Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Dalbiri · 24 Oct 2006

I am a big fan of Kuldeep Manak, I find he truly expresses the Panjabi spirit and conscious. He has important songs for Panjabis like Kahdi Sardari where he talks of not oppressing the weak and vulnerable. Also Sadaay Soormay, where he talks of respecting females like your daughters and sisters. Plus he has sang about female infanticide which is a big issue now. If I take amrit can I still listen to him? And what about bhangra music in general as well?

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Seeker of the Truth · 24 Oct 2006

Dalbiri, I think it will be wise for you not to listen to bhangra in general since a lot of these singers like to sing about alcohol, sex and jattism. [%sig%]

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Dalbiri · 24 Oct 2006

Ok, but Manak does have some deeply spiritual songs as well as the usual Jatt Ho Gaya Sharabi stuff. Plus songs like Chaklo Gandasa, and Sheran Di Korm are very good for "bir raas"

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Harinder Singh · 24 Oct 2006

I listened to Kuldip Manak a lot. He has sung some songs about Khalsa and those songs are pretty motivating. In many songs these people try to be philosophical and give fundas about life which are quite misleading. For example Kuldip Manak song about women having 365 charittars is disgusting but the punjabis love it. Gurdass Maan is another person who writes philosphical songs but many times his philosphy is misleading and can damage the thought process of the listener. Recently he sang about Guru Gobind Singh. Though the songs was nice but it had a sentence that Guru Ji sacrificed his family for "desh" i e. india. He wrote this to please the majority as he suffers from slave punjabi mentality too. In short you can listen to the religous songs of the singers but do analyse the songs and dont start believing everything they are uttering. Personally, I have boycotted all the punjabi singers as they all suffer from slave punjabi mentality.If you wanna listen to true motivating songs, listen to Jagowale jatha.They are awesome.

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Seeker of the Truth · 24 Oct 2006

To be honest with you, I think you shouldn't worry about these kind of issues. You should just focus on main aspect of becoming an amritdhari. These little issues usually take care of themselves. Good luck on your path and congrats if you take amrit.

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

DutchiSikh · 25 Oct 2006

Is is true that kuldeep manak was a muslim ?

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

ijs · 25 Oct 2006

ya he is a muslim latif mohammad........kuldip is his screen name given to him by his mentor............ but all that apart i agree with harinder singh ji on his views on how irrelevant these songs are to sikhi and also agree with seeker ji that this is just a minor issue..........manak doesnt and shouldnt decide our way of sikhi........lol personally i too have given up listening to punjabi songs esp. the new ones coz they simply suck.the ones of manaks times were still better but now its completely crap.. jagowaala jatha and tigerstyle i prefer if at all i feel like listening ..........for rest of bindaas ,jindaaas,shindaaas and wanabe rapsters its goodbye from me.

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Harcharan Singh · 25 Oct 2006

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh, For those that are worried about how they will fill their spare time once they have taken amrit, worry not, you will have no spare time. There is much to learn and practice. For those who want to fill their musical void, Guru ji says: Page 108, Line 1 ਹਰਿ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਗਾਵਹੁ ਦਿਨੁ ਰਾਤੀ ਸਫਲ ਏਹਾ ਹੈ ਕਾਰੀ ਜੀਉ ॥੩॥ har keertan gaavhu din raatee safal ayhaa hai kaaree jee-o. ||3|| So sing the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises, day and night. This is the most fruitful occupation. ||3|| Guru Arjan Dev Page 131, Line 13 ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਚਾਲ ਜਿਤੁ ਪਾਰਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਧਿਆਏ ਗੁਰਮੁਖਿ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਗਾਏ ਜੀਉ ॥੮॥ gurmukh chaal jit paarbarahm Dhi-aa-ay gurmukh keertan gaa-ay jee-o. ||8|| To live as Gurmukh is the lifestyle by which we come to meditate on the Supreme Lord. The Gurmukh sings the Kirtan of His Praises. ||8|| Guru Arjan Dev Page 208, Line 18 ਜਾ ਕੈ ਹੀਐ ਪ੍ਰਗਟੁ ਪ੍ਰਭੁ ਹੋਆ ਅਨਦਿਨੁ ਕੀਰਤਨੁ ਰਸਨ ਰਮੋਰੀ ॥੩॥ jaa kai hee-ai pargat parabh ho-aa an-din keertan rasan ramoree. ||3|| Those whose hearts are illuminated by God, sing the Kirtan of His Praises night and day with their tongues. ||3|| Guru Arjan Dev Learning and singing kirtan is a lifelong occupation (if not many life-times), there is so much to learn and so much Anand to be had. Don't go for 2nd best when Guru Ji has provided you with a a complete musical framework and words that cover every concievable aspect of life, all inspiration you could possibly crave can and can only be found (in it's completeness and fullest0, in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj. Listen to and sing the poetry, musical measures, guidance, warnings, courage and holy words of emancipation of your Guru, and not self inclined singers. http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-903529149515828668&q [%sig%]

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

S Singh · 25 Oct 2006

Manak's Massa Rangar tape was good.

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Dalbiri · 25 Oct 2006

ya he is a muslim latif mohammad........kuldip is his screen name given to him by his mentor............ --------------------------------------------------- Yeah, but like it or not he is Sikh now.

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Dalbiri · 25 Oct 2006

For example Kuldip Manak song about women having 365 charittars is disgusting but the punjabis love it. ---------------------------------------------------------- In the Dasam Granth there are 404 stories about women charittars, actually a small few are about mens charittars too.

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Harinder Singh · 25 Oct 2006

If you listen to the song, it says that women pretend to be afraid of shadows during the day but in the night they even have the gutts to cross rivers(to meet their lovers). The manmukh males love this kind of attack on women as it gives them satisfaction in terming women as disloyal,deceivers and sex hungry. I doubt Guru Ji wrote whole of Dasam Granth and especially tria charittars. Guru Ji never distinguished between men and women. He only distinguishes between manmukhs and gurmukhs. I feel that the kaami manmukhs irrespective of their gender are undependable and do possess lots of charitars whereas gurmukhs irrespective of their gender are pure and dependable. <> He is neither a sikh nor a muslim. He is just a punjabi and has done tremendous service to the punjabi culture. I think even yamla jatt and gurdass mann cant match him. Plus he seems to have lots of affection for punjabis and also sikhs and he gets loads of affection from punjabi jatts in return.

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

gupt · 01 Nov 2006

wot maharaj has written in dasam granth, is wot kalyug will be like, look how bad it is now, ppl doing guru sahib's beabdi, kalyug get's worser ever day, image 10yrs down the line WW3

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

DutchiSikh · 01 Nov 2006

It's the same thing with Chamkila. He wrote and sang many sharaab and songs about girls. But on the same he sang a beautiful song called "baba tera Nankana" How should we deal with this?

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Dalbiri · 02 Nov 2006

Author: DutchiSikh Date: 11-01-06 04:12 It's the same thing with Chamkila. He wrote and sang many sharaab and songs about girls. But on the same he sang a beautiful song called "baba tera Nankana" How should we deal with this? -------------------------------------------------- Well I don't think we should shoot people that for a start.

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Dalbiri · 02 Nov 2006

Well I don't think we should shoot people for that for a start.

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

DutchiSikh · 04 Nov 2006

do you know who shot hem then?

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Harinder Singh · 04 Nov 2006

Though shooting chamkila was wrong, but his songs were unforgiveable.Even to this day, chamkila remixes are highly popular and continue to corrupt the minds of punjabis.

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Dalbiri · 04 Nov 2006

Well, the thing with Chamkila was that he sang gunday songs but they were what really does go on in pinds between some jatt women and their brother in laws. Just ask any open member of your family from the previous generation. If Singhs killed him then they were wrong. I don't like the stuff but killing someone for crap like that has no precendent in Sikh history. You have a point though DutchiSikh, we don't know who really killed Chamkilla but Khalistanis are usually accused. Plus some dhadhis refer to the killing of dirty singers in their lyrics, which I know isn't the strongest evidence. I'm just saying, IF Singhs killed him they were wrong. But we will never know.

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

Dalbiri · 06 Nov 2006

You know, if there ever was one singer that should've been sent back to God for disgracing Panjabis surely it must be Daler Mandi! His cheesey grinning face is enough to make any Sikh/Punjabi/Singh sick!

Re: Can I listen to Kuldeep Manak if I take Amrit?

manmitchera · 09 Nov 2006

i use to be inlove with bhangra....but gurbani stoped it....but theres really rare songs that i listen to (old school only)....every bhangra song now days is full of crap(drinking and harassing women)