Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Roopkaur · 01 Apr 2007

I understand Sikhi believes in equality of all, and anyone can join the fold of Sikhi, no matter what caste you are. However, is that all Sikhi is about? Us being open to all castes? I have had a few conversations about this with some of my peers, and many believe it is okay to keep cutting your hair, shave/wax your legs, go to parties/ clubbing, etc. but as long as you do not beleive in caste, your okay. I think that Sikhi is equally open to all, as anyone from any creed, caste, race can become a member of the Sikh fold. However, does that mean that in equality there are no responsibilities. If we take Canada as an example, all citizens are equal under the law, however, there are still rules and laws that we are required to follow as Canadian citizens, in order to enjoy the priviledges of the rights. Likewise, I think it is important to realize that Sikhi is not just about the rights and priviledges of everyone being equal, but we have to realize that there are responisibilities that come with the title of Sikh as well

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

singh5 · 01 Apr 2007

I agree that a lot of people seem to have a really dumbed down impression of what Sikhi means. Sometimes it's not even accurate. Usually a non-practicing Sikh will say Sikhi means, everyone is equal, be a good person and God is one. Those are all true of course, but those values are shared by most religions. I can't think of many religions that say *don't* be a good person. But the fact is that these remain just concepts and theories without the spiritual practice of Sikhi which is naam. True character is built only through naam. Guru Sahib says clearly, "ਨਾਮ ਬਿਨਾ ਕੈਸੇ ਆਚਾਰ ॥੧॥" meaning, how can one have character without naam? and also "ਕਾਮੁ ਕ੍ਰੋਧੁ ਬਿਖੁ ਬਜਰੁ ਭਾਰੁ ॥ ਨਾਮ ਬਿਨਾ ਕੈਸੇ ਗੁਨ ਚਾਰੁ ॥੧॥ ਰਹਾਉ ॥ " meaning, lust, anger (and other vices) are such an extreme burden on a person, without naam how can s/he have virtues and righteous action? Very few people set out in life to be "bad". But it happens to many. Without the transforming power of naam, the 5 vices continue their effect and a person slips up. Only through naam can someone truly have a virtuous, strong and immovable character. Only then is someone truly a "good person." All others are always susceptible to a major fall. The key to Sikhi is naam and the spiritual practice. To get naam a person has to receive deeksha from Guru Nanak which is only possible now through amrit from the the Punj Pyaaray. Only through this naam and spiritual lifestyle obtained from Guru Nanak, accompanied by the rehit, can someone really enjoy the benefits of Sikhi and truly incorporate the concept of equality, One God, etc. That's my opinion anyways.

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Dalbiri · 02 Apr 2007

It does say a lot that over 300 years after the initiation of the Khalsa, we still have caste and are as obsessed about it as Hindus. Did we fail in the objective of a casteless society then?

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Man Singh · 02 Apr 2007

Singh5 ji has clarified the matter. Castless society on paper is not enough. This nis just beginning. Real sikhi is practising sikhi. Without practising it , it is simply a ritual of calling oneself a `sikh'. As just merely by shouting sugar , sugar, sugar will never make your mouth sweet, the same way merely by calling yourself a sikh, just by calling you are castless will not help anything. To be a sikh, you have to practise it. Look at Aryasamaji's the same way. Swami Dayanad asked them two things: 1. Read and follwo Vedas 2. Abandon and condemn idolatory and What Arya samajis are doing today. They just stick to secondary teaching of their founder and abandon the primary teaching ot reading and follwing Vedas. Same way is with Sikhs today. Sikhs are doing exactly what Great Gurus opposed(sticking to the rituals only). Cast is present in every community in the world in one form or the other. Muslims even after 1000 years of conversion could not eliminate castism from their society. Christians even after 1600 years of their conversion could not eliminate castims from their society. Sikhism, Aryasamajism and all none could create a castless society. Why? Becasue castism evolved due to socioplitical , historical conditions of Indian subcntinent and will be eliminated when those conditions will change. As economic developement is taking shape in India, cast is becoming irrelevant among so called uppercast people thought not non exustant. becoming irrelevant is first step of elimination. reservation politics is playing improtant role in keeping castims alive otherwise by this time it might have got eliminated. Elimination of south Korean castims is an example.

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Dalbiri · 02 Apr 2007

As just merely by shouting sugar , sugar, sugar will never make your mouth sweet, the same way merely by calling yourself a sikh, just by calling you are castless will not help anything. To be a sikh, you have to practise it. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- And from what i see the vast majority of practising Sikhs still haven't left this behind. It does look pathetic, especially to those raised in the west. I mean you have to ask about just how effective amrit is in achieving its goals. All the simran in the world doesn't excuse looking down on others let alone at your own people. If particular "caste" groups have some important understanding that others don't then it falls on them to try and disseminate this information panth wide, not create barriers between ourselves. The result of this is obvious, we are the only people who have fully failed in a guerilla war against a government in modern times. The reason for this was a particular caste tried to dominate the movement and leave the others behind. In the end it was members of the same caste that turned gaddhaar and caused its failure. Like I said before, if at a fundamental level we cannot create a flat society amongst us then we have to ask what WE are doing wrong. Not blame external forces. You said the following as an explanation of the perseverance of caste in Indian society. "Becasue castism evolved due to socioplitical , historical conditions of Indian subcntinent and will be eliminated when those conditions will change." You don't think that one of the big things the Gurus attempted with Sikhi was exactly this? What about the fact that outside of India caste still persists stronger than ever. How can you blame India for this. The truth is some people calling themselves Sikhs (including a majority of amritdharis), actually like caste and fight to preserve it. That is the long, short and tall of it. Also: "Cast is present in every community in the world in one form or the other. Muslims even after 1000 years of conversion could not eliminate castism from their society. Christians even after 1600 years of their conversion could not eliminate castims from their society. Sikhism, Aryasamajism and all none could create a castless society. Why?" Why are we excusing caste in our society by looking at other communities failures? Are we just run of the mill ourselves? Did we not have a full fronted direct attack on caste bequeathed by Dasmesh Pita himself in the Amrit ceremony? In the end, all the kamae and simran and wearing bana in the world can't hide that someone who adheres to caste in this day and age, especially outside of India, is just plain simply backward looking. Even Hindus don't obsess about it as much as us now outside of India and presumably within too. One of the key innovations that Sikhi wrought was a flat hierarchyless society. That made us different from everyone else. Sadly this is lost now.

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

singh5 · 02 Apr 2007

I think the point of the original post was that you can't have things like casteless society unless you have the rest of Sikhi. People aren't magically going to reject caste and class. Only if all the rest of the principles of Gurmat are also accepted, in particular naam, is this going to be possible. Naam brings forth divine qualities from the person. Do different classes of people exist? Are their differences between a Jat and a Khatri and a Brahmin? There are cultural differences between these groups. Obviously no human is born better than any other but it's willful blindness to say that these groups don't have clear differences. Only when we take on a Khalsa identity are those differences going to go away. The benefits of Sikhi come as part of the whole package which includes naam, amrit vela, rehit, etc. If you reject those latter features and expect that caste will magically disappear from society, it's just a delusion.

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Roopkaur · 02 Apr 2007

I do not think that amrit Chakking alone can make caste dissapear because I do not think that in SIkhism, caste is denied. Gurbani mentions the castes over and over again, HOWEVER, these old castes are only eliminated once we come into the sharn of Guru JI and disown those castes and declare "humree jaat paat Gur Satgur". And to get amrit chuk is not the only requirement to take on Guru Sahib as your jaat and paat. You also promise during that initial ceremony that you will keep Guru Sahib's rehit, such as getting up at amrit vela, and japping naam, refraining from bujjar kurehits etc. Someone mentioned that it was because of one caste that the kharku leher failed. First of all, it was not a failure in the sense that we as Sikhs still exist in both India and out because of the Shaheediiaa of many many mahaan GUrsikhs. Secondly, the only reason it went downhill at the end of the leher was because the focus moved away from REHIT, and got more on recruiting larger numbers. Today, like stated by the posters above, any person born into the SIkhi/Punjabi culture think that the only requirement for being a SIkh is to pay the word some lip service and that is it. THis is closer to the caste system because the caste is something you are born into. The initiation system that Guru Sahib ji started, whereby you enter a contract with Guru Ji by saying that there are certain conditions you wil follow so that you can be Guru Sahib's Sikh, is unique because you CHOOSE to be a SIkh, you CHOOSE to follow Guru Sahib's path, you CHOOSE to make Guru Sahib your honor by rejecting the previous caste system. >One of the key innovations that Sikhi wrought was a flat hierarchyless society. That made us different from everyone else. Sadly this is lost now.< I agree that this is lost. And again it goes back to the hesitancy to follow rehit. Now, just so we can excuse ourselves from following rehit, we have made different groups, THe Khalsa SIkhs (those who amritdharee) the Sehajdharee Sikhs (those who arent amritdharee but somewhat follow SIkhi) and the SIkhs (those who are born in a SIkhi oriented household yet follow no SIkhi, except for maybe go to the gurdvara once a week or so). There should be no castes, and there would not be, if all of those who claim to be SIkhs would just follow Guru Sahib's rehit, and this includes me.

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Man Singh · 02 Apr 2007

Yes `Totality' , `complete package' is the answer.

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Dalbiri · 02 Apr 2007

Bhai Jis I get your point but if you are saying that Panjabis are that dumb that they are generally unable to see that discrimination and oppression is plain wrong, without going into the deepest levels of spirituality, we are in real deep trouble. Nowerdays almost all civilised societies are based on this premise. We must be really behind not to catch up on this. Then again looking at the female infanticide, drug, wife burning and general corruption problems in Sikh society we shouldn't be surprised. Having an understanding that looking down on members of your own community with contempt and disdain is plain evil doesn't require amrit but plain old common sense and humanity. (Note I'm not knocking amrit but you should get my point).

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

singh5 · 02 Apr 2007

I think every society theoretically sees that discrimination and oppression are wrong. But in practice I don't think there is any society that doesn't practice it. Punjabis may have caste but in the West we have class and race distinctions. Western society abandoned slavery less than 150 years ago. It still has not solved the class and race issues I've mentioned. Like I said before, having a genuine belief and practice that all are worthy of compassion, mercy and love is something that a spiritual practice of naam and bani can instill. Otherwise people may pay lip-service to the concept of egalitarianism but it doesn't exist.

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Dalbiri · 02 Apr 2007

But still from my experience the vast majority of practising Sikhs who do simran etc. still haven't got over the caste thing so it doesn't seem to help much in that department.

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Roopkaur · 02 Apr 2007

I agree with Singh5. I just finished reading BlaCk Like Me, and the southern Whites discussed in that text honestly believed they were doing the right thing by segregating Blacks and treating them worse than animals. Many of them thought it was the Christian thing to do. As for your claim that practising Sikhs still look at caste, I do not understand what you are trying to say. Are you suggesting there is no point in doing simran and getting amrit chhuck? We could take that argument to many places, such as, People do paath and still lie, lets just forget about doing paath then, or a lot of people wear turbans but cut their beard, so the turban isnt helping much. There are kameeaa in all of us, noone is perfect escept for Akaal Purkh and Guru Sahib. Yet, it is not in the rehit that we can find the kamee, but in the person themselves.

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Harinder Singh · 03 Apr 2007

I was a bit amazed to find that many rehitvaan gursikhs who keep pretty decent rehit(including sarbloh bibekis haha) suffered from caste effect too. I just couldn't believe it but then "saachi livai bin DEH NIMANI" and VERY VERY FEW sikhs get the daat of LIV. Though in west caste isnt that big a factor, but colour etc are. The root of all this is body/haume/ bikh and one has to JAPP LOTS OF NAAM(not just keep decent rehit) plus one needs to have Guru Kirpa to completely rise over things like colour,ancestory,caste. IN punjab jatts are the main culprits. Deep down almost every jatt(including the ones who are into sikhi) feels that non jatt sikhs are darpok or inferior. I myself was born in a jatt family but have developed deep dislike with the whole jatt stuff. Its due to this reason that we dont have khalsa raj and WE DONT DESERVE IT. The khalistan movement though wasnt a failure but dint give us khalistan because there were very few naam abhiyaasis involved. There were very few people like Bhai Anokh Singh Ji Babbar. But the future is going to be different as Khalsa is going to come back. Infact Khalsa is already back and the play will start soon. RAJ KAREGA KHALSA

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

CSJ · 03 Apr 2007

Alteast people start by not using last names in gurudawaras in ardaas in speeches etc. [%sig%]

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Harinder Singh · 05 Apr 2007

Recently I had a discussion with my dad regarding casteisn in sikhi. He told that though casteisn has no place in sikhi, but being jatt is something different and special. He then gave examples of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji, Baba Jarnail Singh Ji, Baba Budha Ji and Baba Deep Singh Ji all being jatts, haha. I think that day isnt far when people in Punjab would start to claim that Waheguru Ji is also a Jatt, haha and might even attempt to change the True Naam from Wahe-Guru to JATT-Guru,hahaha.

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Harjas Kaur · 06 Apr 2007

[quote]Its due to this reason that we dont have khalsa raj and WE DONT DESERVE IT. The khalistan movement though wasnt a failure but dint give us khalistan because there were very few naam abhiyaasis involved. There were very few people like Bhai Anokh Singh Ji Babbar. But the future is going to be different as Khalsa is going to come back. Infact Khalsa is already back and the play will start soon. RAJ KAREGA KHALSA[/quote] Wahegurooo! [%sig%]

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

CSJ · 06 Apr 2007

"Its due to this reason that we dont have khalsa raj and WE DONT DESERVE IT." I think even we get it we will kill each other like in misil times. First land will be divided according to cast. Amritdhari peoples are already divide by proving they got better amrit then other people because they belong to certain group. So I dont think there are too many true khalsa mostly we are from outside only. One raagi singh was telling me that One time in gurmat camp they were talking about kes and kid went to home and told his parent that we should keep kes. They told him this for other sikhs, Jat sikhs dont need to keep kes. [%sig%]

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Harinder Singh · 07 Apr 2007

Though the present AKJ is a very very shallow reflection of Bhai Sahibs time, but it is still the best jatha in the panth(the other jathas are in terrible state),and even in AKJ , caste is a big factor. Maya has entered AKJ too. You have marriages based on caste, on physical roop, for immigrating to west(deep down almost everybody in Punjab is ready to get nri rishta, leave their old parents,leave Guru de dharti, remove their Sri Sahib and run to west). Its ghor kalyug. I am yet to hear of a wedding between a gursikh from jatt background and a gursikh from scheduled caste(so called) background. I feel its upto youth to change all this. May be the youth shud DELIBRATELY marry out of caste. Guru Sahib will NEVER give KHalsa Raj to sikhs lost in casteism. Dear Bhai Beant Singh Ji who sent Bibi Indra to Hell belonged to a so called low caste. During khalistan movement, large no. of police officials who killed sikh youth(for promotions from New Delhi) were jattan de kaake(shame on their very existence). A real jatt is one who slays the 5 demons and opens up the dasam duar, rest all are fake foolish jatts. I also feel that in the future a war for khalsa raj is coming in Punjab and quite a few of punjabi jatts are going to join the enemy of khalsa(for maya benefits) and will be taught an unforgettable lesson by Khalsa. Pragtiyo KHalsa PARMATAM KE MAUJ RAJ KAREGA KHALSA

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

Man Singh · 07 Apr 2007

Khalistan movement faild not becasue of cast. It failed because it streted from the wrong place. origin of Sikhi is Nankana Sahib now in Pakistan. The first place to be liberated should be nankana sahib. Any other attempts will fail as we should strat from root and not from trunks and leaves etc. Those who move on spritual path naturaly forget cast. Anybody using cast proudiness even after Amrit chakhh are simply a non strarters in sprituial path. Sikhs are unique only becasue they are soldiers with spritual bent side by side and that's why it is ensured that they will never do any crime against humanity and never torture any innocent creature. As mentioend by many above, most of the `khalistani fighters' were simply fighters without any spritual bent. they were definitely sipahis but not sant sipahis. Therefore , te day on which sant sipahis will strat liberation of nankana sahib, rest of khalistan will be ensured.

Re: Is caste all there is to Sikhi?

CSJ · 08 Apr 2007

"AKJ is still the best jatha in the panth" How can you say that just because you belong to it. This is exactaly what I said before, If we go beyoned cast then we will fight for jathebandi. That is same as cast nothing diffrent. I thing when we take amrit we belong to Guru sahib not to any jathebandi. Amrit is Amrit no one got better Amrit. Avastha come from deeds and Naam only. I heared people say we dont belive in saints but they got only referances foom Bahi sahibs's books and there jeewan. what is the diffrence same everywere. After cast people promote there jathebandi. Why not only Khalsa. [%sig%]