New book on Indo-Canadian gangs stirs controversy
Seeker of the Truth · 17 Oct 2006
A new book on life inside Indo-Canadian gangs is creating a clash of opinions within the Lower Mainland's South Asian community.
The author says the novel Daaku is a fictionalized account of one young man's life in the world of Indo-Canadian gangs, based on fact.
[b]Ranj Dhaliwal told CBC News that some of his friends growing up in Surrey were used by Sikh temple leaders to rough up their opponents in temple elections.
"This is the stuff I've heard about, where I've had friends that are saying, 'I had to go and beat somebody up for one of the older guys.'
"And these are guys that wear their turbans. They're very religious. It's more political than anything else."[/b]
Dhaliwal says he is breaking a code of silence in Surrey's Indo-Canadian community because he has had friends killed in gang warfare and because he believes many Indo-Canadian parents are unaware of their children's true lives
He has also challenged leaders of the Indo-Canadian community to say this sort of violence doesn't happen.
[b]Author 'totally lying,' says temple leader
The President of the Gurdwara Singh Sabha Society in Surrey, has done just that, saying Dhaliwal's allegations are not true.
"I don't agree with this idea at all," says Joginder Singh Sidhu. "I don't know if he has allegations against somebody, but since nothing has been proved so far, and there have been no arrests to that effect, I would say that he is totally lying."
Sidhu says that in his 30 years of running Sikh temples, he has never seen the sort of violence detailed in the book.
"To kill somebody or to beat up somebody is against the religious thoughts or the religious views or the religious principles."[/b]
http://www.cbc.ca/arts/story/2006/10/16/bc-indo-canadian.html#skip300x250
[%sig%]
Re: New book on Indo-Canadian gangs stirs controversy
Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 18 Oct 2006
"Sidhu says that in his 30 years of running Sikh temples, he has never seen the sort of violence detailed in the book."
That is in itself unbeleivable. In 30 years of Gurdwara Politics anyone would have come across instances of violence or intimidation for one reason or another. Even camp organisers and presenters of Panjab Radio get assaulted over their political inclinations.
When is the community going to stop burying its head in the sand and actually dealing with the realities that are out there?
Re: New book on Indo-Canadian gangs stirs controversy
Harjas Kaur · 24 Oct 2006
"Sidhu says that in his 30 years of running Sikh temples, he has never seen the sort of violence detailed in the book."
That is in itself unbeleivable. In 30 years of Gurdwara Politics anyone would have come across instances of violence or intimidation for one reason or another."
Okay, I laughed when I read this statement. But in this era of oppression in western countries, I don't see any good this book will accomplish. Sikhs need to stick together protectively...especially where turban and kirpan are targeted for legal discrimination. Proving stereotypes or creating fear of Punjabi communities will only invite backlash, discrimination and repression. Particularly in anti-Muslim, anti-Indian, anti-Pakistani racists who do not discriminate one from the other post 9/11 and still call a sardar, "Osama.".
[%sig%]
Re: New book on Indo-Canadian gangs stirs controversy
Seeker of the Truth · 24 Oct 2006
<<>>
I disagree. This book will expose the truth about these Punjabi gangsters and high profile community leaders.
Re: New book on Indo-Canadian gangs stirs controversy
Moorakh Mugad Eaan · 27 Oct 2006
i think the nature of the relationship that Seeker of the Truth is referring to is quite self explanatory.
People in positions of power, be those political or business related, all have access to money and money can buy muscle. Often muscle is required to keep the balance as it is for those in power, or to tip the balance for those who want to take it.
Wether that means people getting the public riled up and getting hot headed youth to do their dirty work (as i have often seen in Gurdware), or wether corrupt police and "professional" thugs and gangsters are employed (in both Gurdwara politics and in the world of business), these things occur and the correllation is there. Sometimes covert, sometimes overt, but it does exist.
Like the saying goes, Power Corrupts. The odds of a completely honest person surviving in either business or politics is quite slim.
Re: New book on Indo-Canadian gangs stirs controversy
wutzurpoison · 12 Nov 2006
Harjas
no offense friend but your comment:
Sikhs need to stick together protectively...especially where turban and kirpan are targeted for legal discrimination. Proving stereotypes or creating fear of Punjabi communities will only invite backlash, discrimination and repression.
would u call it sikhs sticking together when a man kills his wife or fails trying?? last i read both husband and wife were sikhs. we tarnish our image ourselves and give mainstream media something to write about. these issues have been in our community from the 70's and here we are in 2006 just now thinking we need a resolution?
if someone is willing to put something forward to force us to talk about the issues instead of keeping our heads in the sand then power to them.
[%sig%]
Re: New book on Indo-Canadian gangs stirs controversy
Harjas Kaur · 14 Nov 2006
"Harjas
no offense friend but your comment:
"Sikhs need to stick together protectively...especially where turban and kirpan are targeted for legal discrimination. Proving stereotypes or creating fear of Punjabi communities will only invite backlash, discrimination and repression."
_____________________________________________________________
"would u call it sikhs sticking together when a man kills his wife or fails trying?? last i read both husband and wife were sikhs. we tarnish our image ourselves and give mainstream media something to write about. these issues have been in our community from the 70's and here we are in 2006 just now thinking we need a resolution?
if someone is willing to put something forward to force us to talk about the issues instead of keeping our heads in the sand then power to them."
______________________________________________________________
A book exposing corruption in a community will not service that community, it will only give a black eye to that community by airing dirty linens in public.
If the Sikh sangat can't police itself, and requires exposing problems like investigative journalist Kim Bolan, who exposes the Sikh community to extreme prejudice and public harm, then something is definitely wrong with the sangat. My opinion, the sadhsangat needs to police itself and put its best possible appearance before the public eye.
Otherwise Sikhs will be shunned, legislation will be enacted to curtail their freedoms and religious rights, their societies and Student Unions will be on government FBI/CIA watch lists....oh wait, we already have that.
What I'm trying to tell you is exposure against the crimes and wrongdoing of the Sikh community will simply blur into prejudice against Sikhi with retaliatory backlash. Why invite more hostility? Why curtail more freedoms? If Sikhi is associated with criminals, terrorists and gangs, what government would permit amritdhari children to wear kirpan, kara, and dastaar? These will be subject to search and seizure for the security of the school.
Note, I did not say protect criminals in the community. I said protect the public relations of how the community is perceived.
[img]http://images.amazon.com/images/P/0771011318.01._AA240_SCLZZZZZZZ_V65551842_.jpg[/img]
Is a criminal and terrorist and cultic image of Sikhi one that should be promoted to the public? In my opinion, such a book is the worst kind of sell out because it blurs real human problems into the fabric of a religious community, thus jeopardizing the security and respect of that community.
[%sig%]