Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Kulbir Singh · 18 May 2004

Sikh priests decry seva dal advertisement Ask Malaysian gurdwaras to stop non-veg in langar Our Correspondent Amritsar, May 18 The five Sikh high priests while taking a serious note of an advertisement denigrating Guru Gobind Singh, the 10th Sikh Guru, by Miri Piri Seva Dal head Gurinderpal Singh Dhanola, issued directions to the Sikh sangat not to drag the name of Sikh gurus in any type of campaigning and warned that such advertisements should not be repeated in the SGPC elections scheduled for July 11. In another significant decision, the head priests denied permission to Malaysian gurdwaras for serving non-vegetarian food in the langar. Both matters assume significance as this is the first time that such issues were deliberated upon at a meeting held at the Akal Takht secretariat today. Akal Takht Jathedar Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti said they had received a communication from Kishan Singh, secretary, Kalang Gurdwara in Malaysia, who stated that a kind of meat was being served in many gurdwaras there and sought permission for its continuance which was denied to them. The head priests also took objection to the name of ‘onkar’ (religious symbol of Sikhs) used as the name by a TV channel. In another decision, the head priests directed the demolition of steps constructed for the handicapped in Sacha Dhan Gurdwara at Mohali and demanded a report on the construction near the parkash of Guru Granth Sahib there. Satnam Singh, a nihang who had presented himself here for placing kalgi on controversial Baba Bhaniarawale, was awarded ‘tankhah’. The meeting also took a serious note of book ‘Guru Garib Niwaz’, written by five persons eulogising a self-styled guru of Padhri Kalan. The head priests also discussed taking Guru Granth Sahib to a ‘mazaar’ in Sansara village near Rajasansi and another instance of taking the holy book to a marriage palace by Gurjant Singh in Raikot.

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 24 May 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki Fateh. I believe the Jathedars have been "misled"..... NO MALAYSIAN GURDWARA serves "meat" in Guru Ka Langgar.... However there is such a thing known as MOCK MEAT and this is s substance VEGETARIAN BASED Soybean mixed with some other 100% VEGETARIAN substances that is made to "look and taste" like various "meats" like chicken, duck, fish etc. The Flour cookies are even coloured and shaped to "look" like fish, chicken drim sticks, duck parts. Everyone knows that is is MOCK MEAT and the term is self explanatory. This stuff is cooked and served in many Gurdwaras and Klang is not the only one. Although from my personal point of view, I also discouraged the use of this stuff as to me eating MOCK MEAT is "enjoyed by the MIND" ( although strictly speaking the MOCK MEAT is 100% VEGETARIAN and served in all VEGETARIAN BUDDHIST chinese restaurants etc as well)...BUT to mislead the Jathedars into placing it under BAN as a "meat" is self defeating and makes a mockery of Guru ka Langgar ( implying that the Jathedars dont even know SAAG from MAAS...as in GURU NANAK SAHIB JEES SHABAD in the GURU GRANTH SAHIB JEE. Action should be taken against the person who misled the Jathedars into giving this wrong interpretation to MOCK MEAT. This is most probably local gurdwara politics as in the Canada Chairs/Carpets in Langgar issue...and the Jathedars are being used for personal ends to score points. Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani.

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

???? · 24 May 2004

If i am not mistaken what is served is served in malaysian Gurdwaras is called mock meat, which is made of soya beans. They are made to look like real meat. The chinese vegetarians in the East have come up with very imagitative ways of making soya beans to look like real meat. So is it wrong? [%sig%]

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Mkhalsa · 25 May 2004

We call it veggie meat here. I used to eat it all the time. I see nothign wrong with it (except its anti bibek stuff) but if its not a bibek langar, there shouldnt be any problem in serving it? I have seen people make dal with it here etc.. As long as its widely known that its not meat...

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 05 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khlasa Waheguru Ji KI fateh. SO far there has been no comment from the Authorities on this MOCK MEAT issue.......and the MALAYSIAN GURDWARAS continue to be "maligned" as meat servers which is UNTRUE.??? However certain NIHUNG GURDWARAS in INDIA DO SERVE JHATKAMEAT and call it MAHAPARSAAD but that has not been BANNED ??? I find it surprising that in this age of Computers internet and instant communication...... a wrong decision has been made and is not being corrected ???? Why is MOCK MEAT made of 100% VEGETARIAN BASE termed "meat" when this is just a colloquial term ??? Jarnail Singh

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

?????????? · 05 Jun 2004

Mkhalsa, Why is Veggie meat (Soya Beans) not allowed if you are Bibek ????

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

. · 05 Jun 2004

mock meat is gross... when i was young my brother and i got in trouble for having cigarettes made of gum. its the same thing (in my opinion :-) )

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

khalistani · 05 Jun 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! cause in bibek u can only eat stuff made by an amridhari and it has to be made in sarab loh that aint the case with veggie meat bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Mkhalsa · 06 Jun 2004

Did you make it yourself from scratch? if not, its not allowed. If you get the soya beans and boil them and strain them and then put in all the other stuff like gluten (which you kneaded by hand etc) then sure, its perfectly alright, but if you ask me, thats a pretty big waste of time.

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 07 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Yes I agree with Mkhalsa Ji. Its a waste of time. To be really bibek we must endeavour to grow the soya beans ourself, harvest them, wash them, boil, strain etc etc..... a pretty tall order in this age and time. More important as Bhai Randhir Singh Ji proved in his life time is COMPLETE IMMERSION IN GURBANI +++ bibek as far as humanly possible. But the GURBANI IMMERSION part is more important and by far moire vital and will also help us to sustain our bibek ( of mind/heart/thoughts etc rather than just "food" alone ). If a cow has been fed "stolen Chara" or fed with feed bought with impure earnings, impure food etc...its milk will be IMPURE even if a bibeki milked it himself using sarb loh utensils.... so how will that help bibek ?? My understanding is we must stress MORE on GURBANI and the bibek taught by GURBANI....first and foremost...and then follow the sarbloh bibek of food. Jarnail Singh

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

???? · 07 Jun 2004

What do you mean by did you make it from scratch, I just get the pack from the shop and cook it. Is that OK. Thanks again

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Mkhalsa · 07 Jun 2004

if you didnt make it yourself, its not bibek.

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

chee chee · 07 Jun 2004

is the meat langar also given to maharaj for bhog ? [%sig%]

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 09 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dear Chee Chee Ji: >>>>>>You write: is the meat langar also given to maharaj for bhog ?<<<< NO veer Ji there is NO MEAT in the LANGGAR. The Thing is called "MOCK MEAT" and it is a 100% SOYABEAN++ATTA based concoction made to "LOOK" like meat..... Of course if we take an "argumentative" stance - the food of the cow is 100% VEGETARIAN......but what comes out is MEAT......then 100% Vegetarian SOYA BEAN ++ Wheat Flour = "mock meat" could mean meat to some ??? I really dont know. Vegetarians the world over consume this stuff...and by the way it is MORE COSTLY than the real meat because it is MANUFACTURED !!!! Jarnail Singh

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

veg · 09 Jun 2004

If I start calling paneer with a name like white meat, that does not make it meat.

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

. · 10 Jun 2004

"If I start calling paneer with a name like white meat, that does not make it meat." yes, but.... If you make the paneer smell, taste and look like meat it makes it "imitation/wannabe meat".

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

believer · 10 Jun 2004

wjkk wjkf. i think its more to do with the intention behind the eating of this MOCK MEAT. it shouldnt be made to look like meat in anyway-esp. in langar(if that occurs). you wouldn't dress up ur veg to look like meat!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! soya is pure vegatarian and is tasty- it has nothing to do with meat-its just another form of food. yeh its similar in its chewiness- but that dnt make it wrong to eat. Personally i dnt think that it should b called MOCK MEAT or anything like that cuz its teaching youngsters that there's ways around issues like not eating meat. these are my personal views so please forgive me if it has offended anyone. Bhul chuk marf karni. wjkk wjkf.

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Mkhalsa · 10 Jun 2004

but still not meat

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 11 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. As the saying goes....a rose by any other name is still a rose... BUT a PAPER ROSE is NOT a rose.....it may look like one, even made to semll like one, feel like one.....BUT it still is NOT a rose. Veer MKhalsa is RIGHT. Soyabean based mock meat is NOT meat.....it may look like meat, smell like meat, taste like meat......BUT IT IS NOT MEAT. Being anti this seems like brahmanwaad creeping in...although the actual brahmins have no problem with this stuff and eat it.. Jarnail Singh

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

. · 15 Jun 2004

Sorry, i was under the impression we were supposed to counter the desire to indulge in meat. I guess I was thinking that if you change tofu/soy products and make them look/smell/taste like meat it was just wasteful. I thought simple was better. I guess i was wrong... its only the physical act of eating meat that is wrong? I still don't understand why someone would want to eat "mock meat". I did say it was just my opinion in my first post, where I said my brother and I got in trouble for having gum cigarettes (that looked like real cigarettes, and they had powder around them, so you could pretend to be smoking). But just one more thing.. who cares what brahmins eat? If they eat mock meat, that actually makes me question it more. Like I said.. I still don't understand. thank you

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 15 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. No need to be sorry. In fact your reason is precisely why I also OPPOSE this mock meat thingy ( besides the cost as this costs the sangat/langgar sewadar more to prepare compared to simple usual langgra fare). I beleive the CONTROL should be on the MIND....that is why in one Hukm GURU JI GOBIND SINGH JI tell us to AVOID even Dreaming/thinking/imagining secual contact with someone other than our married partner. This is proof enough that controlling the mere "PHYSICAL" craving for meat/sex /alcohol/ other pleasures etc is not enough...we MUST keep our MIND CLEAN as well. You talk of gum "cigarettes"...my dad used to slap any child in his class that put a pencil/pen/ etc in his mouth and "pretended" to smoke...and many got this punishment every week because of watching films that showed macho actors smoking. Sometimes I face such children in my classes too and they get the same treatment.....I abhor even the "idea" of smoking entering any of my young minds' and polluting them. But then the other side of the argument is if someone wants to eat this mock meat for reasons of taste/feel/texture etc...why should we become "religious police" and ban them just because of the word meat !! I hope this clarifies things.....and promotes iur mutual understanding... May Guru ji have Kirpa. Thank You also. dass Jarnail Singh

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

. · 16 Jun 2004

I guess we agree? I didn't say it was just because it had the word meat in it. I don't think it matters what its called. I was trying to say.. eat paneer, eat tofu, eat soy products, etc... but don't make them look/taste/smell like meat. If people want to eat it, they should... but it would be better if they didn't... I mean it would be better if they didn't want to!

Re: Malaysian Gurdwaras denied permission to serve non-veg

.::singh::. · 17 Jun 2004

"Sorry, i was under the impression we were supposed to counter the desire to indulge in meat. I guess I was thinking that if you change tofu/soy products and make them look/smell/taste like meat it was just wasteful. I thought simple was better. " ...yo man...simple...we not baamans (brahmins) iite...u jus gotta control ur own self thas it ...if u eating soya..i'm pretty sure u've eaten meat b4..it taste notin like ite.. if meats rite infronta u n u hav a desire to eat it ...THAS RONG OK..not eating something tht looks or if u wanna push may b for u it even taste like it..so lets jus close this post..by sayin don b baaman eat the damn soya man..its protein...we gotta hav our proteins..if we ain't eatin meat fish or eggs...we gotta hav soya..cuz its pure plant matter..thas all i'ma say.. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh