Re: A Panth Without Its Guru
the real maha moorakh · 03 May 2004
> How successful has our Panth been? Or have we seen the greatest beatings we've ever received and we still are lying around like nothing has happened.<
This is so true. I have never thought about this before, but the greatest defeats of the sikhs and the greatest humiliations have happened after the time that pad ched birs became prominent. THis should be a clue for the panth to get thier act together and place our Satguru ji back on his throne is the guru if they want to see the chardi kalaa of the panth. How can the sikhs be in chardi kalaa without thier guru?
Re: A Panth Without Its Guru
vaheguroo~vaheguroo · 03 May 2004
"Its time we start putting things together the way they use to be."
YEAH, like the shabads in sri guru granth sahib jee
a benti to all sangata, if you are taking santhya classes, or know of any, please ask the giani jee to teach in larrivaar.
most people only think its hard because they (including myself) dont have the proper education for it.
how can we spend several years aqcuiring knowledge to live a supposed better life in this world when we cant even take any time out for our guru, for the one thing in this kalyug that will not only help us through this world but in teh worlds to come??
i feel i shouldnt be making such comments because i dont even follow my own advice.
Re: A Panth Without Its Guru
curious Singh · 05 May 2004
Vaheguroo jee ka Khalsa
Vaheguroo jee ki Fateh
>>oppressed and lost and in bad shape because we have abandoned our Guru. Not only abandoned, but most Sikhs have even forgotten who our Guru is.<<<<
>>>On the Guru Gaddi today, we have a saroop that was not given Guruship by Guru Gobind Singh ji<<<
>>>>If we have a pad-chhed saroop published by Chatar Singh Jiwan Singh, it will be different and have different breaks than one publishd by SGPC or Damdami Taksal. So which is the Guru? And which "Guru" is the one that is wrong? Can our Guru be wrong? No. Is it Ik Oankaar Satgurparsad or Ik oankaar Sat Gurparsad ? So many other examples exists<<<<
>>>Return Sri Guru Granth Sahib to the throne! It's the only way our Panth will ever recover from this dark age.<<<<
WOW - SO now the Ink, the paper, the har cover is the GUru?
I thought it was the CONTENT which was the Guru!!!
I thought my GUru was - BANI GURU GURU HAI BANI
and not the cover, the paper etc.
it's the CONTENT that counts isn't it??
I feel very offended when you say that Padh-Chhed isn't Guru - jus cause it has brakes - its the SAME BANI - the SMAE GURU
or am I completly lost?
bhul chuk di Khima Bakhsni
Waheguroo ji ka Khalsa
Waheguroo ji ki Fateh
Re: A Panth Without Its Guru
Balpreet Singh · 05 May 2004
curious Singh,
If the baNee in the pad-chhed bir is broken wrong, then we are reading our Shabad Guru wrong. In lareedaar saroop, we use our own budhee as Guru Sahib has given us, to break words. If we make a mistake, it is our own mistake.
In a pad-chhed bir, the words are already broken by someone according to their own budhi. I have no option but to read the words as they are broken. I don't use any of my own understanding, nor do I even need to do any veechaar. If it says "Pank jo moh pag nahee chaalai..." I read it that way. If it says "Pankaj moh..." I'll read it like that. I have no need to learn any viaakaran, I have no need to reflect on what I've read to see if it makes sense, I'm just regurgitating what someone is feeding me.
Don't you see that pad-chhed takes away the entire experience of paath. It forces the paathee to make mistakes because the words are already broken and often they are broken incorrectly. Can the Guru ever be wrong? Well in pad-chhed, if we call it our Guru, we are making our Guru wrong.
Sree Guru Gobind Singh jee gave us Lareedaar Sree Guru Granth Sahib jee as our eternal Guru. Who are we to change it?
If Pad-Chhed is acceptable and still Guru, then would it also be ok to split up the baaNee in Guru Granth Saahib jee according to each Guru ie. change the sequence? We wouldn't change the contents, just the order. If pad-chhed is ok, then so is this. But we know today that Bhai Manee Singh jee made this mistake and was punished by the Panth. The Panth rejected it.
In the same way, when the first edition of pad-chhed was being printed, the whole Panth got together to stop the press. The presses were stopped at Raag GauRee.
If we reject the original and true saroop of our Guru, we cannot expect Guru Sahib to do kirpa on us. We are really a Panth who has forgotten it's Guru.
Re: A Panth Without Its Guru
Curious Singh · 05 May 2004
THanks for filling me in :)
bhul chuk di khima
WAheguru ji ka Khalsa
Waheguru ji ki Fateh
Re: A Panth Without Its Guru
jagroop singh · 06 May 2004
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
i just wanted to say that thanks to this forum, i found out about Lareedar Saroop - i never even knew there was such a thing!
The points put forward in favour are so UTTERLY CONVINCING that it shows the current state of affairs...that Akaal Takht will not stop the issuance of Padd Ched Saroops is atrocious!
Dhan Siree Guru Granth Sahib Jee!