Boy or girl?
Harcharan Singh · 03 Feb 2007
http://www.sikhnet.com/sikhnet/news.nsf/NewsArchive/6738135EBE0C77EC8725727600639218 Women from India's Punjab say they still face pressure to abort female fetuses by RAVEENA AULAKH Boy or girl? Blue or pink? Most doctors would say chances are 50-50, boy or girl. But this law of nature doesn't seem to apply to Canadians whose roots are in the Punjab region of India. Anubha Dhanju says she noticed the imbalance because of an innocent comment by her son. "My son came home one afternoon and wondered why girls don't go to school," she says. Ms. Dhanju, a teacher in Mississauga, says her son had noticed there were few girls of Indian origin in his class at Roberta Bondar Public School, located in a part of Brampton where many immigrants from India have made a home. The next time she was at his school for a parent-teacher meeting, Ms. Dhanju noticed the same thing. To some community workers in the area, there is no mystery. "We kill our girls in the womb, even before they are born," says Amandeep Kaur, a consultant with the Mississauga-based Punjabi Community Health Centre. "It's sad, but the truth." Figures from the 2001 census supplied by Statistics Canada suggest a slight skew in the usual gender ratio among people with South Asian backgrounds. But officials with the Peel District School Board, which oversees schools in Brampton and Mississauga, disagree that there is an issue. "We have not observed this," says Varsha Naik, a community liaison co-ordinator for the Peel board, although she acknowledges that "certain communities from South Asia still continue to put greater value in having a male child." According to the 2001 census data, the proportion of girls under 15 in the South Asian communities of Mississauga and Brampton is two percentage points below the ratio for the rest of the population in those municipalities. "There are more boys than girls [in the Punjabi community]," says Manjeet Kaur, who worked as a supply teacher with the Peel board for a year. "It struck me at some schools right away when I started teaching." Despite the government's best efforts, sex-selective abortions are common in India, especially in the north. Last year, British medical journal The Lancet reported that, since ultrasound technology became popular in India 20 years ago, allowing parents to know the gender of their unborn child, the boy-girl ratio has changed markedly. The most dramatic decline came between 1991 and 2001, from 945 girls for every 1,000 boys to 927. According to India's 2001 census, in Punjab, the north Indian state that has the highest per-capita income, the ratio was 793 girls to 1,000 boys, down from the 874 girls to 1,000 boys recorded in 1991. "[The community's] obsession with boys is the same here as well," Ms. Kaur says. "People have moved from India to Canada, but the mentality remains the same." Last January, she says, a young Brampton woman came to her for counselling. A 24-year-old with two toddler daughters, she had already been coerced into having an abortion once after an ultrasound indicated she was carrying another girl. "When I met her, she was pregnant the fourth time and had found out it was a girl again. She was terrified her family would make her abort the fetus again." Ms. Kaur counselled her, told her of her rights, even offered to talk to the family. "I had to meet her again but she never turned up," Ms. Kaur says. "When I called a few days later, she told me she had been forced for another abortion." The bias against girls is rooted in traditional Indian culture, where a girl is looked down on as a burden for the family, says Kuldeep Deepak, the outspoken producer and host of Oakville-based radio show Punjab Di Goonj. He says a daughter spells sleepless nights for parents who worry about finding a husband for her. "Then there's the problem of putting together a sizable dowry," says Rosa, a counsellor at India Rainbow Community Services in Mississauga, who asked that her family name be withheld. To many parents, girls get married and go their own way, while a boy is someone who'll look after them in their old age and carry on the family name. Baldev Mutta, the executive director of Punjabi Community Health Centre in Brampton, says the practice of sex-selective abortions is rampant in the Greater Toronto Area. The pressure on expecting mothers to abort females comes from across the family, especially if they already have one or more girls. "It's a sensitive issue," says Liberal MP Navdeep Singh Bains. "But one we need to address." Mr. Bains, who represents Mississauga-Brampton South, says education is crucial. "Gender equality is an intrinsic part of the Canadian social fabric; we need to embrace it too," he says. "But one of the most hopeful things is that the younger lot don't bother about these things." His friend recently had a baby girl and he went around town distributing sweets, a tradition if a boy is born. "Attitudes are changing," Mr. Bains says. A question of connection The Toronto area is Canada's capital of diversity, with visible minorities expected to form more than half the population within a decade. Yet new research suggests visible minorities are feeling less connected to Canada, and the next generation seems to feel even less of a bond with the country. In a series of stories this week, The Globe and Mail explores this phenomenon and its possible solutions. [%sig%]