Re: Bana
Gurpreet Singh Dhillon · 23 Apr 2004
Singhnee, its really amazing that you wear bana, there is no need for Guruji's Singhnee to wear a chola.
Re: Bana
Gurpreet Singh Dhillon · 25 Apr 2004
yes i was misquoted, a man and woman are equal therefore they should dress equally.
Re: Bana
loon harami · 25 Apr 2004
Vaheguroo ji ka khalsa, Vaheguroo ji ki fateh!
There's some evidence to suggest GUru GObind Singh ji maharaj use to wear chooridaar chola (with pajami), they have the chola sahib in Anandpur Sahib.
Bhul chuk muaf!
Vaheguroo ji ka khalsa, Vaheguroo ji ki fateh!
Re: Bana
I dont understand · 26 Apr 2004
theres some people out there who believe that women only wear bana to show off?
what is up with that?
I hate society......
Re: Bana
immortal Light · 28 Apr 2004
Mkhalsa wrote>>>and with chunnis.. many singhnees have told me its to "cover themselves up" ie neckline on suit is too low, suit is too see-through, suit is too tight etc..unknown...>>>
I'm a bit confused..Singhnees are worrying about their grace so why would they need to worry about covering themselves up? I mean..why would graceful singhness be wearing low neckline suits, see-through suits, tight suits anyway?? Grace is not merely made by a covering of a cloth..it is just an accessory to salvar-kameez. I notice ladies in the kitchen often wear those scarves set out in the entrance of Gurdwara Sahib and they wrap their chunni around their neck..so are they less graceful? Most Singhnees wear jeans, pants, shirt, tops, etc to school/university, work, at home etc..I don't see a chunni wrapped around their front..
Just some observations..guroo jee warned us against manmat..
Re: Bana
singhsation · 29 Apr 2004
The question of bana is interesting.
My personal take: bana is your panj kakaars and whatever is necessary in accordance to those kakaars.
Is wearing a chola, bana? We use the words interchangeably but there is nothing inherently spiritual about the chola, and this is coming from someone who does wear a chola.
The nihang-type chola that we commonly see today was not created by Sikhi - it is simply clothing which, most likely, was prevalent during the time of Dasmesh Pita ji. As such, Hindus and Muslims wore it as well. I recall seeing a picture of Sivaji (Hindu general of the Maharattas) wearing what looked like a chola. I'm only assuming this - please correct me if I'm wrong.
The chola was worn by the Sikhs because it was the clothing worn during that particular time. If a Singh wanted to wear trousers over his kachera and go into battle, I doubt if Maharaj would have said no. Moreover, there was probably a fair bit of variance in the cholay available, just like there is variance in the types of pants available.
I like wearing a nihang-chola because the jathebandee I took amrit from was headed by a nihang-singh and I instantly fell in love with it.
It reminds me of Sikh warriors like, I'm sure, wearing the kilt reminds the Scots of their own proud history. In the end, it's clothing - just that. Makes little difference whether you wear the clothing of the 16th century or of the 21st century.
With regards to it just being clothing, this is why you have so many different variations of what is popularly called 'bana'. You have nanaksaris with their particular bana, you have Taksalis wearing a long kurta and calling it bana, and you have Nihangs wearing their version of 'bana' - they are just clothes.
Sant Baba Jarnail Singh ji Bhindranwale was about as mahan a Sikh as one is ever going to find. Did he wear bana? What was that bana? Was it a chola? If so, what kind of chola was it? Baba ji wore a long kurta and a kachera, as per Taksali tradition. Just another form of clothing - wearing a chola or jeans makes absolutely no difference in your bhagti, simran, Sikhi. If it does, then you need to re-evaluate what you are doing, because these things should not be subject to mere clothing. Regards.
daas
[%sig%]
Re: Bana
Bhujangi Fauj · 30 Apr 2004
This is damdami taksaals perspective on this issue.........
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Author: admin
Date: 04-30-04 19:47
Damdami Taksal does not approve of bibian wearing bhana without a pajami as it is against gurmat. Only one group allows bibian to be in the panj pyarey, and majority of those people are the ones who support bibian not wearing pajami's.
It is common sense, most bibian were shocked at even the idea of not wearing a pajami. No other group approves of bibian not wearing pajami's. This is 100% manmat and Damdami Taksal does not approve of it
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[%sig%]
Re: Bana
singhsation · 02 May 2004
What is your sister proving by not wearing a pajami?
Why stop there? Many gurdware have sporting functions including wrestling where Singhs wrestle with their tops off - next time such an event takes place, make sure your sister shows up and takes off her top - after all, equality is the key and if Singhs are able to do something, so too should Singhnian.
Moreover, too make a really strong statement, all like-minded women should show up and take off their tops en masse - that will really prove something.
People throw around this word equality as if it supposed to mean identical - it's not, especially in the physical sense. A khalsa, is a khalsa, is a khalsa BUT this holds true in the spiritual sense NOT the physical. Why then did Maharaj ji make the distinction between kaur and singh - why bother with these two distinct terms based solely on gender? Because there is a difference between men and women.
If there are any doubts in your mind, please go to the library and sign out an anatomy book.
As for your statement pertaining to Singhs being able to do stuff that bibian cannot, it's a simple fact of life and the opposite is true as well - bibian can do things Singhs cannot. Bibian can give birth and breastfeed - should Singhs now cry out for equality and demand they too be able to give birth and breastfeed?
Yes, yes - the heart of not exposing the legs and breasts is a cultural/societal phenomenon; however, the reason that I said the above is to highlight that there exist significant differences between the bodies of men and women and these cultural norms (at least in most cultures) takes these physical differences into consideration.
dear Sister - do not take these words as harsh for the sake of being harsh -
Fight for equality but do it where it carries some meaning, where it is important - fight for equality in education, in the professional world, academic world. Fight for equality in panthic seva. Fight for equality in Sikh birthing issues, in a culture which continues to kill its baby girls. Fight for equality in the political field, both in and outside the gurdware - so that a bibi's voice carries the same importance as that of a Singh's voice.
These are all activities where equality actually means something. Showing off legs or breasts because singhs can show their legs or chests proves nothing, means nothing, and does little in effecting real and meaningful change in our community, be that the Punjabi community or the Sikh community.
daas
kaur!!!!! wrote:
> WJKK WJKF!!!
>
> i am upset from hearing this that bibian cannot wear a bana,
> chola with out a pajami this is WRONG!!! OUR RELIGION IS ABOUT
> EQUALITY!!!! HOW CAN YOU SAY SINGHS CAN DO THINGS BUT BIBIAN
> CANNOT?????!!! this is totally wrong! society has become so bad
> its unbelieveble, you get every one gossoping oh look at her
> she wears a dastaar thats for singhs its people like this that
> are changing our religion!! i cannot believe such people!
> bhanji if you want to wear a bana, chola with out a pajami go
> right ahead i am behind this all the way!! we have rights to we
> are all EQUAL!! my sister wears a dastaar n wears a bana with
> out pajami she gets people shouting, giving her dirty looks,
> gossoping about her but at the end of the day its what right
> shes doing. i am going to follow my sisters footsteps its
> bibian like this that set good examples! so bhanji go for it!
>
> WJKK WJKF!!!
Re: Bana
kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 02 May 2004
hmmm singhstation you always seem to love to take things to the extreme in order to maintain your stance
just because singhnees want to not wear pajamees does not mean they want to take off their shirts
and what kind of decent-minded singh takes his shirt off in public anyway?
singhs are supposed to dress appropriately just like singhnees.
wrestling or not.
how many khalsas wrestle with their shirts off ?
most of the people i see wrestling with their shirts off have haircuts, or they are typical "turban for the heck of it" types of "bhekhi" (outwardly) sikhs
and the other thing...
guru jee did NOT see difference in daughters and sons...
there is no such thing as kaur
it's all a conspiracy
every sikh, every khalsa, man and woman, is a singh
singh is in guru jee's bani
kaur isn't
i don't know where this word "kaur" came from and i don't know if it is guru jee's real hukam that all women should be "kaurs"
call me crazy.
but that's what i feel.
Re: Bana
singhsation · 03 May 2004
kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n wrote:
> hmmm singhstation you always seem to love to take things to the
> extreme in order to maintain your stance
"Always" is too strong of a generalization, however, I agree that taking examples to their extreme does not always represent issues falling somewhere in the middle.
That said, I do not think comparing female breasts to female legs is "extreme". Both are female body parts which have been 'sexualized'.
>
> just because singhnees want to not wear pajamees does not mean
> they want to take off their shirts
Given, but that was not my point. The argument being made by a forumite sister was centered on this strange interpretation of what "equality" means - if equality means bibian should be allowed/encouraged to expose their legs in public like Singhs, then it follows that bibian should be allowed/encouraged to go topless when Singhs go topless.
>
> and what kind of decent-minded singh takes his shirt off in
> public anyway?
Many decent-minded Singhs take off their shirts in public - it depends on the purpose. Wrestling is one purpose, swimming is another, going jet-skiing with your friends is yet another, beach activities (volleyball etc) are another example and the list goes on.
There is no lack of decentness in a man taking off his shirt in the above examples, keeping in mind the context - a man taking off his shirt in gurudwara would be an idiot unless there was a very good reason for it.
There is no social stigma with men exposing their chests nor is the male chest sexualized like the female chest.
>
> singhs are supposed to dress appropriately just like singhnees.
>
>
> wrestling or not.
AND, in wrestling, taking off your shirt and wrestling in shorts or even your kachera is APPROPRIATE for Singhs.
> how many khalsas wrestle with their shirts off ?
thousands upon thousands upon thousands......they've been wrestling sans shirts since Guru Angad Dev ji Maharaj encouraged His Sikhs to wrestle.
> most of the people i see wrestling with their shirts off have
> haircuts, or they are typical "turban for the heck of it" types
> of "bhekhi" (outwardly) sikhs
your personal experience appears to be very limited.
However, to be fair, this may be due to the fact that amritdhari men are fewer in number than non-amritdharis. Therefore, based on population breakdown alone, you'll find amritdhari men number fewer in a given sporting activity then their non-amritdhari brethren.
>
> and the other thing...
>
> guru jee did NOT see difference in daughters and sons...
>
> there is no such thing as kaur
>
> it's all a conspiracy
>
> every sikh, every khalsa, man and woman, is a singh
>
> singh is in guru jee's bani
>
> kaur isn't
>
> i don't know where this word "kaur" came from and i don't know
> if it is guru jee's real hukam that all women should be "kaurs"
Interesting point. I honestly don't know the origins of the word kaur.
Did Guru ji begin the practice of calling amritdhari females kaur or did Guru ji call them Singhs? When did the practice of calling females 'kaur' arise?
>
> call me crazy.
Hey Crazy! :)
>
> but that's what i feel.
Fair enough.
daas
Re: Bana
tarunjeet singh · 04 May 2004
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa
Vaheguru ji ki fathe
It's great that Bhenji feels the desire to want to wear banna, I don't think anyone would disagree with her there. But what you need to understand bhenji is that like mentioned before showing of the legs for a women is not deemed acceptable in our society, yes i agree with equality in SIKHI but what you must not do is ever create kaam in the mind of another person by dressing unappropriatly. Would it be such a big deal for you to wear a pajami? i wouldn't have thought so, evn if it means that it will stop someone looking at you in the wrong way. Also would this mean that if a girl who is not amritdhari would be allowed to come to the Gurudwara with a knee length skirt on??? We have to be realistic.
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa
Vaheguru ji ki fathe
Re: Bana
princess of power · 04 May 2004
i think you need some help with self esteem, and perhaps depression....
It sounds like you're always sad because you don't feel good enough (when in direct contrast sikhs are usually chardi kala ..i.e happy to be in their beloved's bhana - will) and you want to take on an identity...
but dear sister, Sikhi starts on the inside! when you have it, you could wear a sack and still feel in supreme reassurance of being the Gurus Sikh.
And yes you feel love for the Guru and want his roop, but where does it say that wearing western clothes is not the roop? when they have also been designed according to Vahegurus creation and will and buddhi?
Humbleness is very good, but not the kind that destroys you and makes you sad inside, that is the way of getting illnesses, the humbleness that makes you want to jap vahegurus name because he is so great and we are so small (nothing) is the one that brings happiness and bliss!!
good luck sister!
Re: Bana
singhsation · 04 May 2004
Mkhalsa wrote:
> Lets look at a few things, because this debate is pointless..
>
> 1) Girls shaved/waxed/overly moisturized/plastic looking legs
> are over-sexualized in western society
> 2) This disease has spread to us
Look at punjabi culture, and you will find that women's clothing has kept the legs covered for centuries - this is before the influence of Cosmopolitan or Elle.
> 3) Singhnees have hairy, not so moisturized legs that look
> almost exactly like a singhs.
> 4) Hair legs are NOT sexualized in any culture that I know of
Hairy legs or not, it was considered inappropriate for women to bare their legs in public in Northern Indian culture if not throughout the subcontinent.
I'm not sure how far back this trend goes. Perhaps it was due to the influence of Islamic/Moghul culture or perhaps it goes further back then that. In any case, I think you will be hard pressed to find female clothing trends in the Punjab where legs were not kept covered.
aside: There is some arguement that Indian culture used to be different before the English imposed their Victorian ideals on society but, usually, this argument is made by those who believe Indian society was more sexually care-free before the British rule.
> 5) What kind of idiot would stare at a singhnee in bana?
> Someone should slap him
Agreed.
> 6) therefore its ok for a singhnee to wear bana without pajami
> as long as she is doing it for the right reasons and not being
> an exhibitionist.
I, for one, could care less whether a singhnee chooses to wear a pajami or not - it's a personal choice and all the power to that choice. However, I do not buy the weak arguments made in support of not covering the legs. It has little do with equality or what Guru ji would or wouldn't have approved - it's about personal choice and only that.
>
> >>>what you must not do is ever create kaam in the mind of
> another person by dressing unappropriatly<<<<
>
> how far do you guys want to take this debate? I know of someone
> who is highly attracted to girls faces (better than anything
> else). Should singhnees start covering their faces as well? How
> about perverts that are attracted to hands and feet? should
> singhnees wear socks and gloves? how about people that are
> attracted to the mere shape of a woman? I KNOW!! Singhnees
> should start wearing burqas and hijaabs!!!! Thatll fix em!!
Yes Mkhalsa, that makes complete sense, all Singhnees should wear burqas. sheesh......
I can't comment on anyone else's posts but mine had next to nothing to do with the creation of kaam and how it relates to bared legs; i wrote only on the covering of legs in punjabi culture and the issue of equality. In writing the posts I discussed the sexualized nature of the legs (hairy or not).
>
> If someone wants to have kaam, they will have kaam no matter
> what a girl is wearing.
Agreed.
Of course if a girl is wearing a
> miniskirt and lots of makeup and is waxed and plucked, then
> yeah part of it is her fault, but theres a line.
I disagree. Kaam is the problem of the kaami; it doesn't matter if it is a waxed and plucked face which creates that kaam or a hairy leg. In short, it doesn't matter what the trigger for that kaam is, the fault lies in the person experiencing the kaam. Even if a person has dressed in such a way and is acting in such a way so as to entice you, if you give in, the fault is entirely in you and not the enticer. This is only my opinion....
regards,
daas
[%sig%]