Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Dastaar

Dastaar

Indy · 07 May 2003

Where has Guru Ji ever used the work Keski to mean Kakaar? Used Dastaar yes, but not a recent invention Keski.

Re: Dastaar

Admin · 07 May 2003

Dear Gursikh, Please read the material in the literature section or read the previous postings with respect to the Keski issue. We strongly believe that Keski is a kakaar and if you believe Kes is a kakaar, we have no issues over it. We advocate and preach Keski as a Kakaar and in all amrit sinchaar held at Tapoban Sahib, Keski is preached as a Kakaar. Let us not get into the Keski Vs Kes debate. Most of the times, this debate ends with bitterness. We want the visitors of this forum to leave this forum with increased vigour to keep rehit and Sikhi. We don't want to start another Keski Vs Kes debate here. Please pardon us for not allowing this debate on this site at this time.

Re: Dastaar

Sarbloh Badman · 07 May 2003

bhai sahib ji i would also like to hear specific rehitnamas/hukamnamas on teh keski issue where it is addressed directly as a kakkar...i am not sure whch is right at the moment and here is the only place i can learn!

Re: Dastaar

Indy · 07 May 2003

Dear Administrator, I greatly admire your response as it is more civil than what I usually recieve when engaging in these type of exchanges. However in Sikhi, we should not hide from the truth. Other AKJ forums for instance have let me initiate a discussion but disallowed me from posting replies where one is expected to answer questions that automatically arise...this is akin to a prosecution without any form of defense. It is interesting to see that this site as well as others only puts forward one side of what even you cannot deny are controversial topics currently raging in the Sikh Panth. If you are happy in your Sikhi then that is great. Do you not think the rest of the Sangat requires the flip side of the argument? In Sarbloh Granth Sahib and a hand written letter to the Sangat of Kabul, Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaaj has clearly stated the Kakaars - and yes Keski is not once mentioned. People ignoring these basic historical facts will do so at their peril. This is from Guru Ji's own pen. For me at least this carries more weight than any rehitnamey. On one AKJ site at least some of the Singhs have agreed that Dastaar and not Keski is mentioned. ie 'Sabat Surat Distaar Siraa' Thank you for your time. Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!

Re: Dastaar

Mkhalsa · 08 May 2003

I suggest you read the keski as a kakkar articles on this site and rehat maryada points on contention on akj.org. Off of the top of my Head, I know the following.. Kach, Kara, Kirpan, Kangha, Keski, Eh Panj Kakkari Rahit Dharay Sikh Soeey -Rehatnama Bhai Chaupa Singh

Re: Dastaar

Mkhalsa · 08 May 2003

The following is a conversation I had with some others a year or so ago... ---------------------------------------- Seeker Kaur says: Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Singh Jee 1 says: Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Kee Fateh Singh Jee 2 says: Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh Singh Jee 1 says: veer jee, can you help us find why keski is a kakar? Singh Jee 2 says: hanji? Singh Jee 1 says: keski, whats its defintion as a kakar Singh Jee 2 says: first of all Singh Jee 2 says: lets start with history Singh Jee 2 says: do you know about the singh sabha movement bhenji? Seeker Kaur says: nahi ji Singh Jee 2 says: ok well Singh Jee 2 says: around the 1800s Singh Jee 2 says: sikhi was down the drain, brahminism reigned supreme, they even had a statue of ganesh at harmandir sahib Singh Jee 2 says: it was that bad, people would worship gianis, etc Singh Jee 2 says: a lot of that brahminism is still around (caste system, sants) Singh Jee 2 says: and some other rituals we tend to do that we cant weed out quite yet Singh Jee 2 says: but anyway, around the late 1800s, hundreds of gursikhs got fed up with it Singh Jee 2 says: they said we arent hindus, we are sikhs Singh Jee 2 says: we gotta get this outta our religion right Singh Jee 2 says: and so they started the singh sabha movement, to remove hinduism from sikhi Singh Jee 2 says: (thats why theres so many gurudwaras called singh sabha still around) Singh Jee 2 says: they created gurudwaras, retook akal takhat Singh Jee 2 says: they rewrote the maryada to the original using historical documents and because most of these were the most educated sikhs on the planet Singh Jee 2 says: so they fixed it Singh Jee 2 says: well something thats always been there is dastar right, everyone has to wear dastar Singh Jee 2 says: anyway singh sabha died down around 1930s Singh Jee 1 says: its what makes a sikh a sikh Singh Jee 2 says: in the 1940s, a jathedar came about in akal takhat Singh Jee 2 says: Gurmukh Singh Musafir Singh Jee 1 says: yup Singh Jee 1 says: thats it Seeker Kaur says: hunji Singh Jee 2 says: and he noticed that well not many women were taking amrit Singh Jee 2 says: because they wanted to have new hairstyles and what not Singh Jee 2 says: and dress in saris like their hindu counterparts in india Singh Jee 2 says: right Singh Jee 2 says: so he said fine in the next 4 days Singh Jee 2 says: anyone who comes Singh Jee 2 says: he said anyone who comes in the next 4 days doesnt have to wear keski Singh Jee 2 says: now this pissed off all the singhs that just fixed sikhi right Singh Jee 2 says: but they couldnt do anything because he was the jathedar Singh Jee 2 says: and they respected that they were too humble Singh Jee 2 says: because these were some chardi kala singhs right Singh Jee 2 says: and so anyway this gurmukh singh guy has control Singh Jee 2 says: and so for those 4 days thousands of women went to akal takhat to take amrit without dastar Singh Jee 2 says: and then more demand for it started Singh Jee 2 says: and he said every other week, then every other day Singh Jee 2 says: then the other takhts started doing it and eventually, keski just got phased out Singh Jee 2 says: now, bhai randhir singh was around during this time and he said no.. gurmukh singh is wrong Singh Jee 2 says: and thats why akj still requires keski Singh Jee 2 says: because bhai randhir singh jee didnt allow his jatha to change with this manmat Singh Jee 2 says: i dont agree with groups, but here akj is right Singh Jee 2 says: this man changed sikhi Singh Jee 2 says: over the course of time it became accepted Singh Jee 2 says: and people said then whats the 5th kakkar? Singh Jee 2 says: and eventually it became kes out of ignorance and people deciding to forget history Singh Jee 2 says: but if you talk to anyone in their 70s or 80s they will tell u what i just said Singh Jee 2 says: i learned it from harsharan kaur jee and others Singh Jee 1 says: What about a list of reasons, or points? Singh Jee 2 says: ok, so list of reasons Singh Jee 2 says: Theres a book they handed out at a samagam Singh Jee 2 says: bhenji are u still with us? Seeker Kaur says: hunji Singh Jee 2 says: before i start on that do u have any questions? about the history etc? Seeker Kaur says: nahi ji Seeker Kaur says: not at the moment Singh Jee 2 says: ok Singh Jee 2 says: now on to the word kakkar what does this mean? Singh Jee 2 says: linguists seem to say it comes from the punjabi verb karna, which means to do or make Singh Jee 2 says: now if you notice all the other kakkars are made, right? Singh Jee 2 says: but we dont make our hair, god does Singh Jee 2 says: but we do make keski, thus keski is a kakkar Singh Jee 2 says: in bani it says saabat soorat dastar siraa, this means that the human body must always have a dastar on it Singh Jee 2 says: also, some people right from birth dont have any hair because of disease Singh Jee 2 says: how can they be amritdhari then? Singh Jee 2 says: u cant take amrit with only 4 kakkars Singh Jee 2 says: then amrit would be imperfect and not for everyone Singh Jee 1 says: Seeker kaur! make sure you're reading everything hes saying Singh Jee 2 says: and what if they lose their hair to a disease? Seeker Kaur says: i am! Singh Jee 2 says: then they are no longer amritdhari Singh Jee 2 says: also, why are only guys required to wear keski? Singh Jee 2 says: if you saw me at gurudwara with a braid Singh Jee 2 says: would u consider me a singh? Singh Jee 2 says: never!! Singh Jee 1 says: imagine if all men stopped wearing their dastaars, sikhi wouldnt be carried on and it would go down the tubes Seeker Kaur says: waheguru Singh Jee 1 says: no one to carry on the tradition Singh Jee 2 says: so why is this split? if in sikhism men and women are equal? Singh Jee 1 says: sooner or later Singh Jee 1 says: other things would become lost too Singh Jee 1 says: the dastaar is the backbone of keeping sikhi alive and pure Singh Jee 2 says: in all the old rehitnamas Singh Jee 2 says: by Bhai Daya Singh Jee and others Singh Jee 1 says: chaupa singh, nandlal singh Singh Jee 2 says: and even historical accounts by goray and muslims Singh Jee 1 says: british generals Singh Jee 1 says: etc. Singh Jee 2 says: they say people took amrit with dastar, always, even women Singh Jee 2 says: which astonished many outside observers, so they made a point of writing it Singh Jee 2 says: and all the old rehitnamas have requirements for each kakkar Singh Jee 2 says: (Ex. kanga must be wooden, kirpan must have a sheath) Singh Jee 2 says: why isnt there a similar requirement for kes? Singh Jee 2 says: why is it that kes is considered a kurait? Singh Jee 2 says: its held higher in sikhi than any of the kakkars Singh Jee 2 says: if u cut ur hair then u have to pesh Singh Jee 2 says: why not pesh for any of the other kakars? Singh Jee 2 says: if u drop ur kanga u just say waheguroo and do ardas, u dont go pesh Singh Jee 1 says: okay Seeker kaur bhenji Singh Jee 1 says: are you convinced yet? Singh Jee 2 says: yes, because i have a lot more information Singh Jee 1 says: i think Singh Jee 2 is more then willing to do more seva and go on and on Singh Jee 2 says: yes... Seeker Kaur says: waheguru Singh Jee 2 says: so what do u think? Singh Jee 2 says: still need more information? Seeker Kaur says: nahi bhaji, i think its good Singh Jee 1 says: if you read everything, theres no way you wouldnt have been convinced Singh Jee 1 says: so Seeker kaur, start wearing a keski! Seeker Kaur says: oh bhaji, i am convinced Seeker Kaur says: waheguru Singh Jee 2 says: ok bhenji, keep learning about gursikhi! Singh Jee 2 says: Waheguroo jee ka khalsa! Waheguroo jee kee fateh!! Seeker Kaur says: waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Singh Jee 1 says: Vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji kee fateh ------------------------------- This Singhnee now wears dastar proudly :)

Re: Dastaar

Admin · 08 May 2003

The issue of keskee being a kakaar can be addressed from two different angles. The first being historical and the second being purely logical. Historical: The most convincing evidence that Keskee was given as a kakaar at first amrit sinchaar comes from the Guru Keeaan Sakheean. These are records from Bhatts, or poets who recorded events. This is the most authentic record of what happened. These Guru Keean Sakheean were published by Piara Singh Padam. The following is a great link about these puraatan writings, dated around 1708: http://www.sikhreview.org/march2001/chronicle.htm Some of the most convincing passages read like this: "Assigning the word Singh first to his own name and thence to the names of all the Five Chosen Sikhs, Guru ji called out Fateh (the victory salutation) and raised aloud the spirited chant of Sat Sri Akal. "Thereafter, Guru ji pronounced, ‘on your rebirth in the Khalsa Panth, your previous lineage, caste, creed, calling, customs, beliefs and superstitions, etc. stand annulled from now onwards. Transforming you into the Order of Khalsa, I have endowed you with the apparel of the Almighty God, you shall have to keep its honour. Before administering this nectar of steel, I also bestowed you with five kakaars (Ks, i.e. defining emblems). You have never to keep them away from your body even by mistake. I gave you, at the start, a blue keski, kangha, kirpan, sarbloh ka kara and white kachhehra. In the event of the loss or misplacement of any of these, get its infringement pardoned in the Sangat by going to Gurdwara without any delay." Another account by a different bhatt in the same records reads: "Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Tenth Guru, son of Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji, in the year Seventeen Hundred Fifty Two, on Tuesday - the Vaisakhi day - gave Khande-Ki-Pahul to Five Sikhs and surnamed them as Singhs. First Daya Ram Sopti, Khatri resident of Lahore stood up. Then Mohkam Chand Calico Printer of Dawarka; Sahib Chand Barber of Zafrabad city; Dharam Chand Jawanda Jat of Hastnapur; Himmat Chand Water Carrier of Jagannath stood up one after the other. All were dressed in blue and he himself also dressed the same way. Huqqah, Halaal, Hajaamat, Haraam, Tikka, Janeyu, Dhoti, were prohibited. Socialization with the descendants of Prithi chand (Meenay), followers of Dhirmal and Ram Rai, clean shaven people and Masands was prohibited. All were given Kangha, Karad (***Karad is synonomous with kirpaan***), KESGI, Kada and Kachhehra. All were made Keshadhari. Everyone's place of birth was told to be Patna, of residence as Anandpur. Rest, Guru's deeds are known only to the Satguru. Say Guru! Guru! Guru! Guru will help everywhere." In the story of how Satguru Gobind Singh jee iniated Baba Banda Singh Bahadur in the puraatan Guru Keeaan Sakheean, it is written that Guru jee himself tied a "keskee" on his head. Other rehitnamas such as Bh. Daya Singh insist that all Sikhs should wear dastaar, but the Bhat Vehis leave no doubt that Keskee is a kakaar. A Version of the Bhai Chaupa Singh rehitnama also contains the famous lines "kachh kaRa kirpaan kangha keskee, eh panj kakaaree rehit dhaaray, sikh soee". The interesting feature of the rehitnamas however is that they themselves acknowledge that they are not authoritative and complete sources for rehit. In more than one rehitnama you'll find a disclaimer that the complete rehit is that which was given by the punj pyaaray, the one written is just a supplement. Not any of the authoritative rehitnamas actually give a list of the "five kakaars". This is only found in the puraatan Bhatt Vehis. It's often brought up that Guru Gobind Singh jee himself has written of kes as a kakaar in the Kabul hukumnama. It can't be stressed enough that the Kabul Hukumnama is universally considered a fake. It does not follow the traditional hukumnama format. It does not contain the nishaan of Satguru Gobind Singh at the top nor a personal message by him. The hand writing is clearly not by Guru Saahib and contains only the writing of a scribe. But in all traditional hukumnamas, the top portion always contains a message and manglacharan by the Guru in his own hand to authenticate the hukumnama. Dr. Ganda Singh has collected all the historical hukumnamas in his book "Hukumnamey" and he does not include this hukumnama in that book, due to it being a blatant fake. This hukumnama has come into prominence in recent years only. A Second point that is often brought up is that Guru Saahib in Dasam Granth has written of kes as kakaar in the shabad "nishanay sikhee...". It is important to understand that this shabad is not considered part of the body of Dasam Granth. It was not added by Bhai Mani Singh and is not contained in puraatan saroops. In present day saroops of Dasam Granth it is included in the last pages but as an Appendix. The numbering at the top of those pages is done in Gurmukhi letters to indicate that they are an appendix and not part of the body. The Shabad in question appears on the appendix "gugga". Analysis of the language used and the date this shabad started to appear make it clear that it is a later addition. Overall, the historical writings leave no doubt that Keskee is a kakaar. In fact, wherever the term "kakaar" has been found in historical writings, keskee is listed as one. Logical: No jathebandee in the Panth today can deny that women and men in Gurmat have equal rights and responsibilities. If men must wear a dastaar and keskee, then women also must do so. All are Khalsa, no Khalsee exists. No Singh can receive amrit with braided hair or bun at the back of the head, so why can a Bibi? There is complete equality. Khalsa is beyond gender and hence, all rehits and kurehits are the same for all Khalsa. 2ndly, all the kakaars are external. The Guru has bestowed the Kakaars to the Sikh during amrit sinchaar. Guru Saahib did not bestow kesh. These are naturally occuring on most humans. The panj pyaaray can dress the abhilaakhee in all kakaars but cannot give the abhilaakhee Kesh. In the Banda Singh Bahadur story in the Bhatt Vehis, Guru Gobind Singh himself dresses Banda in the Kakaars and the story makes a point of saying how keskee is tied by Guru Saahib. Kesh thus is a naturally occuring thing, not something bestowed during amrit sinchaar. If kesh is a kakaar, then why the need to say "don't cut kesh" as a bujjer kurehit? If I must keep the kesh, then obviously I cannot cut them. If a Sikh removes any kakaar, he must appear before the Punj Pyaaray and receive a tankhah but is not considered a patit and amrit is not re-administered. If a Sikh cuts the Kesh, s/he is bujjer kurehitee, patit and must be re-initiated into the Khalsa. Thus it is clear that kesh cannot be a kakaar. Kesh are not a kakaar, but much above kakaars. To maintain kesh, two kakaars are given: kangha and keskee. Thus, even logically looking at the evidence, Kesh clearly cannot be a kakaar. During the early 1800s a rot set into the Sikh community where many old principle and rehits were lost. Many enemies of the Panth encouraged the abolition of fundamental rehits. At this time Sikh women stopped receiving khanday kee paahul (and in some jathas/places ie. Hazoor Saahib they still receive Kirpaan Kee Paahul, not Khanday kee). Women stopped wearing Kachheras and keskee also was lost. In 1900s, there was a big struggle to make kacherras mandatory again for women and the re-popularising of Khanday kee Paahul. Some women had remained strict in rehit in some places and some jathas, but it was rare. The rehit of keskee was maintained even at the Akal Takhat for women till 1930 until the Jathedar, Gurmukh Singh Mussafir removed this condition. There has been significant improvement from the dark days of the 1800s and pre-Singh Sabha, but unfortunately the whole Panth has not embraced Keskee as a kakaar yet. Hopefully in the near future, just as women were restored the right to receive Amrit and keep other kakaars, they too will be restored the kakaar of Keskee. With this, we encourage all other seekers to read the article in the "Gurmat" section on Keskee. We, as was mentioned earlier, will not entertain any debate on keskee as all that needs to be said has now been said.

Re: Dastaar

Sarbloh Badman · 11 May 2003

oh man they were such heavy posts.......ive got no doubt in my mind keski is a kakkar now thanks guys :)

Re: Dastaar

snigga · 12 May 2003

MKhalsa can you please refrence daas to histroical texts or any texts that may make mention of the 4 day ban on keski being the kakaar. ***just so daas can clear all doubts that the comments made in fact are authentic to history.

Re: Dastaar

Mkhalsa · 13 May 2003

Actually my history lesson comes not from reading, but talking to gurmukh pyare at samagams. I was eating langar at a samagam awhile back when Bibi Harsharan Kaur sits next to me and just starts talking about sikh history and everything... Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Jee, Her life etc... Back then I did not know who she was and I was first thinking, why is this lady talking to me, and then i realized what she was talking about, and it became a very long conversation. Then Khalsa jee from vancouver joined in, as most poeple know he did a lot of seva of Bhai sahib. This was an amazing experience and I learned a lot. Other things I picked up at other samagams where there are others, or younger singhs/singhnees who have been learning from older singhs/singhnees as well. I think talking to the older gursikhs will make us all a lot smarter. I did learn a bit here and there from forums/sites etc. :) I think you can probably get information on this from some books, i just dont know of any, perhaps some other gurmukh pyare can help with that.

Re: Dastaar

Big Fool · 13 May 2003

MKhalsa, Is it true that Bibi Harsharan Kaur Ji has had the sangat of Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji? I came to USA last year, and just went to Dixie road gurdwara casually, it was the first time I had been to a gurdwara in Canada (Toronto), the lucky thing was that when I went, there was a rehansbhai on at that time, so I stayed for a few hours and listened to Bibi ji's kirtan for the first time, it was amazing! I live in the UK and only know that Giani Amolak Singh and Bhai Jeevan Singh have been blessed enough to have this Gurmukhs sangat, I was just wondering which other singhs/singhnees out there have aldo been blessed with his sangat also? I think its amazing when I hear about Bhai Sahib, I think the Gurmukhs (Bhai Jeevan Singh etc) should contribute towards writing about Bhai Sahib, I know Bhai Jeevan Singh is not very well, and some singhs in the UK have approached him with this request...but it is difficult, the thing is that once these Gurmukhs leave this world...any chance of 'finding out more' goes also... Forgive me if I have said anything out of context..

Re: Dastaar

a real bum. · 15 May 2003

do people outside of jatha believe in keski as a kakar?

Re: Dastaar

Kulbir Singh · 15 May 2003

>>>> do people outside of jatha believe in keski as a kakar? >>>>>>> Many scholars have acknowledged that keski is kakaar. They include famous non-akj scholars like Pyara Singh Padam who wrote multiple books on Sikhi. He is a renowned historian and scholar. He has openly written that he believes in the AKJ assertion that Keski is kakaar instead of Kes. Then there is very famous Sikh scholar called Giani Udham Singh, who has written a great book on the importance of Kes and another book on the greatness of Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. Don't want to go off-topic here but his book on Guru Nanak Sahib is an absolute master piece. He has presented many proofs to prove that Guru Nanak is greatest of all. In one of his books, Giani Udham Singh clearly writes that he is more inclined towards accepting keski as kakaar. Another great writer, who wrote a book called "Kakaar Philosoph" is a retired judge Sardar Bishan Singh. He has presented great proofs to prove that Keski and not kes is kakaar. The bhatts, who were like reporters in olden days, have clearly recorded Keski as a kakaar. All scholars believe that the Bhatt Vahees are the most authentic record of old time. Let us answer the question who the bhatts were. Bhatt are people who as part of their tradition record all events that happen in their neighbourhood. There are many bhatt Vahees and these Bhatts were spread throughout India. There are bhatt Vahees recording the visit of Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib in Bihar and other parts of India. When Guru Sahib did the 1699 Vasaakhi event, the Bhatts recorded that event and have written Keski as kakaar. Some people here have written that keski is a new word. This is a misconception. The word "keski" has been recorded in Mahan Kosh written by Kahn Singh Nabha. This word appears in 300 years of Bhatt Vahees (Vahee means record or account). So the answer to your question is that yes outside of Jatha, Sikhs do believe that Keski is a kakaar. Daas, Kulbir Singh