Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

Dass · 02 Jan 2007

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru JI Ki Fateh I've recently seen a poster of a NaamDhari Kirtani Jatha who were due to perform at one of the Guru Ghars in Slough. Is it ok for Guru Ghars to allow this as from my understanding the NaamDhari's do not regard Dhan Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji as the Eternal Jot of the Guru Sahibs but believe in Dhea Dhari's. Therefore how can such people do Kirtan in Guru Sahibs hazoori knowing they are not committed. I simply don't understand the committee members of the Guru Ghars and how they make their decisions regarding such issues!!! My intention was not to offend anyone and if I have I sincerely ask for your forgiveness. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

kharkoo · 02 Jan 2007

I think it's irresponsible for the committee to allow a namdhari jatha to do kirtan who are visable in their appearance and openly follow a dehdhari guruship. If people want to see namdharis do kirtan than they can visit them in their temples and sit with their dehadhari guru.

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

fury monster · 02 Jan 2007

which guru ghar in slough??

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

Tanu Kaur · 02 Jan 2007

Dehdharis or not, they're the only samparda to carry on the traditional kirtan maryada of the Gurus.

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

Dass · 03 Jan 2007

Penji Tanu Kaur I agree they perform traditional kirtan maryada of the Guru's, therefore is that good enough reason to accept them and their dhedhari guru?? Responses like these really do surprise me!! I guess everyone's entitled to their opinion. My other question is why is everything split into Samparda's isn't everyone part of the one Khalsa Panth??? The Guru Ghar was Ramgharia Sikh Temple in Slough. Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki Fateh

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

sikh and proud · 03 Jan 2007

when?

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

Dass · 03 Jan 2007

It was all of last week.

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

Tanu Kaur · 03 Jan 2007

Veer Ji Im not saying lets accept them or anything, I was just stating a fact. Maybe if l made an effort to learn proper kirtan maryada, then we wouldnt have to invite Namdharis in the first place.

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

Man Singh · 03 Jan 2007

If you embrace them they will someday realise the truth. If you kick them out , you will loose them permanently. For example Guru Nanak Dev Ji visited my village sometime. Our forfathers transfer this great news from generation to generation and have great regards for Him and his teachings. After his visit this isolated village in Utter Pradesh, villagers innocently keep on singing glories of the lord and of the Guru. As per present definition of Sikhism they are not Sikhs. Will you allow such innocent villagers to do keertan in any Gurudwara in teh world. They saw and heard Guruji only once in their life and naturally can not understand whole philosophy as at that time even Sri Guru Granth Saheb Ji was not in the present form? My feeling is that we should allow any honest effort of singing glories of the lord and those of the Guruji. More we involve with others wider our penetration will be in our efforts to sprea the message of great Gurus.

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

GSINGH76 · 03 Jan 2007

Since we are all here in such "chardi kala" spirits, have many have you done this as an individual or sangat before you criticize other jatha's.............. The naamdhari's in UK have done this in November 2006............15 Sri Aad Guru Granth Sahib de paaths, 136 Sukhmani Sahib de paath, 443 chaupaie de paaths, 108 ughardanti de paaths, 449 Jap Ji Sahib de paaths, 11 chandi de var de paaths, 15 moolmantar de paaths...............

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

kharkoo · 04 Jan 2007

wow GSINGH76, well done! I must applaud the naamdhari's in the UK for their level of accuracy!

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

akaali · 05 Jan 2007

We should encourage more people like them to bring Keertan in the traditional form to be sang in the Guru's Darbar. This art form has become RARE! These Namdhari's bring this talent BACK to our Keertan stages again after MANY decades of degeneration of Keertan Maryada. The vaja does not belong in keertan according to history and tradition of Sikh music. No one should cringe at them singing Gurbani in Sikh Gurdwaras. They do an AMAZING job! Watch the video from Slough Gurdwara, December 31st, 2006 - Bhai Baljeet Singh & Gurmeet Singh Namdhari: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-3812092610668249224 People like us, should let them perform traditional gurmat keertan, and we simply sit back and take anand of the Shabad. :)

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

Premabhagti · 06 Jan 2007

WJKK WJKF Bhai "Dass"ji wrote: "I agree they perform traditional kirtan maryada of the Guru's, therefore is that good enough reason to accept them and their dhedhari guru??" While I don't believe in Dehdhari Guru myself, I'd like to point out that it is the message of the "shabad" that we are looking to absorb, not the looks of the"artist" that is singing the shabad. Just like Guru Gobind Singh ji said, don’t forget that Guru doesn’t love the Sikh but loves the rehit. Thus, the Guru loves the discipline of that Sikh. Bhai "Dass" ji wrote: "Responses like these really do surprise me!! I guess everyone's entitled to their opinion. My other question is why is everything split into Samparda's isn't everyone part of the one Khalsa Panth???" I think by saying this you have just answered your own question. If you really believe that "everyone is part of the one Khalsa Panth" then why are you arguing against allowing Namdharis to sing in the Gurudwaras? Surely then they are also part of the Panth.So why not allow them? Quoting the SGGSji: suix kIrqnu swD pih jwie ] (190-2, gauVI, mÚ 5) sun keertan saaDh peh jaa-ay. Listen to the Kirtan of His Praises, at the Feet of the Holy. jnm mrx kI qRws imtwie ]3] (190-3, gauVI, mÚ 5) janam maran kee taraas mitaa-ay. ||3|| Your fears of birth and death shall depart. ||3|| Please note that Guru Arjan Dev ji is saying to " Listen to the Kirtan of His Praises, at the Feet of the Holy". The message is to listen to the Kirtan, there is no condition about the artist singing the kirtan. Otherwise Guruji would say,"Listen to the Kirtan of His Praises, sung by Amritdharis and non-dehdharis only, at the Feet of the Holy." Please note that the great Pakistani Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, being a muslim, was allowed to do Shabad Kirtan in many Gurudwaras in his lifetime.This is one of the factors of Sikhism that should be appealing to other religions in that our Gurudwara welcomes people from all walks of life and religions to sing the praises of the Lord through Gurbani, unlike Islam where non-muslims are not allowed in mosques altogether, let alone singing the praises of God. Please do not take offence from my post as I am only trying to iron out my point,and please forgive me if you do so.Please also feel free to point out the many mistakes I have made so that I may learn from them. Bhul Chuk Muaaf

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

CharhdiKalaa · 07 Jan 2007

Can someone who doesnt follow Sikh Rehit Maryada do Kirtan in Guru Hazoori and in front of Guru Pyari Sangat? [%sig%]

Re: NaamDhari Kirtan at Slough Guru Ghar

Harcharan Singh · 09 Jan 2007

Kirtan was lovely. Shame they didn't perform Anand Sahib in Ramkali! [%sig%]