questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
Rochak Malang · 19 Apr 2004
Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa!
Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!
i was having a few questions about Amritvela Simran sessions held by AKJ (i haven't been to any yet).
Are 1. non-Amritdharis or 2. those who have taken Amrit from another jatha other than AKJ allowed? Are those who have not taken Naam dridd allowed?
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
Kulbir Singh · 19 Apr 2004
----------
Are 1. non-Amritdharis or 2. those who have taken Amrit from another jatha other than AKJ allowed? Are those who have not taken Naam dridd allowed?
------------
If an abhyaas program is done at a Gurdwara Sahib, then how can you stop anyone from coming?
Same way, I don’t think anyone asks for identification, standing outside the door of abhyaas room, to find out whether one has done naam-driR or not. At least I have never witnessed it anywhere. The thing is that, worldly people don’t reach at abhyaas place in the early hours of amritvela, that starts at 2amm, and before they come in, abhyaas is normally over.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 19 Apr 2004
Some people prefer that non-amritdharis or non-naam-drir people dont' come because they have elitist mentality.
HOwever it is true that the most benefit is for those who have gotten gurmantar from PUnj Pyare (naam drir or not) - they will actually taste the sweetness the most.
Naam drir advantage is that the PUnj Pyare - Guru suroop - literally put gurmantar into your soul... and then naam abhyaas becomes must easier.
Any type of elitism for listening to naam simran ... I dont' know if it's appropriate. We're not brahmins. Gurbani and gurmantar are sarab sanjee... anybody who wants to listen can listen.. anybody who wants to taste - can taste by taking khande-ke-pahul.
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
Rochak Malang · 19 Apr 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Thanks for your responses jee. i was disturbed because i heard of an account (not sure how true it was) where someone who took amrit from another jatha was refused entry.
thanks again
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 19 Apr 2004
dear "daas" jee ... sorry about that incident jee... the person who did that to you is practicing manmat... elitism like that is not part of gursikhi...
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
vaheguroo~vaheguroo · 19 Apr 2004
Author: Kulbir Singh
"The thing is that, worldly people don’t reach at abhyaas place in the early hours of amritvela, that starts at 2amm, and before they come in, abhyaas is normally over. "
but what if they do come at that time? before i got naam drirh, i went to a naam abhyaas program (but i felt sort of intimidated because i had never heard that kind of simran before and went home without even sitting down..)
i definitely agree that naam drirh is beneficial to doing simran, but how can we just deny someone their right to come to the guru's house? how dejected will they feel when they find out that they cannot meet their guru? what if they just need that little inspiration of darshan of guru jee to take amrit?
im really confused, on the other hand i think that guru jee might not want to see someone if they haven't taken amrit..?
i remember a saakhi where there was a sikh who did a lottt of seva, and guru jee called him and said i'll give you anything u want because u do so much seva, and the sikh asked for nothing but a small space in guru jee's charan...but guru jee said, im sorry i can give you anything else but not that because you haven't taken amrit....
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
Mohan Singh · 20 Apr 2004
"A Singh"
Are you implying Bhai Nand Lal and Bhai Ganaiya Jee were Nigura (without the Guru/unbaptised)?
Its clear both became Gursikh, whether through Khanda Da Pahul or with Charan Pahul, becuase they do not have "Singh" in their name does not change this. Banda Bahadur was discovered to take amrit when Persian acccouts were studied eventually.
Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
Rashpal Singh · 20 Apr 2004
VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh
People who have not had Naam Drirhta are not allowed in the actual Darbaar where swaas swaas simran is happening, as this method cannot be revealed to anyone who has not been given it by the Panj Piare and the Panj Piare ALONE can give you it, you CANNOT get it off anyone else. When you are given amrit by the jatha, the panj tell you that you are not to show anyone how to do swaas swaas simran. Therefore, people are not allowed entry into the hall where it is happening. Although, there is also the argument that people should be allowed to come to the Gurdwara whenever they want and meet the guru whenever they want…..interesting subject!
VaheguruJiKaKhalsaVaheguruJiKiFateh
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
Kulbir Singh · 20 Apr 2004
It is hukam of Punj Pyaaray to not teach the Gurmat technique of Naam abhyaas to anyone, nor give naam to anyone. Only the Punj Pyaaray have right to do so.
Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written about Sant Hira Singh jee Daudpuri, who started giving naam to others. Sant Hira Singh jee was a very accomplished gursikh and used to do naam abhyaas day and night. He was one of the main companions of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. While doing Naam abhyaas, he used to start floating in the air.
In the village he lived, many became tyaar-bar-tyaar Khalsa, as a result of his sangat. His personal kamaayee increased manifolds. Once a bibi saw Sant jee coming and accosted him, "Vey Hira Siyaan, suniya hai tu jiss dey sirr uppar hath rakh deven, uss noo hosh nahi rehindi. Vey mere sirr uppar vee hath rakh dey" (O Hira Singh, I have heard that on whom you touch on head, he loses consciousness. Place your hand on my head too".
Sant Hira Singh laughingly placed his hand on that old lady's head and she really lost consciousness. Swaas swaas naam started vibrating in her body, with great alacrity. She remained in these colours for more than 24 hours.
This way, playing miracles forbidden by Guru Sahib, Sant Hira Singh jee lost all his kamaayee and one day, he discovered to his horror, that he could not retrieve the darshan of Jyot of Vaheguru. He tried and tried but all in vain. He would go to the side of wells at midnight and do Naam abhyaas, standing on one leg, for hours and hours but all in vain. He could not retrieve his old spiritual state. His inside became dark like normal people. No longer he could view the charan-kamal of Vaheguru. No longer he could get into Dasam Duaar. No longer the divine lotus in his navel would blossom. He did not know what to do.
In such distressed state, he arrived back at Narangwal, the village of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. Bhai Sahib jee and other accomplished Singhs already knew why he had come. The Singhs at that time had all 5 Akali Shaktis (spiritual powers) and knew everything in and out. They knew the purpose of arrival of Sant Hira Singh jee but kept ignoring him. They did not heed to his requests and supplications.
Sant Hira Singh's agony knew no bounds. His bairaag was uncontainable. He would stay seated where the shoes of sangat were kept and his eyes kept shedding divine tears.
After many days or weeks, the Singhs realised that the time for embracing Sant Hira Singh jee had arrived. They organised an amrit sinchaar and subpeonoed Sant Hira Singh jee. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written what happened inside, very beautifully. Basically, the Punj Pyaaray made him realise that he had lost all his spiritual state because he had started giving naam and technique all alone. They said that this was the sole right of the Punj Pyaaray and no one else had any right to give naam.
Sant Hira Singh jee repented his mistake and within moments, his spiritual state came back. He was back in his old spiritual state in no time.
From this saakhi, we clearly learn that we don't have authority to teach naam to anyone. By the same token, if Singhs are doing naam abhyaas in their house where non-amritdharis too live, they don't have to do it gupt abhyaas. They can do it loudly as long as they are in their room. If they are absorbed in abhyaas and some sees them or hears them, they don't lose anything.
If sangat at a gurdwara sahib is doing abhyaas and a person who has not got naam driR comes, there is no need to stop doing abhyaas. We cannot stop anyone from coming to Gurdwara Sahib and it is not right to do so either. If someone comes, and has not got naam driR, that person will not come second time, as he will have no idea what Singhs are doing. Only that person, who has got naam driR, can do abhyaas with singhs. Others would freak out and not come second time.
Rest Guru Sahib knows. This is all I have learned from sangat.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
singhsation · 20 Apr 2004
could someone please clarify whether my understanding of this is correct:
1) Naam and naam abhyaas is to be given by Panj Piare and as such, an amritdhari Sikh should not go about telling non-amritdharis about it.
my thoughts: I'm not quite sure what my own thoughts are on this but it seems reasonable - make sure the person is willing to take amrit and thus takes the initial step.
2) "People who have not had Naam Drirhta are not allowed in the actual
Darbaar where swaas swaas simran is happening."
my thoughts: Is this correct? What if someone is amritdhari but has not had naam drirhta - are they rejected as well?
With regards to point 2, given that AKJ is pretty close to being the only group, or easily accessible group, which does naam drirta would mean that only those who have taken amrit from an AKJ jathaband ee are allowed entrance. This scares me a little bit - it means thatamritdharis are being distinguished along the lines of which group organized their amrit sanchar.
I guess one way around this problem would be for a non-AKJ sikh to take amrit again from an AKJ jathebandee or get pesh in front of AKJ Panj Piare but this further accentuates the problem.
The underlying message becomes, one group's amrit sanchar is better than another's or that one group's amrit sanchar entitles a sikh to different rights or that one group's amrit sanchar produces different spirituality.
Or am I wrong? To reiterate the question, can an amritdhari Sikh who has not had naam drirta attend a swaas swaas simran darbar?
A second question, is there any harm in teaching a fellow amritdhari Sikh swaas swaas simran or do they have to take amrit again or get pesh in front of Panj Piare from the AKJ in order to learn?
Third and final question, given that it is primarily AKJ jathebandees who do naam drirta during amrit sanchar, does this give sikhs who take amrit from the AKJ an advantage over those who take it from other jathebandees who don't do naam drirta?
Thank you.
- daas
ps. HUGE OVERSIGHT on my part! I don't even know what naam drirta is exactly - for all I know, it may have taken place when I took amrit but I didn't realize what it was - the Panj Piare who conducted the amrit sanchar I was in, were not affiliated with any group (as far as I am aware) - maybe the Taruna Dal.
Can someone describe what naam drirta is, or is that not allowed? I'm thinking that maybe most jathebandees do naam drirta but just don't label it as such while the AKJ gives it a name. If thats the case, then it changes everything....
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
vaheguroo~vaheguroo · 20 Apr 2004
kulbir singh jee, thank you for sharing that saakhi
imagine losing the darshan of vaheguroo AFTER knowing what it feels like...
you said:
"If someone comes, and has not got naam driR, that person will not come second time, as he will have no idea what Singhs are doing. Only that person, who has got naam driR, can do abhyaas with singhs. Others would freak out and not come second time. "
htat's so true, that's exactly what happened to me...i was almost scared because i had no idea what they were doing...
and is it really possible to actually give naam to someone just if they're sitting beside you? i mean like in that saakhi sant hira singh jee had to place his hand on top of people's heads (this is definitely wrong) but i dont think someone can be given naam just by hearing it, they can only imitate it but not REALLY know it...what are your views on this?
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
Kulbir Singh · 21 Apr 2004
---------
2) "People who have not had Naam Drirhta are not allowed in the actual
Darbaar where swaas swaas simran is happening."
my thoughts: Is this correct? What if someone is amritdhari but has not had naam drirhta - are they rejected as well?
--------
Singhstation jeeo, a person who has taken amrit from Punj Pyaaray but has not got naam driR cannot be stopped from entering swaas swaas abhyaas asthaan (place).
Every person who is an amritdhari has Naam-Gurmantra, unless such person has taken amrit from some fake-sant group. All normal amrit samagams conducted with correct Panthik maryada and in the presence of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee (unlike Kooka Samprada), give out Naam Gurmantra. But, in all amrit sinchaars, Gurmat technique is not taught.
Without Gurmat technique, one cannot japp naam. How is one going to japp naam, if one does not know how to japp naam? Where would one concentrate, if one is not taught where to concentrate? I have witnessed such unfortunate ones begging pseudo-sants to teach them Gurmat technique. I have witnessed such unfortunate amritdhari Sikhs asking everyone, where they should concentrate their dhyaan or surtee.
It is ironic that these unfortunate ones will ask everyone about naam techniques but if you tell them to go to next amrit sinchaar samagam and ask the punj pyaaray, water from 100 pots falls on their head (hehe, translation of a Punjabi saying). They totally shy away from getting pesh and asking the Punj Pyaaray about this. What can you say about them. They are stuck in organisational thinking and don't think about their spiritual needs. We know that today, in Khalsa Panth, very few amrit sinchaars teach the correct technique of Naam abhyaas but instead of going there for amrit chhakk, the unfortunate ones go everywhere else but there.
Anyway, this is a separate topic but what I am trying to say is that anyone who has received Naam from Punj Pyaaray cannot be refused from coming to Naam Abhyaas samagam. I could be wrong and this is just my personal opinion. Guru Sahib diyaan galaan Guru Sahib jee jaanan. Asee kee jaan sakde haan?
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
singhsation · 30 Apr 2004
Thank you Kulbir Singh -
I'm relieved to hear that that is the case. There are so many splits in the Sikh community, it would be terrible if a sikh was denied access to simran with any group.
Four quick questions - in going to a swaas swaas abhyaas session, how difficult is it to pick up on the technique? Is is something that can be picked up fairly quickly by someone who has been doing simran for a long time, or must it be taught by someone?
Can the technique be taught by one gursikh to another or must a gursikh learn from the Panj Piare?
If a gursikh goes to the Panj Piare to learn the technique, must they take amrit again?
Is the technique important? To clarify, is there only one proper technique of doing simran?
Thank you.
daas
Kulbir Singh wrote:
> ---------
> 2) "People who have not had Naam Drirhta are not allowed in the
> actual
> Darbaar where swaas swaas simran is happening."
>
> my thoughts: Is this correct? What if someone is amritdhari but
> has not had naam drirhta - are they rejected as well?
> --------
>
> Singhstation jeeo, a person who has taken amrit from Punj
> Pyaaray but has not got naam driR cannot be stopped from
> entering swaas swaas abhyaas asthaan (place).
>
> Every person who is an amritdhari has Naam-Gurmantra, unless
> such person has taken amrit from some fake-sant group. All
> normal amrit samagams conducted with correct Panthik maryada
> and in the presence of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee (unlike Kooka
> Samprada), give out Naam Gurmantra. But, in all amrit
> sinchaars, Gurmat technique is not taught.
>
> Without Gurmat technique, one cannot japp naam. How is one
> going to japp naam, if one does not know how to japp naam?
> Where would one concentrate, if one is not taught where to
> concentrate? I have witnessed such unfortunate ones begging
> pseudo-sants to teach them Gurmat technique. I have witnessed
> such unfortunate amritdhari Sikhs asking everyone, where they
> should concentrate their dhyaan or surtee.
>
> It is ironic that these unfortunate ones will ask everyone
> about naam techniques but if you tell them to go to next amrit
> sinchaar samagam and ask the punj pyaaray, water from 100 pots
> falls on their head (hehe, translation of a Punjabi saying).
> They totally shy away from getting pesh and asking the Punj
> Pyaaray about this. What can you say about them. They are stuck
> in organisational thinking and don't think about their
> spiritual needs. We know that today, in Khalsa Panth, very few
> amrit sinchaars teach the correct technique of Naam abhyaas but
> instead of going there for amrit chhakk, the unfortunate ones
> go everywhere else but there.
>
> Anyway, this is a separate topic but what I am trying to say is
> that anyone who has received Naam from Punj Pyaaray cannot be
> refused from coming to Naam Abhyaas samagam. I could be wrong
> and this is just my personal opinion. Guru Sahib diyaan galaan
> Guru Sahib jee jaanan. Asee kee jaan sakde haan?
>
> Daas,
> Kulbir Singh
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
gupt singhnee! · 02 Aug 2006
the AKJ amritvela is for people h hav had amrit frm AKJ and is for them only...i dnt think this is right..fair enuff if the amrit vela is for amritdharis and amritdharis only then that is fine! i 100% agree with that but the fact is if u hv nt had "AKJ amrit" wich is wt it is 2 sum ppl now no mater wt u say..den u cnt do simran wit dem..its wrong! if sum cums 2 dt av n be told dt u cnt cum bcaus eu rnt akj ds it is wrong! u may aswel ju say u cant do simran here go away plz...n if dt person is amritdhari..den say..unles u go pesh in front of "akj panj piyare" u cnt cum here...
Re: questions regarding AKJ Amritvela Simran sessions
raj karega khalsa · 02 Aug 2006
I took amrit, not at a jatha smagam... so i wasnt taught the gurmat technique of japping naam. but everytime i go to surrey, i always try to go to Khalsa School amritvela programs. When i frist walked in, i was just like wut the heck? but wen i mathha taeked to Maahaaraaj and sat down, i jus loved it. the atmosphere was wikd. no words can describe it. I'm planning on going again soon too... The gursikhs who do abhiyaas are not teaching you how to do simran, I just sit there and listen, maybe repeat with my tongue...