Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

How do you justify Prakaya Bhava

How do you justify Prakaya Bhava

Kulbir Singh · 18 Oct 2006

Chandra Singh and other learned Hindu sajjans, Could you please justify the prakaya bhava between Radha and Krishna? Prakaya Bhava is not justified between ordinary people. So how is it justified for Sri Krishna and Radharani? Or, is it all spiritual and not physical? [%sig%]

Re: How do you justify Prakaya Bhava

santbirsingh · 19 Oct 2006

i think we all know that there is a LOT in hindu mythology which would be completely morally unacceptable in any society. i think baba jarnail singh jee says it brilliantly when he asks sikhs who should be more ashamed of their past. sikhs, who have gurus who lives compltely flawless lives, or hindus. he goes on to say that ask hindus why shiva had his lingum cut off. they won't answer you... but the truth is there. this isn't disresepct, but there can not be any denying the fact that the hindu holy texts are filled with amoral, sexist, racist and absurd mythologies. while many modern day hindus would state that these stories should be understood in an allegorical, metaphorical manner, the truth is this. if you really push them, they'll admit that they believe it REALLY happened, as do the VAST majority of hindus around the world... there is a huge difference in our dharams. one that we should not be ashamed to be proud of. instead of one's duty being to one's caste alone, as it is in hinduism. for us, our duty is to akal purkh sahib alone. that is the real difference.

Re: How do you justify Prakaya Bhava

Balbir Singh · 20 Oct 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear Kulbir Singh Ji! What is 'prakaya bhava' and who are Radha and Krishna? Please explain. Perhaps inviting experts like Professor Inder Singh Ghagha for such discussions who have spent life studying deities is better. Balbir Singh

Re: How do you justify Prakaya Bhava

aman201285 · 20 Oct 2006

wats prakaya bhava? sory duno wat dat means [%sig%]

Re: How do you justify Prakaya Bhava

H Singh · 20 Oct 2006

what does "prakaya bhava" mean?

Re: How do you justify Prakaya Bhava

S Singh · 20 Oct 2006

I think that this thread might turn a little ugly.

Re: How do you justify Prakaya Bhava

Kulbir Singh · 20 Oct 2006

----------- Perhaps inviting experts like Professor Inder Singh Ghagha for such discussions who have spent life studying deities is better. ----------- No Thanks! I don't need Professor Ghagga jee's expertise on this. I want to hear a devoted Hindu's, perhaps from Chaitaniya Mahaprabhu's samprada, to explain it. Perhaps there is something they know that we don't. We may be taking it literally. [%sig%]

Re: How do you justify Prakaya Bhava

santbirsingh · 20 Oct 2006

sorry if i came across as a jerk. as is clear from the ramayan and from the mahabharat, one's caste duty is higher than even one's ethical obligation to act in a moral manner to one's fellow human being. various tales in these epics, especially with regards to Krishan in mahabharat show this to be true. these two works are still the most important, popular and influential hindu religious texts and are widely known and taught in india today. so where exactly is the falsehood of the statement. is it wrong to criticize a religion for what that religion states???