Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

taksal and bibis chola

taksal and bibis chola

aaaaaaaaa · 11 May 2004

from another taksali: "most bibian were shocked at even the idea of not wearing a pajami. No other group approves of bibian not wearing pajami's. This is 100% manmat and Damdami Taksal does not approve of it " WHY? Why is it 100% MANMAT? It should be respected if a bibi has the courage to do it. I do not understand this position of hatred against it. It should be up to the bibi. Someone explain this to me.

Re: taksal and bibis chola

DKaur · 11 May 2004

---"most bibian were shocked at even the idea of not wearing a pajami. No other group approves of bibian not wearing pajami's. This is 100% manmat and Damdami Taksal does not approve of it "--- I do not see how this is manmat? Sikhi is suppose to be equal. If singh's do not have to wear a pajami then why do bibian? It is society that influences us to think this way. There are pratan bibiaan (eg. Mata Bhaag kaur, Mata Gulab Kaur) that did not wear anything. If this was wrong, don't you think that they would of had been told to put some clothes on? Tapoban Sahib is not against bibiaan not wearing a pajami. We've had nashaan sahib seva done at Tapoban Sahib, and bibiaan have done punj seva for this, and no they did not have to wear a pajami. To say that a bibi is not comfortable not wearing a pajami is one thing, but to say it is manmat is another. I do not see how this is manmat. Can anyone explain to me how this is manmat???

Re: taksal and bibis chola

kaur · 11 May 2004

"There are pratan bibiaan (eg. Mata Bhaag kaur, Mata Gulab Kaur) that did not wear anything. " I just want to mention that this was because of the high avastha reached by these Gurmukh Pyaray and not for any other reason. They reached such a state (one I am not familiar with at all) at which they knew nothing of what was on their bodies or around them. Just so no one gets the idea that it is OK to walk around in a kashayraa only with a loyee. [%sig%]

Re: taksal and bibis chola

Gursikh · 11 May 2004

------- ---"most bibian were shocked at even the idea of not wearing a pajami. No other group approves of bibian not wearing pajami's. This is 100% manmat and Damdami Taksal does not approve of it "--- ---------- Well if this is Damdami Taksal maryada as someone put it, what can we say about it? There is no point in arguing over this.

Re: taksal and bibis chola

S Singh · 11 May 2004

It should be up to the Gursikh Bibi.

Re: taksal and bibis chola

khalistani · 11 May 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!! mata bhag kaur jes chola AND, i repeat, and, pajami are kept at hazoor sahib. bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!!

Re: taksal and bibis chola

Rashminder Singh Oz · 11 May 2004

i would say up to the bibi kaurs and singhs are same in sikhi same maryada same choices same life style everything same we are not hindu's we are not muslim's WE ARE SIKHS OF GURU GOBINDH SINGH JI GURFATERH JI

Re: taksal and bibis chola

DKaur · 11 May 2004

Yes i am aware of how high their avasta is. It was just an example. Women prefer to wear a pajami and that is fine. But to say that it is manmat if a bibi does not wear a pajami is wrong. Sikhi is suppose to be equal. Why can't a bibi walk around without a pajami? is it because a singh might get wrongful thoughts in their minds? this can be vise versa too. How do we know that a bibi does not get wrongful thoughts in her head when she sees a singh walking around in a chola without a pajami? If bibiaan do not want to walk around without a pajami that is fine, but to say it is manmat is wrong. If this is against sikhi, then sikhi is not equal. [%sig%]

Re: taksal and bibis chola

Jaspreetkaur · 11 May 2004

I agree with Dkaur. If it is Taksal Maryada for a bibi to wear a pajami at all times, then that is fine. BUT not everyone follows Taksal Maryada. I myself believe it is FINE for a bibi not to wear a pajami as long as their kachara is up to knee length and stops at the knee, this also applies to singhs as well.

Re: taksal and bibis chola

some1 · 11 May 2004

a khalsa is a khalsa is gender less....khalsa lives under one maraya no?

Re: taksal and bibis chola

Gurpartap Singh · 12 May 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Sikhi is equal for all does that mean that we don't need to maintain modesty? Males can go around wearing vests as they don't have anything on the chest to worry about. Would the bibis now start complaining that why they should not be allowed to do this??? At most of samagams when a singh is going for ishnaan they will be wearing a kashera and vest and with towel and other stuff he will be walking towards shower room. I don't know of west but its very common in India. Even at home also no one sees a problem with this. Does it means tomorrow bibis should also rise and ask for equal status and start going around in undergarments just because they think sikhi is equal for everyone. To all who don't agree with me. Please just because sikhi says all are equal and no difference between man and woman, don't start using it to change the gender specific roles/manners. Everyone knows what effect it can have on some one who is not that high avastha seeing a bibi walking around wearing kachera without pajami where as it may not be that bad effect seeing a singh in Kachera. I hope I make sense to all those who want equality. We will die fighting over things for dressing and maryada rights only but we won't even think that "Ausar beetyo jaat hai kaheyo maan le mero Har jas re mana gaaye leh jo sangi hai tero" Naam japo naam japo naam japo Gurmukho gurpyaareo naam jao Don't keep ur budhi and sikhi limited to wearing cholas and kacheras. Bhul chuk khima karni ji Daas, Gurpartap Singh

Re: taksal and bibis chola

A Singh · 12 May 2004

I call out to all my Gursikh BHAJIS!!! I have heard a lot of this "we are equal" talk within Sikh today and outside of it. The Sikhi stuff we can all see here. Outside of it, I'm tired of being told during long hot summer day's to wear my shirt button done up with a tie in a hot stuffy office, when all the time, the ladies are free to wear dresses and sleeve-less tops!!! This is just one of many many examples, before someone starts taking issue with the example. The point is, Bhaji's this is overall the world, in Sikhi and outside of it, going too far, it is time we made sure as Gursikhs who believe in equality meaning to be identical and the same enforced this properly! I call for all my brothers to start wearing Chunnis on top of her Dhumalas and to ensure that they also wear a salwar kameez if they are not wearing cholas (without pyjamas), as it is only fair if we also get to do this, like the Bibis.

Re: taksal and bibis chola

njsingh · 12 May 2004

Khalistani, Guru Gobind Singh Jees chola and pjami are also on showcase @ historical gurdwaras, hajoor sahib I believe. None the less, it doesn't mean since Guru wore pajami, it is manmat to not wear pajami. Similarly, if puratan bibis wore it, it doesn't necessarily have to be an example, because singhs don't always wear pajami although guru gobind singh jee did.

Re: taksal and bibis chola

kaur · 12 May 2004

What is the BIG deal if a bibi is not wearing a pajami? It is a personal choice, and everyone should respect that choice. Singhs and Singhnees are equal no matter what the western culture or any other says so, in Sikhi we are equal, that is the bottom line. Why does it bother the Singhs and some Singhees if some bibiaan choose not to wear a pajami??? WE ALSO have hair on our legs just as Singhs do!! Will this put wrong thoughts in those Singhs minds? No one can use the excuse that womens legs are seen as 'sexual' in many cultures. But what is so sexual when a woman has hair on her legs just as men do? It works both ways. Singhnees should not be wearing salwar kameez or chunnis. They should be wearing Guru Sahibs Baana, which was given to both genders. I walk around my house and outside without a pajami on, so is that seen as Manmat?? Taksal also doesn't believe bibiaan should be allowed to do Punj Pyarai sevaa. But didnt Guru Sahib state men and women are equal? If a Singhnee is not going to wear a pajami with her cholay, just make sure your kachara is at knee length, and doesnt slide up your leg, same goes for singhs. We are always going to have our own views on topics like these. So lets just stop arguing and work on our Sikhi and follow Guru Sahibs rehit. [%sig%]

Re: taksal and bibis chola

hm · 12 May 2004

would u be happy if your mum or wife sister is walking with bana showing their legs above knees in sangat? of course not. so its a matter of drawing the line, at least 3 quarters of the leg shud be covered then i dont see a prob. maybe other people have different views but you obviously cant walk round showing most of your thighs off. sikhs are not just any jungali culture like others the khalsa is perfect. well what kind of purity do you show by baring your thighs?

Re: taksal and bibis chola

Mkhalsa · 12 May 2004

>>>would u be happy if your mum or wife sister is walking with bana showing their legs above knees in sangat? of course not.<<< If my sister was wearing bana, shes not walking around "showing" to the sangat, (by saying this you are attempting to degrade singhnees by calling them showy and objects to be looked at), I wouldnt mind. Bana is bana and if they are doing it for the right reasons, why should i stop them? what gives me the right? and by the way, havent we already had this debate like twice in the last month or so?

Re: taksal and bibis chola

whoami · 12 May 2004

dkaur "There are pratan bibiaan (eg. Mata Bhaag kaur, Mata Gulab Kaur) that did not wear anything." is this correct? i read this post early this morning and all day this statement has been causing me to have a real headache - are we not supposed to be careful of what we wear - do we not owe a responsibility to ourselves and to others to dress respectfully? these bibiaan may have attained an extremely high state of spirituality but what about others around them who may have seen them they have not - and seeing naked women would that not be a hindrance to other people and there spiritual path? i'm sorry but i find this messed up big time - and extremely wrong - we have a responsibility to others not to incite kaam etc.. in others - so whats going on here? oh u near god now so do as you pls? pls people help me out here what the hell are we saying here............ if i've said anythig wrong pls forgive me and help me understand but this is not a sikhi i want to be apart of - if this is what we do? this reminds me of that scene in the 2nd matrix film where everybody is making out with everyone else........... i thought we were supposed to strive towards being saintly respectful people?

Re: taksal and bibis chola

sikh · 12 May 2004

benti why do some of the more learnerd sikhs who post on this website not contribute on some of the controversial taboo subjects? your thinking, knowledge and understanding of gurmat on these posts would be most welcome by people who are searching for a gurmat answer....... pls dont stay quiet you have an advantage over us so please don't sit back and not post

Re: taksal and bibis chola

Admin · 12 May 2004

>>>> and by the way, havent we already had this debate like twice in the last month or so? >>>> Agreed. This thread is now closed.