Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

singh13 · 12 Oct 2006

http://www.panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/2814/2006-10-11.html fateh ji just came across this any more info on this? or the video?? thanks .. good work jeo fateh ji

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Bazzer · 13 Oct 2006

Stay in Chardi Kalaa Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

akj1001 · 13 Oct 2006

i can not see the message. please guide me to reply to the same thankssingh13 wrote: > http://www.panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/2814/2006-10-11.html > > fateh ji > > just came across this > > any more info on this? > > or the video?? > > thanks .. good work jeo > > fateh ji

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

akj1001 · 13 Oct 2006

now i have got the news clip. it is shameful to the news people to have mentioned the name without the word 'singh'. this is nothing but 'ahnakkar' which every body should avoid. on the other side you are writing 'bhai kulbir singh ji' and on one side inder s. ghagga. how so ever one bad may be but you must write singh with his name if he uses this word. every body is equal in the eyes of akaal purakh.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

S Singh · 13 Oct 2006

The debate was a very good one. Just one correction, in the article it says no one seriously debated with him previously to the debate with Kulbir Singh. Truth is, on radio stations he would hold debates everyday with other scholars. But, unfortunately he would always end up getting the upper hand because Ghagha Saab is a very knowledgeable man and renowned scholar with very great debating skills. But Guru Jee did kirpa and all the Panthic Sikhs with Kulbir Singh Jee routed him twice. Now he no longer comes on radio openly challenging others to debate with him.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

ijs · 13 Oct 2006

boleeeeeeee so nihaaaaaaaaaaaaaal...............sat sri akal............... we need more of such debates at the intellectual level to root out such problems.............and for that we need more gyani gursikhs.....like the tapoban singhs may waheguru bless him with more power.................. fateeeeehhhhhh ji

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Balbir Singh · 13 Oct 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! Gurdev is singing [gurbani]bilhwrI gur Awpxy idauhwVI sd vwr ][/gurbani] "balihaaree gur aapnay di-uhaarhee sad vaar." [gurbani]ijin mwxs qy dyvqy kIey krq n lwgI vwr ][/gurbani] "jini maanas tay dayvtay kee-ay karat na laagee vaar." SGGS 462-19 Thanks to Gurdev who transforms mind beings to dayvtay. Some hate dayvtay. They are popular as demons. Some demons spend whole life studying the nature of dayvtay to attack on them. What surprises me is why such demons get a chance to speak before Sikhs whose Guru is leading them to become dayvtay. Balbir Singh [%sig%]

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Ek_singh · 15 Oct 2006

This was very good debate. I hope they have more debates like these in which noone looses respect for each other. There were few times when S. Inder S. Ghugga just ignored the points which should not be allowed in real debate either he should anwser or just accept he has no anwser. The main concern I have is with S. Inder Singh Ghagga's misuse of Gurbani without using the real Gurbani Grammar where he misquotes Bhagat Kabir's saloaks from Sri Guru Granth Sahib. I think it is highlighted very well in debate. Please organize more debates such as these and produce video recordings that way we can make our own judgements. Good Luck! [%sig%]

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

SomeSingh · 15 Oct 2006

vadhiyaa(n).

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Singhz R Kingz · 15 Oct 2006

where can we watch the video debate? i already tried on google video but its missing parts 1 and 4. anyone know where it could be possible to find the rest?

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

N30 S!NGH · 15 Oct 2006

Gurfateh Sadh Sangat Ji, Here is my unbias 2 cents: This is coming from who disagrees with tapoban on many fronts mainly idealogy/mindset. With that said, I must give my unbiased opnion, kulbir singh did amazing job in debate refuting claims of inderjit singh ghugga. Kulbir Singh and jatha members was also very sincere and respectful in the debate and from the video it seemed like they gave the other party warm welcoming feeling when from start of debate to end of debate at Tapoban Sahib. They maintained and uphelp Gursikh nature. This whole video debate was exactly what my imagination perceived an "Ideal Gursikh Vichaar". It was great to see my ideal imagination of what gursikh vichar should be into "reality". It also reminds me of hakum of sri guru hargobind sahib which myself i been guilty not to follow through: [quote]Four types of Conversations. 1) Heth - Where you listen to someone because you know they have more kamai and more knowledge than you. You are humble when listening. This also applies to school. 2) Vaadha - Where you actually do your research and share to positively add to a conversation constructively. Even if there is disagreement, you should not hurt another's feelings or prove that you are better. 3) Jalapa - Where you say stuff to put the other down. Try to make yourself look good. 4) Vitaardha - Where you keep talking and don't listen to anyone else (the majority of us). *** This is from a sakhi where some pundits asked Guru Hargobind Ji what type of conversations are allowed. Guru Hargobind Ji said a Gursikh only takes part in the first 2 types of conversations. *** [/quote] I also wish kulbir singh also maintain this nature of debate on online forums. Now regarding orginal article on panthic.org: I am sorry to say but article on panthic.org does not do justice at all describing this debate. Unfortunately, author of that article decided to take bias approach by going low and subtly attacked inderjit singh ghugga character by mentioning - " Ghagga became so uneasy that he asked for drinking water three times. Witnesses stated that his hands were trembling and he was perspiring heavily throughout the debate." I say so what? This person is 70-80 year old .. duh that should be enough to explain hands were trembling and perspiring heavily and reason for drinking water... give him a break...quite lame really to attack him on these points. Instead of panthic weekly observing debaters body language and writing an article about it and adding further "mirch masala" to it.. they would have win some "crediblity" if they would have translated some of exceprts shown in video debate. over and out ! [%sig%]

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

cSingh · 16 Oct 2006

****Admin Cut: This thread is not about N3O. Please take up your issues with him directly.****

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

S Singh · 16 Oct 2006

You can watch Kulbir Singh Jee and Inder Singh Ghagha both debate on the following link. (All 6 videos) http://www.panthic.org/news/123/ARTICLE/2816/2006-10-11.html Kulbir Singh Jee is the one in blue, and S Inder Singh Jee Ghagha is the one in grey.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

fresno sikh · 17 Oct 2006

SSAKAL. Good Job kulbir Singh ji and other supporting singhs. I cannot imagine Ghagha is not aware of the kamai of sikh sants who did naam kamai and merged into whaeguru and propagated the Gurmantar Whaeguru. Shame on such panth dokhis like Ghagha who after acquiring some theoritical knowlegde are distorting gurbani. He is nothing but full of ego and ironically the whole gurbani is full of updesh for such munmukhs. "Sakat (manmukh) Har ras saad na janaeh tin antar homai kanda hai jio jio chale chubay duk paveh ...... " Whaeguru Whaeguru Whaeguru Whaeguru Whaeguru Whaeguru

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Balbir Singh · 18 Oct 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! We do not realize God through debates. Explanation of scriptures (Shaastraarth) used to take place in presence of all great masters and kings. The success of Shaastraarth depends on the personal growth and consciousness of each participant. True Shaastraarths are of different dimensions. It sounds like one singing a line of the hymn and another the next line of it. I find it pity when two seek one another for such debates on topics that they claim to have understood intellectually. In the above referred debate one party claimed that there is no such thing as the power of Naam. It is the totally different opinion than the Gurus Truth. Another party claimed that by doing Waheguru Jaap one can do certain chamatkaars. I could not find Gurus suggesting once doing Simran of the word 'Waheguru'. Simran any way is not to do certain Chamatkaars. Only true Simran has answers for all, not debating before knowing and experiencing it. Balbir Singh

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

M B Singh · 18 Oct 2006

Well done Veer Kulbir Singh. Guru Sahai Hove. [%sig%]

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

S Singh · 18 Oct 2006

Balbir Singh, did you even listen to the debates clearly or are you just trying to act too budhiwaan? the Singhs didn't do a debate in favour of Chamatkars. Sardar Ghagha Jee claimed that there is no such thing as Chamatkars, to which Kulbir Singh Jee proved that there are such things. Kulbir SIngh did not argue that we should do Naam to acquire or do Chamatkars. I think that before anyone makes more comments, they should atleast listen to the debate carefully.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

jagroop singh · 18 Oct 2006

VahiGuruJeeKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJeeKeeFateh! Dearest Veer Balbir Singh Jee, It would be useful if you defined what you think 'Chamatkaars' are. Secondly, do we take it that you do not believe 'VahiGuroo' is the Gurmantar? If not what do you think the Gurmantar is, giving reasons. You wrote: "Simran any way is not to do certain Chamatkaars". Please explain this definition of yours regarding 'True Simran'. You wrote: "Only true Simran has answers for all, not debating before knowing and experiencing it" You have made many assumptions in your haste to dismiss the debate. Should Gursikhs not respond when others misquote and twist even simple meanings within Gurbani? Secondly, how do you know whether the Singhs involved in the debate have or haven't experienced True Simran? Veer Ji, do you now see how your post has come across?

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Roopkaur · 18 Oct 2006

I agree with S Singh. The debate was totally legitimate. When someone does a direct attack on the Sikh dharm, it is the duty of a SIkh to defend it. I do not think Balbir Singh has listened to the actual points of the debate properly.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

jas_akj · 18 Oct 2006

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.... sangat jio...i did watch the video a bit on the net but its not very clear,the sound is very soft and it keeps on buffering most of the time.....im trying to download it to my pc but somehow...i cant....can some be kind enuf to pls guide me.....thank you and btw.....good job done veerji kulbir......Guru Rakha!!! waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Balbir Singh · 18 Oct 2006

Pray Truth for all and say Satsriakal! Dear all! This is right. I have given my views on the writings from different people and the text from panthic news. ************** Dear Jagroop Singh Ji! Quote "It would be useful if you defined what you think 'Chamatkaars' are." It is God's Chamatkaar all that is happening, In my view. Ego can do neither Simran nor ego can do any Chamatkaars. Quote "Secondly, do we take it that you do not believe 'VahiGuroo' is the Gurmantar? If not what do you think the Gurmantar is, giving reasons." Gurmantar is what the Guru gives us. No where, Gurdev has suggested us to jap 'vahiguru'. Quote "Please explain this definition of yours regarding 'True Simran'." Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is explaining this often. I do not need to repeat it. Quote "You have made many assumptions in your haste to dismiss the debate. Should Gursikhs not respond when others misquote and twist even simple meanings within Gurbani?" This is a good approach. Direct experiences with true Simran and its earnings will make it more effective. Quote "Secondly, how do you know whether the Singhs involved in the debate have or haven't experienced True Simran?" All the Guru's statements become our experiences. Gurbaanee is the scale. It is not the Gurmukhee language and its grammar. Quote "Veer Ji, do you now see how your post has come across?" I hope true Sikhs do not want me to praise activities that Gurus never wished His Sikhs to do. ************** I have read some posts from Kulbir Singh Ji on this Forum. I admire his dedication to Sikhi. True Simran is above all. I tried few times to listen lectures from Inder Singh Ghagha Ji. I was surprised why he spoke against many Godly words that the Gurus praised though. Balbir Singh

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

RS_Singh · 18 Oct 2006

Waheguroo Ji Gurfateh...the debate is over and no matter whtever one says, inder ghagga is only a vidwaan(a misguided one tht is) and he 'lost' to the Singhs who spoke only of the TRUTH. Yes, view the debate carefully 1st b4 u actually pass comments . Gurfateh. [%sig%]

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

jagroop singh · 19 Oct 2006

VahiGuruJeeKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJeeKeeFateh! Dearest Veer Balbir Singh Jee, Sadly you have not addressed any of the issues raised and furthermore your 'answers' come across as attempts to elude the issues you yourself raised... That is of course your choice however if you cannot defend what you wrote with words, you should not have attacked with words in the beginning. It seems you didn't watch the whole video - is this correct? If so then your original words are even more innappropriate and unfair. i hope you take my comments in the spirit if Sikhi Veer Ji; i'll make this my last reply.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Prabhjoyt Singh · 19 Oct 2006

Well done to Bhai Kulbir Singh But i didnt understand 1 thing when Inder Singh Ghagga mentioned the Jap Ji Sahib Pauri "ik Du Jeebo Lakh hovay Lakh Hovay Lakh vees Lakh Lakh gera Akhiay Ek Nam Jagdees" he asked for Prof. Sahib Singh's meaning on it but why Did Bhai Kulbir Singh Give him Harbans Singh's? also what Was the Debate iin Bhagat Kabir Ji? and did Ghagga accept his mistakes or is he still gonna do his dodgy parchaar? [%sig%]

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Jatinder Bir Singh · 19 Oct 2006

First of all, sare veer who participated in debate from Tapoban, did very good job. Sarian nu Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh. Kulbir Singh veer ji raised one point in this debate and Inder Ghagga didn't answer that point. Point was why you didn't write about other issues like that we should put our attention to make more amritdharis. One of other Singh was also mentioning that Ghagga is just here to get more exposure. Everyone needs to understand these issues. There is a say ' Lose, but never loose the lesson'. In brief, one looses a battle should not worry about but when one looses its lesson is the biggest lost. Our recent past experience and well-established facts very well describes us that Sikh Kaum is facing an enemy who wants to cut our roots from our own culture, religion and history. From every aspect of life we are facing different problems everyday. Except a couple, did other sects face these kind of problems? Answer is NO. From religious point of view people like Ghagga, Kala Afgana a lot other misguided or backed (by some others) intellectual people are confronting Panthic intellectuals. At low-level Ashutosh, Bhaniarewala and others are trying to divert normal person's thought and strength. At political level we have tons of political leader (which I need not to mention names of all) in past and present, been used against panthic political strength. I personally have only one question to Ghagga or any other person who is in the same row that you have enormous time to put against something happening for better, did you ever even tried to think about the actual panthic matters? You have time to prepare yourself and do debate against those people who devoted their lives and families for Sikh Panth, have you ever raised your voices against Sikh genocide. In fact all your acts are just to demoralize them and try to divert their attentions from real panthic matters. Its just like Amrita Pritam wrote a poem after seeing the tragedy of 1947 ‘Aj akhan varis shah nu, kite kabran vichon bol, te aj kitabe ishk da koi agla varka phol. Ik roi si dhee Punjab di tu likh likh mare van, aj lakhan dhian rondian, tenu varies shah nu kehan’ but she kept quiet at the time of 1984 Darbar Sahib attack and Delhi genocide. There we had same Sikh girls who were raped in front of their parents. I was reading one of the other view in this forum that Ghagga always go to radio and do open challenge and at the end with his way of intellectual and forced logics, keep upper hand. Everyone needs to understand here that a corrupt minded person who has good ability to prove wrong doings to right, doesn't mean that he is right and on the other hand a humble person who can't act that fast and most of the time he can't prove his logic, doesn't mean that he is wrong. I have a long story to tell here but to cut it short, these problems like Ghagga, Kala Afgana, Ashutosh, Bhaniarewala etc. are like short timed mushrooms (Punjabi say ‘Be mausmi khumbhan). These little problems are just to divert our attentions so that we couldn’t look into those people’s matter who are actually controlling the whole show. Be prepare. Gur Fateh.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

a singh1976 · 25 Oct 2006

Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Ji Ki Fateh I have watched the debate very closely and I agree with the Bhai Kulbeer Singh Ji that some things need to be changed in the book written by Prof. Inder Singh Ghagga. Agreeing with that I need to point out that you need to read the whole book to understand what he is trying to say. He is fighting against all the bad things going on in the punjab nowadays. We need to understand that history is always written by the one in control, and I ask you when have the sikhs been in control? Since the time of Guru Gobind Singh Ji to the time Maharaja Ranjit Singh, the sikhs have been fighting various battles and just basically trying to survive. At the time of Maharaja the Ranjit Singh, his government was run by mostly hindus and muslims, as he kept all the Sikh Generals busy fighting wars for him. After Maharaja Ranjit Singh, it was the English that were in control. After the English, the destiny of the Sikhs was controlled by the Indian Government. During all this time, who do you think was writing the sikh history? Gurbani is supreme and above all things, but we need to beware of the hindu / muslim influence added into our history. Some of the things, that hurt the feelings of the Sikhs 1 - Naam Simran I have read the whole article and from what I understand he is trying to say that we need to really understand what is written in the Gurbani and to stay away from mindless repetition. He has raised this point because of the Naam given by various saadhs and deredars, like the Radha Swami dera and Sacha Sauda dera. That is the naam simran is fighting against. Is he wrong to fight against the pakhandi saadhs. 2. Matter of Eating Meat I recently read the Rehat Maryada posted on the SGPC website. It is clearly written in the maryada that a amritdhari may not eat any meat prepared the MUSLIM way. Meaning the sikhs are allowed to eat meat, but not halaal meat. 3. Nowhere in his article does he say that we should not take amrit, on the contrary he explaines the full meaning of amrit and says that we should become true Sikhs. I can go on and on, but it is better to read is articles yourselves. I agree that in some places he went a little too far and needs to change is language. He says things too directly for some, and like they say truth is sometimes bitter and hard to swallow.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Roopkaur · 25 Oct 2006

The issue of eating meat, though Gurbani clearly tells us that we are not supposed to, is not the issue here. The issue is that he said that Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji ate halal meat because they got scared. My Guru Sahib, who is the Guru Roop of Nirbhau Akaal Purkh, does not get scared of anyone. Also, the biggest issue is that he does not believe in Naam, I do not call that just going a bit too far, that is attacking Sikhi itself. There have been people that have taken off their kirpans and stopped following Sikhi, so instead of telling people to read his stuff, I recommend that we listen to Akaal Takht Sahib, and avoid him. We can find stuff that is good in works by atheists as well, but if someone said AKaal Purkh does not exist, and tried to prove the Sikhi beleives this too, would you sit their and let them say this? Well, saying Naam is a Gorakhdhanda is close to that, when you are saying that what SIkhi is about is just pakhand, and when he says such blasphemous stuff about our Gurus, it is no longer just a random book, it is a direct attack on Sikhi. The truth is that he cannot attack SIkhi, and expect not to be challenged for it, thats the truth, whether it is hard to swallow or not.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

S Singh · 31 Oct 2006

Chandra Singh, Missionary here refers to the Sikh missionary organizations. From what I have read of their books, they are not as Vijaydeep Singh has described them. They are not “influneced by Lutharanian Protestant Christainty”. Anyone who says this has not read books by the missionary college. The missionaries follow the official Akal Takht maryadha. The recent Kala Afghana movement is trying it’s level best in hijacking the missionary institute’s name. The missionaries do have some draw backs. They seem to believe or prove everything in the light of science. They tend to disbelieve many things that cannot be proven by science. They don’t realize that spiritual laws are different from scientific laws. The missionaries believe in Professor Sahib Singh’s translation of Guru Granth Sahib Jee. The Kala Afghanists just pretend they believe in Sahib Singh’s translations, but in reality they translate many Tukhs that are in contradiction to Sahib Singh’s translations. Example is “Ganga Kee Laher, meri tooti Zanjeer”.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

vikramjit singh randhawa · 10 Nov 2006

thx a lot kulbir singh jee.May god give power to all of us to completely kick people like ghagha out of our sikhism

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

ns · 11 Nov 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Had a listen in on all of the debate, a couple of obvious points missed by our dear tapobaan veers. 1. Kulbir Jee is no katha vacheck and has no experience of being one hence how quickly he compromises with ghagga is unbeleiveable!! 2.It would've been better to have a professional katha vachek such as Prof Darshan Singh Jee , Jaswant Singh Jee parwana to actually challange him properly on his text and leave him admitting being wrong in everything.I mean the issue on naam is so ludicroous gagga persists in saying it will take time and there is no point in discussing. 3. Final obvious point is that this happened in someone's house which does nothing to gagga infact the very next day or so he's on the air with the mpeg created on this site: http://www.singhsabhacanada.com/audio.php check the top audio file on what he says of this debate titled " sada bera gharak " Gagga is indeed a confused bloke who has nothing better to do but to casue confusion in the panth.Jatha singhs should've never be involved infact gaaga does mention in one of his audio files that the best soultuion should be an SGPC comiittee which violates certain topics or certain kathavacheks from writing their own kalpana, this we all know is not going to happen by the sgpc and nowonder you have loose katha kars in the panth. Why I say the akj should've not been involved is becasue this gagga is not a naam ablakhi he has no knowledge of naam and as he menitons clearly in the debate and sticks to his view.How the hell do you think you can prove him wrong in a couple of hours, this cannot be done at all. We have to view what has this debate done apart from change a few of his lines in his works. What it should've done was to prevent him from speaking on stage at all and this is not going to happen becasue I feel Kulbir Singh was the wrong person for this job it should've been a much more professional kathakar. Why wasn't anyone professional used?? Finally the way Kulbir Jee quickly gives into the debate when being challanged of the 84 events Kulbir Jee starts talking of akal purkhs kel and karms without actually even mentioning once at all that it was the kel of the hindu goverment with the Sikhs and has been since independence of India. Why did you mention this kulbir sahib??

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Paaras Kaur · 11 Nov 2006

ns, Your message is charged with a lot of negative energy towards Kulbir Singh. You definately have issues with him aside from his role in the debate. Regarding your first and second points, what difference would it have made if you got someone who calls themself a "katha vachak" in place of Kulbir Singh? A "katha vachak" doesn't necessarily know how to debate. I personally don't think anyone could have confronted ghagga better than he did in the debate. Have you even seen the videos? There are a lot of sikhs in the world who live their day to day lives as normal individuals without the title of "professional katha vachak's". All you need is pyaar for Guru Sahib, some good debating skills and your set to take on any idiot like ghagga, just as Kulbir Singh demonstrated in the video. I have nothing against katha vachaks, but one thing is for sure, they don't have the answer to everything. Any gursikh who reads and vichaars gurbani can do what a katha vachak can. With regards to your third point about the debate itself. A lot of good came out of doing the debate, be it in someones basement. Those videos on google have provided worldwide proof of this ghagga guy's twisted beliefs. People across the globe have now been exposed to his messed up views on naam and Guru Sahib. Sri Akal Takhat Sahib has issued a statement on him and others, so a lot of good came out of this first step. Your point on him not being a "naam abhlakhi" as a reason for not understanding what naam is, is completely useless. The majority of the panth doesn't have naam drir, but does this mean they don't believe in the concept of naam? NO! That is not a reason for him to be putting out garbage trashing the very concept of naam and its power! [%sig%]

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

ns · 12 Nov 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Paars Kaur Jeeo, On the contrary you have a lot of positive energy on the side of Kulbir Jeeo. If it's your opinion that no one could've done a better job then that's good for you. I menitond first of all that yes I 've seen the videos twice.I 'm aware of a lot of sikhs who have immense pyar for Guru Sahib and don't live with a professional title. My problem is that the debate was tackled well by Kulbir Jeeo but I expected better from him, I expected it to be exceptional however it was weak on various points and I'm pretty sure he knows which ones they are, there is no point me creating a list here, however if Kulbir Jee asks me personally I will list it. Bhan Jeeo I don;t have nothing against Kulbir Jee or akj , tapoban or any panthic jathebandi, however, are you sure they have the answer to everything. Only Guru Sahib has the answer to everything and our problems not any jathebandi, this has been displayed by Mahraaj's kala in various ways. If you look back to 1984, who did the sewa of removing a mahaan paapan indrian gandhi from her acts, yes they were singhs but not belonging to any jathebandi.....this is not to disrepect jathebandi singhs who were shaeed and carried on the movement, this is to highlight to you that a particular group or jathebandi is not the answer to our problems,only Guru Sahib Jee knows our answer and will make it work through his sikhs.In fact SGGS has the answers to everything but the kaum is too young and imature and doesn;t understand them fully.If you read of puraatan Sikhs they lived their life according to one or two lines from SGGS and now we have Sikhs debating over the whole of SGGS as if they have comprehended it all in short life span, tell me how can we keeraa mokraae sikhs including me comprehend SGGS over our small 50-70 year life span what our Guru Sahiban took 300 odd years to compile?? You say a lot of good came out as it's gone worldwide proof of the gaaga's twisted beleifs, I agree but I personally think it should've been done in a better way, if it happens again I hope tapobaan singhs can do an even better job.You say Siri Akal Takht sahib has issued a statement, bhan jeeo Akal Takht and the jathedaar are in hand in glove with the RSS, Badal, this is obvious as you can see form the events occuring in Punjab. Tell why hasn;'t the Akal Takht summoned KPS Gill for the atrocites,rapes,murder, genocide which he casued in Punjab? Tell my why when recently a group of Sikhs from village Kaakii in India were beaten up by his staff when all they were asking the jathedaar was to listen to them about mahan bedabi of SGGS sarrops in their village. Thanks for telling me that my point on naam is useless, I agree but I feel I have a point, why, well could you explain the concept of naam drirr in 1 hour or two hours or two days tell me?? What Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Jee wrote over many many years could we put it across in 1 hour, 2 hours...??

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

**** · 12 Nov 2006

ns you said: "this is not to disrepect jathebandi singhs who were shaeed and carried on the movement, this is to highlight to you that a particular group or jathebandi is not the answer to our problems,only Guru Sahib Jee knows our answer and will make it work through his sikhs.In fact SGGS has the answers to everything but the kaum is too young and imature and doesn;t understand them fully." In any way wouldn't you think as you have said bhai sahib kulbir singh ji and the other singhs had made 'it work through his sikhs'. 'Only SGGS has the answers.' Their stances were based on gurbani so guru ji is giving his answers through his sikhs. The panth may not be so united right now and from the young and imature i think gursikhs who follow hukam with dedication are more reliable to face Gaggha. "If you read of puraatan Sikhs they lived their life according to one or two lines from SGGS and now we have Sikhs debating over the whole of SGGS as if they have comprehended it all in short life span, tell me how can we keeraa mokraae sikhs including me comprehend SGGS over our small 50-70 year life span what our Guru Sahiban took 300 odd years to compile??" Old scientists took years to research many things which we learn in a matter of days in school. Guru maharaj has given us an ocean and we can make use of it as much as possible to defend the panth then from falsehood. "Thanks for telling me that my point on naam is useless, I agree but I feel I have a point, why, well could you explain the concept of naam drirr in 1 hour or two hours or two days tell me?? What Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Jee wrote over many many years could we put it across in 1 hour, 2 hours...??" I believe many who have watched the clips know very well that this was not an opportunity taken to explain the whole concept of naam in a short selected given time. If someone is trying to kill even the basic knowledge, to say there is no benefit in japping naam, why will others (the public )who yet have to learn that there is something with japping naam have any interest in taking laha of it. It is an experience for individuals to experience but not when your being guided in the opposite direction.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

S Singh · 14 Nov 2006

ns, many 'katha vachaks' debated with Ghagha and lost very badly. Being a katha vachak does not mean you automatically have a lot of knowledge in Gurmat and good debating skills. Most Katha Vachaks are good speakers, not good debaters. What Ghagha needed was someone with good debating skills and who has a lot of knowledge on Gurbani, which unfortunately most Katha Vachaks lack. Kulbir Singh has both, good debating skills, and knowledge of Gurbani. He confronted Ghagha because the Toronto sangat approached him to debate with Ghagha.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

ns · 15 Nov 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Dear "***" I agree with all you say apart from : "Old scientists took years to research many things which we learn in a matter of days in school. Guru maharaj has given us an ocean and we can make use of it as much as possible to defend the panth then from falsehood." On the contrary new scientisits are telling us new things all the time, as what we have with us keeps changing and is dynamic.Similarly SGGS interpetations vary from historic to present time, parcharks, but on certain basic concepts are the same such as naam and will remain the same. On the united front it would've done a better and perhaps a burial job of Gagga if certain panthic individual such as Prof. Darshan Singh Jee was also approached and this should have been done in a main divaan so all would've got the message on gaagga and his worthless works, not just a select few on forums and who have access to the internet.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Niranjan Singh · 15 Nov 2006

ns stated : "if certain panthic individual such as Prof. Darshan Singh Jee was also approached" ns Ji, Prof. Darshan Singh's would NOT have debated Ghagga, in fact instead of criticizing Ghagga, he without the Sangat's approval compromised with Ghagga and party. If it was not for the Sandesh from Sri Akal Takht Sahib, Prof. Darshan Singh and Ghagga would be sharing the same stage for a common cause. I believe the letter of thier compromise is available online somplace.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

ummm · 15 Nov 2006

I was also bombarded with emails and other info on this debate, so i decided to watch it myself, whilst accepting that debates that are properly arranged and judged are definitely different, I would call this a discussion on the views of one confused individual with those who have tried to follow gurbani and gurmat as best as they can. It was interesting to see Ghagga's points were baseless accusations that he made and didn't really have any proof for such writings, the naam one intrigued me a great deal as I found that the way he used the Gurbani tukka was a discredit to his so called education, to use postives to make a negative point seems rather foolish. There has been much critcism over the title of this debate which went on panthic.org and other sites, personally I would agree that he did lose the debate, throughout he accepted that he was wrong on this point and that point, a person acceptence of thier wrong doings, is also an accepetance I was wrong, I lost on this point. Though I concur that to really finish these nasataks off, there needs to be some real debate from all sides and hukamnama passed these people are not classed as great historians of our time, or they will end up twisting history and gurmat even further.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

**** · 15 Nov 2006

"Similarly SGGS interpetations vary from historic to present time, parcharks, but on certain basic concepts are the same such as naam and will remain the same." Yes many have tried using their own knowledge for which many agree and disagree on the outcomes. Also like you have said 'on certain basic concepts are the same such as naam and will remain the same.' This is what bhai has tried proving because Ghagga has been explaining something totally contrary to it.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

a singh1976 · 17 Nov 2006

Wahe Guru Ji Ka Khalsa Wahe Guru Ji Ki Fateh Prof. Inder Singh Ghagga did NOT lose the debate. Bhai Kulbeer Singh did not even listen to Prof. Ghagga's reason's behind his writings. Sure he is a great debater, but does he really understand the Gurmat? Now that is a question? He was arguing based on what he was taught since childhood. You have to read the whole book to understand what the person is trying to say. What the opponents have been doing are taking a sentence here and a sentence there and debating about it. I say that Prof. Ghagga is a better sikh that all of us, who has the courage to write the bitter truth. Yes, sometimes the truth is bitter and is hard to swallow. For your knowledge I am not supporting him blindly, I have read his books and understand his frustration regarding the present condition of the sikhs. 1. He wants us all to be true Sikhs and start reading and UNDERSTANDING Sri Guru Grand Sahib Ji. 2. He wants us to stop believing in fake sants and saadhs who take a line out of Sri Guru Granth Sahib and misinterpret it for their own good and the start feeding it to he unknowing sangat. IT IS THIS NAAM SIMRAN THAT HE IS AGAINST. MINDLESS REPETITION OF ONE LINE OR WORD AND BOTHERING TO KNOW WHAT ELSE IS WRITTEN IN SGGS. 3. He is a staunch follower of the Sikh Rehat Maryada as published by the SGPC. 4. His fight is against those Sikhs that might look amritdhari on the outside, but on the inside are followers of the HINDU philosophy. ONE MAIN REASON BEHIND THE OPPOSITION TO HIS BOOK IS THAT HE HAS WRITTEN ABOUT THE LIES, GURBANI PAATH DARPAN A BOOK WHICH WAS PRINTED BY THE DAMDAMI TAKSAL. HOW CONVENIENT THAT BHAI KULBEER SINGH DIDN'T EVEN GO NEAR THAT SUBJECT? Panth Ka Das

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

Roopkaur · 17 Nov 2006

>Prof. Inder Singh Ghagga did NOT lose the debate. Bhai Kulbeer Singh did not even listen to Prof. Ghagga's reason's behind his writings. < When someone admits they are wrong, that is called losing a debate. >Sure he is a great debater, but does he really understand the Gurmat? Now that is a question? He was arguing based on what he was taught since childhood. < Who? >You have to read the whole book to understand what the person is trying to say. What the opponents have been doing are taking a sentence here and a sentence there and debating about it. < If an atheist says that we must help all of humanity, and that there is no God, we cannot all of a sudden start excepting his latter theory just because his former theory is correct. Likewise, if he says we must not go to pakhand Sadhus, but don't do naam abhyaas, you cannot say he is correct on both premises. That tactic is called sugar-coating, it has been used by politicians for centuries. You give the audience a bit of what they want to hear, and the rest is your own propaganda. Open your eyes and smell the roses. >I say that Prof. Ghagga is a better sikh that all of us, who has the courage to write the bitter truth. Yes, sometimes the truth is bitter and is hard to swallow.< Guru Ji says Gur Satgur Ka Jo Sikh Akhaaye, So Bhalke Uth Har Naam Dhiaavai. This guy is saying that Naam Dhioanaa is pakhand (and worse). Umm... I don't know if its just me, but the two just don't seem to be adding up. >For your knowledge I am not supporting him blindly, I have read his books and understand his frustration regarding the present condition of the sikhs.< Most people follow him after reading his books, if that is blindly or not, lets just say no comment. >1. He wants us all to be true Sikhs and start reading and UNDERSTANDING Sri Guru Grand Sahib Ji.< Yeah and he plans to do this through making up his own historical tidbits, and ignoring what all of bani is telling us to do. i.e. Jap Naam. Great action plan! >2. He wants us to stop believing in fake sants and saadhs who take a line out of Sri Guru Granth Sahib and misinterpret it for their own good and the start feeding it to he unknowing sangat. IT IS THIS NAAM SIMRAN THAT HE IS AGAINST. MINDLESS REPETITION OF ONE LINE OR WORD AND BOTHERING TO KNOW WHAT ELSE IS WRITTEN IN SGGS.< No this is not what he is against. He is against the repitition of one word, no matter in what context it is. While Bani says, To Jap Naam Saas Giraas, i.e. 24/7. Once again, both of these statements do not seem to match, yet you seem to think they do. >3. He is a staunch follower of the Sikh Rehat Maryada as published by the SGPC.< Ummm, rehit maryada says a Sikh is to get up at amrit vela and jap naam. We all know what he says. > His fight is against those Sikhs that might look amritdhari on the outside, but on the inside are followers of the HINDU philosophy.< And the best way he found to do this was through attacking the core of Sikhi itself? I.e. by screwing people over so they no longer wear their kakaars and so people lose their faith in the very essence of Sikhi? Come on, there has got to be a better way than that! So the way he plans to get rid of these so called amritdharees is to spread propaganda that will lead to NO amritdharees (although that can and will never happen). >ONE MAIN REASON BEHIND THE OPPOSITION TO HIS BOOK IS THAT HE HAS WRITTEN ABOUT THE LIES, GURBANI PAATH DARPAN A BOOK WHICH WAS PRINTED BY THE DAMDAMI TAKSAL. < If this was the main reason, as you claim, than why was it not addressed even once in debate? Doesn't make sense to me, does it to you? >HOW CONVENIENT THAT BHAI KULBEER SINGH DIDN'T EVEN GO NEAR THAT SUBJECT?< The debate was centred on the issue of Naam, in a debate, the two sides debate on one issue until it is resolved. Would would the above topic be brought in if the debate was on Naam and faith? Just doesn't make sense man. [%sig%]

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

southampton · 18 Nov 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa - Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! This is my first time really on this forum, so humble baentee to all to forgive my ignorance and please tell me if i am making a mistake. Why does anyone care who won the debate or who lost it? Isn't it more important that people learnt from the debate, and perhaps clarified their own view on how they interpret Sikhi at a personal level? Am i wrong? or am i missing something fundamental about this whole issue lol? Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa - Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!!

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

**** · 19 Nov 2006

southampton, i understand what you are saying and asking. The debate being spoken on this form was not just a debate started and finishing on a website. It's not really a point of a number of people just giving their views, it is important because this was a cause for the panth. Challenging someone who from decades has been trying to put people astray on a path which is nothing near to the fundamentals of sikhi. Therefore it needs to be seen and understood what was said positively and what was contrary.

Re: inder ghagga loses debate to tapoban singhs?

ns · 19 Nov 2006

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Niranjan stated : "ns Ji, Prof. Darshan Singh's would NOT have debated Ghagga, in fact instead of criticizing Ghagga, he without the Sangat's approval compromised with Ghagga and party. If it was not for the Sandesh from Sri Akal Takht Sahib, Prof. Darshan Singh and Ghagga would be sharing the same stage for a common cause. I believe the letter of thier compromise is available online somplace" I'm very surprised that this is the case , for an x Akal Takht Jathedar to also support Ghagga that naam simran is nothing, are you absolutely sure , or are you just painting Prof. sahib jee with the same brush for the sake of it. I rather not trust loose comments and would need hard evidence to prove what you say on prof sahib who has said many a times in his works that naam simran is the key, I have my proof as I have listened to them. Generally when we in the panth run out of steam we have nothing else but to do some painting of all with the same brush....