listening/reading???
lifetimes away from 1 · 16 Apr 2004
wjkk wjkf.
Dear Sangat,
is it ok to listen to paath if you can't read it personally??
its most probably beta to read it urself but if you are unable to for whateva reason then is listening to it ok??
i don't read paath form a gutka cuz i havent got newhere to do paath without being disturbed or loosing concentration and i know that sounds bad but i'd ratha not do paath if it means being disrespectful as i hav to share my bedroom i dont think its appropriate to do paath when sum1 is in the same room sleeping and i havnt got newhere to put the gutka. what should i do?? just listen to the paath on tape/CD, or should i read from the gutka?
what are the sangats views on this??
Bhul chuk marf karni.
wjkk wjkf.
[%sig%]
Re: listening/reading???
simran_sewa_sacrifice · 16 Apr 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!!
i would strongly suggest you not listen to a recording and do your patt from gutka (or memory, or listen from another Gursikh) if you can:
1. your ears are blessed from listening to the Gurbani
2. your eyes are blessed from looking upon the Gurbani
3. your mouth/tounge are blessed from reciting the Gurbani
as for the person who is sleeping, tell them to also join you and awake and read bani as well, if they are stubborn and dont comply then given them a fair warning that in morning time you will recite Gurbani regardless if they are bothered. who knows maybe when the Gurbani reaches their ears they too will change for the better
-bhulla chuka di maafi ji
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!!
Re: listening/reading???
kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 16 Apr 2004
there is a sakhi bout sant baba harnaam singh jee rampur kheray vaalay ... he was doing katha and he said if you just do some extra paath with your nitnem and simran, in a few months you can have darshan of akaal purakh... and a singh tried it but he had no results... so he asked baba jee and baba jee took a hukam from guru granth sahib jee and also he had darshan from guru sahib and he was told that when somebody does paat, Guru Sahib hears the paat that the person DOING the paat hears in his heart.
what i mean is if I do jap ji sahib paat, and the only thing that I really digest in the whole uchaaran is "asankh moorakh andh ghor" ... or "mannai pavai mokh duaar"... or "asan loay loay bhandaar" ...
then THAT is all that guru jee really hears.
if you do it with pyaar you will get more credit, of course.
in my situation there have been many times when i was not able to fully concentrate on bani. i have tried many things to make gurbani hit my heart.
a new thing i started to do was listen while reading the english translation - i finally started to understand "namastwang akale" means "salutations to the timeless" and "namo sarab kale" means "salutations to the destroyer of all" and "adesang adese" means "salutations upon salutations to you, God"
I didn't know these things before and there are many more things.... this is a way to learn but DOES IT COUNT AS NITNEM or just gurbani vichar i don't know........
but the key is sunnia (listen) mannia (accept) man keetaa bhaao (create love for it, and follow it).
i think if you can accept bani, love bani, and follow bani - if it hits your heart- when you listen to it... then it is definately okay.
i dont' knwo anything else... guru jee knows there have been so many times when i lose concentration ...
i'll be surfing tapoban while doing rehiras... :\
so i have to change my own behaviour for sure.