Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

< Female Punj Piyare >

< Female Punj Piyare >

Jagroop Singh · 01 May 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! Sadh Sangat Jio, From various Sikhs, i have received various viewpoints regarding the following question: - Can female Gursikhs do Seva as one of the Punj Piyare i.e. giving Amrit? If you think they should/shouldn't/are not allowed according to Gurmat, please provide evidence of your reasoning/GurBani. Thanks. Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Panth Says Yes · 01 May 2004

Sat Sri Akal: Panthic Rehat Maryada says yes. It is the hukam of the Panth. Period and end of story.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Mkhalsa · 01 May 2004

Read this: [url=http://www.mkhalsa.com/lit/femalepanj.html]http://www.mkhalsa.com/lit/femalepanj.html[/url] [%sig%]

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

uk singh · 02 May 2004

Think about this: Only 5 people from specific castes stood up as well. Does that mean Panj Pyare can only be khatri, jatt, water carrier, clothes washer, or barber? What about a Chumar (shoe maker) or Tarkhan? Can they not be in the Panj Pyare then? Your whole argument is illogical. What about gorae Sikhs, some white person may have been there, and there definitely were those of Muslim descent, can they not be Panj Pyare either? I keep hearing this argument again and again, but it makes no sense. ====================== Mkhalsa - Guru asked for 5 heads...he did not ask a gender specific question, caste, age, nationality etc. I have never heard of any bibian performing Amrit Sanchar after the period of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. This seems to be a leftist post modern movement in line with 'Western' thinking. This whole concept is insane. It's another contorversial addition in the Panth, along with all the others....people have nothing better to do than discuss controversies and boos thier haumai by try and win petty nonsensical debates.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

the real maha moorakh · 03 May 2004

>>Mkhalsa - Guru asked for 5 heads...he did not ask a gender specific question, caste, age, nationality etc.<<< If guru ji did not ask a gender specific question, than why are we asking it today? Although physically a women is different from a man, there is no difference between their atmaas. and the physical body of the panj pyaarey of today is different from the oroginal panj pyaarey, whether they are male or female. so if you want o use this argument, make sure every panj pyaarey are physically the same as the original panj,. and then your argument will be valid. If this seems like a leftist modern point of view, then your argument seems like a muslim/hindu/punjabi culture influenced view.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Mkhalsa · 03 May 2004

Uk Singh, I think your question has been answered. You disproved yourself.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

uK SiNgH · 04 May 2004

A man is a man, and a woman a woman and the twain shall never equate! Both have distinctly different roles in our growth and development, in the household, and in society. Both are equally important. Neither is superior or inferior. We do know which one is (generally) stronger and which is "fairer," though! And on this basis, we also know who dominates where, in our own life everyday! I believe that any attempt to prove them as equal, and interchangeable, when God Himself made them different, is futile. It is in vogue among many females to prove that all females can do everything most males can do. This is physically impossible, but, even the governments are afraid to contradict it! (I am, perhaps, the only fool) Those who abuse their partner because of a physical, economic, or a social advantage, are simply, foolish. We are not discussing abuse, or abusive domination here, which is a serious problem in all cultures. Having eliminated that, I believe that a discussion of male domination is unnecessary. Abuse of the females by males, though quite widespread, does not change a common phenomenon that the male is, by nature, the dominant gender in human social structure. Where mutual love and love of God prevails in a household, the question of equality becomes irrelevant. In some ways, all children respect their mother more than their father, and the mothers have enjoyed that authority. Trying to demonstrate equality through a role reversal, just for the sake of political correctness, is already producing a very unbalanced society. (I can see eggs and tomatoes flying from the audience) Forgive me, I am, simply trying to present some food for thought! The Gurus have supported this view also. They used the husband and wife model to illustrate God and man, with a given, that, the husband dominates and the wife submits. In fact they clearly opposed the reverse, as in Gauri Ki Vaar: "Over the head of the manmukh is the order of the woman; to her, he ever holds out his promises of goodness. Those men who act according to the orders of women are impure, filthy and foolish. Those impure men are engrossed in sexual desire; they consult their women and walk accordingly. One who walks as the True Guru tells him to, is the true man, the best of the best. He Himself created all women and men; the Lord Himself plays every play. You created the entire creation; O Nanak, it is the best of the best." (SGGS p.304) (By Dr. Sant Singh Khalsa) Please do not ask me to provide references. Research has shown that in the households where male figure is weak or absent, or the female dominates over the male, the children are more maladjusted in their own marriage afterwards, especially the female children (who, in turn are the mothers of future generation). The same could be said of a household with an abusive father. I cannot tell why women, as a rule, have not been appointed to positions of religious authority. I am sure it is not because women are, spiritually, or intellectually, inferior or superior. The mothers of the past have enjoyed great respect, and I have seen them enjoy their role in the Sikh society with dignity. I have never seen some wife protest during Amrit Parchaar against her husband being the only one chosen for the Five Beloved! An unspoken understanding between the two genders has continued since before Guru Nanak. The mothers of the past did not miss their role as some religious head. Is this a serious issue among the Sikh women of today? The original Five Beloved, were all male. Today's Five Beloved represent the same body of Sikhs. How can a female represent a male member of Five Beloved of the past? Just another thought, what happens if in the middle of a ceremony, a female member starts her menstrual cycle? Should she be allowed to continue? How will the others know? We will, then, need to add a requirement, to the Maryada, of wearing a tampon, during the Amrit Ceremony! Before you start cutting and pasting the quotes re menstruation. I am well aware of them. To keep it simple, it seems there are some good reasons why females are not given these roles. Females are equal, but different than men. God made us different for a purpose. A female should fulfil the role of a female, a mother, a daughter, and a sister, in the society, with dignity, with occasional exceptions. This is not a question of inferiority, superiority, or equality.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Mkhalsa · 04 May 2004

>>the male is, by nature, the dominant gender in human social structure<<< Really? theres a whole science that disagrees with you there, its called anthropology, an actual STUDY of human cultures shows that female dominance is just as common as male dominance, and up until 10,000 years ago (when we developed the new phenomenon of growing our food) men and women were considered equal, in fact women would have had more power in the society as they gathered up to 80% of consumed food for a tribe! >>>>The Gurus have supported this view also. They used the husband and wife model to illustrate God and man, with a given, that, the husband dominates and the wife submits. In fact they clearly opposed the reverse,<<<< Using bani in a context of human social relationships is TOTAL MANMAT and a twist of bani. Guru sahib is CLEARLY talking about the relationship between god and human, a submissive one. This redefining of bani I see by some people is incredibly wrong and almost blasphemous. Such misguided things include the interpretation of "patti parmeshar" etc And regarding the shabad, do you know what it is actually saying? its been discussed on this board, i suggest you do a search. it is talking about those who submit to kaam and are led around by the opposite gender due to kaam. >>>The original Five Beloved, were all male.<<<< This has been addressed many times, repeating the point again and again doesnt make it more true. The original panj were punjabi, does that mean punjabi people can only be in the panj? the original panj were of a certain age, can only people of those ages be in the panj? the original panj had darshan of guru sahib in human form, can punj today only be qualified after having human darshan? the original panj had black hair (most likely) can only black haired people be in the panj? all humans, man or woman, black or white, young or old, have the SAME soul!!! This vessel really doesnt matter!! I know many many singhnees who are much more qualified for panj seva than a moorakh like me, yet because I was born into a male body, im more qualified than a singhnee whos devoted 30 years to massive bhagti? I dont think so. >>Today's Five Beloved represent the same body of Sikhs.<<< You would have them represent the male chauvanistic sikhs. What if a singhnee needs to ask the panj a question which only a singhnee could answer? does this mean guru sahib is unqualified to help his sikh because we have made up ridiculous rules about singhnees not being in panj? .>>>Just another thought, what happens if in the middle of a ceremony, a female member starts her menstrual cycle?<<<< You should know a LOT better than saying such a thing!! Guru sahib himself says to say a woman is impure during the menstrual cycles is total MANMAT!!! so what? its totally natural. What if a singh gets a paper cut during amrit sanchar and starts bleeding? These arguments are getting more and more ridiculous. I suggest you put some logical thought into this and be truthful to yourself and guru jee as well as sangat before responding. You have not said anything new which hasnt been said or disproved in forum posts and emails over the last 10 years.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

unknown... · 04 May 2004

WahegurujikakhalsaWahegurujikifateh i totally agree wid MKhalsa's statements/advice. Pls my fellow sikhs, try to think things such as above more from Guru ji's point of view and not urselfs, cz we all have limited thinking in many ways but Guru ji is PERFECT. WahegurujikakhalsaWahegurujikifateh

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Niranjan Singh · 04 May 2004

uK SiNgH : I along with many other Sikhs have taken Amrit where one of the Panch was a Singhni. Do you consider us to be Sikhs ? If not, then what are we ? Are you saying that you are you a better Sikh than us because you had 'male' Panj Piyarays, and we didn't ? Or are you a better Sikh because of your Rahini-Behanee ? The Panj represent the Spirit and Body of Guru Gobind Singh Ji (eg: "Khalsa Mero Roop Hai Khaas, Khalsay Mai Hao Kaor Nivaas") Where does it say that Guru Gobind Singh Ji only resides in males, and where does it say than females are NOT Khalsa ? Why are dera dwellers so afraid of a female Khalsa ? Will it take another Mai Bhag Kaur to liberate you out from these Sanaatan-Masand phobias ?

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

g · 04 May 2004

a sikh is a sikh, man woman white black brown doesnt matter anybody can be panj

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

M4A1 · 04 May 2004

Interesting statements. Why was Mai Bhag Kaur never a part of the 5? There have been many charhdikala gursikhs that have had jathas of only singhs in the 5.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

M4A1 · 04 May 2004

There are valid arguements from both sides. I don't think this can be solved by a discussion. A panthic level gurmatta or by asking Guru Sahib themself could equate a definite answer.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 04 May 2004

M4A1 you say why was Mata Bhag Kaur never... hmm why was Baba Deep Singh never? why was Bhai Mani Singh never? why was Bhai Nand Lal never? hmm... your question is irrelevant.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Mkhalsa · 05 May 2004

Also, Even if mai bhag kaur WAS in the panj at some time in her life at an amrit sanchar, why would it be advertised? I know many singhs/singhnees who have done seva in panj at one time or another in their life, but they dont go around advertising it, so asking for proof of the actual individuals in amrit sanchars throughout history is asking for things that dont exist. Prove to me there was an amritsanchar, say in the year 1843, where would you find such proof when there is no living witness, documents are probably not around, what if you do find something that says an amrit sanchar occured in such a year, would you EVER find a record of who were in panj seva? who were the abhilaakhees? so saying theres no proof singhnees were in panj since guru sahibs time is not saying a lot.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

g · 05 May 2004

you all want to preach about sexual equality... but then you say Female cant be in Panj... thats not equality thats going totally against equality... and why do singhs sit around at home when the wife cooks for them and takes care of the kids... thats not equality either.. you can preach all you want but I have yet to see anyone to practices it

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Bhan-G · 05 May 2004

Waaheguru ji ka Khasaa Waaheguru ji ki Fateh Someone wrtoe :"I have never heard of any bibian performing Amrit Sanchar after the period of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. This seems to be a leftist post modern movement in line with 'Western' thinking" Yes there aare western panj pyari which have been composed entirely of bibi. I'd say it's probabllly because there were no singhs iiat the time that were fit for it... It's an evloving world. guru nanak went all over his part of the world and sikhi has spread everywhere---It's just male chavanisitic anti-gurmat thinkng wanting to keep women down that would think that panj pyare could possibly be a gender issue.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

uk SIngH · 07 May 2004

Yes there aare western panj pyari which have been composed entirely of bibi. I'd say it's probabllly because there were no singhs iiat the time that were fit for it... It's an evloving world. It might be an evolving World but this does not mean you have to change tradition and use our own limited budhi to include women in the panj. in the future people might say why use water for amrit, lets use milk, lets not use a sarbloh bata but use a ceramic one?

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Gaiani · 07 May 2004

Uk "singh" u come across as a sadistic female hater. why do u think both genders have the same kaakaars, same uniform, same nitnem? Common sense here, the picking of the punj is based on sprituality of the person not their gender. And about your claims about poeple who will follow this example and use milk instead of water, thats the dumbest thing iv ever heard, how does it relate to this thread?

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

uk singh · 07 May 2004

-----------Uk "singh" u come across as a sadistic female hater - thanks for the complement. -------------------- this was in reply to someone who thinks an evolving world means changing the Gender of the Panj. the fact remains that Vaheguru's hukam prevailed at the time that only men came forward with their heads even with women present. If the Guru wanted a mixed Amrit Sanchaar, then for sure some ladies would have come forward. we are running away from the basic fact that people don't put Sikhi into practice and are influenced by their ambient milieu. India has the predominant 'Hindu' culture and in the West it is the counter culture of the 60s, re-anointed as the mainstream culture. the amount of useless information you hear about Women not being in the sangat at the time is complete garbage as the sadda sent was for everyone. As there is no viable proof of any bibian performing seva in the panj before this modern take on the Amrit Sanchar, I rest my case. Surely many chardikalaan females existed before this wave of Feminism we have seen post 1960's! Why did they not take part in any amrit sanchaar if complete equality was a given? I've never seen an AKJ sanchaar in the UK with women in the Panj - not down South anyways? Maybe I haven't been to any of the more 'recent' events! we really need to define the word 'equality' with great care. Guru Nanak Dev Ji never proclaimed an equality for the genders that is claimed by the second wave of feminists. I would be very interested in knowing any verse from Gurbani that sounds anything similar to Betty Freidan or Gloria Steinem's version of equality. Addressing problems by quick fixes like feminism is akin to quackery as it addresses the symptoms and not the causes. The cause of social problems is that individuals do not act like Sikhs. We need to mend that behaviour rather than applying artificial patches of corrupted ideologies. By encouraging women to be more like men and vice versa is the disruption of the natural order that has been unleashed on the Western world since the beginning of the Second Wave of feminism. let us not forget, that Guru Gobind Singh Ji did not eliminate the gender differences when he created the Khalsa. Guru Ji recoginzed the differences between the two genders and gave them different last names. Singh-the brave fighters- and Kaur-paragons of royal grace. This desire to make warriors out of Khalsa women is one of the bigger problems we face. === Are you saying that you are you a better Sikh than us because you had 'male' Panj Piyarays, and we didn't ? Or are you a better Sikh because of your Rahini-Behanee ? Rab jane - I cannot possibly comment on your spiritual status and nor can anyone else..

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Gupt Singh · 07 May 2004

>>>>>>>this was in reply to someone who thinks an evolving world means changing the Gender of the Panj.<<<< Let me ask you .. If One abnormally ‘converts’ sex and become s a male – si it perfectly okay to be in Panj ? It’s the SAME JOT, same SOUl same SPIRIT >>>the fact remains that Vaheguru's hukam prevailed at the time that only men came forward with their heads even with women present.<<< Fact remains that there’s not natural born ‘GORE’ Sikhs in India – they can’t become Sikhs? Or jus cause someone’s a ‘gora Sikh’ they can’t become Panj? Ur comparison is PATHETIC >>If the Guru wanted a mixed Amrit Sanchaar, then for sure some ladies would have come forward<<< Surely some ‘tarkhan’ would pop up – now that no ‘Tarkhan’ did Too bad? `No ‘Gora Sikh’ popped up – sorry to bad – you can’t be in Panj ur argument is PATHETIC >>>we are running away from the basic fact that people don't put Sikhi into practice and are influenced by their ambient milieu.<<< I think most of us are following the Teachings of the 11 Roops of Guru Nanak dev jee, which SPECIFICALLY instructed us to treat men and Women alike ;) >>>India has the predominant 'Hindu' culture and in the West it is the counter culture of the 60s, re-anointed as the mainstream culture.<<< Don’t see how that’s relevant? >>>As there is no viable proof of any bibian performing seva in the panj before this modern take on the Amrit Sanchar, I rest my case.<<< U don’t seem to understand – do u? If someone does Seva of being one of Panj – they try to be HUMBLE – and do go and do ‘hoo haa’ about it and say ‘hunji yesterday I was in the Panj’! >>>Surely many chardikalaan females existed before this wave of Feminism we have seen post 1960's! Why did they not take part in any amrit sanchaar if complete equality was a given<<< How do u know they weren’t?? >>>we really need to define the word 'equality' with great care. Guru Nanak Dev Ji never proclaimed an equality for the genders that is claimed by the second wave of feminists. I would be very interested in knowing any verse from Gurbani that sounds anything similar to Betty Freidan or Gloria Steinem's version of equality.<<< Sikhism teaches EQUALTY – which includes same rights! >>y encouraging women to be more like men and vice versa is the disruption of the natural order that has been unleashed on the Western world since the beginning of the Second Wave of feminism.<< they’ve got the SAME RIGHTS We’re not making them more like men! Trhey got the same RIGHT’s as men!! It’s like you say ‘prove to me that car was droven by Women 100 years ago – they didn’t so they can’t now either ur arguments are utterly nonsense! >>>let us not forget, that Guru Gobind Singh Ji did not eliminate the gender differences when he created the Khalsa. Guru Ji recoginzed the differences between the two genders and gave them different last names. Singh-the brave fighters- and Kaur-paragons of royal grace. This desire to make warriors out of Khalsa women is one of the bigger problems we face.<<<< KHALSA MERO ROOP HAI KHAS KHALSE MEH HO KARO NIVAS Not ‘Khalsa MARDO MERO …’ Guru jee gave his roop to KHALSa- and not only Khalsa MEN Remember MAI BHAG KAUR! >>>>Are you saying that you are you a better Sikh than us because you had 'male' Panj Piyarays, and we didn't ? Or are you a better Sikh because of your Rahini-Behanee ? Rab jane - I cannot possibly comment on your spiritual status and nor can anyone else..<<<< Well obviously – your saying Women aren’t SUPPOSE to be in Panj – then according to you – Veer jee above’s Amrit must be wrong – according to you – IF that is the case! Bhull chukk di Khima Bakhsni Waheguru ji ka Khalsa WAheguru ji ki Fateh

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Jagroop Singh · 07 May 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! uk Singh wrote "This desire to make warriors out of Khalsa women is one of the bigger problems we face". Please explain why this is a problem. Dhan Siree Guru Granth Sahib Jee!

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Ek Sikh Punjaban · 07 May 2004

Yes i think that women should be able to be Punj Piyare. I says so in the panth. One of our Guru's said that women are very important.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

khalistani · 07 May 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!! just to let people know, sant jarnail singh je khalsa bhindranwale was against bibis going in and doing panj sewa theres a whole speech about sant je and how he talks how bibi and panj and kiran da amrit for bibis is wrong, etc. i think its on saintsoldiers nanaksar, rara sahib also do not allow bibis in the panj nihangs do not allow bibis in the panj nether does damdami taksal just though sangat wud like to know... :) bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!!

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Jassy J. · 07 May 2004

i guess it is ok. if the female gursikhs follow gurmat more than male gursikhs then why not? when Guru Gobind Singh Jee prepared amrit di pahol he never said that there would be a difference between male gursikhs and female gursikhs. just because the very first 5 pyares were male, doesn't mean that females cannot be the 5 pyares. maybe you can call this a tradition because it has been like that for hundereds of years. but this gotta change because this is completely against gurmat! my point is that yes females can be the 5 pyares!

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

vaheguroo~vaheguroo · 07 May 2004

yehh, i knew that baba jarnail singh jee didnt agree with singhnees in the punj, but why?? can someone post why he didnt agree with this??

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Mkhalsa · 07 May 2004

>>>This desire to make warriors out of Khalsa women is one of the bigger problems we face. <<<< We can all see whos chela you are uk singh. I suppose you also beleive that women shouldnt be taking khanda da amrit but rather kirpan da amrit from one man? Singhnees ie "khalsa women" were warriors, are warriors, and always will be warriors no matter what you say. Also, khalistani, saying nihangs dont allow women to be in panj isnt saying much because many dont think women should be taking amrit in the first place! There are just as many groups that allow women to be in amrit sanchar as dont, so lets not bring group names or gursikhs names (ie baba jarnail singh jee) into this. lets talk about facts and common sense.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

uk singh · 08 May 2004

--------We can all see whos chela you are uk singh. I suppose you also beleive that women shouldnt be taking khanda da amrit but rather kirpan da amrit from one man?---- Not sure where this is going, but you assume too much. --------We can all see whos chela you are uk singh. I suppose you also beleive that women shouldnt be taking khanda da amrit but rather kirpan da amrit from one man?--------- Please provide a list of Samparday from Guru Ji's period that allow bibian to perform this seva? ======== -----uk Singh wrote "This desire to make warriors out of Khalsa women is one of the bigger problems we face". Please explain why this is a problem.----------- Feminism is not much about ‘equality’ as it is about altering the balance of power. The feminist want the power and seeking ‘equality’ is merely a camouflage. And so are the cries of ‘oppression’ that the feminists and other post modernist liberals make. The Guru promises full spiritual equality to men and women, but nowhere in Sikhi would you hear anyone say – the Sikh revolution really wants to transfer the societal setup from patriarchy to matriarchy, or transfer the ‘power’ to women. As you do know, the status of women in Sikhi is radically different from pretty much all other ‘civilized’ realms of religion, the ancient Stone Age matriarchal tribes excepted of course. The Guru exalted the status of women from the causers of the ‘original sin’ (Genesis), ,‘one-half of man’ (Quran) or ‘witch/Maya’(Hindu milieu) to the ‘honour of man’(Guru Hargobind Sahib) and the ‘creator of kings’(Guru Nanak Dev Ji). But based on my understanding, there really isn’t anything similar to the power driven feminism of the late 20th century in the message of Sikhi. Women seeking power is a deviation from the normal feminine behaviour and against the basis of natural way in which heterosexual relations function. Man commands the power, and women nurture and submit, ensuring a compatible relationship. There is nothing bad about this setup; howsoever politically incorrect it might sound. That’s how the genetics has made men and women. Fighting against the Will of Vaheguru can’t take us far, thought it can certainly begin the decay of society as we see all around ourselves. Finally, the basic question that needs to be asked is this- if women don’t share ‘equal power’ with men, does it make them oppressed? Probably in the feminist worldview, but not in an objectivist rational order. Feminism is all about transforming patriarchy into something that is less than desirable and I’m not too keen on seeing that happen in the realm of Sikhi.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Bhan-G · 08 May 2004

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Has any one mentioned Mata Sahib Kaur. Wasn't she included in the first AMritsanchaar adding the sugar to the water? It seems like a big fear thing- things might get out of hand if women are allowed to participate in what men have been doing traditionally. There was mention of womens physcial weakness. Does it seem probable that a woman is too weak to participate in Amritsanchaar? Or is it more likely that singhs are uncomfortable having a woman in such close proximity that they might have problems thinking of a singhni as sister while she squats with bare legs sticking out of kacherra pressed upand moving against bare legs of singhs on either side and touching hands of singhs while stirring the sugar in to the water for 45-1hr. (If anything about this statement bothers you in any way then the answer is probably YES) Seems as though it is mostly worry that they might get distracted and lose focus. Just seems fear of spiritual weakness on the part of men rather than womens physical weakness that keep women segragated. And who knows perhaps it has something to do with why there was all female panj pyari too. Maybe everyone is just afraid of mixing genders and what could result. Too bad we can't just look on each other all of us as sisters -soul sister brides of husband waheguru regardless the gender of what body we inhabit. It seems silly it should even be an issue for anyone who looks only to waheguru as "male" and just goes to show how spiritually stunted people are who even consider it a problem.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Mkhalsa · 08 May 2004

>>>Please provide a list of Samparday from Guru Ji's period that allow bibian to perform this seva? <<< The Khalsa Panth. Please provide me a list of "samparday" from guru sahibs time where 1) lineage can be proven beyond a reasonable doubt or 2) they havent become corrupted with brahministic or other practices I can prove the lineage of the khalsa panth without a doubt and the khalsa panth as a body accepts females in panj pyare. >>>>Women seeking power is a deviation from the normal feminine behaviour and against the basis of natural way in which heterosexual relations function. Man commands the power, and women nurture and submit, ensuring a compatible relationship. There is nothing bad about this setup; howsoever politically incorrect it might sound. That’s how the genetics has made men and women. <<<<< So you are basically saying, guru sahib has elevated the status of women, but they are still subordinate. what sikhi are you following? i dont recall a strong khalsa panth and a subordinate khalsee panth? do you? perhaps i read the wrong history books... Regarding your "natural order" theory which you keep repeating again and again.. saying the same thing again and again will not make it more true. history, science and actual STUDIES of human civilization show this is not the case and in fact women had equal to more power than men in ALL hunter-gatherer (pre horticulture/agriculture) civilizations. This women being subordinate is a rather new phenomenon in human history. If you want me to go into details I will. Throughout history, it has been shown, that in human civilizations, the power lies with the food producers in the society. In hunter-gatherer societies (pre-10,000 years ago) women gathered up to 80% of the food consumed by a tribe. Yes, men hunted due to the fact that womens pelvic bones have such a structure that they cannot run as fast for catching wild game as men can. BUT women still gathered 80% of the food. this is still true in most surviving hunter gatherer cultures. and in all of these cultures, women had the power due to the fact that they produced all the food! the men relied on them! Women in these societies could also practice more power because they could control their reproduction. Human Women do not go into "heat" or esterus due to the fact that we walk upright, because of this, human women can be active at any time and do not know when they are ovulating.. before we started producing food, women did not have enough body fat to ovulate AND breast feed. so by breast feeding for a few years, women controlled their pregnancies, and there lies the key to why women had power. Once we began to grow our own food, horticulture, or raise animals, pastoralist society.. women became relegated to the home. They began to have more body fat due to more food available and could ovulate and breast feed and could be pregnant. So women quite literally became baby factories. And this is where we see patriarchal and chauvanistic societies develop. Women no longer controlled the food or their procreation, so they were relegated to the house. The feminist movement is partly because of birth control where women can control their reproduction for the first time in 10,000 years. Guru sahib didnt need to wait for this. He gave us birth control. Its called NAAM and our command to avoid kaam! Because of this, SINGHNEES can control our gurudwaras, can lead armies, can give amrit, can do anything.. because singhnees are not relegated to be baby factories like women of other cultures, they arent told to shutup and go in the kitchen.. singhnees can put singhs to shame, this is the power guru sahib gave them. Singhnees have power in our society, a god-given power, because they can control their reproduction through naam and they can control food production today by working along with their husbands, or in the old days, they had to tend to the farms etc because their husbands had joined in guru sahibs armies. Guru sahib gave us what science later analyzed and has yet to discover. Sorry for the long post, but im tired of this "natural order" gandh with no proof to back it up.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Jagroop Singh · 09 May 2004

Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh! UK Singh wrote: "Feminism is not much about ‘equality’ as it is about altering the balance of power. The feminist want the power and seeking ‘equality’ is merely a camouflage". Dear Veer Ji, you're reading of feminism is seriously limited and generalised. As i am sure you are aware, it's not quite as simple as that...i won't cut and paste lots off stuff off the internet - that would certainly waste time. UK Singh wrote: "And so are the cries of ‘oppression’ that the feminists and other post modernist liberals make". i don't see why you are bringing postmodernism into it - what's your point here...are you trying to point to some sort of change, re: feminism, between the modernist era and what some now refer to as the contemporary postmodernist era...perhaps you are; it's just not very clear at all though. UK Singh wrote: "The Guru promises full spiritual equality to men and women, but nowhere in Sikhi would you hear anyone say – the Sikh revolution really wants to transfer the societal setup from patriarchy to matriarchy, or transfer the ‘power’ to women". Again, you are alluding to a very convenient (for your argument that is) yet completely limited concept of feminism. As i am sure you are aware, not all feminists over the last 80 years were the kind of 'anarchists' that you paint them out to be...again, i do not wish to point to the obvious and digress as a result. UK Singh wrote: "As you do know, the status of women in Sikhi is radically different from pretty much all other ‘civilized’ realms of religion, the ancient Stone Age matriarchal tribes excepted of course. The Guru exalted the status of women from the causers of the ‘original sin’ (Genesis), ,‘one-half of man’ (Quran) or ‘witch/Maya’(Hindu milieu) to the ‘honour of man’(Guru Hargobind Sahib) and the ‘creator of kings’(Guru Nanak Dev Ji)". This part of your post is absolutely excellent; this shows you have perhaps even unintentionally grasped what Guru Sahib was doing; the practice of Burquah (full length head/face/bodylegs veil) was so strongly set against what Sikhi was about that 3rd Nanak Sahib would not even allow women who wore it to attend Sangat! Now that is a SERIOUSLY STRONG STATEMENT that Guru Sahib made! You can call it whatever you like by the way...the action speaks louder than any words. UK Singh wrote: "Women seeking power is a deviation from the normal feminine behaviour and against the basis of natural way in which heterosexual relations function. Man commands the power, and women nurture and submit, ensuring a compatible relationship. There is nothing bad about this setup; howsoever politically incorrect it might sound. That’s how the genetics has made men and women. Fighting against the Will of Vaheguru can’t take us far, thought it can certainly begin the decay of society as we see all around ourselves". Nurture and submit - what like Mai Bhago...i gues if you were right that particular historical happening would read: "and she stayed quiet as the men decided not to follow Guru Sahib into battle; she scolded herself for even thinking she should say something and quietly proceeded to wash the dishes and sweep the floor - as every good woman should". i think Veer MKhalsa Jee has succinctly relegated your argument. As for inferring that it is this imbalance of gender power-relatations that has caused 'the decay of society'...you seriously need to do some flower-arranging or something to get in touch with your feminine side Veer Ji! Your point is so limited that to be honest what can be said in reply aside from the following: that is absolute nonsense! UK Singh wrote: "Finally, the basic question that needs to be asked is this- if women don’t share ‘equal power’ with men, does it make them oppressed? Probably in the feminist worldview, but not in an objectivist rational order". Objectivist-rational order; Veer Ji, as Veer MKhalsa Jee did, i am going to 'assume too much' here and declare that much of the terminology you use in your post is in fact for the purposes of intentionally mystifying what you are putting across. i feel as though you have yet to learn that the intellect is limited...for instance, what if i was to begin a thread called 'the nature of objectivism' and was to argue there is no such thing as objectivism...me and you could carry the debate on for aeons and aeons and no progress would be made. Always remember that Guru Sahib is more than just a philosopher...the philospher tries to ascertain Truth from an objective position whilst Guru Sahib is actually part and parcel of the Truth...subjectivism and objectivism do not apply here. As Sikhs, this is what we try to achieve by living and breathing Siree Guru Granth Sahib Jee. UK Singh wrote: "Feminism is all about transforming patriarchy into something that is less than desirable and I’m not too keen on seeing that happen in the realm of Sikhi". Guru Sahib sees patriarchy as unnatural...just as He sees matriarchy as unnatural...Natural is about balance, ying and yang, equilibrium. This is where your arguments fall flat on their face. You are effectively saying that patriarchy is natural, correct, positive etc. What you fail to do is quote Siree Guru Sahib in support of your attitudes...i accept every quote from Siree Guru Sahib that has been put forward to challenge your views as my support. Dhan Siree Guru Granth Sahib Jee!

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

uk singh · 09 May 2004

In remembrance of the Khalsa who have passed away, this discussion as far as I am concerned is to be suspended until a more suitable time.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

guru da dass · 10 May 2004

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh I have been monitoring this thread and to me it raises even more questions. If a person puts their heart and soul into Sikhi and follow rehet in every way then wherein lies the difference between any member of the Khalsa? If liberation from oppression is a core value of the Khalsa then why are we looking for excuses to bar full participation by women in the activities of the Khalsa Panth? This seems to be a disturbing trend. I know women who are taught not to and do not perform their Nitnem when they are menstruating. In certain groups women are barred from paticipating in Akhand Path because they menstruate and because of a taught aversion towards women because they wear salvar or pyjamee (it does not seem to matter if rehet states that one has to take full shower and wear clean clothing before doing a rol) Is is inherently right to deny voice and participation in Panthic activities solely based on gender? That is at least 50% of the Panth. I think the Gurus would disagree with you when by the time of Guru Gobind Singh 40% of Sikh missionaries were women. Have we not taken a step back in Gurujee's mission itself? Who is to say they did not officiate in ALL duties requiring Panthic attention as well? It is one thing to SAY one does not discriminate but it is ACTIONS that speak louder and clearer. A Sikh must be one in thought, speach and action. When one excludes an entire section of the Khalsa for reason of race, occupation, caste or gender from participation in religious or Panthic matters we are no longer following Gurujee's Hukam...we are discriminating and becoming the oppressors the Gurus so vigorously fought! I have taken amrit when 2 women were in Panj Peeyarey, and the Darban was also a woman. It was a truly Chardhikala Amrit Sanchaar that occured and a tremendous amount of kirpa occured there. I suppose you are going to say I was hallucinating or making it up. Then I CHALLENGE you to meet me and tell this to my face! I took amrit 21 years ago jee. Amrit has begun a process that continues to turn my life on its head. That anyone champions human rights and gives a voice and a role to the disenfrenchised and the underrepresented champions the Guru's cause. The Gurus brought light and nudged the conscience of the whole world. Why as Sikhs would we want to step back from this glorious heritage and apply shackles within our own Khalsa Panth? By the way one of the Sikhs who has left this world was also a woman who was an inspiring role model for other young women and young men. She was learning Gatka, was an infectious budding leader, and was blossoming into a fine strong Gursikh. Do we not need people like this? Is building strong leaders and getting EVERYONE involved in whatever talent and capacity not in our Panth's best interest!! Or are we going to fall victims to our narrow insecurities and prejudices?? Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh [%sig%]

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

want to know now pleasee · 11 May 2004

I know that DAMDAMI TAKSAAL is 100% against this.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Mkhalsa · 11 May 2004

>>>>Author: uk singh Date: 05-09-04 07:37 In remembrance of the Khalsa who have passed away, this discussion as far as I am concerned is to be suspended until a more suitable time.<<<<< HOW DARE YOU USE THEIR PASSING AS A WAY TO BACK OUT OF AN ARGUMENT!!! I knew these gursikhs and loved them very much. backing out of a debate by invoking their passing is disgraceful!!! Just admit you have no way to counter the points and end it, instead you disgracefully bring the deaths of gurmukh pyare into it as a way to back out. What cowardice.

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

Rashminder Singh Oz · 11 May 2004

thanx guru da daas ji i agree with u, 100% correct........ i wish people should start accepting the fact that bibian can do all sewaas what singhs can do. i myself want a baby girl after i get married, i want her to be parcharak in her coming future, i will try my best to make her best parcharak for spreading guru ji's message about dastaar for bibian , make her good kathakaar and kirtanee may guru bless me with such a daughter come on gursikhon lets change our mentality.............. there is no sex difference in terms of gurmat rehit maryadaa. chardikalaaaaaaaaaaaaaa waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

guru da dass · 11 May 2004

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh To tell you the truth I don't really care if the Taksal is against this or not. I am no less a Sikh then any of them. I f they don't like it that is their problem. I am sick and tired of this oppressive discrimination in so many shades under the guise of gurmat against 50% of the Sikh panth.The soul wears the body of the Akal Purakh's choosing and it is our narrow point of view that locks us into patterns or discrimination. Gurujee is without vair and is a lot more fair then many groups out there. The heck with them!!

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

uk singh · 12 May 2004

If the rest of the readers agree that this was indeed a disgraceful and/or cowardice move, then I will gladly continue...

Re: < Female Punj Piyare >

singh · 18 May 2004

Panthic Rehat Maryada says yes. It is the hukam of the Panth. Period and end of story. can you tell me where in the Maryada, this is outlined..? MKhalsa, don't get wound up so easily. Believe in the Will of Vaheguru