no insult intended) with no evidence. And it, for me, still does not prove the existence of a God without resorting, literally, to a leap of faith. Finally, if God did exist why would he respect me for "pretending" to believe in him because of a supposed 50/50 gamble. Would he rather that I was honest to myself and lived an honourable life?

Re: Can one be an Athiest Sikh?

Singhz R Kingz · 25 Apr 2007

Ok I see what youre saying But as a "SIKH", we all do paath right? and where did all this bani come from? "Dhur ki baani aayee, tin saglee chint mitaee" take mool mantar for example: every word describes God. so whose paath are you going to do if you dont believe in god and bani states many qualities of god??