Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

CSJ · 04 Apr 2007

Is any body know why somebody can not wear gol turban who is working for sgpc. I was told by raagi singh that when they are on duty they are not allowed to wear round turban. They have to wear this patiala type turban. i think round turban is our orignal style. [%sig%]

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

BirRaas Singh · 04 Apr 2007

If Guru Gobind Singh come back tommorow, the SGPC would probably tell Maharaj to wear a patiala shahi pag, loose kurta pajama and a dodgy butter knife kirpan.

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 04 Apr 2007

Baba Ram Singh Ji Mukhi DamDAmi Taksal refused to wear the SGPC uniform and continued to wear Round Dastar with Chola...I think he did take heat because of this from SGPC and eventually they transfered him from Amritsar to Haryana> I know a lot of what the UK Nihungs say is just hog wash, but honestly the more I think about it, the more I agree with what they have to say about SGPC. The SGPC began in 1920 (or whatever) but now they (SGPC) don't consider anyone else or any other Jatha but themselves as Sikh which is very arrogant of them.

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

CSJ · 04 Apr 2007

What we expect from other countries if in darbar sahib the person cant wear our bana. What is there reason for doing that. [%sig%]

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

abc2 · 04 Apr 2007

I'm not saying you're right or wrong .. perhaps you're right. But when you say 'SGPC' at least I know exactly who you're talking about. OTOH when you say 'UK Nihungs' who are they? That's not a jatha. Who speaks for these individuals and knows their opinion on SGPC? I don't think it's safe to simply assume that a 7 year old website written by one person continues to represent the views of a number of unknown UK individuals, and then to attribute that perspective to "the UK nihungs". Maybe they've changed their minds, or maybe they never all shared that opinion with the webmaster in the first place. My point being this: the SGPC seems more democratic and unified as well as larger and more powerful. If it's wrong about its turban style policy or anything else, then steps can be taken to change that, proving that SGPC does not, unlike some groups perhaps, claim infallibility.

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

Khalistan_zindabaad · 04 Apr 2007

at amrit vela your allowed to wear watever you like to do the seva i.e. bana goal dastaar etc. its only after you cant

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

Bachitar Singh · 04 Apr 2007

You can wear a Gol one just not a white colored one. A couple weeks ago the chardhi kala jatha was doing keertan in the middle of the day wearing blue gol dastaars

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

jassmannn · 05 Apr 2007

You can wear any coloured Turban at any time of the day. What has style of Turban got to so with anything? The gol pagh represent no caste, wheras other turbans have been assocaited with regions and castes. I don't know where is says anything in any religious scripture that you can't wear a white turban, or not allowed to wear it a certain way. Can someone tell me where this information is coming from?

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

CSJ · 05 Apr 2007

"A couple weeks ago the chardhi kala jatha was doing keertan in the middle of the day wearing blue gol dastaars" Only people emplyoed by sgpc cant wear gol dastar. Chardhi kala jatha is not working for sgpc that is why they were wearing gol dastar. Hajoori raggis and people on any other duties are not allowed but this is wrong anyway . A person should choose himself what style of dastar he wanted. [%sig%]

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 05 Apr 2007

its coming from sgpc, self appointed so called "agoos" (leaders) of the panth. This whole voting system and SGPC needs to abolished. People think democrartic process is fair and just...no way this whole system is corrupt and filthy. I pray that one day, even if it s not in my lifetime that there is a revolution and these modern day SGPC masands are thrown out of our Gurdwaras and Sikhi.

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

abc2 · 05 Apr 2007

Sarab loh ji just take it easy. The SGPC controls most of the gurdwaras but it does not micromanage. When you say "SGPC masands" these are very strong words and unless you can back it up with evidence then it's uncalled for. As for throwing people out of Sikhi, I don't think you'll find any mainstream support for that extremist notion. Coming from the UK, it seems to me that if you kick the chair out from underneath SGPC, there are already several decidedly undemocratic organisations who would be likely to contend for the control of the gurdwaras. What's surprising about these organisations is that they have formed alliances despite deep-seated underlying differences in beliefs, providing a good example of how unity can work. Of course this unity between them will only last until the "enemy" (which is our flawed but democratic-in-name-anyway representative the SGPC) is out of the competition. From the UK perspective, it's well disguised, but it's obvious now where the support for deposition of SGPC is coming from. Follow the money, and our Punjabi heritage protection is traceable to UK government grants and lottery awards. Furthermore our new guardians of Sikh traditionalism have a history of reselling Sikh artifacts to the highest bidder while simultaneously attacking SGPC at every opportunity for its failure to protect and preserve Sikh heritage. So at the level of individuals involved, I suspect the allure of money and power is just as strong as the people behind SGPC. The only DIFFERENCE if you get rid of SGPC control over here, is that foreign-based people with the same and perhaps more (hidden) motives will replace them. Nothing will change for the sangat. On the "hidden" charge, it's now transparent because of international actions over the last couple of years that not just SGPC who are being targeted - it's other Sikh groups such as Shere Punjab, R4G campaign and anyone else who tries to do ANYTHING for their community apart from shut up and continue to put daswand into the box. These actions are being coordinated in an organised way. So what I'm saying is: it seems that SGPC may be "corrupt", but so is whatever it is that wants to replace it. Parliamentary democracy is rife with corruption, but we don't try to replace it overnight by "revolution". The more representative something is, the better. There's nothing wrong with being interested in heritage and traditionalism, but unity and the democratic representation of the Sikh people by Sikh people and not Mi5 or whoever is a higher priority. [%sig%]

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 05 Apr 2007

abc2 ji, i understand your point...my statements stem from frustration, something needs to be done though...but what? It is a fact that Sikhi has been hijacked by these political, non religious, oppurtunistic personalities ( no need to mention names as everyone already knows them). What can we do as individuals besides Ardas?

Re: Gol Dastaar Ban in Darbar Sahib

Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 05 Apr 2007

LOL Funny I think I just found the answer to my own question on another recent post by Harjas Kaur: "Former Jathedar Bhai Ranjit Singh who was responsible in taking out Nakli Nirankari Bachna has literally called for the stoning of Vedanti by Sadh Sangat and asked the youth to come forward and free Akal Takht from this gang. I once again urge all Sikh organizations and Gurdwaras in diaspora to pass resolutions totally boycotting Joginder Singh Vedanti and call for his immediate removal" Thank you Karjas Kaur Bhenji :-). But I would still like to here from you abc2 Paji WJKK WJKF