Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Kulbir Singh · 18 May 2004

I just received a phone call from a friend, informing me that Manmohan Singh the ex-Finance Minister of India has become the prime minister of India. Sonia Gandhi has refused to accept this position listening to her "inner voice". It should be remembered that Manmahon Singh is a very close friend of the Sonia-Gandhi family. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Kulbir Singh · 18 May 2004

Manmohan Singh: India's architect of reforms The decision of India's Congress party leader Sonia Gandhi not to become prime minister begs the question of who will be her replacement. One likely candidate is Manmohan Singh, widely regarded as the architect of India's economic reform programme. The academic-turned-civil servant, who studied economics at Cambridge and Oxford, became India's finance minister in 1992 when the country was plunging into bankruptcy. India had an unsustainable fiscal deficit - 8.5% of the GDP. Its foreign exchange reserves had sunk to around $1bn, roughly equal to two weeks of imports. In his maiden speech as finance minister he famously quoted Victor Hugo - "No power on earth can stop an idea whose time has come". That served as the launch for an ambitious and unprecedented economic reform programme in India that was firmly supported by the then Congress party Prime Minister PV Narasimha Rao. Bold reforms Mr Singh slashed red tape, simplified the tax system and removed stifling controls and regulations to try create an environment conducive to business. The economy revived, industry picked up, inflation was checked, and growth rates remained consistently high in the 1990s. The economy, under Mr Singh's stewardship, grew at a steady 7% per annum. In recent years, he has lamented that the economy was not growing "fast enough" under the Hindu-nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party-led government, which lost the recent elections. Mixed model He is a strong advocate of a "mixed economy model" with an important role for government-owned companies, especially in infrastructure and agriculture. Mr Singh believes that economic reforms mean the modernisation of state-run companies, not the selling off of profit-making government-owned enterprises. His unexpected anointment as the finance minister in 1992 capped a long and illustrious career as an academic and civil servant. He has taught economics in universities in India and abroad, including the prestigious Delhi School of Economics and Oxford University. In his role as a technocrat, Mr Singh headed India's central bank, advised the government on managing the economy and was a governor with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the Asian Development Bank (ADB). Thatcher admirer Mr Singh has often talked about the "privilege" of being taught by such eminent economists as Joan Robinson and Maurice Dobb. Sonia Gandhi's decision has opened the way for Mr Singh He also once confessed to an admiration for former British prime minister and free market practitioner Margaret Thatcher. "There are many people in India that admire Ms Thatcher. I have met her several times. I have great admiration for her," he told an interviewer. Dr Singh's independent career in politics has been less illustrious. Though he served as the finance minister during the Congress government between 1991 and 1996, he lost the one time he contested the parliamentary elections. He has been elected to the upper house of the parliament twice. A trusted confidante of Congress leader Sonia Gandhi, Dr Singh,72, keeps a low profile in the party . The consensus-believing genial politician is also seen as a leader who keeps himself above petty power games. 'Human face' Mr Singh piloted the economic manifesto for the Congress party during this year's election campaign. Since the results came in, he has been actively involved in writing up a shared economic programme with the allies of the Congress party. A believer in globalisation with a 'human face', Dr Singh's vision of the road to prosperity for India lies in restructuring the role of the government. "It is getting government out of activities where governments are not very efficient at doing things, (and) getting government more actively involved where we feel markets alone cannot provide the necessary amount of goods that our people need-basic education, basic health care, environmental protection measures, basic social safety needs," he once said. Dr Singh once told an interviewer that he was "very surprised" when he was invited to become the finance minister by PV Narasimha Rao. "I didn't believe it. When I asked some friends of mine they said, "You are going to become the scapegoat. You're going to fail and maybe within six months you will be out". "And I said I was the Fagin of my peers. I'd held all the top civil service jobs, but here was an opportunity to play a political role, and there was an odd chance that we would make a success of it, in which case I would have a footnote in India's history," he said. What is now to be seen is whether, more by chance than design, Manmohan Singh is to become the next prime minister of India. The money markets would definitely rejoice in such an outcome. However, running a country as complex as India successfully is another thing altogether. Whether Mr Singh could pull along with the allies of the Congress and act independently is another question mark.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

m · 18 May 2004

Does anybody know what his sentiments are towards Sikhs. Or is he another bhamin with a Pug?

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Rashpal Singh · 18 May 2004

Does he wear a Dastaar, and is he keshadhari or even amritdhari?

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Kulbir Singh · 18 May 2004

He is keshadhaari and wears a dastaar (always white). As for this political views, we all know that he is a staunch congressi and adheres to the Congress policy. The Sikhs like Captain Amrinder Singh and Jagmeet Singh Brar who are members of the Congress party insist that Congress party today is not the same as it was in 1984. All the leaders have changed. Is it true? Only partially. The leaders who were responsible for the riots in 1984 were still given party tickets and were elected in these elections. The Congress Party is trying to portray itself as a secular party. Time will tell how secular they are. Let us wait and see. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

The Singhpranos · 18 May 2004

Manmohan Singh is a "thinking mans" P.M. articulate and brilliant in his thinking..... it would be a coup to see a Sikh as a world leader Tony Singhprano [%sig%]

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Rupinder Singh · 18 May 2004

WaheGuru Jee Ka khalsa WaheGuru Jee Kee Fateh, Manmohan Singh being a Prime Minister will be a win and loss at the same time. Win - It will bring a turbaned Sikh("used in lose terms") face on the international politicals. Loss - Manmohan Singh's forte is finance, being PM will restricte him to flow his full energy towards what he is best in. Although, he may have a higher level views on the economic policies of the country but he'll be limited to the constraints of the other state affairs. Let's see how this unfolds. GurFateh

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Singh · 18 May 2004

I like the idea of an Apnaa as the next PM of India.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Another singh · 18 May 2004

Singh: What do you mean by Apnaa? having a dastar doesn't make you a sikh, being one does

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Niranjan Singh · 18 May 2004

This photo is supposedly taken at Manmohan Singh's residence : [img]http://www.ajitjalandhar.com/20040518/news_images/fd001.jpg[/img] Note the "OM" poster in the background. If this is really his residence, then it proves that this guy is a Pagridhari Hindoo. The actual picture and caption are on the bottom on the following page : http://www.ajitjalandhar.com/20040518/ [%sig%]

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 18 May 2004

he's been a congress buddy thruout..evenduring 84 and after and never rose a voice..u think he's gonna be beneficial? its the same as vajpai in power

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

ns · 19 May 2004

Sorry to dissapoint but I thought people on this forum were quite knowledgeable politically, it seems not the case and here is a reminder: Though on the surface the ascension of a Sikh to the post of Prime Minister may seem a great indicator of Indias secularity, I think those Sikhs who are educated, must realize the price of such heights is silence in the face of well-documented and systemic murder, rape and torture of your own community. If Manmohan Singh is a true democrat, he should begin his prospective term by: 1) Apologizing for telling to world that "there are no human right violations in Punjab" as leader of the Indian delegation during the United Nations World Conference on Human Rights in Vienna in 1993; 2) Expelling and prosecuting Sajjan Kumar and Jagdish Tytler, both now Members of Parliament, from his party for leading anti-Sikh pogroms in 1984. Please review this news article from last year: [1]http://cities.expressindia.com/fullstory.php?newsid=`300. It quotes a widow of the pogroms as saying: "Jagdish Tytler, Sajjan Kumar and H.K.L. Bhagat are all free men today. They celebrate festivals. My entire family was burnt alive in front of me. Why would I celebrate festivals?; 3) Prosecute the hundreds if not thousands of Congress party workers who murdered Sikhs during the 84' pogroms; 4) Express regret for the reign of Beant Singh, former Congress Chief Minister of Punjab, under whose watch disappearances, cash bounties, and rape as a political tool became common place and according to Human Rights Watch, Congress government approved. According to the 1995 Human Rights Watch report, Dead Silence: The Legacy of Abuses in Punjab: Those who are aware of the abuses and who condoned them among civilian government officials included officials at the highest levels of the state and central government administration. 5) Prosecute the thousands of police officers who disappeared thousands of Sikhs according the both Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch during Beant Singhs reign in Punjab. In Dead Silence, Human Rights Watch reports: One police officer told HRW that he estimated that over a five-year period, 500 people were killed by police from his police station alone. So called encounter killings became so much a part of Punjabs political landscape that few police officials denied the practice existed and many tactily admitted that it was condoned. Rather than numbers, if you want a fathers perspective on how these Congress government lead abuses affected their families, please view the following: a. [2]http://www.punjabjustice.org/interviews/clips/AjaibSingh-suicide.WM V (This is the story of Ajaib Singh, a desperate father who committed suicide after his family could not get justice for the disappearance of his son during the Congress governments reign) b. [3]http://www.punjabjustice.org/interviews/clips/GurcharanSingh-Compen sation.WMV (This is the story of Gurcharan Singh who wont accept government money to drop his case against the Indian government for disappearing his son, wanting instead a simple acknowledgement that the government was responsible for his sons disappearance, which they refused to acknowledge of they were going to make a cash payment) 6) Apologize for the army assault on Darbar Sahib in 1984 and express regret for the needless destruction of handwritten hukamnamas and manuscripts from the Gurus in the Sikh Reference Library at Darbar Sahib. Of note, there were no militants anywhere near the Reference Library. Its destruction by the Congress lead army was simply cruel Perhaps Manmohan Singh should begin his reign by apologizing to these fathers and their families for the murder heaped upon them during the Congress governments reign in Punjab and at the center where he was the Finance Minister. Power comes with a price. In India, power for a Sikh, whether your Manmohan Singh, Amrinder Singh or Prakash Singh Badal comes at the price of staying silent while substantially portions of your community is literally wiped out. Id hope wed expect more for ourselves. Gur Fateh!

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Kulbir Singh · 19 May 2004

Here is the latest from BBC. For a keshadhari and Dastaardhaari person to become the Prime Minister of India is a very significant happening. Daas, Kulbir Singh India set for new prime minister Manmohan Singh - thrust into the limelight by Sonia Gandhi's shock decision Congress MPs have picked former finance minister Manmohan Singh to be India's next leader after Sonia Gandhi's shock rejection of the post on Tuesday. The move paves the way for Mr Singh, the architect of the country's economic reforms, to become India's first Sikh prime minister. Mrs Gandhi says she will continue to head the Congress party. Both leaders are due to meet the president soon to formally claim the right to form the next government. Depth of feeling Earlier on Wednesday, Mrs Gandhi rejected emotional appeals from Congress MPs and supporters to change her mind and accept the premiership. In a statement to her party workers Sonia Gandhi said she would continue to head the party and remain in politics. "But I appeal to you to understand the depth of my sentiment when I say I cannot reverse my decision," she said. Mrs Gandhi was elected the chairperson of the Congress Parliamentary Party at a meeting of party MPs. She then nominated Mr Singh for the post of prime minister - a move accepted by the meeting. "I have always admired his qualities of head and heart. I urge you all to give him your unstinted support," she said. Manmohan Singh said he would do his "utmost to live up to the great trust reposed" in him and paid tribute to Mrs Gandhi. "The example of sacrifice set by Sonia Gandhi is in keeping with the highest standards of idealism that was generated during the freedom struggle," he said. She and her close aides met alliance partners through Wednesday morning, all of whom said they would support her choice for the post. Vigil Earlier in the day, senior Congress members had resigned from their party posts to put pressure on Mrs Gandhi to rethink her decision. Riot police were deployed in the sweltering heat outside Mrs Gandhi's Delhi residence which was under siege from Congress party supporters. When news filtered through to them of the Congress party efforts to make Mrs Gandhi change her mind, they burst into cheers of ""Bring back Sonia Gandhi". One man, Ram Avtar reached the residence on Wednesday morning after travelling from the town of Bareilly in the state of Uttar Pradesh. "We will not accept anybody else but Sonia Gandhi as prime minister," he told BBC News Online. "We will give our lives if need be for her." A strike was observed in Bareilly and another Gandhi stronghold, Amethi, now represented by her son Rahul Gandhi, in protest against her decision to refuse the premiership. But Mrs Gandhi proved to be unwavering in her decision. Rallying stocks In a boost to the Congress-led coalition, the DMK party in the southern state of Tamil Nadu said it would join the government, after earlier saying it would only support it from outside. "We understand the reasons behind her decision and we will accept her choice," DMK party president M Karunanidhi said. Stock markets - which fell dramatically on news of the surprise electoral defeat of the pro-market BJP party - rallied for the second successive day. An emotional Mrs Gandhi told gasping Congress MPs late on Tuesday she had decided to listen to her "inner voice" and "humbly decline this post". The announcement sparked uproar among Congress MPs who surrounded her in parliament's central hall in Delhi. Amid tearful scenes speaker after speaker pleaded with her to reconsider. But Mrs Gandhi pleaded to her party to "understand the force of my conviction". Despite the assassinations of both her mother-in-law Indira and husband Rajiv, Mrs Gandhi said she faced no threat but had never set out to be prime minister. "I request you to accept my decision and to recognise that I will not reverse it," she said. The Congress party gained a surprise victory in the country's recent election, but it does not command an overall parliamentary majority.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Kulbir Singh · 19 May 2004

Academics hail Manmohan's election as next PM New Delhi, May 19. (PTI): An elated academic fraternity today hailed Manmohan Singh's election as the Congress Parliamentary Party's Prime Ministerial candidate, saying the country would move forward under his leadership. "He is an experienced economic administrator. He is a person of tremendous international credibility which will be important for the country in going ahead," Suman Bery, Director General, National Centre for Applied Economic Research, told PTI. He said Singh's statement about central importance of growth for mitigating poverty shows his determination to continue on the path he had set for the country some years ago. Prof. B B Bhattacharya of the Institute of Economic Growth said Singh was honest, full of integrity and a very open minded person, suitable for coalition politics. "He does not impose himself, tries to build consensus and listens to everybody; moreover he understands economics," he said adding that his election augurs well for the country.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

hk · 19 May 2004

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/msid-684492,curpg-6.cms A quiet intellectual with oversized glasses, Singh is seen as a deeply honest man in a country where politics is often tainted by corruption. He won the ‘Honest Man of the Year’ award in 1996 for his clean image. But some economists wonder if the task would be tougher for him this time round because Congress would be in power in an alliance that includes leftists and communists, whereas last time he had a free hand. [%sig%]

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

rs · 19 May 2004

I don't see much good coming to Sikhs from this guy. Zail Singh was a 'sikh' and what did he do for us? In fact, he can do much more damage to us than people from other communities. The likes of Badal, Barnala, Zaila, Beanta and KPGill are all proof of this. I'm not saying that Manmohan Singh will neccessarily be like any of these people, but a psuedo sikh in power can definitely do more harm to us than a non-sikh.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Kulbir Singh · 19 May 2004

President invites Manmohan to form govt Wednesday, 19 May , 2004, 21:01 Manmohan Singh was on Wednesday night appointed Prime Minister of India to head the first-ever Congress-led coalition at the Centre after Sonia Gandhi rejected appeals to take up the top post, and instead got her party to back the distinguished economist, declaring that the country "is safe in his hands". President A P J Abdul Kalam appointed the 71-year-old Sikh to succeed Atal Bihari Vajpayee after he along with Sonia met him for about 15 minutes at the Rashtrapati Bhawan to bring to an end an extraordinary political drama triggered by her decision not to become Prime Minister despite frenzied pleas by her partymen across the country. Emerging from the meeting, Singh told reporters that they made available to the President letters of support from various political parties. Standing by his side, Sonia Gandhi said, "I think the country will be safe under Dr Manmohan Singh." Singh said the mandate was for Sonia Gandhi who in turn said that now the final decision has been taken and that she was relaxed. "I was under tremendous pressure, but now everything is over... it is a happy moment," she said.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Kulbir Singh · 19 May 2004

India will be safe in Manmohan's hands: Sonia Wednesday, 19 May , 2004, 22:15 New Delhi: A relaxed and beaming Sonia Gandhi stood beside her trusted lieutenant Manmohan Singh on the forecourt of the Rashtrapati Bhavan this evening as he announced to the world that the President has appointed him as the country's Prime Minister. A humble 71-year-old Singh, at the peak of his political career, did not forget to mention that the mandate of the people in the elections was for Gandhi who had raised her esteem before the countrymen by declining to accept the top political post despite being elected as leader of Congress Parliamentary Party. "I feel humble and say that the nation has given us mandate and the mandate was for Sonia Gandhi," he said. Clad in a cream colour saree, Sonia looked on and agreed that she was relaxed. She articulated the "tremendous pressure" she was under for the last couple of days. She said she was happy that the uncertainties about who would be the Prime Minister were over. "I had been under tremendous pressure from my colleagues, party workers and people across the country (to accept the post of PM). So, naturally being under such pressure takes you down a bit. But now that everything is over, I am very happy. I think that the country will be safe in Dr Manmohan Singh's hands," she said.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Khalsa · 19 May 2004

New Delhi, May 18. (PTI): Soft-spoken and mild-mannered economist-turned-politician Manmohan Singh shot into prominence after he steered the economy from the pits of a severe balance of payments crisis and saved the country from the verge of defaulting its external payments in 1991. Known as "Mr Clean" and a gentleman politician, the Oxford-Cambridge educated architect of the country's economic reforms changed the face of India in the global comity of nations during the five years he held the post of Finance Minister from 1991-96. Born in Gah (West Punjab), now in Pakistan, on September 26, 1932, Singh, as Finance Minister in the Narasimha Rao's Congress government had changed the fundamental way the corporate India thinks and with it the life of millions of middle-class Indians by liberalising the economy. The economic czar changed the outlook of foreigners towards India, whose economy was in a shambles in the early 1990s, with an unsustainable fiscal deficit of close to 8.5 per cent of GDP and the economy stagnating at a Hindu rate of growth of 4.0 per cent. An unassuming personality, Singh has held several positions including Chief Economic Advisor and Finance Secretary before becoming Governor of Reserve Bank and then Deputy Chairman of Planning Commission and UGC Chairman in 1980s and early nineties. Singh, who unshackled the country from the bureaucratic controls and licence-permit raj, had taken the economy from the brink of bankruptcy to a high growth path of 6-7 per cent during his five years stint at North Block. The 72-year-old Rajya Sabha member from Assam has been welcomed by trade and industry as an instant choice for the coveted post because of his impeccable credentials, bureaucratic experience and intimate knowledge of international economics. Singh, who is universally well regarded, was educated at Punjab University first and then in Oxford and Cambridge. His potential was evident when he won Cambridge's prestigious Adam Smith prize in 1956. The following year, he returned to India as a University lecturer and for the next nine years remained at Punjab University before being posted for international duty with UNCTAD (1966-69). He then joined the Delhi School of Economics as a professor. Two years later, his academic career was cut short and he joined the government to serve in various capacities. In all these positions, those who worked with him have nothing but admiration for Singh's talent and conduct. Hard-working, meticulous, charming and "such a nice man", they all said about Singh. Despite being "unfailingly polite", Singh is known for his hard and bold economic decisions. Architect of reforms As Finance Minister, before he presented his historic budget in 1994, Singh went to the then Prime Minister Narasimha Rao and told him that India needed a strong vision to take it forward. "I said to him (Rao) it is possible that we will still collapse. But there is a chance that if we take bold measures, we may turn around and that I said is an opportunity. We must convert this crisis into an opportunity to build a new India, to do things which many people before us had thought should be done but somehow never done," Singh had said. Rao had backed Singh to the hilt and India embarked on a path of reforms. And government that year entered into an understanding with RBI to deny itself the right to draw on the RBI to fund its deficit. This put an end to unlimited monetisation of fiscal deficit, which was considered to be a historic move to improve the financial health of the country. Looking back, Singh says when he stood up in Parliament stating the case for reforms, his argument was that in the midst of an unprecedented crisis, it was time to think big rather than tighten the belt. "We could, in a traditional way, tighten our belt and we did that, tighten and tighten. But persistence on that path would have led to more misery, more unemployment," Singh had said. He had suggested an "alternate path" -- Stabilisation plus a credible structural adjustment programme -- that would shorten the period of misery. "It would release the innovative spirit, entrepreneurial spirit which was always there in India in such a manner that our economy would grow at a much faster pace, sooner than most people believed. That's exactly what happened," Singh had said recalling the old days. Ready to take responsibility For what Singh has done as Finance Minister, there are as many critics as admirers. Thrice he had submitted his resignation during his five-year tenure but the then Prime Minister (Rao) did not allow him to quit. First time was when Congress Party was agitated by the hike in fertilizer prices; the second time when the financial scam involving big-bull Harshad Mehta came to light; and lastly when Joint Parliamentary Party submitted its report to critise some Union Ministers and his Ministry on the scam. "In fact, I was the one who discovered the scam and took Parliament into confidence," Singh had said at that time. Singh said "the scam had started in 1988 and I did not know about it till 1991-02. I was too busy pulling the country out of the quagmire of bankruptcy in which it was stuck. Forex reserves were down to 1.0 billion dollars, industrial production to 2.2 per cent and the overall growth rate to less than 1.0 per cent." With pride, he had said the forex reserves have gone up manifold, growth rate averaged 6.0 per cent, inflation down to 4.5 per cent and industrial production was up by 12 per cent and economy was in a fair shape before the Congress government fell in 1996. "Even if they were to spoil things, they still have 7-8 months to mess up," he had said when the United Front government assumed office in 1996. Fortunately, the reform foundation that Singh had laid had only taken the country forward and was pursued by the subsequent United Front and NDA governments. Unlike the crisis days of 1991, Singh would be a proud man as he takes over as PM with the country's GDP growth clocking 8.1 per cent, forex reserves comfortable at 118 billion dollars with exports at over 60 billion dollars, farm output at record high of 212 million tonnes and inflation at 5.0 per cent.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 19 May 2004

k, Zail held position of President, its a token position, like the Governor General here in canada, which has no power just money. BUt manmohan Congressiyaye is no PM with ultimate power. He stood by indira ghandi during the 84 attack, and by rajiv during the riots, did'nt raise a voice, instead he went to United Nations and said there where no human rights violations? WOW DEFINATLY A HONEST GUY.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Guldeep Singh · 19 May 2004

Maybe once we should savor the moment of a Sikh leading one Sixth of the World Population. Has it become part of our Sikhi Rehat to bring down a fellow Sikh whenever they gain prominence? Someone posted a photo of S. Manmohan Singh w/ a “OM” pictured behind him and said this was “supposedly” from his house. We are not sure but what the heck let’s just post it and label him a “Hindu w/ a pug.” Yesterday I saw him on TV meeting people in what was definitely his living room and there was a huge lighted transparency of Harimandir Sahib in the back round. So we can’t be happy because he is not Amritdhari? Is our classification of “Sikhs” only Amritdhari’s? If that is the case, we should stop telling people that there are 23million Sikhs in the world because there are probably less than 2 million Amritdhari’s. Out of these less than 100,000 are Rehitvaan Nitnemi. Let’s face it most of the 23million Sikhs are “Regular” Sikhs and we should be happy when one of them attains greatness whether in business, politics, or the Arts. I am the last person to say something good about the Congress Party. I was livid when they gave tickets to Jagdish Tytler and Sajaan Kumar. But look how ironic the picture has become for them. Their boss is a Sikh and throughout their tenure they will on many occasions need him and beg him to get things done. Many times they will have to stand while their Sikh boss sits. Lets look at all the good an International Sikh figure can do for global Sikh recognition. We should not bring down S. Manmohan Singh with baseless accusations. For a change, lets be happy for a fellow Sikh. Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

singh.. · 19 May 2004

Is it true, as "Gabroo" said above, that Manmohan Singh went to the UN and told them that there were no human rights violations in 1984 ? please confirm this.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Singh · 19 May 2004

maybe this might solve the french govs position on banning our Paghs in France when they see a Paghwala as head of 1/6th of the people of this world. If he were to visit France, I doubt the French gov would have the guts to stop him from entering the French parliament with his Pagh on his head.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 19 May 2004

guldeep singh, u can't just forget what he did and idd'nt do! 84 he did'nt raise a voice, u want sikhs 2 support this man? ]

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Singh · 19 May 2004

Manmohan SIngh only came into politics during the early 90's.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Kulbir Singh · 19 May 2004

Sonia’s image has grown larger than life, says SGPC Vedanti announces ‘siropa’ for new PM Varinder Walia Tribune news service Amritsar may 19 The Jathedar of Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, announced to honour the new Prime Minister with a “siropa” after the dramatic turn of events catapulting Dr Manmohan Singh as Prime Minister. Appreciating his loyalty towards his party (the Congress), the Jathedar told The Tribune that the country had given proof of its secularism with the appointment of Dr Manmohan Singh who belonged to a microscopic minority. He said Sikhs believed in “sarbat da bhala” (welfare of all). Hailing the step, he said merit, honesty and eminence had been given the rightful recognition. He said this was for the first time that a Sikh had been honoured with the highest executive post of the country after Partition. He, however, said that being a visionary, Dr Manmohan Singh would help in resolving the long-standing issues of Punjab. He said such coveted posts could be obtained with the blessings of the Almighty only. He hoped that being Prime Minister, Dr Manmohan Singh would be instrumental in the development of this holy city. Mr Manjit Singh Calcutta and Mr Dilmegh Singh, both secretaries of the SGPC, said the choice had been made by rising above caste, creed or religion. Mr Calcutta said it was an exalted position that had merited a person of Dr Manmohan Singh’s stature, calibre, competence and sincerity. He added that Dr Manmohan Singh had done the holy city proud. Mr Calcutta said by giving the top executive post to a person of the minority community, the image of Mrs Sonia Gandhi, Congress President, had grown larger than life. Mr Calcutta, who is also a member of the Political Affairs Committee of the Shiromani Akali Dal, said Mrs Gandhi had taken the wind from the sails of certain senior BJP leaders who had launched a hate campaign against her. He said Mrs Sonia Gandhi had saved the nation by maintaining harmony of the country with the elevation of Dr Manmohan Singh. Such a move on the part of Mrs Gandhi had cut certain BJP leaders to size. Mr Calcutta said Mrs Gandhi had narrowed down the gap between the Sikh community and the Congress which had strained relations after Operation Bluestar. Such a move would strengthen the roots of the Indian democracy. In a democracy numbers play a role, but this time merit had been counted by the Congress. Showering praises on the Prime Minister-designate, Mr Calcutta said that he was a man of few words who had full faith in communal harmony. The Chairman of the National Commission for Minorities, Mr Tirlochan Singh, while talking from Delhi, said history of sorts had been created in the world and in democratic traditions wherein a person of a minority community in a country had been made head of the executive. He said the Congress had taken a path-breaking step in upholding the democratic traditions of the country.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Singh · 19 May 2004

Manmohan Singh is like the Paul Martin of India. Great economist, and visionary. Lets give the guy a chance. He's one of our boys from the Pends.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Kulbir Singh · 19 May 2004

Jhelum gives India its second PM Prabhjot Singh Tribune News Service Chandigarh, May 19 Phenomenal rise of Dr Manmohan Singh as the second Punjabi to the highest political position in the biggest democracy of the world has added yet another feather to the cap of Jhelum, an important district of West Punjab, now in Pakistan, for giving independent India two Prime Ministers. Mr Inder Kumar Gujral, first Punjabi to become the Prime Minister of India, also migrated from Jhelum at the time of the Partition. Situated in north of Rawalpindi, this historic district has produced many eminent Punjabi writers, bureaucrats and even defence officers. The Jhelum forms its boundary on the East and to South lies the Pakistan Occupied Kashmir. Mr Gujral was accorded a warm reception when he visited his ancestral district after relinquishing the office of the Prime Minister of India a few years ago. Both Mr Gujral and Dr Manmohan Singh were born in Jhelum district. While Gujrals settled in Jalandhar, Dr Manmohan Singh’s family made Amritsar its home district. Last time when Mr Gujral became the Prime Minister, Akalis went overboard and hailed his appointment and announced support for him. This time, too, they did not lag behind in lapping up the “son of Punjab” by declaring full support to him. “We expect the new Prime Minister to visit Amritsar to pay obeisance both at Golden Temple and Durgiana Mandir,” remarked a senior police officer and added that the state police was geared up to make arrangements for the anticipated visit. “India has proved to the world that minorities have as much say in the political system as in any other liberal democracy elsewhere,” says Mr Tarlochan Singh, Chairman, National Commission for Minorities. “Every Punjabi in general and Sikh in particular feels elated at Dr Manmohan Singh’s becoming the Prime Minister of the country.” Mr Umrao Singh, a former MP and Punjab Minister, said the election of Dr Manmohan Singh as leader of the Congress Parliamentary Party (CPP) was a big slap on the face of the Akalis, who had been projecting the Congress as an anti-Sikh party. “It was the Congress which had made Giani Zail Singh, also a Sikh, the President of India. And now it has honoured the community by making Dr Manmohan Singh the Prime Minister. Dr Manmohan Singh has made the Sikh community proud and now the people of this region can hold their head high because of the respect he enjoys the world over,” he added. SAD elated over Manmohan’s election Sarbjit Dhaliwal Tribune News Service Chandigarh, May 19 The top SAD leadership is happy over the selection of Dr Manmohan Singh as the prime ministerial candidate by the Congress even though it is not ready to say anything on record. A close aide of Mr Badal said there were reasons for the SAD to be happy. First of all, Mr Badal enjoys a good personal equation with Dr Manmohan Singh. After becoming the Chief Minister of Punjab in 1997, Mr Badal had a number of meetings with Dr Manmohan Singh to put the state’s economy back on the rails. Secondly, Dr Manmohan Singh is free from any sort of bias against the Akalis, especially the Akali leadership. Otherwise, there is a long history of Akali-Congress confrontation. However, it is a political compulsion of the Akalis to support Dr Manmohan Singh as the Prime Minister because he will be the first Sikh to hold this office. When Mrs Indira Gandhi had put up Giani Zail Singh as the presidential candidate, the Akalis — forgetting for a while that he was a Congress candidate — voted for him as he was the first Sikh to hold such a prestigious office. The Akali leadership has information that Dr Manmohan Singh had cautioned the Amarinder Government for not going beyond a limit against Mr Badal and his family as it could boomerang on the party. Akali leaders say Dr Manmohan Singh had also opposed the arrest of Mr Badal by the Vigilance Bureau. Because of this reason, Capt Amarinder Singh asked the bureau not to arrest Mr Badal and his son but put up a challan in the court against them. Ludhianvis from Dhan Pothohar elated Amarjit Thind Tribune News Service Ludhiana, May 19 Ludhianvis, especially those settled here from the Dhan Pothohar region in Pakistan, are elated following the elevation of Dr Manmohan Singh as Leader of the Congress Parliamentary Party, paving the way for his installation as the Prime Minister heading the United Progressive Alliance. A regular visitor to the city, he was last here to preside over a function organised by the Dhan Pothohar Brotherhood and to attend the marriage of the daughter of a relative. He also presided over a lecture of intellectuals on May 6, which was organised by Prof Satish Sharma of Arya College. Talking to The Tribune, his nephew Kanwarjit Singh Sahni, who runs a cloth house in Kapurthala, was happy that his uncle would now be the Prime Minister. “It is a great feeling and the people in our neighbourhood in Vasant Vihar are pouring in to convey their greetings. We have also called up our aunt and congratulated her, through she was surprised yet happy at this unexpected development,” he added. He said he last met his uncle at the marriage function of one of his cousins in Ludhiana. “Dr Manmohan Singh took part in all the ceremonies, though he is a reserved man. He takes keen interest in the affairs of the family and does not hesitate to give his opinion in times of crisis,” he added. Amanpreet Singh, another nephew of Dr Manmohan Singh, said he had come to know about the latest development on the television. “It is a great feeling and all members of the family are now greeting one another. Our neighbours in South City, too, are pouring in with greetings. The telephone lines at our gas agency in Miller Ganj and at our home were held up for two hours,” he added. He said that his aunt had invited them to Delhi and witness the swearing-in ceremony of Dr Manmohan Singh. He said he would be leaving tonight with all members of the family. Prof Satish Sharma, who knows Dr Manmohan Singh for the past 12 years, said he rightly deserved to occupy the august chair and would take the country to greater heights. “He is a patient listener and has a good grasp of everything going around him. Another little known fact about him is that he is frugal in his lifestyle and dietary habits.” Recalling his last visit a few weeks ago, Mr N.S. Nanda said it was not well known that he is a Kohli and hails from Chakwal in Pakistan. This region would now have the distinction of sending two Prime Ministers — Mr I.K. Gujral and Dr Manmohan Singh — to the highest elected post in the country. The entire brotherhood was happy and would organise a public reception in his honour, he said. He added that the soft-spoken leader was well versed with the ills plaguing the country and would work towards taking the reforms launched by him to their logical end. It was a great honour for the Sikh community which had never seen someone among them elected as the Prime Minister. Father foresaw a PM Ashok Sethi Amritsar, May 19 The prophetic wish of late Gurmukh Singh, father of Dr Manmohan Singh, to see him as the Prime Minister of India is likely to come true tomorrow. The ecstatic members of his family, including two brothers, Mr Surjit Singh and Mr Daljit Singh, were eagerly awaiting the announcement on the television sets at their residence in the Ranjit Avenue locality. Dr Manmohan Singh is the eldest of the four brothers and six sisters and was born in Gaya village in Peshawar (Pakistan) in 1934 where his father was a dry fruit merchant. After Partition, his family moved to Amritsar and continued the business in Majith Mandi. After completing his schooling, Dr Manmohan Singh did his graduation from the local Hindu College and moved to Khalsa College, Hoshiarpur, to do his postgraduation in economics. According to his brother, Mr Surjit Singh, their father wanted Manmohan Singh to join his dry fruit business, but he wanted to pursue higher studies. It was his highly motivated commitment to continue his economics studies that he requested his father to send him to London where he did his Ph.D in economics from Oxford University. Celebrations in Amritsar Tribune Reporters Amritsar, May 19 It was celebration time for the city residents. Delighted over the prospects of Dr Manmohan Singh becoming the next Prime Minister, they illuminated the city burst crackers, distributed sweets and exchanged greeting. The celebrations were not confined to Dr Manmohan Singh’s family. Ms Surjit Kaur, mother of Mr Marjit Singh Bhatia, a local jouralist, recalled their old family ties. She said Dr Manmohan Singh’s mother was like a sister to her. A former Minister of State for External Affairs, Mr R.L. Bhatia, welcomed Dr Manmohan Singh’s appointment as Prime Minister. In a statement issued here today, Mr Bhatia said he (Dr Singh) had done the city proud. Mr Bhatia said Dr Manmohan Singh would definitely give top priority to the development of the city, besides looking after trade and industry. Mr Bhatia congratulated the Congress president, Ms Sonia Gandhi, for taking a courageous step by appointing a highly respected economist as the Prime Minister. He said this would enhance the image of the country. ‘I was sure Manmohan would rise one day’ Varinder Singh Tribune News Service Hoshiarpur, May 19 All my colleagues were sure and had predicted that Manmohan Singh would rise one day,” says 93-year-old Shiv Nandan Bharadwaj, a retired Principal and teacher at the local Government College, from where Dr Manmohan Singh did MA (economics) and later taught for about two years. Meanwhile, old residents of this city still remember an affable Dr Manmohan Singh and his moving about on a green Hercules bicycle when he was a lecturer at Government College here. “Well done, Manmohan. It is a good news. He still remembers me and had enquired about my health from a friend recently. He was a member of the Tagore Literary Circle, of which I was the in charge. Apart from carrying on with his MA, he was a regular member and a visitor at the circle’s meetings,” recalled Mr Bharadwaj. Mr Bharadwaj said: “He was an extraordinary student and a cheerful and calm person, who used to interact with everybody. His teachers had predicted that he would rise one day and I am happy that the day has arrived during my lifetime.” He maintained that Dr Manmohan Singh was a favourite student of Dr K.K. David, in charge of the Economics Department, and Prof Bodh Raj of Punjab University college from where he did his MA (economics) in 1954. How friends view Manmohan P.P.S. Gill Tribune News Service Chandigarh, May 19 Dr Manmohan Singh is no stranger to Punjab or Chandigarh. There is jubilation in the region as a Punjabi is tipped for the post of Prime Minister for the second time. Earlier, it was Mr Inder Kumar Gujral. He has keenly observed Punjab’s politics, economy and governance and has also monitored the performance of successive governments in implementation of reforms, policies and programmes. His contemporaries have fond memories of him. Prof S.N. Ahuja, a former Chairman of the Department of Economics at Punjab University, recalls: “He was always a voracious reader. Books seemed to be his only friends and reading the only hobby. He is very nice person and ever helpful. He is a man of few words and hardworking”. Staying on the Panjab University campus, Prof M.L. Lakhanpal was his neighbour. He has since retired as the Vice-Chancellor of Jammu University. Asked about his impressions of Dr Manmohan Singh, he replied: “I am at least 16 years elder to him. As a neighbour, we were good friends but he is a great friend”. “After I became the Vice-chancellor of Jammu University in 1986, I found that the university had no money. I went to Delhi and met Dr Manmohan Singh, who was then Deputy Chairman of the Planning Commission. I asked him how do I run the place when there is no money. I asked for around Rs 20 lakh. He sanctioned Rs 2 crore, Prof Lakhanpal recalls. “On return, I told this to Governor Jagmohan and Chief Minister Farooq Abdullah. They just laughed it off. But within a week, I got Rs 2 crore”. Prof Lakhanpal said: “In honesty, he is super, above board. And he still walks very fast as he used to those days”. Reacting to the news of Dr Manmohan Singh ready to occupy the high office, Panjab University Director (Public Relations) Sanjiv Tewari said: “We are privileged that one of our alumni is to head the country”. Prof V.K. Gupta, a student of Dr Manmohan Singh, said: “It is difficult to find any fault in my teacher. He first taught me when I was in MA (second) year and later guided me as Ph.D student. We were also colleagues later. I owe my career to him. He was so humane that he would attend even to minor problems that we faced as students. We were always scared of disturbing him at work. He was a good and able teacher”, Prof Gupta teaches at Panjab University. Dr S.S. Johl, Vice-Chairman of the Punjab Planning Board, said: “He is the best bet for the country. No one else knows the economic pulse of the country better than him. He stands tall among politicians and intellectuals. He is the best gift the Congress can give to the United Progressive Alliance. Personally, I would have had no objection even if Ms Sonia Gandhi was to become the Prime Minister. Now that she has declined, her choice of him is the best”. Some of his family members live in Amritsar. He is the Chairman of the Centre for Research in Rural and Industrial Development, Chandigarh. During interactions at seminars and round-table conferences, he would freely express his concerns over Punjab’s governance and sustainability of agriculture. Recently, when he was in Chandigarh for a seminar on reforms in Punjab Dr Manmohan Singh told TNS: “The Punjab economy is not growing as fast as earlier. Rather it has trailed the national economy. Education and health are very important. We need to have a blend of traditional and modern technology. It should not be taken as traditional versus modern”.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 19 May 2004

to who ever said he came into politics in 90s, tha's a warped view of history!

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Jagjit singh · 20 May 2004

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I think it is fantastic news that Dr manmohan singh will be PM of India today. Although he is Congressi, he is significantly less anti-sikh than the likes of badal. At least he is honest, and does not abuse sikhi and its traditions. In India, a sikh Pm was unthinkable, just a few days ago. If he electioned for this instead of Sonia Gandhi, never would they have let him win, and the BJP would have brought up a raft of anti-sikh sentiment. How much he will do for the Sikh Quam cause will be dependant on how much the Sikh Quam lobbies him on issues like justice for Delhi roit victims, drawing back the influence of Hinduvata, and freedom for youth languishing in jails. Just to bring justice to the victims of the delhi roits, the main issue which should be lobbied for, would be an immensely courageous move for him, as the perpetrators are in his party, and given tickets by his party. But at least we have a Sikh for the first time as a recognised world leader. A person is a world reknowned economist, and someone who has widespread respect in Indian society. He will actually do more parchaar for sikhi, than most will think. When he goes to America, Europe and is photographed with other world leaders, the press will point out he is a Sikh. The beard and turban will get re-associated with Sikhs, rather than Bin laden for many ignorant people, especially in Europe. Activists in UK should now approach approach him and lobby him to bring up the turban issues with the European leaders. Furthermore, he is a very intellectual sikh. I remember a few months ago, reading an article about Sanjay Dutt, a film star, going on stage at an awards ceremony, and saying, " I have a joke, 2 Sikhs playing chess, get it thats the joke." The whole audience was in a fit of laughter. Basically part of the Hinduvata strategy of humiliating minority groups. So what did the Akali Dal do, Sukhvir Badal had him as a chief guest, campaigning in Punjab with him, rather than reprimading him. Today in Dr Manmohan Singh we have a world leader, an intellectual, with a proven track record. Some Sikhs have criticised him, but I, realising how hard it is for Sikhs to succeed in India, wish him well, and hope he is equally as succesfull as he was before. My only concern is that he has a track record of an honest man, who never got caught up controversial issues. Unfortunately as PM he will be surrounded by hoods, and buffoons, in MPs in congress and BJP, and they will all be on his case. It is very hard for a honest man to survive in the company of scheming, and corrupt people. I hope his government survives a full term. May Guru Ji bless him with good sense, conviction, and some Sikhi stature. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Kulbir Singh · 20 May 2004

Keep gas prices down: Wife tells Manmohan New Delhi: Prime Minister-designate Manmohan Singh came under pressure to keep down the price of cooking oil -- by his wife. Gurcharan Kaur, meeting reporters for the first time since her husband's sudden elevation to the top job, expressed concern about the cost of liquid petroleum gas. "I hope the LPG prices don't go up further. We are already at 240 rupees" a cylinder, the housewife said. Kaur said her husband, like outgoing prime minister Atal Behari Vajpayee, was fond of poetry, particularly in Singh's native language Punjabi. She said she had never imagined her husband, a soft-spoken former professor and civil servant with little experience on the campaign trail, would lead the world's largest democracy. "Whatever he does, he will do a good job. I have full confidence. He's a very balanced person," she said. Asked about any marital tiffs at home, she said she was quick to seek reconciliation. "He also makes up," Kaur said.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

Guldeep Singh · 20 May 2004

Bhai Jagjit Singh, excellent post. Gabroo Khalistan Ji, he stood by Indira Gandhi in 1984?????? Do you have some evidence that he stood by her. He didn't speak out? Even if he did would we have heard about it? He was a nobody in 1984. Do we like Badal & Co. better? They "spoke" out. Which Sikh leader in India is acceptable to you? Don't you get it? This is the ultimate payback! This is "sticking it to" Indira Gandhi & Rajiv Gandhi. A SIKH WILL RULE ALL OF INDIA! I'm sure you know that Guru Gobind Singh Ji made friends w/ Aurangzeb's Son, Bahadur Shah after Aurangzeb's death. Guru Sahib led Sikh & Moghul forces against rebels in Agra. Bahadur Shah didn't speak out when the Sahibzada's were being bricked alive but he wasn't involved in the attrocities either. S. Manmohan Singh may not have spoken out but, he did not commit any Sikh attocities. Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

GABROO KHALISTAN DAH · 20 May 2004

yah but we had generals liek general mann who gave back all his medals...and retired from his postion.....after the attack may dsps, and other high ranking officials retired from their postions baba bhagat pooran singh ji sent back all his medals 2 the carrupt government..coudl he not make a stand? by giving up his kursi? instead he went to the geneva convention and spoke tot hem of no ill done in india. i'll post the link about the geneva one within the hour

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

MB Singh · 21 May 2004

Brothers/Sisters I agree with most of the views of S. Jagjit singh & Guldeep Singh Ji. Few years back, I have seen that man, alone (I repeat alone) near Dukh Bhanjani Ber in Harminder Sahib, Amritsar. That was mid night. One or two or A.M. I was impressed by his visit to the temple at that time. This shows his affection for the place & humility. Brothers; I have not seen a single popular sikh leader, alone in Harminder, in my life. Neither Tohra nor Longowal. (What to speak of Badal). Nor Simranjit Singh Maan. These sikh leaders are great in many ways; but the desire for listening the "Spirtual music of Harminder" alone, should be there. He may not be as "gurmukh" as the Guru wants, but after all he is son of a "Gurmukh Singh". Just see the photographs of his parents. They look nice sikhs. Dr Manmohan Singh is a sikh and son of a sikh family. That is too much. None of his sisters and brothers and their families, shown on TV or News papers, trim hair. He must be reading Gurbani, in his daily routine, I think. His wife is said to read that (News paper reports). He is humble and competant. And that image of siikhs, needs to be shown to the world. But at the same time, we should not expect too much from him, for the panth. He has his limitations. I feel, it is the time we pray and hold Sri Akhand Path, for the "success" of Dr Manmohan Singh - Sikh. He needs help from his community. May the Guru stands, by the side of His sikh and love for the Guru grows in his heart. I feel the "seedling" is there, already. Daas.

Re: Manmohan Singh - India PM?

uk_singh · 22 May 2004

MB Singh veer ji great post and i think this speaks volumes about the man - if he carries on remembering guru-ji and vaheguru-ji everything will be ok but as they say the rest is vaheguru-ji's hukam but for now lets all celebrate and be proud we have a sikh in such a position also is it not amazing that on the 20th anniversary of the attack on darbar sahib the ruler of the country now is a sikh! but we must all remember we all have duties and responsibilities to be good sikhs!