Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

anti-nang website

anti-nang website

Anti-Nang, Pro-Akj · 27 Apr 2004

gurfateh all sangat!!! http://www.freewebs.com/why-i-chose-nangs/ New Website, with a bit of humour, which basically counter arguement's nangish ideology such as weed, chatka etc etc Alot more will be coming up these next few weeks, watch out for never before seen images of niddar and the nangs!! woohoo!!! Gurfateh people!!

Re: anti-nang website

Mkhalsa · 27 Apr 2004

:O you beat me to it!! Singho, email me!! its about time someone did this. congrats!

Re: anti-nang website

UK Singh · 27 Apr 2004

If this is a purely satirical attempt at belittling the Nihangs that's fine. But you really need to improve on the material and factual evidence. Oh, and Nindiya of Niddar Singh or any of the others in his clique will not get you far... You are doing them a great service if you choose to slander.

Re: anti-nang website

singhl · 27 Apr 2004

I hate the UK nungs as much as anyone.... but that website is just embarassing... it does not counter any arguments...its childish humour... do you think this will do anything to counter what they are doin? not really... what is needed is a real effort to stop them....not little 5 minute job websites... sorry to be so harsh...bt singhji just purely criticisng people with no ctual reasoning is seen as nindya... we KNOW nidar is wrong...its just up to people to put it the effort and show the facts what ppl dont realise is that niddar likes to play the victim... "oh look at these singhs! all they do is nindya! is that real sikhi then" we need him 2 see he wrng!!

Re: anti-nang website

P.Singh · 27 Apr 2004

cool! Fully read this thread: http://sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=4153&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=0

Re: anti-nang website

Sohanganee · 27 Apr 2004

This is horrible :( [%sig%]

Re: anti-nang website

immortal Light · 27 Apr 2004

P.Singh..I don't understand why you wanted the sangat to view that thread? Is there something wrong with it?? I found it be quite inspiring and uplifting. After all if we can not gain from other lovers of the beloved..why not just become hermits?? But alas, that is what our Guroo Jee's warned us against. :) :)

Re: anti-nang website

P.Singh · 27 Apr 2004

The 14 year old in me was happy to see the website because sometimes you just wanna tell people off who are spreading falsehood. BUT thinking with a calm mind I think the website should be re-done without the sarcasm and on a more serious note.

Re: anti-nang website

immortal Light · 27 Apr 2004

Dear brother, you failed to answer my question..I was asking what was wrong with that link you provided (the one from Sikh Awareness site)? It was talking about being open to other faiths..perhaps you need to read it again veer?

Re: anti-nang website

Harmeet Singh · 27 Apr 2004

If anything this website will promote Nidar Singh's profile and go further to prove his claim that anti-nihang people lack any common sense and prefer to slander. They are already proving to be a match for people both physically and mentally, and also spiritually as they have never slandered anyone's character even though they have critised people's opinions. I am also surprised at the moderators of this forum for allowing such a website to be posted because I assumed that Gursikhs steer clear of slandering others and dont allow personal hatred to get in the way of Gurmat. By allowing such slander on a panthic website it goes to prove that these days people are only Gursikh by name, not by action. Everyone around the world is still waiting for the AKJ and Taksali Sikhs to counter what has been said on the Nihang websites. Where have the intellectual Sikhs gone? Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: anti-nang website

Mohan Singh · 28 Apr 2004

I thought the website was pretty funny. For the Sangats information the site wasnt designed by mature adults or scholars so I wouldnt put it down. I think its a nice attempt at making people chuckle. This line particularly made me laugh: "Once again. Santa will not be bringing you Jhatka presents this Christmas." Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: anti-nang website

immortal Light · 28 Apr 2004

I am shocked that Gursikhs who utter such sweet praises are referring to a fellow Gursikh as "Santa" (Claus), have we no shame left?? Are we ANY ONE to judge or fall to the level to use such terms?? Let me guess..will I be called a Nang too for humbly asking that all Gursikhs deserve respect? I have nothing to do with Nihangs or Nangs or any of these petty issues Singhs these days have taken board, instead of working on their own Sikhi. Spend time reflecting the good inside yourself, spend less time calling Gursikhs 'Santa'..truly so disgusting.. Jathedar Baba Santa Singh ji re-built and restored Akali Bunga Sahib after the dishonouring by the Indian Army..don't forget that..

Re: anti-nang website

Kulbir Singh · 28 Apr 2004

--------- Jathedar Baba Santa Singh ji re-built and restored Akali Bunga Sahib after the dishonouring by the Indian Army..don't forget that.. --------- May I humbly say that for this precise, Santa Singh was excommunicated from Panth in 1984, by Siri Akal Takhat Sahib? Many years later to that, and just couple of years ago, he got pesh at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib and supplicated for forgiveness from Panth. His pleas were heard at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib and he was re-admitted to Khalsa Panth. Now that he has joined the Panth, no gursikh should have any problem with him. He is a known scholar and his translation of Pracheen Panth Parkash is the best I have seen to date. For that work, I commend him. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: anti-nang website

Kl Singh · 28 Apr 2004

"Jathedar Baba Santa Singh ji re-built and restored Akali Bunga Sahib after the dishonouring by the Indian Army..don't forget that.." --Didn't he get the money to restore Akali Bunga Sahib from Indira Gandhi? I don’t think that is praiseworthy.

Re: anti-nang website

Harmeet Singh · 28 Apr 2004

Its really a shame that Gursikhs would even make such a website simply because they dont agree with what others do. If the AKJ are endorsing this website by keeping this thread then its a disgrace. The AKJ are no better than those they ridicule. Its an embarressment to Sikhs. The amount spent making that website would have been better spent doing simran or ardas for the Panth.

Re: anti-nang website

immortal Light · 28 Apr 2004

From another forum: They (Jathedar Baba Santa Singh jee) were claimed to be tankhaiyas of the Panth. Why? because some government officials had made donations to the Buddha dal treasury. This was outrageous. Can't a man make a donation to a charitable fund...could we stop all government officials such as civil servants and clerks stop donating money to their local Gurdwaras. Would all the pardhans, sants and mahapurakhs be tankhaiyas who accepted dontaions from government workers? and Jathedar Baba Santa Singh Ji Nihang went 'pesh' in order to keep unity within the khalsa panth. Jathedar Baba Santa Singh Ji Nihang went pesh for a mistake they didnt even commit. If government officials donated money to the Buddha dal this had nothing to do with the rebuilding of Akaal Takhat Sahib.

Re: anti-nang website

Kl Singh · 28 Apr 2004

But when was Akali Bunga Sahib restored? and was it restored because of operation blue star?

Re: anti-nang website

Mkhalsa · 28 Apr 2004

>>>are referring to a fellow Gursikh <<< Thats the point, they are in no way SIKHS,

Re: anti-nang website

. · 28 Apr 2004

i think its great but you should have legitamate points against the nangs and explain why they are bad rather than ONLY poking jokes..

Re: anti-nang website

immortal Light · 28 Apr 2004

Mkhalsa, Who is not a Sikh? As that statement was about Baba Santa Singh Jee..he is the fellow Gursikh I am talking about..how is he not a Sikh??

Re: anti-nang website

jagjit singh · 29 Apr 2004

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I have to agree with Veer Harmeet Singh. I am not too impressed by the site, and I believe it is a complete own goal. It is just falling into the trap. Most nihangs have stated that people should debate with them. When they show people this, it will just show, immaturity, and a complete lack of knowledge and debate. In reality, when we have debated with, they have no leg to stand on. The reality is they have presented their arguments in a professional website, with good presentation. What is needed is a well presented site, logically setting out the debate, and answering the key issues. I have often considered it, but there always seems to be something more important to do, neither do I have any good PC skills. I think it is desparately needed if anyone has got the skills. We can provide the content. It is just about being positive and professional. As far as this site a benti to take it off. You are not doing yourself any favours. Gursikhs should always be positive, constructive, and mature. If anyone interested in debating, then currently there is a debate happening on this link. The dabate is happening with a nihangs, other Gursikhs who at my great surprise are dithering over the issue. http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/community/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=4813&t=4813 I have just sent the below message. Soon it will be approved. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I will be brief as I am leaving today. I will be back in about a week and can discuss this further. Firstly, you will find it apparent, that everyone who promotes Snaatanism, never puts there name to their mails. It is always just ask Niddar. Why? When you promote it, why do all hide behide e- mail addresses, hardly Nihangs like Boota Singh and Garja Singh. Eventhough everyone in Uk knows who created the website, they still deny it. Why are they so embarassed by there own thinking? Debating on egroups as Narsangha, Brown Cookie, khalsa 108, and an array of false names. I have never come across nihangs like these. And such I believe they are the shamefully destroyed a proud history of Panthik seva by Nihangs: - Good nihangs who followed mainstream sikhi thinking of no meat, bhang, alcohol, idol worship, etc, etc. In answering Veer ji question. There are many good nihangs dals. Harian vela dal is the one that comes to mind. The do not do meat, bhang, alcohol, etc, and their jathedar suffering much torture after 84. Close to my own village, he was tied up behind a jeep and draggged, causing him much injury. The problem is the nihang dals that promote Snaatanism. Snaatanism basically is an idealogy that states, it is the oldest theory, hence insinuating it is correct and everything else is wrong. It believes in not one maryada but in many maryadas and many groups, i.e. nihangs, nirmallas, udasses and seva panthis. Recently it mentioned Taksal was the fifth, with no reasoning, and has yet to implement it, or is just saying it to keep the taksal happy. The opposite to it is the Khalsa idealogue. Khalsa idealogue believes in Oneness. We believe in One Akal, One Guru - Shabad Guru, One Guru Khalsa Panth, and One Rehat Maryada. So this is where we differ. Snaatanism, believes in four groups, where rehat is non-existant or not important, Amrit is not important, and many do not take it, idol worship, etc etc. Where as we believe that Sahib Siri Guru Gobind Singh ji created only one Guru Khalsa Panth where everyone is equal, and everyone follows the same maryada, as stated by Guru Ji himself. We do not accept intoxicants, no idol worship, and Amrit is fundamental to becoming a Sikh of the Guru. Historicaly this debate has been going on for some time. It came to the fore at the time of Arya Samaj. Swami Dayanand, the key propogator of Snaatanism was very succesful in bringing many aspects of it into mainstream sikh thinking. Ideas such as caste, idol worship which at that time even happened in the Harmandar Sahib complex, etc etc. The reaction came in the form of the Singh Sabha Movement and Gurdwara Sudar Laher in which Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, Sant Attar Singh Mastuana, and Baba Gurbachan Singh Bindra wale were prominent. These two movement reasserted Khalsa ideologue back into the Panth. The sense of Panthik spirit and Oneness. Depsite there differences in maryada, their thinking in terms of Panthik and khalsa Ideolgue were the same. The pivitol time was Bhai Kahn Singh ji Nabha book, Hum Hindi Nahin, which basically finished all debate by Snaatanists. Today due to so many sikh youth shaheed, and corrupt leadership, Snaatanism is reasseting itself in the Panth. Through RSS, and also through illiterate sikh thinking, Snaatanism is going from strength to strength. Today almost all the Punjabi universities who publish books on sikhi, are funded by RSS minded groups. The Sikh intelligensia who traditionally countered this, is now very old and weak. Prof Harbhajan Singh, Pyare Singh Padam, and Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara have all passed away in recent years. The prominent jathas, i.e. AKJ and Taksal are consumed by internal divisions and are weak. Spokesman are its following has got itself mixed up with Kala Afghana. This only leaves Sikh Missionary, who is very aware of what is going, but still remains quiet. Snaatanism thinking is diluting traditional sikh idealogue, and attempting to re-package it. By protraying itself as oldest, purataan, is attempts to cloud issues, and cause doubt. Because Sikh have been weakened by lack of access to its literature, and solidarity only via SGPC maryada, they have been succesful. Snaatanistic nihangs are even more dangerous. They are not linked to RSS, but follow the same Swami Dayanad thinking. They deny this, but I have often challenged them to show me how their idealogue differs from that of Swami Dayanand. What they have done, is overtake the proud history of the Nihang Dals which is widely respected in Sikh History, and use it to push their non- sikhi Snaatan thinking. Similar to way the BNP in Uk have hijacked the flag of United kingdom. Many youth, especially Gatkha youth love hearing stories from our history. But they are using these great examples of Sikhi Spirit to promote their meat, bhang, alcohol, idol worship, non-acceptance of khalsa Panth, but acceptance of Indian Nationhood. Those prominent youth who now seem to be dithering on this, need to think about by associating or just accepting them, exactly what are they accepting. Do not just blindly play into the whole Purataan history routine. Do you honestly think Sahib Siri Guru Gobind singh ji said bhang, meat, idol worship is fine? Is that the khalsa he created? If so the the Taksal maryada is completely wrong aswell as there is no mention of this in there. The youth you have with you, if in five years they are eating meat, or doing narcotics as some amritdharis have done in UK, would you still accept as an amritdhari? Would you let him, as a person who drinks and does drugs do talks to young kids in your camps? What is a kurehit anymore? If tomorrow is a Amrit Sanchaar, a person is peshed saying he drinks and has done drugs, the panj cannot say anything to him, because according to your statements, you it is allowed according to Sanaatan maryada. Essentially if that is the case, what is the difference between you and the Radha swamis, they give Naam, with no consideration of rehat. In the future anyone could get Naam from the Panj, but still do meat, bhang, alcohol and idol worship. So logically please think. Do you really accept Snaatanism? Leave out attachment to proud nihang history. But just look the basic facts of the idealogue, and decide - do you really accept it not? Will be back in a week. Will answer any points then. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: anti-nang website

Harmeet Singh · 29 Apr 2004

Jagjit Veerji, I humbly suggest instead of spending so much time on the internet trying to find was to defame people's character that you go and meet these people face to face. I respect you for the knowledge you have but your behaviour does reflect Gursikhi. Many of your past posts have been very informative, especially about your spiritual experiences. Veerji, as yet I have seen none of the Nihungs slander anyone, or insult anyone. I also read the thread on the Damdami Taksal website which you posted. You claim that these Nihungs have insulted Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji, but I have found no evidence of this anywhere myself. Maybe they have changed their websites. We all have the right to change our minds dont we? I asked myself whether Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji, or indeed any great Gursikh of the past would have resorted to name-calling and slander if someone called him a lair, or whether he would meet the people, confront them, and use the power of knowledge to fix the situation. Bhai Sahib Ji was a great Sikh but he was also human, and therefore capable of making mistakes like everyone else. Even Sant Jarnail Singh Khalsa Bhindrawalleh never claimed to be perfect. If we think humans are perfect then we are no better than the Naamdharis who pray to their living Guru. After reading this thread I went on the Nihung websites myself to see what all the fuss was about and it appears that you have taken this matter personally instead of doing the Gursikh thing and debating with them with knowledge and wisdom. On their website they have even invited people to debate with them in person. Why not take them up on it calmly and rationally and record everything on video? Then put the video on the internet for all to see. If you have debated with them could you please give us the results of this debate? Jagjit Veerji, as a side point, this is the internet, and I think people have the freedom to choose nicknames for themselves. It doesnt mean they have anything to hide or are being malicious. My own daughters use nicknames on the internet, and so does my wife. Even on Sikhi forums many people come on using so many nicknames, some good, some bad. I think you are just looking for excuses to ruin people's reputation. I have read their articles on meat, what they call 'mahaparsad' and found it to be balanced. Their article on Keski appeared to promote the idea of women being proud of wearing keskis. They leave the decision about meat to the individual, and that is inline with the Akal Takht if I am not too much mistaken and give overwhelming evidence for their claims. I also read their other articles and found them to be well researched. Although I do not agree with eating meat myself, I respect the right of others to eat it. I do not find the pictures of goats very appealing but such killing goes on in every country to provide meat for the masses. Why should killing a goat by a Sikh be any worse than a Sikh eating meat at home after buying it from the Supermarket? The end result is the same is it not? Are you going to condemn the thousands of Sikhs who buy meat in supermarkets too? I am not sure on their stance of bhang however or whether they are promoting it or not. I will find this out in the future perhaps. Jagjit Singh ji, the Nihungs do not worship idols from what their websites say and in fact have sections countering claims that they are hindus or RSS. If anything, they clear a lot of doubt with regards to how Sikhi views the Hindu demigods. I find myself respecting other faiths after reading the their websites. Although their information is at times difficult to digest, I find it interesting. I dont agree with everything, but I am still on the path of learning. Considering the amount of ainda and name calling being done on the AKJ forums, I think the Nihung websites are far closer to the message of Sikhi because they have not resorted to such behaviour. They praise Gurbani and bring out lots of hidden history and give the youth much to be proud of about their heritage. My reason for this statement is based on the behaviour of people on both sides, and the type and quality of information presented. At present, their websites appear to be providing a lot more evidence for their claims than anyone else on the internet. I will be visiting their training centre in Slough this weekend (where I live) to see for myself what goes on. I want my children to learn how to look after themselves and have been thinking of sending them to some kind of self defence class. If their martial arts live up to their claims I will send my children there. Jagjit Veerji, I will ask them to reply to your claims against them and see what they say. I will let you know what they say.

Re: anti-nang website

Nihang Singh · 29 Apr 2004

VahigurooJiKaKhalsa VahigurooJiKeFateh!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Jagjit Singh is stating that there is one Sikhi and that in reality there should only exist one homogenous Panth. He quotes Kahn Singh Nabha. However I feel that Jagjit Singh has not read any significant portition of Bhai Kahn Singhs books. For instance Kahn Singh believed in Charan Pahul Amrit for the Sahijdhari Sikh. An intiation similiar to Hazoor Sahib Kirpan Amrit. He quotes from Sahijdhari rahit VajibulArjz. Thus from the standpoint of Kahn Singh it is not homogenous like Jagjit Singhs One God, One Panth, One Guru belief. This totally challenges Jagit Singh's theory. It shows pluralism. On page 466 of Gurmat Martand by Kahn Singh, translated: For Sahijdhari Sikhs instead of CharanAmrit, now five stanzas of Japji with a Kirpan, in clean water it is stirred, this can be given as Amrit. This first step it done by one Singh, someone has love with Bani then this same technique can give and intiate other Sahijdharis. This is also known as the Janam Sanskar. (In the Taksal Maryada) K Singh The pivitol time was Bhai Kahn Singh ji Nabha book, Hum Hindi Nahin, which basically finished all debate by Snaatanists. Today due to so many sikh youth shaheed, and corrupt leadership, Snaatanism is reasseting itself in the Panth. Through RSS, and also through illiterate sikh thinking, Snaatanism is going from strength to strength. Today almost all the Punjabi universities who publish books on sikhi, are funded by RSS minded groups. The Sikh intelligensia who traditionally countered this, is now very old and weak. Prof Harbhajan Singh, Pyare Singh Padam, and Bhai Joginder Singh Talwara have all passed away in recent years. The prominent jathas, i.e. AKJ and Taksal are consumed by internal divisions and are weak. Spokesman are its following has got itself mixed up with Kala Afghana. This only leaves Sikh Missionary, who is very aware of what is going, but still remains quiet

Re: anti-nang website

Mkhalsa · 29 Apr 2004

Harmeet Singh, you are coming in two years later when its been resorted to name calling. Why not read old forum posts all over the web? They have been debated with!! Everytime they are disproved they say we are nindaks, they delete their response, change their names, lie about what was said, say we havent answered their questions, when they have only maneuvered around our answers, in short have done every dirty tactic they can to come out as "winners" or look as if they are poor victims. I personally am tired of debating with them and have stopped trying to even make it intellectual, because frankly its a big waste of my time and doesnt realy do anything.

Re: anti-nang website

uK SiNgH · 04 May 2004

{{{{{{{{Jagjit Veerji, I will ask them to reply to your claims against them and see what they say. I will let you know what they say}}}}}}}}}} Harmeet Singh Ji - did you have a positive discourse with the Nihangs?

Re: anti-nang website

ivana puke · 04 May 2004

"Everytime they are disproved they say we are nindaks, they delete their response, change their names, lie about what was said, say we havent answered their questions, when they have only maneuvered around our answers, in short have done every dirty tactic they can to come out as "winners" or look as if they are poor victims. I personally am tired of debating with them and have stopped trying to even make it intellectual, because frankly its a big waste of my time and doesnt realy do anything." What an untellectual remark.. and what a LIE. Dont just make stuff up. Its so untellectual that you cant even back up what you say. Not on any forum have you made a point mkhalsa. All of your silly points and assumptions have been countered by someone, neatly and patiently too i might add. This debate goes NO WHERE in any forum so don't boast that you won! However you do support the freewebs site. You actually wanted to make it yourself. Your exact words are: ":O you beat me to it!! Singho, email me!! its about time someone did this. congrats! " Only a moorakh would do that, want to do that, or support doing it.. That's why the creator has now taken it offline! Im an AKJ bibi and I fully disagree with your approach to the enitre subject matter. No Gursikh would support that site's insult and slander. Jatha and Taksal included, wouldnt support such rubbish. An incredible circus act. Its wrong for any SIKH! It goes against basic Sikh principles. To the site's creator, you have not spoken out against something, but you've made a mockery of the people you represent. The site does nothing but show the ignorance and blind hatred towards the target. And to such an extent that a wellwritten site cannot be created to counter, but instead, this site was created. This does nothing but prove that a response cannot be written with reason. As an amritdharee, Its so LOW for a GURSIKH to do someting like that. And from a scholorly perspective, a very unprofessional approach to debating an argument for the topic at hand.

Re: anti-nang website

Mohan Singh · 05 May 2004

Penji, if you were in the know about this website, you would be aware as everyone else is, that it was not removed by the authors; it received complaints from (allegedly) the UK Nihang community and Freewebs deleted it. And please do not be sure the authors were either Gursikh or even adults, unless you know them personally, of course. Please give me a claim the UK Nihangs have which stands unrefuted, and even though Guru says do not argue with fools, I will clear up any doubts you may have, and I am sure much of the Sangat will assist. And do not slander Mkhalsa Ji, unless you believe yourself to be better than him. He is a definate Gursikh, not a "liar" as you attempt to claim. I do honestly doubt if you are an AKJ bibi, "ivana puke" Kaur. Apologies if I have offended anyone. Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: anti-nang website

Admin · 05 May 2004

This thread has now been locked. Nothing new is coming out of this. No new messages will be entertained under this thread. Admin