Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Debate Videos- Sants Vs Kala Afghana/supporters., must see videos

Debate Videos- Sants Vs Kala Afghana/supporters., must see videos

N30 S!NGH · 21 Jan 2007

author- kam here are two of the first two videos into the talks on sikhi issues with kala afgana and the sants arguing against his ideas. The videos show Sant Hari Singh Ji Randhawae Walae and Sant Nihal Singh Ji Harian Vela Walae argueing on points of Sikhism with Kala Afgana and his son. Please enjoy the videos and share your views on the topics discussed Video 01 [url=http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-2436660112608428261&hl=en-GB]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=...61&hl=en-GB[/url] Video 02 [url=http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-4999976974928696676&hl=en-GB]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=...76&hl=en-GB[/url] New video added. Video 1 of 3 videos of Sant hari Singh Ji Randhawae Walae debating issues in Sikhism with Kala Afgan supporter. Video 2 gets heated. Video one Gurmat Ansar Maas Nirnay Part 01 [url=http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-5895759949331183922&hl=en-GB]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=...22&hl=en-GB[/url] Last two videos are up.Unfortunately the first 20 minutes of the second video are not up. will try to do it again. That is the lot then enjoy Gurmat Ansar Maas Nirnay Part 02 [url=http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-6893103195459808759&hl=en-GB]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=...59&hl=en-GB[/url] Gurmat Ansar Maas Nirnay Part 03 [url=http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-3225891937244018271&hl=en-GB]http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=...71&hl=en-GB[/url] Videos posted by kam1825 can be downloaded from: [url]http://www.gurmarag.net/SikhAwareness/Video/Vichar%20on%20Various%20topics%20by%20Sants/[/url] These are very interesting videos, it touches on controversial issues that has causes many doubts within panth and also new sikh youth generation - sri dasam granth, meat debate, usage of word - "sant" when describing gursikhs other than guru sahiban , existence of bhai bhalla, women doing seva in panj pyares. [%sig%]

Re: Debate Videos- Sants Vs Kala Afghana/supporters., must see videos

fresno sikh · 22 Jan 2007

SSAKAL Kala Afgana and supporters are full of hatred against everything sikhi stands for. They are Pagri Dhari Hindu RSS employees. Some facts About Kala Afgana from book Sab Dusth Jakh Mara: This is case of Sexual Assult by kala Afgana on defendant Karanjit Bhullar dated 28th Feburary 1992: 1) Kala Afgana was 68 year old in 1988 where he sexually assualted Mrs Bhullar 35 year old female at Gurudwara Topaz st (canada) where he was a granthi. His wife and Daughter were on gurudwara premesis. 2)kicked out by gurudwara comittee after tape recording of kala Afgan by mrs Bhullar. 3) Court awarded 5000.00 dollar damages to Mrs Bhullar and threw out case of counter suit of defamation of cahracter of kala afgana. He came to canada in 1984 after being retired as an inspector. I think he was 10th pass but claims that he read all the granths of hindus and sikhs. He has Govt of India working behind him after seeing sikhs have a strong hold in Canada. How can somebody with an acid tounge who claim to genuinely believe in sikhism discredit Taksals and other shromani jathebandhis it is clear from the videos these are bunch of thugs operating to confuse sikh masses. sorry for the grammatical errors in the post

Re: Debate Videos- Sants Vs Kala Afghana/supporters., must see videos

Khalsaspirit · 23 Jan 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, From these videos this is interesting to see that at least so called Sants now started to listen. I have to say this because if they had the same patience about 60 years ago on December 13th, 1946 at Amritsar then the issue of RAAGMALA was resolved. As you all know on 2nd decision making meeting they walked out because they had no patience and acceptance to the facts and finally Jathedar Mohan Singh Nagoke had re issue the hukamnama of Co-Status on the divisive bani which was clearly proved by Sikh Scholars it is not GURBANI. From these videos this is also clear they accept the patronage of Sri Akal Takhat Sahib, and then what was the problem in 1936, 1946 to accept the Sri Akal Takhat Sahib’s decision on RAAGMALA until today they are following it. Any way we should stick to Sri Akal Takhat Sahib Decision for both. Now from these videos we need self analysis on principle of Gurmat. We are very scared from RSS. I have do not see a single reason to worry from these culprits at same time I am very worry from the culprits which are within the Sikhi Bana and play for them and innocents followers of certain SANT class support their action. A very good example is: In the first videos Baba Nihal Singh ji asked that do you believe in damdami taksal? I do not know why he asked question(by the way he is a good speaker I find in these videos). Every one knows the situation of today’s taksal of Mehta faction how that one is controlled by above mentioned culprits. There were clear evidence that this is under controlled by RSS yet still their followers support them because of ego and ignorance about Gurmat. Next example is: Actually I have question for everyone and find the answer. There is Panth approved Sikh Rehit Maryada. Aside from some loop holes i.e. Amrit vela Banis, meat and few other, the basic structure is followed by every jatheybandi. Until this today’s Mehta faction taksal published its own styled rehit maryada against the Sikh Rehit Maryada if I am not wrong pudlished in 1986. Another words went against Akal Takhat sahib as much as possible. So I have no idea which damdami taksal Singh sahib was referring to. So you are supporting the people with in you who go against Gurmat then how you can debate with others so sangat needs to control these deras. There is no doubt that kala afgana policy is totally against Gurmat and has to address seriously by Sikh scholars with authorization from Takhat sahib. As I mentioned in one of earlier posts that Sikh panth is at the same corner where it was 3 decade ago and we have lesser n lesser gursikhs who are in chardi kala at this time but still Guru will do kirpa if we become eligible. Now come to Dasam Granth. Who started issue on Dasam Granth? and why? This is a question. Do not blame on others look in to your self? I can hint you whoever create issue about RAAGMALA in General public in these days are the ones and they are doing this for very very political reasons and of course for Maya and they did the same 60-70 years ago and we have continued division from that and now this one will promote further. So it is my very sincere and humble request to all that please for the sake of Guru sahib’s respect do not policize there bani into general public. Please stick to the Guru Sahib’s bachan “Vaadee binsay, khoji upjay “ My wording might hurt some one I beg for sorry but this is truth. Guru Mehar Karey Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Debate Videos- Sants Vs Kala Afghana/supporters., must see videos

KhalsaKhardkoo · 27 Jan 2007

N3O where can you download the videos, Sikhsangat took this thread off, I'm glad it wasn't done here

Re: Debate Videos- Sants Vs Kala Afghana/supporters., must see videos

Man Singh · 01 Feb 2007

why ppl abuse RSS everytime anybody in the world does a thing incampatible to present day Sikh way fo thinking? I wonder even Muslims with economic and political might 66 countries , christians with might of 164 countries are also spreading poison against it. Poor Hindus/Sikhs do not have even a single vote in UNO are being harraseed everyheere in the world and , RSS is being use hate hate target. This RSS phobia is giving RSS more and more publicity and popularity in turn. I wonder what magic this organisation of 2000 people with around 10 Crore a year finacial budget have to make mighty wordl organisations busy in destroying civilisational values originated from soil of India scary. Sikhs also join these foreign gangs focussing elimination of all Indian rligions from face of the earth. This is the time of unity and not of infighting. We talk about `saare jagat me khalasa panth raaje' and still narrow down kahlaistan to merely Indian part of Panjab and around. We have no guts even to include nankana sahib andpakistan occupied panjab? But we have enogh words to abuse RSS every now and then. I feel RSS has spread Gurbani around the whoel India from Gujratt to Assam and from kashmir to kanyakumari more then what our keertan mandlis with Sikh label has done? Just think and act?