Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

GATKA FOR SHOW? SHASTER VIDYA?

GATKA FOR SHOW? SHASTER VIDYA?

DAMAN SINGH KHALSA · 11 Oct 2006

Wahegurujeekaakhalsawahegurujeekeefateh!!! Sangat jeeo, i was told by some Singhs that it is very rare to find Singhs or Singhnees these days that teach Shaster Vydia!! They told me that these days gatka has become nothing but for show, and the reason behind that is because when performing or playing gatka, it looks better????? I heard something like that many time in the past whenever I would ask someone if they know ANYBODY that teaches SHASTER VIDYA!! soooooooo please if the sangat can please clarify this whole issue for me, and it would be greatly appreciated if anyone can guide me towards someone that teaches Shaster Vydia. bhul chuk maaf Wahegurujeekaakhalsawahegurujeekeefateh!!! [%sig%]

Re: GATKA FOR SHOW? SHASTER VIDYA?

Dalbiri · 11 Oct 2006

I know one prominent "Gatka" expert and I know for a fact that he mixes styles with other martial arts (no names mentioned). I don't see no problem with this as any art that doesn't develop and adapt over time is doomed. But when they make out that what they are teaching are THE actual techniques from the days of the Gurus, that is wrong. Whether the hybrid form is an effective martial art is another matter and it could easily be argued it actually adds to the traditional shaster vidya techniques. Martial arts were made for war, if it is effective in battle then it should be adopted and no martial artist worth their salt would restrict themselves in this matter (of life and death not showmanship or physical training like today). And it is true that for performances, martial arts are always altered for dramatical effect. Gatka is no exception, at least from what i have seen in the west.

Re: GATKA FOR SHOW? SHASTER VIDYA?

Pwalla! · 11 Oct 2006

Waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fathe Gatka is not that bad to be honest, it’s more then a show. It’s more of a parchar and others get motivated with the 'show' what ever you want to call it. In india I hear that moneh and others get inspired with Gatka, but I would agree that’s its more of a show. Shastar Vidiya is very good, but in the UK I don’t know no one who is abhiyaasi and a true gursikh that teaches this art. There is one so called nihang by the name of Nidar, but I wont learn of him as he is a RSS ******. BEWARE of this person as he is very dangerous and will only convert you to his RSS ways. No need to argue with me if he is or not. Sorry for this hankari email. Waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fathe

Re: GATKA FOR SHOW? SHASTER VIDYA?

Fauja · 11 Oct 2006

WaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa WaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh i actually agree with gatka being just a show today. People are just learning how to spin kirpans, but i think u shuld learn how to fight with and without weapon under all different circumstances (such as like without a shaster on the street or without an arm or something for war) anways if u live in Toronto, Canada I know a very very very Chardi Kalaa Gursikh who teaches Combat training/gatka.. you can research his akhada. its called Yudh Gatka Akhada so check it out, he teaches martialarts/combat training/gatka/shaster vydia/and gets u in the best shape of your life/he teaches u how to use your mind to your advantage and your surroundings to your advantage/and how to stay aware at all times.. anyways check his akhada out in Toronto, Canada.. Yudh Gatka Akhada WaheGuru Ji Ka Khalsa WaheGuru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: GATKA FOR SHOW? SHASTER VIDYA?

A Singh · 13 Oct 2006

Possibly in SGPC or School collages run by Sikh institutions, Gatka can be part of the course or physical training for self defence. It should taught to girls & boys since they are small. During annual sports events Gatka competition should be held.